X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Fantasy Implications of Mark Melancon Joining the San Francisco Giants

Pierre Camus analyzes the fantasy impact of Mark Melancon joining the Giants, including whether he's a viable 2017 fantasy baseball draft pick, value or sleeper.

Mark Melancon wasn't in the running for a record-setting deal like fellow firemen Aroldis Chapman or Kenley Jansen. He settled for $62 million over four years in San Francisco.

The Giants were in desperate need of a proven closer to solidify their bullpen. They now appear to have their man in place which should have a positive trickle-down effect on the entire pitching staff.

Melancon doesn't throw as hard and may not be as exciting as Chapman or Jansen, but is there a chance that he could be more valuable for fantasy owners in 2017?

Editor's note: Be sure to also check out our 2017 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard. It's already loaded up with tons of great rankings articles and draft analysis. Aside from our tiered staff rankings for every position, we also go deep on MLB prospect rankings, impact rookies for 2017, and dynasty/keeper rankings as well. Bookmark the page, and win your drafts.

 

2017 Fantasy Baseball Outlooks

Melancon has quietly been the most reliable closer in the bigs since 2013. He came to Pittsburgh that year as a valuable setup man, recording 26 holds in the first half before taking over the closer role. He saved 16 in the second half of that season, followed by a 33-save season in 2014 and a league-leading 51 saves in 2015. Melancon made his third All-Star appearance and was on his way to another stellar season in 2016 before being traded. Once the Pirates realized their post-season run was over, he was sent to the Nationals and closed out 17 more games en route to free agency before landing in San Francisco.

His 131 saves over the last three years leads all closers, four ahead of Jansen. His strikeout rate doesn't match most of his contemporaries, but an 8.2 K/9 won't hurt fantasy owners either. Since moving to the NL, he hasn't posted an ERA over 2.50 or a WHIP above 1.00. There is little doubt that moving to a pitcher-friendly park in San Fran will keep those ratios at or below their current rate. Playing for a perennial contender like the Giants will keep Melancon in the running for the league lead in saves again.

It's practically a miracle that the Giants managed to reach the postseason in spite of their bullpen. As a team, they led MLB with 30 blown saves on the season. Santiago Casilla led the way (and the majors) with nine blown saves before being mercifully taken out of the closer role in September. He is now in Oakland, but the rest of San Francisco's bullpen should follow a similar hierarchy to last season.

Will Smith, who was acquired from Milwaukee at the trade deadline, should be the eighth-inning lefty option and primary handcuff. Smith wasn't overly impressive in his brief time with the club, posting a 2.95 without a single save. He did have a nice 34.7% K% and struck out nearly 13 per nine innings. The Giants dealt top prospect Phil Bickford to acquire Smith, so the front office must believe he has the stuff to be an important late-inning arm. He is definitely worth a late-round pick in leagues that record holds.

Hunter Strickland did nothing to show that he was closer material, blowing five of eight save opportunities last season. He could see time in the eighth inning but will have competition from fellow righty Derek Law. Law had a nice debut, posting a 2.13 ERA and 0.96 WHIP with 14 holds. Both Strickland and Law have a K/9 comparable to Melancon's 8.2. Barring injury to Melancon and/or Smith, neither should see many save opportunities this season but could again see 15-20 holds apiece. Sergio Romo has saved 84 games for the Giants over the past nine years and served as a valuable setup man, but he is a free agent and it's unclear whether the team will bring him back.

An overlooked impact of Melancon signing in San Francisco could be a slight uptick in wins for their imposing starting staff. Despite posting the best ERA of his career, Madison Bumgarner won three fewer games in 2016 (15) than he had the previous two years (18). Johnny Cueto often took the bullpen out of the equation by throwing a league-leading five CG, so it's hard to imagine his win total going up too much. Jeff Samardzija barely finished with a winning record at 12-11 and only threw one complete game. With a bit more consistency, he could be in line for the most improvement.

Just knowing that one of the most reliable closers in the game is waiting to shut teams down in the ninth inning should give the entire staff a confidence boost. Given the health issues in New York and L.A., San Fran may enter 2017 with the best overall pitching staff in the National League, bolstered by the addition of Melancon for end-game situations.




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Shane Bieber

Staying in Toronto for 2026
Salvador Perez

Agrees to Two-Year Extension With Royals
Gustav Nyquist

Jets Move Gustav Nyquist to Injured Reserve
Noah Hanifin

Expected to Return From 10-Game Absence Tuesday
William Eklund

to Remain Out Wednesday
TB

Max Crozier Available Tuesday
Tristan Jarry

Lands on Injured Reserve
Jason Zucker

Placed on Injured Reserve
Trevor Story

Opts in for Remaining Two Years on his Contract
Pyotr Kochetkov

Starts on Tuesday
Luguentz Dort

Available on Tuesday
Yu Darvish

to Miss All of 2026 Following Flexor-Tendon Surgery
Jacoby Brissett

to Start Again in Week 10
Kyler Murray

Given 4-8 Week Timetable for Foot Injury
Anthony Edwards

Considered Questionable For Wednesday
Yves Missi

Out Tuesday
Zion Williamson

Expected to Miss at Least One Week
Bradley Beal

Sidelined on Tuesday
Kawhi Leonard

Out Versus Thunder on Tuesday
A.J. Brown

Won't be Traded at Deadline
Garrett Wilson

"Untouchable" in Trade Talks
Jakob Poeltl

Questionable Vs. the Bucks on Tuesday
Kawhi Leonard

Uncertain for Tuesday
Precious Achiuwa

Has Agreed to Sign With the Kings
Darius Garland

Could Make Season Debut As Early As Wednesday
Shota Imanaga

Becomes a Free Agent
Jimmy Butler III

Downgraded to Questionable Against the Suns
Luis Robert Jr.

White Sox Pick Up 2026 Option on Luis Robert Jr.
LaMelo Ball

Will Not Play Tuesday
CFB

LJ Martin Expected to Play in Top-10 Matchup Against Texas Tech
PGA

LIV Golf Expanding To 72-Hole Format In 2026
Rashid Shaheed

Being Shipped to the Seahawks
Sauce Gardner

Colts Acquiring Sauce Gardner From the Jets
Travis Hunter

Not Expected to be Out Long-Term
Brian Thomas Jr.

has Low-Grade Ankle Sprain, has Chance to Play in Week 10
Jakobi Meyers

Jaguars Acquiring Jakobi Meyers
Al Horford

Sits Out Tuesday's Game
Chet Holmgren

Back in Thunder Lineup Tuesday
LaMelo Ball

May Remain Out Tuesday
Zion Williamson

Considered Questionable for Tuesday
Jared McCain

on Track to Make Season Debut Tuesday
Joel Embiid

Available Tuesday
Filip Forsberg

Has Multi-Point Outing Monday
Brock Boeser

Notches Three Points in Overtime Victory
Joey Daccord

Continues Home Success Monday
Connor McDavid

Surpasses 1,100 Career Points
Auston Matthews

Sparks Maple Leafs Comeback
Noel Acciari

Sustains Upper-Body Injury
Kyler Murray

Still the Starting QB When Healthy
Atlanta Braves

Braves Hire Walt Weiss as Their Next Manager
Kris Bubic

Cleared to Begin a Throwing Program
Brandon Woodruff

Declines Mutual Option for 2026
Freddy Peralta

Brewers Exercise 2026 Option on Freddy Peralta
Lucas Giolito

Declines his 2026 Player Option
Daniel Gafford

to be Limited on Monday
Jabari Smith Jr.

Sidelined on Monday Night
Josh Hart

Available to Play on Monday
Kyler Murray

Officially Inactive on Monday Night
J.J. Spaun

Finishes Sixth at Procore Championship
PGA

Matti Schmid Finishes Tied for 46th at Baycurrent Classic
Keith Mitchell

Finishes Tied for 10th at Baycurrent Classic
Si Woo Kim

Finishes Tied for 21st at Genesis Championship
Mackenzie Hughes

Misses The Cut at Sanderson Farms Championship
Max Greyserman

Finishes Second at Baycurrent Classic
Austin Eckroat

Finishes Tied for 56th at Baycurrent Classic
Luke Clanton

Finishes Tied for 56th at Bank of Utah Championship
Morgan Barron

Out Week-to-Week
Terry McLaurin

Commanders Don't Think Terry McLaurin Will Play in Week 10
Jayden Daniels

to be "Out for a While" With Dislocated Elbow
Adam Lowry

Ready for Season Debut Tuesday
Pierre-Luc Dubois

to Miss "Extended Period of Time"
Omarion Hampton

Not Expected to Return to Practice Until After Week 12 Bye
Robert Thomas

Set to Return Monday
Quinn Hughes

Available Monday
Justin Brazeau

Remains Out Monday
William Nylander

Rejoins Maple Leafs Lineup Monday
Pete Alonso

Officially Opts Out of his Contract With Mets
Alex Bregman

Opts Out of his Contract With Boston
Edwin Díaz

Edwin Diaz on the Open Market This Winter
Cody Bellinger

Becomes Free Agent After Opting Out
Robert Suarez

Opts Out, Becomes Free Agent
Kyle Larson

Wins His Second NASCAR Cup Series Championship at Phoenix
Ryan Blaney

Concludes the 2025 Season with A Win at Phoenix
William Byron

Strong Championship Effort Ends With Late-Race Flat-Tire Crash
Quinshon Judkins

Browns Optimistic Quinshon Judkins Can Play in Week 10
Tucker Kraft

Done for the Year With Torn ACL
Denny Hamlin

Overtime Four-Tire Call Costs Denny Hamlin the Championship
Chase Briscoe

Championship Bid Never Really Started After Two Tire Failures
Brad Keselowski

Nearly Steals Phoenix Race
David Onama

Suffers First-Round TKO Loss
Steve Garcia

Scores First-Round TKO Win
Ante Delija

Suffers His First UFC Loss
CFB

Dylan Raiola Suffers Season-Ending Injury
Waldo Cortes-Acosta

Gets Knockout Win
Themba Gorimbo

Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 110
Jayden Daniels

Suffers Dislocated Elbow on Sunday Night
Jeremiah Wells

Gets Back In The Win Column
Yadier del Valle

Remains Undefeated
Jayden Daniels

X-Rays Come Back Negative on Jayden Daniels' Left Arm, MRI to Come
Jaelan Phillips

Gets Dealt to Eagles for a Third-Round Pick
Isaac Dulgarian

Cut By UFC Following Submission Loss
Daniel Frunza

Still Winless In The UFC
Charles Radtke

Dominates Daniel Frunza
Allan Nascimento

Gets Submission Win
Philipp Kurashev

Stays Hot on Sunday
Cody Durden

Suffers Second-Round Submission Loss
Jaylen Warren

Records First Career Two-Touchdown Game in Week 9 Win Over Colts
Michael Pittman Jr.

Leads Colts With Nine Catches in Week 9 Loss at Pittsburgh
Max Scherzer

Doesn't Plan on Retiring
Michael King

Becomes Free Agent After Declining Mutual Option
Austin Cindric

is A Driver to Avoid for Phoenix DFS Lineups
Yoshinobu Yamamoto

Named World Series MVP
Alex Bowman

Could Alex Bowman be A Sneaky Tournament Play for Phoenix?
Noah Gragson

Should DFS Players Roster Noah Gragson At Phoenix?
Erik Jones

Is Erik Jones Worth Rostering for DFS at Phoenix?
Michael McDowell

an Easy Recommendation for DFS at Phoenix
Chase Briscoe

Probably Won't Win the Title
Joey Logano

Could Play Spoiler in Championship Battle at Phoenix
Tyler Reddick

Seeking to End Winless Drought, but Probably Won't Have the Speed
NASCAR

Bubba Wallace Looks to Protect Top-10 Points Finish at Phoenix
Brad Keselowski

Hasn't Been Fast at Phoenix With RFK Racing
Daniel Suarez

With Nothing at Stake, Expect Little From Daniel Suarez
Kyle Busch

Qualifies Well, but Will Probably Finish Worse Than he Starts
Chris Buescher

Ryan Preece has a Shot to Overtake Chris Buescher as RFK Racing's Lead Driver
Austin Dillon

Looks to Avoid Finishing Last in NASCAR Playoffs
AJ Allmendinger

A.J. Allmendinger Might be a Worthy DFS Option
Shohei Ohtani

to Start Game 7 of World Series
Alejandro Kirk

X-Rays Come Back Negative on Alejandro Kirk's Hand
David Onama

Set For UFC Vegas 110 Main Event
Steve Garcia

Returns At UFC Vegas 110
Waldo Cortes-Acosta

Set For Co-Main Event
Ante Delija

In Search For His Second UFC Win
Themba Gorimbo

A Favorite At UFC Vegas 110
Jeremiah Wells

Looks To Return To The Win Column
Yadier del Valle

Looks To Remain Undefeated
CFB

Arizona State Quarterback Sam Leavitt Out for the Season
Isaac Dulgarian

Looks To Win Back-To-Back Fights
Daniel Frunza

Looks For His First UFC Win
CFB

Arch Manning Listed as Questionable for Vanderbilt Matchup
CFB

Arion Carter Listed as Questionable Ahead of Oklahoma Matchup

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP