TAP FOR 6 MONTHS OF PREMIUM FREE 💰
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Champ or Chump - Jake Odorizzi and Eric Hosmer

It took the better part of four months, but baseball's offseason is finally starting! Eric Hosmer signed a massive contract to vacation play baseball in San Diego, while Jake Odorizzi was traded to the Minnesota Twins for a ham sandwich and a few extra baseballs.

One of these players is capable of turning a substantial profit in 2018 fantasy leagues, and it's not the one who just inked a nine-figure deal.

Here's a closer look at Odorizzi and Hosmer's fantasy value for the upcoming season.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball draft tools and resources:

 

The Fantasy Jury is Out

Jake Odorizzi (SP, MIN) ADP: 288.8

Odorizzi was roughly a league average pitcher in his 143 1/3 IP last season, posting a 4.14 ERA and 21% K%. His xFIP (5.10), BABIP allowed (.227), and extreme fly ball tendency (47.3% FB% last year, 45% for his career) have convinced fantasy owners that the season was a total fluke, making him an afterthought on most draft boards.

Expecting regression to the mean is one of the trademarks of this column, but Odorizzi may have landed in the perfect situation to keep it up. His extreme fly ball profile, combined with a slightly plus IFFB% (9.3% last year, 9.6% career), allow him to consistently post BABIPs under .300 (.269 career). His .227 BABIP may increase a little, but it won't be as bad as some are expecting.

His new team may also serve to mitigate any regression. The 2017 Tampa Bay Rays finished second in Statcast's Outs Above Average metric with 23. Byron Buxton of the Minnesota Twins topped that mark by himself with 25 OAA, helping his team finish first in the league with 31 total. Tampa Bay's superlative outfield defense likely played a role in Odorizzi's .067 BABIP on flies (and .528 on line drives), but his new team is even better.

Odorizzi allowed slightly more line drives last year (22.1% LD%) than he has over his career (21.3%), giving him room for positive regression. He'll likely need this to offset the deficiencies of Minnesota's infield, where the 3B tandem of Miguel Sano and Eduardo Escobar combined for -10 Defensive Runs Saved, 2B Brian Dozier was below average (-4), and SS Jorge Polanco was roughly average (-1). Joe Mauer has an excellent first baseman's mitt (seven DRS), but it's not enough to cover for everybody else.

By contrast, the Rays supported Odorizzi capably last year. Third baseman Evan Longoria compiled 11 DRS in his last season as a Ray, shortstop Adeiny Hechavarria added six more, and 1B Logan Morrison was solid (one). Brad Miller wasn't great at second (-4), but otherwise the infield was strong. This helped Odorizzi best his career .240 BABIP on ground balls with a .224 mark, but it may not have been entirely the work of his friends.

Odorizzi saw his grounders allowed get scorched in 2016, averaging 86.6 mph off of the bat. That number fell to 81.8 mph last year, suggesting that Odorizzi was doing a much better job controlling the quality of contact against him. It remains to be seen how sticky this will be, but there's at least some hope that he can repeat his 2017 BABIP on ground balls.

Many fly ball pitchers have an ability to limit damage on airborne baseballs, but Odorizzi's 15.5% HR/FB last season does not reflect this. He has historically been better (11.1% career HR/FB), and contact quality metrics suggest that he just ran into some bad luck last year. His average airborne exit velocity allowed decreased from 93.5 mph in 2016 to 91.9 mph last year, while his rate of Brls/BBE improved slightly (8.4% to 8.2%). Fly ball pitchers give up a few homers, but Odorizzi should be better in 2018.

Minnesota's outfield defense and Odorizzi's fly ball profile are his best traits, but the 28-year old's stuff offers some upside as well. His fastball played elite last year (12.5% SwStr%, 54.9% Zone%), but it lacks the elite spin rate typically associated with such a pitch (2,287 RPM). Still, any repeat could go a long way toward boosting his K%.

Odorizzi also introduced a cutter (7.4% usage in 2016, 16.5% last year) that proved very capable on balls in play (.188/.263/.471) even if its K% numbers weren't great (11.9% SwStr%, 40.3% Zone%, 25.5% chase). His split allows him to induce ground balls when needed (47.9% GB%), but its K% marks are also lacking (11.4% SwStr%, 37.4% Zone%, 37.6% chase). Odorizzi mixes in the occasional slider and curve, but both are more show pitches than legitimate weapons in his repertoire.

Odorizzi is moving to a division where three teams are rebuilding, presenting plenty of favorable matchups. He seems likely to serve as a streamable fantasy starter that is never far enough away from a usable week to drop, making him a name to remember toward the end of deeper drafts. You don't want to start him every time, but he'll help more than hurt if used judiciously.

Verdict: Champ

 

Eric Hosmer (1B, SD) ADP: 77.3

Hosmer was great to own in 2017, as he put up a .318/.385/.498 line with 25 HR and six stolen bases (one CS). Unfortunately, almost none of it appears sustainable moving forward.

Let's start with his league average power. Hosmer wouldn't know what a fly ball was if he tripped over one, posting a FB% of just 22.2% last year. His fantasy season was saved by a 22.5% HR/FB, but his average airborne exit velocity (94.2 mph vs. 95.4 in 2016) and rate of Brls/BBE (6.8% vs. 9.4% in 2016) both declined. He also pulled fewer of his flies (10.8%) than he has over his career (15.1%), meaning that all three of his power indicators are trending in the wrong direction.

Some analysts are expecting Hosmer's numbers to improve after escaping Kansas City, and San Diego was a slightly better ballpark for left-handed HR according to the newly updated FanGraphs ballpark factors (96 vs. 93). However, neither park is great and Hosmer already hit more homers at home (16) than on the road (nine) in 2017. Furthermore, the site's five year averages suggest that Kansas City is better for overall scoring (102) than San Diego (95). Essentially, Hosmer is exchanging one bad park for another.

His .318 batting average takes some of the sting out of power regression, but the .351 BABIP it's based upon is equally likely to decline (.316 career). Hosmer murders his ground balls (87.4 mph last year, 90.2 in 2016) and boasts an above average Statcast Sprint Speed (27.5 ft./sec), but last year's .259 BABIP on the ground (.251 career) was not the primary reason for his success.

Instead, he crushed his career BABIPs on both fly balls (.186 vs. .161) and line drives (.703 vs. .663). His LD% (22.2%) also exceeded his career number (20% LD%). Considering the above decline in airborne contact quality and the random fluctuations LD% is prone to, neither should be expected moving forward.

This is not to suggest that Hosmer is a completely lost cause. His airborne contact quality remains strong enough to produce sustainable power seasons if he hits more fly balls, and he seldom strikes out (15.5% K%, 9.3% SwStr% last year). Heck, he even has enough speed to swipe 10 or more bags! However, his current ADP takes growth as a given when the 28-year old has resisted change in the past. Let somebody else pay a premium.

Verdict: Chump

 

More 2018 Player Outlooks




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Miguel Andujar

Padres Agree on One-Year Contract
Lance McCullers Jr.

Building Up as a Starter
Framber Valdez

Signs Three-Year, $115 Million Contract With Tigers
Joel Embiid

Questionable for Thursday Night
Dylan Harper

Ruled Out Versus OKC
Stephen Curry

Remains Sidelined on Thursday
David Peralta

Hangs Up his Cleats
Los Angeles Angels

Tyler Saucedo Joins Angels on Minor-League Contract
Jalen Green

Questionable Against Golden State
Mike Clevinger

Pirates Sign Mike Clevinger to Minor-League Deal
Kristaps Porzingis

Questionable Versus Utah
Cole Anthony

is Cleared for Wednesday's Game
Jaylen Brown

is Ruled Out on Wednesday
Cade Cunningham

Might Not Play Against Washington
Kenley Jansen

the Favorite to Open the Year as Tigers Closer
Myles Turner

Active Wednesday
Kevin Porter Jr.

is Returning on Wednesday
Isiah Kiner-Falefa

Red Sox Agree on One-Year Deal
Kevin Durant

is Officially Active on Wednesday
Anthony Edwards

is Available for Wednesday's Game
Julius Randle

to Play on Wednesday
Ajay Mitchell

Sidelined Again on Wednesday
Alex Caruso

Ruled Out for Wednesday's Matchup With Spurs
Isaiah Hartenstein

Unavailable on Wednesday
Marcus Foligno

Out Wednesday Against Predators
Kiefer Sherwood

Set for Sharks Debut on First Line
James Harden

Expected to Make Cleveland Debut on Saturday
Martin Necas

Misses Third Consecutive Game
Luguentz Dort

Sidelined Versus Spurs
Josh Hart

Ruled Out Wednesday Due to Ankle Injury
Kirill Marchenko

a Game-Time Call Wednesday
Sam Bennett

Anton Lundell Available for Panthers Wednesday
Bobby Portis

Out With Hip Contusion
Chet Holmgren

Ruled Out Wednesday
Nick Bjugstad

Devils Add Nick Bjugstad in Trade
Artemi Panarin

Traded to Kings, Signs Two-Year Extension
CFB

Sam Leavitt to be Limited In Spring Practice
Jordan Love

Avoids Offseason Surgery
Bligh Madris

Cardinals Sign Bligh Madris to Minor-League Deal
Mickey Gasper

Red Sox Claim Mickey Gasper Off Waivers From Nationals
Yanquiel Fernández

Yankees Claim Yanquiel Fernandez Off Waivers From Rockies
Michael Fulmer

Signs Minor-League Deal With Giants
Grant Taylor

to Transition Back to Starting Role in 2027?
Framber Valdez

Pirates Emerging as Suitor for Framber Valdez
Tayler Scott

Signs Minor-League Deal With Braves
Max Clark

Receives Invite to Big-League Camp
Kevin McGonigle

Tigers Invite Shortstop Prospect Kevin McGonigle to Spring Training
Marcell Ozuna

Pirates Showing Interest in Marcell Ozuna
Brandon Drury

Royals Sign Brandon Drury to Minor-League Deal
Rhett Lowder

Could be Mid-Rotation Starter For Reds in 2026
Gunnar Henderson

Works on Speed in Offseason
Matt Fitzpatrick

Back in Action at WM Phoenix Open
Sahith Theegala

Riding Hot Start Into WM Phoenix Open
J.J. Spaun

Looks to Regain Form at WM Phoenix Open
Viktor Hovland

a Volatile Option at WM Phoenix Open
Rasmus Hojgaard

Aims to Build on Solid Start to 2026
Brian Harman

Looks to Find Form at WM Phoenix Open
Daniel Berger

Has the Tools to Go One Step Higher at Scottsdale
Max Greyserman

Searching for Consistency at WM Phoenix Open
Jake Knapp

Wants Revenge at WM Phoenix Open
CFB

Joey Aguilar Granted Temporary Restraining Order Against NCAA
Joel Dahmen

Carrying Momentum Into WM Phoenix Open
Corey Conners

Unlikely to Contend at Scottsdale
Mathew Barzal

Plays Key Role in Comeback Victory
Sepp Straka

Seeks a Rebound After The American Express
Sebastian Aho

Bags Three Points in Tuesday's Win
Jordan Spieth

Healthy Heading to WM Phoenix Open
Darren Raddysh

Extends Goal Streak to Five Games
Keith Mitchell

Building Momentum for Event in Scottsdale
Nikita Kucherov

Posts Second Straight Four-Point Game
Travis Konecny

Extends Multi-Point Streak Tuesday
Tom Hoge

The Tom Hoge Roller Coaster Heads to Scottsdale for WM Phoenix Open
Elvis Merzlikins

Earns First Shutout of the Season
Filip Chytil

Dealing With Migranes
Rickie Fowler

Worth a Look at WM Phoenix Open
Nick Foligno

Set to Return Wednesday
Dante Fabbro

Returns From Six-Game Absence
Kirill Marchenko

Out Tuesday
Bryan Rust

Returns to Penguins Lineup
Jack Hughes

Misses Second Straight Game
Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen

Out for Olympics
Anthony Cirelli

to Miss Olympics
Xander Schauffele

Making Second Appearance at Phoenix Open
Collin Morikawa

Needs a Bounce-Back at Waste Management Phoenix Open
Hideki Matsuyama

Has a Shot to Challenge at the Waste Management Phoenix Open
Max Homa

Playing Well Heading to Waste Management Phoenix Open
Ben Griffin

Will Need to Find Approach Game to Compete in Phoenix
Michael Penix Jr.

Matt Ryan Not Committing to Michael Penix Jr. as the Starting QB
NASCAR

Billy Horschel Unlikely to Right the Ship in Phoenix
Matthew Stafford

Doesn't Need Offseason Back Surgery
CFB

Joey Aguilar Files New Lawsuit Against NCAA Seeking Sixth Year of Eligibility
Davante Adams

Expected to Return to Rams in 2026
Los Angeles Rams

Rams Sign Sean McVay, Les Snead to Contract Extensions
Diego Lopes

Outclassed At UFC 325
Alexander Volkanovski

Dominates Diego Lopes
Dan Hooker

Stopped In The Second Round
Benoît Saint Denis

Benoit Saint Denis Extends His Win Streak
Rafael Fiziev

Suffers Second-Round TKO Loss
MMA

Maurício Ruffy Gets Back In The Win Column
San Francisco 49ers

49ers Set to Name Raheem Morris Their Defensive Coordinator
Las Vegas Raiders

Raiders Close to Naming Klint Kubiak the Next Head Coach
Arizona Cardinals

Cardinals Finalizing Deal to Make Mike LaFleur the Next Head Coach
CFB

Gus Malzahn Retiring from Coaching
Breece Hall

Jets Want to Re-Sign Breece Hall, Could Use Franchise Tag
Diego Lopes

An Underdog At UFC 325
Alexander Volkanovski

Set For UFC 325 Main Event
Benoît Saint Denis

Benoit Saint Denis Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Dan Hooker

Set For UFC 325 Co-Main Event
Mauricio Ruffy

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Rafael Fiziev

Returns At UFC 325
CFB

Texas Lands Wake Forest Transfer Sterling Berkhalter
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF