RADIO
The final stretch of the fantasy baseball season has found us, so let's keep battling with our starting pitcher starts/sits for fantasy baseball Week 25 -- Monday, September 9 through Sunday, September 15. We continue to keep tabs on rookies getting called up in September, rehabbing pitchers preparing for the playoffs, and teams resting key arms. Stay tuned for every start/sit call and potential two-start choices for your lineups.
For 12 years running, we have been writing this Starting Pitcher Starts and Sits series every week here at RotoBaller. I'm Nick Mariano, here to lead you through the 2024 season. All sorts of firepower and TLC go into supplying this piece each week. We get tons of great feedback on it every year.
If you're new here, read below to catch up on the aim of this piece and how best to use it. Best of luck with your fantasy baseball starting pitcher lineup decisions. Let's jump in!
Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball lineup tools and weekly lineup resources:- Fantasy baseball injury reports
- Fantasy baseball trade analyzer
- Daily MLB starting lineups for fantasy baseball
- Fantasy baseball BvP matchups data (Batter vs. Pitcher)
- Fantasy baseball PvB matchups data (Pitcher vs. Batter)
- Who should I start? Fantasy baseball player comparisons
- Fantasy baseball closer depth charts, bullpens, saves
- Fantasy Baseball live scoreboard, daily leaderboards
Start/Sit Data Overview
Ahead of each week of the fantasy baseball season, we publish the table below. We have the probable starters for every game of the week and a grade for them on a 0-100 scale. The intent is to give you advice and to inspire some confidence (or lack thereof) in your decisions to start or sit certain pitchers.
Please note that beyond the usual "Start" and "Sit" labels, there is a third category called "context-dependent." This is because different leagues call for different actions, and those in start-sit purgatory may be worth the gamble to some.
Also, we put the arms best projected to start or get bulk innings or actionable arms who may return from the injured list or be called up, but some situations are fluid, and we update ASAP to reflect accurate information. September ramps up the day-by-day chaos so check back often!
The "starts" category includes pitchers you'd likely start in every league. The "sits" are pitchers that you likely sit in every league. The "context-dependent" means it is close, and it's up to you to decide based on your league settings or team needs (wins, strikeouts, etc.) how deep your league is, which roto/points categories are scored, and so on. Let's get to it!
Here are your starts and sits for what we're calling Week 25 of the fantasy season, which covers September 9 through September 15.
Week 25 Start/Sit Recommendations (September 9 - September 15)
Updated start/sit recommendations for this week's MLB games. This chart is updated daily as probable starters are constantly changing with postponements, injuries, etc. Scroll down further for a color-coded chart. If you can't see the chart below, click here to see the starts/sits on a separate page:
| Date | Game | Team | Pitcher | Grade | Start/Sit | 2 Starts |
| 9/9 | TB@PHI | TB | Cole Sulser / Tyler Alexander |
15 | SIT | N |
| 9/9 | TB@PHI | PHI | Cristopher Sanchez | 70 | START | Y |
| 9/9 | CIN@ATL | CIN | Nick Martinez | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/9 | CIN@ATL | ATL | Charlie Morton | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/9 | MIA@PIT | MIA | Valente Bellozo | 25 | SIT | Y |
| 9/9 | MIA@PIT | PIT | Paul Skenes | 85 | START | N |
| 9/9 | KC@NYY | KC | Brady Singer | 30 | SIT | Y |
| 9/9 | KC@NYY | NYY | Carlos Rodon | 70 | START | Y |
| 9/9 | NYM@TOR | NYM | Tylor Megill | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/9 | NYM@TOR | TOR | Ryan Burr / Ryan Yarbrough |
30 | SIT | N |
| 9/9 | BAL@BOS | BAL | Cade Povich | 35 | SIT | Y |
| 9/9 | BAL@BOS | BOS | Brayan Bello | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/9 | LAA@MIN | LAA | Reid Detmers | 65 | START | N |
| 9/9 | LAA@MIN | MIN | David Festa | 65 | START | Y |
| 9/9 | CLE@CHW | CLE | Joey Cantillo | 45 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/9 | CLE@CHW | CHW | Nick Nastrini | 15 | SIT | N |
| 9/9 | CHC@LAD | CHC | Kyle Hendricks | 25 | SIT | Y |
| 9/9 | CHC@LAD | LAD | Walker Buehler | 35 | SIT | Y |
| 9/10 | COL@DET | COL | Bradley Blalock | 25 | SIT | N |
| 9/10 | COL@DET | DET | Keider Montero | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/10 | TB@PHI | TB | Taj Bradley | 30 | SIT | Y |
| 9/10 | TB@PHI | PHI | Ranger Suarez | 75 | START | N |
| 9/10 | MIA@PIT | MIA | Adam Oller | 25 | SIT | Y |
| 9/10 | MIA@PIT | PIT | Carmen Mlodzinski | 10 | SIT | N |
| 9/10 | ATL@WAS | ATL | Reynaldo Lopez | 75 | START | N |
| 9/10 | ATL@WAS | WAS | MacKenzie Gore | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/10 | KC@NYY | KC | Seth Lugo | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/10 | KC@NYY | NYY | Marcus Stroman | 45 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/10 | NYM@TOR | NYM | David Peterson | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/10 | NYM@TOR | TOR | Chris Bassitt | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/10 | BAL@BOS | BAL | Albert Suarez | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/10 | BAL@BOS | BOS | Kutter Crawford | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/10 | LAA@MIN | LAA | Griffin Canning | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/10 | LAA@MIN | MIN | Pablo Lopez | 80 | START | N |
| 9/10 | CLE@CHW | CLE | Ben Lively | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/10 | CLE@CHW | CHW | Jonathan Cannon | 20 | SIT | Y |
| 9/10 | CIN@STL | CIN | Rhett Lowder | 25 | SIT | Y |
| 9/10 | CIN@STL | STL | Andre Pallante | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/10 | OAK@HOU | OAK | JP Sears | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/10 | OAK@HOU | HOU | Spencer Arrighetti | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/10 | SD@SEA | SD | Yu Darvish | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/10 | SD@SEA | SEA | George Kirby | 65 | START | Y |
| 9/10 | TEX@ARI | TEX | Nathan Eovaldi | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/10 | TEX@ARI | ARI | Zac Gallen | 70 | START | Y |
| 9/10 | MIL@SF | MIL | Aaron Civale | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/10 | MIL@SF | SF | Landen Roupp | 30 | SIT | Y |
| 9/10 | CHC@LAD | CHC | Shota Imanaga | 65 | START | N |
| 9/10 | CHC@LAD | LAD | Yoshinobu Yamamoto | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | MIA@PIT | MIA | Adam Mazur | 20 | SIT | N |
| 9/11 | MIA@PIT | PIT | Bailey Falter | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | CLE@CHW | CLE | Matthew Boyd | 80 | START | N |
| 9/11 | CLE@CHW | CHW | Davis Martin | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/11 | NYM@TOR | NYM | Sean Manaea | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | NYM@TOR | TOR | Bowden Francis | 80 | START | N |
| 9/11 | TEX@ARI | TEX | Cody Bradford | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | TEX@ARI | ARI | Merrill Kelly | 45 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | COL@DET | COL | Tanner Gordon | 15 | SIT | N |
| 9/11 | COL@DET | DET | Casey Mize | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | TB@PHI | TB | Shane Baz | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/11 | TB@PHI | PHI | Zack Wheeler | 90 | START | N |
| 9/11 | ATL@WAS | ATL | Max Fried | 75 | START | N |
| 9/11 | ATL@WAS | WAS | Jake Irvin | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/11 | KC@NYY | KC | Cole Ragans | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | KC@NYY | NYY | Luis Gil | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | BAL@BOS | BAL | Dean Kremer | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | BAL@BOS | BOS | Nick Pivetta | 45 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | LAA@MIN | LAA | Jack Kochanowicz | 25 | SIT | N |
| 9/11 | LAA@MIN | MIN | Zebby Matthews | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | CIN@STL | CIN | Brandon Williamson | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/11 | CIN@STL | STL | Lance Lynn | 45 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | OAK@HOU | OAK | Joey Estes | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | OAK@HOU | HOU | Hunter Brown | 70 | START | N |
| 9/11 | SD@SEA | SD | Michael King | 75 | START | N |
| 9/11 | SD@SEA | SEA | Bryan Woo | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | MIL@SF | MIL | Colin Rea | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/11 | MIL@SF | SF | Blake Snell | 65 | START | N |
| 9/11 | CHC@LAD | CHC | Jordan Wicks | 25 | SIT | N |
| 9/11 | CHC@LAD | LAD | Bobby Miller | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/12 | COL@DET | COL | Ryan Feltner | 15 | SIT | N |
| 9/12 | COL@DET | DET | Tarik Skubal | 95 | START | N |
| 9/12 | CIN@STL | CIN | Jakob Junis | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/12 | CIN@STL | STL | Sonny Gray | 65 | START | N |
| 9/12 | OAK@HOU | OAK | Mitch Spence | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/12 | OAK@HOU | HOU | Framber Valdez | 80 | START | N |
| 9/12 | MIA@WAS | MIA | Darren McCaughan | 20 | SIT | N |
| 9/12 | MIA@WAS | WAS | Mitchell Parker | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/12 | TB@CLE | TB | Ryan Pepiot | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/12 | TB@CLE | CLE | Gavin Williams | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/12 | BOS@NYY | BOS | Cooper Criswell | 25 | SIT | N |
| 9/12 | BOS@NYY | NYY | Nestor Cortes | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/12 | TEX@SEA | TEX | Kumar Rocker | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/12 | TEX@SEA | SEA | Bryce Miller | 80 | START | N |
| 9/12 | MIL@SF | MIL | Frankie Montas | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/12 | MIL@SF | SF | Hayden Birdsong | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | BAL@DET | BAL | Zach Eflin | 75 | START | N |
| 9/13 | BAL@DET | DET | Brant Hurter | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | KC@PIT | KC | Alec Marsh | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | KC@PIT | PIT | Luis L. Ortiz | 30 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | NYM@PHI | NYM | Jose Quintana | 25 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | NYM@PHI | PHI | Aaron Nola | 70 | START | N |
| 9/13 | MIA@WAS | MIA | Edward Cabrera | 30 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | MIA@WAS | WAS | DJ Herz | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | BOS@NYY | BOS | Richard Fitts | 25 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | BOS@NYY | NYY | Clarke Schmidt | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | STL@TOR | STL | Erick Fedde | 30 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | STL@TOR | TOR | Kevin Gausman | 65 | START | N |
| 9/13 | TB@CLE | TB | Zack Littell | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | TB@CLE | CLE | Tanner Bibee | 75 | START | N |
| 9/13 | LAD@ATL | LAD | Landon Knack | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | LAD@ATL | ATL | Spencer Schwellenbach | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | OAK@CHW | OAK | Brady Basso | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | OAK@CHW | CHW | Garrett Crochet | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | CIN@MIN | CIN | Julian Aguiar | 30 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | CIN@MIN | MIN | Bailey Ober | 65 | START | N |
| 9/13 | CHC@COL | CHC | Javier Assad | 30 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | CHC@COL | COL | Austin Gomber | 25 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | HOU@LAA | HOU | Yusei Kikuchi | 80 | START | N |
| 9/13 | HOU@LAA | LAA | Samuel Aldegheri | 15 | SIT | N |
| 9/13 | MIL@ARI | MIL | Freddy Peralta | 45 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | MIL@ARI | ARI | Eduardo Rodriguez | 45 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | TEX@SEA | TEX | Jacob deGrom | 65 | START | N |
| 9/13 | TEX@SEA | SEA | Emerson Hancock | 45 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/13 | SD@SF | SD | Dylan Cease | 80 | START | N |
| 9/13 | SD@SF | SF | Logan Webb | 65 | START | N |
| 9/14 | KC@PIT | KC | Michael Wacha | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/14 | KC@PIT | PIT | Mitch Keller | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/14 | BOS@NYY | BOS | Brayan Bello | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/14 | BOS@NYY | NYY | Gerrit Cole | 75 | START | N |
| 9/14 | STL@TOR | STL | Kyle Gibson | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/14 | STL@TOR | TOR | Jose Berrios | 65 | START | N |
| 9/14 | NYM@PHI | NYM | Luis Severino | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/14 | NYM@PHI | PHI | Kolby Allard | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/14 | MIA@WAS | MIA | Valente Bellozo | 25 | SIT | Y |
| 9/14 | MIA@WAS | WAS | Patrick Corbin | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/14 | BAL@DET | BAL | Corbin Burnes | 65 | START | N |
| 9/14 | BAL@DET | DET | Ty Madden | 20 | SIT | N |
| 9/14 | TB@CLE | TB | Tyler Alexander | 25 | SIT | N |
| 9/14 | TB@CLE | CLE | Joey Cantillo | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/14 | CIN@MIN | CIN | Nick Martinez | 35 | SIT | Y |
| 9/14 | CIN@MIN | MIN | Simeon Woods Richardson | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/14 | OAK@CHW | OAK | J.T. Ginn | 65 | START | N |
| 9/14 | OAK@CHW | CHW | Chris Flexen | 30 | SIT | N |
| 9/14 | LAD@ATL | LAD | Jack Flaherty | 80 | START | N |
| 9/14 | LAD@ATL | ATL | Chris Sale | 65 | START | N |
| 9/14 | CHC@COL | CHC | Jameson Taillon | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/14 | CHC@COL | COL | Kyle Freeland | 25 | SIT | N |
| 9/14 | MIL@ARI | MIL | Tobias Myers | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/14 | MIL@ARI | ARI | Brandon Pfaadt | 65 | START | N |
| 9/14 | SD@SF | SD | Joe Musgrove | 80 | START | N |
| 9/14 | SD@SF | SF | Mason Black | 30 | SIT | N |
| 9/14 | HOU@LAA | HOU | Justin Verlander | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/14 | HOU@LAA | LAA | Tyler Anderson | 30 | SIT | N |
| 9/14 | TEX@SEA | TEX | Max Scherzer | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/14 | TEX@SEA | SEA | Logan Gilbert | 85 | START | N |
| 9/15 | BAL@DET | BAL | Cade Povich | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/15 | BAL@DET | DET | Keider Montero | 25 | SIT | Y |
| 9/15 | CIN@MIN | CIN | Rhett Lowder | 30 | SIT | Y |
| 9/15 | CIN@MIN | MIN | David Festa | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/15 | KC@PIT | KC | Brady Singer | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/15 | KC@PIT | PIT | Jared Jones | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/15 | NYM@PHI | NYM | David Peterson | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/15 | NYM@PHI | PHI | Cristopher Sanchez | 65 | START | Y |
| 9/15 | MIA@WAS | MIA | Adam Oller | 25 | SIT | Y |
| 9/15 | MIA@WAS | WAS | MacKenzie Gore | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/15 | BOS@NYY | BOS | Kutter Crawford | 35 | SIT | Y |
| 9/15 | BOS@NYY | NYY | Carlos Rodon | 75 | START | Y |
| 9/15 | STL@TOR | STL | Miles Mikolas | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/15 | STL@TOR | TOR | Yariel Rodriguez | 35 | SIT | N |
| 9/15 | TB@CLE | TB | Taj Bradley | 35 | SIT | Y |
| 9/15 | TB@CLE | CLE | Ben Lively | 50 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/15 | OAK@CHW | OAK | JP Sears | 70 | START | Y |
| 9/15 | OAK@CHW | CHW | Sean Burke | 25 | SIT | N |
| 9/15 | CHC@COL | CHC | Kyle Hendricks | 30 | SIT | Y |
| 9/15 | CHC@COL | COL | Cal Quantrill | 20 | SIT | N |
| 9/15 | SD@SF | SD | Martin Perez | 55 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/15 | SD@SF | SF | Landen Roupp | 25 | SIT | Y |
| 9/15 | HOU@LAA | HOU | Ronel Blanco | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/15 | HOU@LAA | LAA | Caden Dana | 20 | SIT | N |
| 9/15 | TEX@SEA | TEX | Andrew Heaney | 60 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/15 | TEX@SEA | SEA | George Kirby | 75 | START | Y |
| 9/15 | MIL@ARI | MIL | DL Hall | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | N |
| 9/15 | MIL@ARI | ARI | Zac Gallen | 70 | START | Y |
| 9/15 | LAD@ATL | LAD | Walker Buehler | 40 | CONTEXT DEPENDENT | Y |
| 9/15 | LAD@ATL | ATL | Charlie Morton | 35 | SIT | Y |
Start/Sit Color-Coded Matchups Chart (September 9 - September 15)
The below grid shows the same data but as a color-coded grid:
