X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Shortstop ADPs - Overvalued and Undervalued

Now that the first day of spring has passed, we are now entering the prime season for fantasy baseball drafts.

Before you enter your draft room this year, it would behoove you to check out our ADP analysis pieces here at RotoBaller. This will ensure that you have a good working knowledge of how players are being viewed, when to grab your targeted guys, and when to let your league mates jump on a guy going too early. In the end, you will look like a genius.

There is not much going on in 2017 fantasy drafts that I absolutely hate in regards to shortstop ADP. I can make the argument that Francisco Lindor is going too early, but once that shortstop run starts, I know from experience the feeling of desperation to get one of the studs. Plus, he presents such a safe floor of all around production. Other than that, not much is happening that I disagree with. But there is a lot of production at the position that is going much too late in drafts, so keep scrolling and be enlightened.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball draft tools and resources:

 

Overvalued Shortstops

Addison Russell, CHC

2017 ADP: 123, SS9

Two full seasons in the MLB and Addison Russell is still going to hurt your teams BA while only providing decent power numbers (21 HR, 95 RBI). His 2016 performance ranked him as the 17th shortstop in standard roto leagues. He's not even the best hitting shortstop-eligible guy on his team, as Javier Baez flashed more fantasy potential in 450 PA, especially with the added value of SB. The power seems to be maturing nicely, but no ones expecting him to hit over 25 HR. His 2016 BABIP of .277 (career BABIP is .299) does lead me to believe the BA will rise, but we're optimistically looking at .250.

Bottom line: you've waited this long to draft a shortstop, might as well build up your rotation/bullpen and wait a bit longer for a safer guy here. I prefer a couple of the guys listed below, and would also rather have Aledmys Diaz for similar stats with a better BA, Jose Peraza for the SB, or Javier Baez for a little bit of everything. Don't hurt your BA until you absolutely have to, or if you're getting elite numbers in alternate categories from the same hitter.

 

Dansby Swanson, ATL

2017 ADP: 170, SS17

Drafting Swanson before the plethora of veterans falling behind him is a classic rookie-hype move, one in which I would certainly recommend in a dynasty/keeper format. But in standard leagues, let's pump the brakes a bit. Swanson has all of 145 PA at the MLB level, in which he hit three HR with a .302 BA, adding three SB. The BA came with a ridiculous .383 BABIP, and came after hitting .261 in 371 PA at Double A. The common realistic projections I seem to see for Swanson are 13 HR, nine SB, with a BA around (usually below) .260. This sounds a lot like another shortstop who was hyped up in Atlanta, but ended up being much better in real life than in fantasy. Y'all remember Andrelton Simmons? Obviously Simmons wasn't a number one overall pick like Swanson, but both are highly touted for their defensive prowess.

Considering his draft position, Swanson is being drafted as a MIF, which I don't have too much quarrel about. If he does hit his projections, he would rank around the 15-17th among fantasy shortstops. But the fact that he is being drafted in the 15th round means those MIF drafters are passing on proven bats like Logan Forsythe, Neil Walker, and even his teammate Brandon Phillips. That's also passing on less-proven guys that I feel have more realistic upside in 2017 like Devon Travis, Hernan Perez, and Marcus Semien.

 

Undervalued Shortstops

Trevor Story, COL

2017 ADP: 35, SS7

I've been talking up Trevor Story all offseason (50 HR candidates, Bold Predictions, Tier One SS Keepers). I have grown tired of praising his power, but just in case you've missed it: 27 HR in 415 PA, second best ISO and Hard% in the league, and top five flyball percentage. This is the player they had in mind when Coors Field was created. I have and will continue to draft Story before Francisco Lindor, Jonathan Villar, and Xander Bogaerts. They are all great fantasy shortstop options, but none have 40/20 potential like my boy. Villar has the rare speed value but I am going to take the Coors Field inhabitant when I have the choice. The run scoring stats will be there, as he was well on his way to 90 R and 90 RBI after scoring 67 and 72 in his 415 PA. Once Ian Desmond and David Dahl are healthy, Colorado will have one of the highest scoring offenses in the league. Story will be in the thick of it, hitting bombs and stealing bases (and my heart).

Here at RotoBaller, we rank Story 23rd overall. That is ahead of both Lindor and Villar. He is currently being drafted behind all of the stud shortstops, and sliding into the late third round/early fourth round. This is too late for the upcoming production. I love the value so much that I have drafted him, as my MIF, two rounds after picking Carlos Correa in TWO drafts already. If you can get him this late, congratulations. But if you miss out on a historic season because you wanted Francisco Lindor's safe floor, at least I warned you.

 

Eduardo Nunez, SF

2017 ADP: 130, SS10

Nuni caught everyone by surprise right out the gate in 2016, exploding for 12 HR and a .836 OPS heading into the mid summer classic. The second half was less-than-stellar, but he still finished with a cool .288 BA, 16 HR, 40 SB, and also found himself on a championship contender out in San Francisco. Don't let the second half woes fool you into thinking AT&T Park sapped his fantasy value away. In just 21 games in the bay, he hit .307 with two HR.

The 16 HR seem just somewhat of an overachievement for Nunez, even though he owned a HR/FB% that was less than one point higher than 2015. However, the speed is real and I think the spacious AT&T Park will play to his strengths very well as he owns a top 25 contact percentage. Speed is valuable this season, and even though CBS and NFBC leagues are getting it right, Yahoo and ESPN users are still taking Nunez after Addison Russell. Don't do it.

 

Marcus Semien, OAK

2017 ADP: 248, SS22

Even on a much less potent offense, Semien finished 2016 ranked higher than Addison Russell among fantasy shortstops. He hit six more HR, stole five more bases, and hit the same putrid BA. He is still only 26 years old, so why is there more than a 100 pick difference in their ADPs? Both experienced a jump from a 9% HR/FB rate to 14%, and both suffered from significant BABIP decreases. For what it's worth, Steamer, Zips, and CAIRO all project Semien to again beat out Russell in both HR and SB while hitting roughly the same BA. If it's the RBI you are worried about, the Athletics added Rajai Davis to the top of their lineup, now get a full season out of stud Ryon Healy, and will also roll out OBP-machine Matt Joyce against RHP to give Khris Davis and Semien plenty of run-plating opportunities.

In every draft that I do not grab two shortstops in the first four rounds (it looks better than it sounds...kind of), I end up with Marcus Semien as my MIF and I love the value. Obviously you shouldn't take Semien in Addison Russell territory, but passing on the Cubbie and getting Semien nine to 10 rounds later allows for a much more rounded-out roster.

 

Jorge Polanco, MIN

2017 ADP: 382, SS32

Here's a hot take for you. Jorge Polanco will finish the 2017 season ranked ahead of Dansby Swanson in standard fantasy leagues. Yet, for some reason the 23-year-old seems to be forgotten on draft day. Between Triple A and 69 games with the big league crew in 2016, Polanco hit 13 HR and stole nine bases. He doesn't have the skillset to eek out many more long balls than that, but he did total 20 SB in 2015. His line drive percentage was the highest among all shortstops last year, and he showed good plate discipline for a player of his age. Polanco should be the Twins everyday shortstop, and could easily beat out Byron Buxton for the second spot in the lineup. Surrounded by Brian Dozier, Joe Mauer, Miguel Sano, and Max Kepler, Polanco will be a serious sleeper for runs in 2017.

Thanks to the line drives and good plate discipline, Polanco will have a higher BA than Dansby Swanson. He has the chance to score just as many runs, and produce roughly the same HR/SB. The only difference? You can get Polanco 17 rounds later.

 

More Undervalued & Overvalued Picks




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Pete Alonso4 hours ago

Returning To Mets On Two-Year Deal
Jalen Suggs4 hours ago

Remains Out On Wednesday
Andrew Wiggins4 hours ago

Heading To Miami
Dennis Schröder4 hours ago

Dennis Schroder Traded To Jazz
Lonzo Ball4 hours ago

Signs Two-Year Extension
Jonas Valanciunas5 hours ago

Traded To The Kings
Draymond Green5 hours ago

To Play Versus Jazz
Jose Alvarado5 hours ago

Unavailable On Wednesday
Aaron Gordon5 hours ago

To Play On Wednesday
Jimmy Butler5 hours ago

Traded To Warriors
Paul George6 hours ago

Available On Wednesday
Cameron Johnson7 hours ago

Returning Versus Washington
Marcus Smart7 hours ago

Will Play On Wednesday
Brook Lopez7 hours ago

Available On Wednesday Night
Donovan Mitchell7 hours ago

Ruled Out Versus Pistons
Bobby Portis7 hours ago

Returning Against Charlotte
Damian Lillard7 hours ago

Will Play Versus The Hornets
Giannis Antetokounmpo7 hours ago

Good To Go Versus Charlotte
Chris Boucher8 hours ago

Cleared For Action On Wednesday
Alexandre Sarr8 hours ago

Remains Out On Wednesday
Jakob Poeltl8 hours ago

Ruled Out Versus The Grizzlies
Darcy Kuemper8 hours ago

Aims To Continue Home Success Wednesday
Lonzo Ball8 hours ago

Unavailable Against Minnesota On Wednesday
Mattias Samuelsson8 hours ago

Ruled Out For The Rest Of The Week
Ty Dellandrea8 hours ago

Could Be An Option Thursday
Alexander Wennberg8 hours ago

Ruled Out For Third Straight Game
Craig Smith8 hours ago

Expected To Return On Wednesday
Quinn Hughes8 hours ago

To Remain Out On Thursday
Mitchell Marner9 hours ago

Labeled As Day-To-Day
Alex Bregman10 hours ago

Cubs Offer Four-Year Deal To Alex Bregman
Josh Manson11 hours ago

Sustains Lower-Body Injury
Jordan Greenway11 hours ago

Expected To Return After International Break
Tage Thompson11 hours ago

Resumes Skating, Still In Concussion Protocol
Sandy Alcantara11 hours ago

Expected To Be Ready For Opening Day
Dylan Cozens11 hours ago

Battling Lower-Body Injury
Brandon Woodruff11 hours ago

Not Expected To Be Ready For Start Of Spring Training
Ilya Lyubushkin12 hours ago

Exits Early On Tuesday
Christian Yelich12 hours ago

Not Expected To Be 100% For Start Of Spring Training
Sidney Crosby12 hours ago

Absent During Wednesday's Practice
Eric Cole12 hours ago

Faces Challenges At WM Phoenix Open
Gary Woodland12 hours ago

A Strong Value Play At WM Phoenix Open
Lee Hodges12 hours ago

Looks To Build On Strong Start At WM Phoenix Open
Ben Griffin14 hours ago

Still Searching For Consistency At Scottsdale
Rashee Rice14 hours ago

Doing Well
Denny McCarthy14 hours ago

A Volatile Option At WM Phoenix Open
Lucas Glover14 hours ago

Looks To Build On Strong Pebble Beach Finish
Andrew Novak15 hours ago

In Good Form Ahead Of WM Phoenix Open
Keith Mitchell15 hours ago

A Sleeper Pick At WM Phoenix Open
Sam Stevens15 hours ago

Looking To Stay Hot At WM Phoenix Open
Matt Fitzpatrick15 hours ago

Worth Considering At WM Phoenix Open
J.J. Spaun15 hours ago

In Great Form Ahead Of WM Phoenix Open
Davis Thompson15 hours ago

Is Riding The Struggle Bus To Scottsdale
PGA15 hours ago

J.T. Poston Looks To Overcome Putting Woes At WM Phoenix Open
Akshay Bhatia16 hours ago

Looks To Stay Consistent At WM Phoenix Open
Robert MacIntyre16 hours ago

A Solid Option At WM Phoenix Open
Corey Conners16 hours ago

A Boom-Or-Bust Option At WM Phoenix Open
Matthieu Pavon16 hours ago

Should Be Avoided At All Costs At TPC Scottsdale
Nicolai Hojgaard16 hours ago

Will Be Hard To Trust At WM Phoenix Open Debut
PGA16 hours ago

Sungjae Im Searching For Consistency At WM Phoenix Open
Justin Thomas16 hours ago

Looks To Rebound At WM Phoenix Open
William Nylander18 hours ago

Scores Hat Trick On Tuesday
Connor McDavid18 hours ago

Tallies Three Points On Tuesday
Ilya Sorokin18 hours ago

Stands Tall On Tuesday
Alex Tuch18 hours ago

Leads The Way In Victory
Jeremy Swayman18 hours ago

Shuts The Door On Wild On Tuesday
Nick Paul19 hours ago

Exits Early On Tuesday
Max Greyserman1 day ago

A Scary Play At WM Phoenix Open
Shane Bieber1 day ago

Not Expected To Rejoin Rotation Until Midway Through The Season
Nolan Arenado1 day ago

Red Sox Discussing Nolan Arenado Trade
Dylan Guenther1 day ago

Returns To Utah Lineup
Nick Leddy1 day ago

Back For Blues Tuesday
Jose Altuve1 day ago

Has Been Working In Left Field
Kansas City Chiefs2 days ago

Andy Reid Won't Retire After Super Bowl LIX
Travis Kelce2 days ago

Doesn't Appear To Be Eyeing Retirement
Cooper Kupp2 days ago

Rams Seeking Trade Partner For Cooper Kupp
Nassourdine Imavov2 days ago

Picks Up Second-Round Knockout Win At UFC Saudi Arabia
Israel Adesanya2 days ago

Gets Knocked Out At UFC Saudi Arabia
Said Nurmagomedov2 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC Saudi Arabia
Vinicius Oliveira2 days ago

Remains Undefeated In The UFC
Mike Davis2 days ago

Loses Decision At UFC Saudi Arabia
Farés Ziam2 days ago

Fares Ziam Extends His Win Streak To Five
Cleveland Browns3 days ago

Myles Garrett Requests Trade, Browns Sticking To Their Stance
Jack Flaherty3 days ago

Returning To Detroit On Two-Year Contract
Las Vegas Raiders3 days ago

Raiders Hire Chip Kelly As Offensive Coordinator
Shohei Ohtani4 days ago

Expected To Pitch In May
Freddie Freeman4 days ago

Starts Swinging, Not Running
Tyler Glasnow4 days ago

Throwing Bullpens, Feels Good Heading Into Spring Training
Kaan Ofli4 days ago

Suffers Second Straight Loss At UFC Saudi Arabia
Muhammad Naimov4 days ago

Gets Decision Win At UFC Saudi Arabia
Jairzinho Rozenstruik4 days ago

Loses Lackluster Decision At UFC Saudi Arabia
Sergei Pavlovich4 days ago

Snaps Losing Streak At UFC Saudi Arabia
Shara Magomedov4 days ago

Suffers First Career Loss At UFC Saudi Arabia
Michael Page4 days ago

Pulls Off Upset At UFC Saudi Arabia
Chris Godwin4 days ago

Tampa Bay Expected To Attempt To Re-Sign Chris Godwin
Justin Tucker5 days ago

Facing More Sexual-Assault Allegations
Alex Bregman5 days ago

Tigers And Red Sox Emerge As "Co-Favorites" To Land Alex Bregman
Nolan Arenado5 days ago

Cardinals Unable To Find Trade Partner For Nolan Arenado
Dallas Goedert5 days ago

Will Be Good To Go Against Chiefs
DeVonta Smith5 days ago

Expected To Play In Super Bowl
Tampa Bay Buccaneers5 days ago

Josh Grizzard Promoted To Offensive Coordinator
Pete Alonso5 days ago

Reds Showing Interest In Pete Alonso
Israel Adesanya5 days ago

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Nassourdine Imavov5 days ago

Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Vinicius Oliveira5 days ago

An Underdog At UFC Saudi Arabia
Said Nurmagomedov5 days ago

A Favorite At UFC Saudi Arabia
DeVonta Smith5 days ago

Not Practicing Again On Friday
Mike Davis5 days ago

Looks For His Fifth UFC Win
Farés Ziam5 days ago

Fares Ziam Looks For His Fifth Win In A Row
Félix Bautista6 days ago

Felix Bautista Expected To Be Ready For Opening Day

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

 
A.J. Brown - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL DFS Lineup Picks

NFL DFS Lineup Picks For DraftKings - Chiefs vs. Eagles Showdown (Super Bowl LIX)

Welcome back, RotoBallers! We’ve made it to the Super Bowl, and we have a rematch of two years ago as it’ll be Patrick Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs (17-2) taking on Jalen Hurts and the Philadelphia Eagles (17-3). The Eagles are looking for their redemption after losing Super Bowl LVII, while the Chiefs are […]


Dylan Sampson - College Football Rankings, NCAA CFB DFS Lineup Picks

2025 Rookie Draft Sleepers - Targets After The First Two Rounds

The 2025 NFL season is almost over, and it's never too early for Dynasty fantasy football managers to get informed about the incoming rookie class. In 2024, there were plenty of steals -- thanks to NFL scouting regularly underrating great players, it's possible to get massive value in later rounds of rookie drafts. This season […]


Garrett Wilson - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL DFS Picks

2025 Fantasy Football Dynasty FLEX Rankings: (Pre-NFL Draft) - Garrett Wilson, Ladd McConkey, Kyren Williams, George Pickens, Ashton Jeanty, Tyreek Hill

Many dynasty fantasy football leagues have extra flex spots compared to redraft setups, so identifying the top flex options is critical in finding success. Additionally, it can be tough to compare the values of two players at different positions, so we're here to assist with our updated 2025 fantasy football dynasty FLEX rankings before the […]


Bijan Robinson - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Rookies, Draft Sleepers

2025 Fantasy Football Dynasty Running Back Rankings: (Pre-NFL Draft) - Bijan Robinson, Breece Hall, De'Von Achane, Ashton Jeanty, James Cook

Running backs are often the primary building blocks for dynasty fantasy football teams, and having a collection of high-end studs at the position will give you a chance to compete for a championship every season. We're here to help you sort through the RBs with our updated 2025 fantasy football dynasty running back rankings before […]


Brian Thomas Jr - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2025 Fantasy Football Dynasty Wide Receiver Rankings: (Pre-NFL Draft) - Justin Jefferson, Brian Thomas Jr., Nico Collins, Rashee Rice, Marvin Harrison Jr.

It's officially dynasty fantasy football rankings and trading season, and let's kick things off by talking about the superstar wideouts in the NFL. WRs usually hold value longer than running backs and make up the core of your dynasty team. Below, you will find our updated 2025 fantasy football dynasty wide receiver rankings before the […]


Caleb Williams - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

2025 Fantasy Football Dynasty Quarterback Rankings: (Pre-NFL Draft) - Jayden Daniels, Patrick Mahomes, C.J. Stroud, Caleb Williams, Cam Ward, Bo Nix

The 2024-25 NFL season is just about to wrap up, and two of the top dynasty QBs are competing in Super Bowl LIX. Meanwhile, the rest of the league's signal-callers are already beginning preparation for next year, just like dynasty fantasy managers should be doing. Below, you will find our updated 2025 fantasy football dynasty […]


Sam LaPorta - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

2025 Fantasy Football Dynasty Tight End Rankings: (Pre-NFL Draft) - Brock Bowers, Sam LaPorta, Trey McBride, Kyle Pitts, Tyler Warren, Dalton Kincaid

If you play in a fantasy football dynasty league, you know there is no offseason, as trades happen all year long. Much like redraft leagues, tight ends are the trickiest position to navigate in dynasty setups, so we're here to assist. Below, you will find our updated 2025 fantasy football dynasty tight end rankings before […]


Jalen Hurts - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

NFL Prop Bet Picks for Super Bowl LIX - DraftKings Super Bowl Specials

Super Sunday is finally here! Super Bowl LIX will match the Kansas City Chiefs against the Philadelphia Eagles at Caesars Superdome in New Orleans, La., with the Chiefs currently favored by 1.5 points. That being said, we are not here to discuss spreads and totals. Oh no, we are here to discuss the props that […]


Saquon Barkley - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Super Bowl LIX Matchups We Love - Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks Including Jalen Hurts, Saquon Barkley, Travis Kelce, Dallas Goedert, more

The end is near in the NFL. Super Bowl week has finally arrived. NFL fans can rejoice as we near the end of a long season. It is bittersweet to hit this point in the season, but the fireworks that should come with the Super Bowl are too great to ignore. This season's big game […]


C.J. Stroud - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, Waiver Wire Pickups

Biggest Fantasy Football QB Busts From 2024 Season

When to take a quarterback in fantasy football drafts might be the hardest decision to make. Sometimes, spending a top pick on a quarterback like Josh Allen is worth it. Other times, waiting until the sixth round to take a quarterback might be the better move.  During the 2024-25 season, though, there were plenty of quarterbacks who […]


Patrick Mahomes - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

2024-25 Super Bowl LIX Predictions, Picks, and Props

The conference championship round saw a lopsided affair go Philadelphia's way in the NFC while the Chiefs emerged from another hard-fought battle with Buffalo. We've had fun trying to predict the action every step of the way and there's no way we're stopping now with the big one ahead of us. That's right, it's time […]


Derrick Henry - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injury News, DFS Lineup Picks

Five Win-Now Players To Buy In Dynasty Fantasy Football Leagues

When it comes to dynasty fantasy football, the ultimate goal is actually quite simple: winning your league. It seems like common sense, but sometimes managers get caught up in other things. Scouting rookies and looking for value plays is all well and good. But if you’re never in a position to win a title, what’s […]


Chris Godwin - Fantasy Football Rankings, NFL Injuries, DFS

Five Pending Free Agents To Buy In Dynasty Fantasy Football Leagues

There will be plenty of stars who will enter free agency this offseason. As a result, dynasty owners might not want to trade for a player who is set to become a free agent. That's because where these players land could affect their fantasy values. Sometimes, though, it is worth taking a risk on players […]