X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Does Pitch Arsenal Really Matter?

In my research over the last couple of months, I have been paying close attention to the pitch mix of each pitcher I study. This means I want to know how many different pitches they can throw and how they distribute those different offerings.

It seemed logical to me that pitchers with more pitches in their repertoire would be better pitchers, and pitchers with fewer would be worse. The other day I realized that I had never actually put that theory to the test, so I was really making a lot of assumptions. So I put it to the test to see what I would find.

I set a 15% requirement here. That means that a pitcher that has four pitches he throws more than 15% of the time will fall into the "four-pitch" category. A pitcher with three pitches over 1% usage goes into the "three-pitch" category, and pitchers with just two offerings over 15% go into the "two-pitch" category. Then I went ahead and took those groupings together and looked at their collective results.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball lineup tools and weekly lineup resources:

 

Trial 1

Four Pitches

Using pitchers that made at least three starts last year, here is the full list of pitchers that threw four different pitches at 15% or more frequency:

Brett Anderson, Cal Quantrill, Carlos Martinez, Casey Mize, David Peterson, Gio Gonzalez, Jeff Samardzija, Jesus Luzardo, Johnny Cueto, Jordan Montgomery, Justus Sheffield, Luis Castillo, Marco Gonzales, Martin Perez, Matt Shoemaker, Mike Fiers, Pablo Lopez, Robbie Erlin, Ryan Castellani, Sixto Sanchez, Sonny Gray, Touki Toussaint, Trevor Cahill, Zac Gallen

Here are the stats this collective group of pitchers has put up:

Year ERA WHIP K/9 CSW% SwStr% AVG SLG
2020 4.46 1.31 8.5 27.8% 10.4% .246 .370
2018-2020 4.22 1.30 8.0 27.2% 10.2% .249 .368

Pretty league average-ish numbers there.

Three Pitches

This is the biggest list, 114 different pitchers fall into this category. Because of that, I will skip listing names and just show the results.

Year ERA WHIP K/9 CSW% SwStr% AVG SLG
2020 4.28 1.29 8.8 28.2% 11.2% .247 .381
2018-2020 4.02 1.25 8.8 27.9% 11.0% .245 .373

Two Pitches

This is also a pretty sizeable list of 61 pitchers. It includes guys like Framber Valdez, Mike Clevinger, Joe Musgrove, Brady Singer, Julio Urias, Max Fried, Tyler Glasnow, and Lucas Giolito.

Year ERA WHIP K/9 CSW% SwStr% AVG SLG
2020 4.52 1.29 9.0 28.0% 11.1% .243 .384
2018-2020 4.33 1.29 8.8 27.8% 11.0% .247 .384

So all together, these groupings of pitchers all look pretty similar. They have nearly identical CSW (called strike + whiff) rates and everything else is also very close. The one that stands out a bit is the four-pitch group being behind in swinging-strike rate. That could be the result of some randomness in how I did this, but I think it could also be a result of some selection bias.

By that I mean, pitchers that only throw or three pitches but have stuck around in the big leagues probably have one or two really good pitches that are good enough to rely on. When you start looking at guys with four or five pitches, that might be a sign that they don't have any dominant pitches and need to survive by just keeping hitters off balance. It makes sense that that could manifest in a lower whiff and strikeout rate, while everything else stays similar - which is what we see here.

 

Trial 2

If we raise the threshold to 25% (meaning now the pitchers in the three-pitch group will be pitchers that have thrown three different pitches over 25% usage) and run it again, here's what we see.

The four-pitch group goes away since nobody threw four pitches exactly 25% of the time. The three-pitch group is restricted to only Brad Keller, Chris Mazza, Gio Gonzalez, Jorge Lopez, Jose Berrios, Masahiro Tanaka, Ryan Yarbrough, Sonny Gray, Tanner Houck, Tyler Anderson, and Wade LeBlanc. The two-pitch and one-pitch groups are about the same size. Here's are how these groups have performed.

Three-Pitch Group

Year ERA WHIP K/9 CSW% SwStr% AVG SLG
2020 4.15 1.43 8.1 28.5% 11.2% .249 .344
2018-2020 4.21 1.29 8.1 27.6% 10.4% .250 .372

Two-Pitch Group

Year ERA WHIP K/9 CSW% SwStr% AVG SLG
2020 4.35 1.29 8.9 28.4% 11.2% .246 .380
2018-2020 4.12 1.27 8.9 28.2% 11.2% .244 .376

One-Pitch Group

Year ERA WHIP K/9 CSW% SwStr% AVG SLG
2020 4.41 1.28 8.9 28.4% 11.2% .246 .380
2018-2020 4.11 1.27 8.7 27.4% 10.8% .246 .375

If you just look at the 2018-2020 rows, the three-pitch group does appear to be the worst. This is pretty much completely opposite of what I expected to find.

 

Does High Velocity Make For a Better Pitcher?

I went ahead and did the same exercise, this time just grouping pitchers by their fastball velocity. I made four groupings based on the average velocity of every four-seamer and sinker thrown by each pitcher. Here's how I made the groups:

Group 1: Velo above 96
Group 2: Velo 93-96
Group 3: Velo 91-93
Group 4: Velo below 91

And here are the results.

Group 1 (high velo)

Year ERA WHIP K/9 CSW% SwStr% AVG SLG
2018-2020 3.52 1.16 10.1 29.4% 12.9% .228 .344

Group 2 (medium-high velo)

Year ERA WHIP K/9 CSW% SwStr% AVG SLG
2018-2020 4.26 1.29 9.2 28.0% 11.2% .245 .373

Group 3 (medium-low velo)

Year ERA WHIP K/9 CSW% SwStr% AVG SLG
2018-2020 4.21 1.29 8.4 27.3% 10.7% .249 .381

Group 4 (low velo)

Year ERA WHIP K/9 CSW% SwStr% AVG SLG
2018-2020 4.21 1.27 7.9 27.3% 9.9% .253 .389

The super high-velocity pitchers (guys like Yu Darvish, Dinelson Lamet, Jacob deGrom, Gerrit Cole, Tyler Glasnow) clearly stand above the rest. There are huge differences between that grouping and the rest. However, you can tell that the 93-95 mile per hour pitchers aren't significantly better than the slowest velocity pitchers. They get more strikeouts, yes, but the ERA and WHIP measures are right around the same.

 

Conclusion

Honestly, my thought when I started this was that I would prove that it's better to have a diverse pitch arsenal and then point out to all of you a list of names of guys that have it. Since this study proved me wrong, I can't do that anymore.

What I will say is that, hey, you shouldn't really care how many pitches a guy throws when evaluating them, because the number of pitches in your pitch arsenal does not seem to correlate with success. Having a heavy fastball sure does though, so you can bump up any pitchers entering the league that are hitting 97+ on the gun.

So that was a bit anti-climactic, but hopefully this will dispel any previously held myths that more pitches means more success.



Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy baseball app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, sleepers, prospects & more. All free!



More Fantasy Baseball Advice




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Cody Bellinger18 mins ago

Cubs Looking To Trade Cody Bellinger?
Brandin Cooks19 mins ago

Preparing To Play In Week 12
CeeDee Lamb24 mins ago

Not Seen At Thursday's Practice
32 mins ago

Blake Snell Has Met With Red Sox, Dodgers
Aaron Rodgers1 hour ago

Jets Owner Suggested Benching Aaron Rodgers
Mike Evans3 hours ago

Practicing Again On Thursday
Chandler Stephenson4 hours ago

Registers Three Assists Versus Predators
Jason Robertson4 hours ago

Totals Three Points In Wednesday's Win
Nils Lundkvist4 hours ago

Exits Early With A Lower-Body Injury
Matthew Knies4 hours ago

Sustains An Upper-Body Injury
Mikael Granlund4 hours ago

Exits Late With Injury Wednesday
Patrik Laine4 hours ago

Returns To Practice
Ausar Thompson5 hours ago

Listed As Doubtful For Thursday
Walker Kessler5 hours ago

Still Missing For Jazz
Jordan Clarkson5 hours ago

Questionable To Face Spurs
Devin Vassell5 hours ago

To Miss Third Consecutive Game
Chris Paul5 hours ago

Considered Probable For Thursday's Game
Khris Middleton5 hours ago

Medically Cleared To Play
Chris Sale15 hours ago

Wins National League Cy Young Award
Tarik Skubal16 hours ago

Wins 2024 American League Cy Young Award
Paul George16 hours ago

Exits Game On Wednesday, Hyperextends Left Knee Again
Scoot Henderson17 hours ago

Leaves Game On Wednesday, Won't Return
Jalen Johnson17 hours ago

Active On Wednesday Night
Zach Collins17 hours ago

Uncertain To Play On Thursday
Austin Eckroat17 hours ago

Heads To The RSM Classic After Win
Harris English17 hours ago

Finding Form Heading To The RSM Classic
Ben Griffin17 hours ago

Continues Playing Well Heading To The RSM Classic
Denny McCarthy17 hours ago

Returns to The RSM Classic
Patrick Williams18 hours ago

Likely To Miss At Least One Week
Kyle Anderson18 hours ago

Available For Matchup With Hawks
Victor Wembanyama18 hours ago

Out Again On Thursday
Jusuf Nurkic18 hours ago

Available On Wednesday
Stephen Curry18 hours ago

Will Play Against Atlanta
De'Anthony Melton18 hours ago

To Undergo Season-Ending ACL Surgery
Tre Mann18 hours ago

Probable For Thursday Night Matchup Against Detroit
Mike Conley18 hours ago

Appears On Injury Report For Thursday With Toe Injury
Donte DiVincenzo18 hours ago

Questionable Heading Into Thursday
Josh Jacobs19 hours ago

Limited With Multiple Injuries
DeVonta Smith19 hours ago

Misses Practice On Wednesday
Isaiah Hartenstein19 hours ago

To Make Season Debut On Wednesday
Tyrese Maxey19 hours ago

Active On Wednesday
Seth Jones21 hours ago

Expected To Miss Four Weeks
Sam Darnold21 hours ago

Limited With Foot Injury
Max Domi21 hours ago

Placed On Injured Reserve
Jalen Hurts21 hours ago

Limited On Wednesday
Connor Ingram21 hours ago

Out Day-To-Day With An Upper-Body Injury
Jake Ferguson21 hours ago

Picks Up A DNP On Wednesday
Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen21 hours ago

Returns To Action Versus Kings
CeeDee Lamb21 hours ago

Listed As Limited, Dealing With Two Injuries
Alex Tuch21 hours ago

Available Wednesday
Tage Thompson21 hours ago

Remains Out On Wednesday
Sam LaPorta21 hours ago

Practicing In Full
Jordan Eberle21 hours ago

To Remain Out On Wednesday
George Kittle22 hours ago

Will Play In Week 12
Ludvig Aberg22 hours ago

Looks To Defend RSM Classic Title
Ladd McConkey22 hours ago

Does Not Practice On Wednesday
Si Woo Kim22 hours ago

An Intriguing Option At RSM Classic
Maverick McNealy22 hours ago

In Solid Form Ahead Of RSM Classic
Eric Cole22 hours ago

Chasing First Tour Victory At RSM Classic
San Francisco 49ers22 hours ago

Nick Bosa Does Not Practice On Wednesday
Christian McCaffrey22 hours ago

Does Not Practice On Wednesday
George Kittle22 hours ago

Limited During Wednesday's Practice
Brock Purdy22 hours ago

Limited On Wednesday
Alexander Mattison23 hours ago

Zamir White Not Practicing On Wednesday
Sam LaPorta23 hours ago

Trending Towards Playing In Week 12
Calvin Ridley1 day ago

Out Wednesday With Illness
Isiah Pacheco1 day ago

To Practice On Wednesday
Connor Bedard1 day ago

Ends Drought With Two Assists
Sam Reinhart1 day ago

Pushes Point Streak To 11 Games
Mark Scheifele1 day ago

Celebrates Ninth Career Hat Trick
Evan Bouchard1 day ago

Rocks Senators With Three-Point Period
Connor McDavid1 day ago

Nets Two Goals During Three-Point Night
TB1 day ago

Nicholas Paul Exits Early With Injury Tuesday
Zach Hyman1 day ago

Sits Out Third Period Versus Senators
2 days ago

Guardians' Stephen Vogt Named AL Manager Of The Year
Milwaukee Brewers2 days ago

Pat Murphy Named NL Manager Of The Year
Jonas Brodin2 days ago

Returns To Action
2 days ago

Nick Pivetta Declines Boston's Qualifying Offer
Jose Siri2 days ago

Mets Acquire Jose Siri From The Rays
2 days ago

Phillies To Meet With Juan Soto
2 days ago

Luis Severino Rejects Qualifying Offer From Mets
2 days ago

Willy Adames Declines Brewers Qualifying Offer
2 days ago

Teoscar Hernandez Declines Qualifying Offer From Dodgers
2 days ago

Juan Soto Declines Yankees' Qualifying Offer
Luis Gil3 days ago

Wins AL Rookie Of The Year Award
Paul Skenes3 days ago

Named 2024 NL Rookie Of The Year
Brady Singer3 days ago

Reds, Royals Discussing Jonathan India, Brady Singer
3 days ago

Sean Manaea To Reject Mets' Qualifying Offer
3 days ago

Braves Have Interest In Walker Buehler
3 days ago

Astros Interested In Willy Adames
Charles Oliveira3 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Michael Chandler3 days ago

Gets Dominated At UFC 309
Karine Silva3 days ago

Suffers Her First UFC Loss
Viviane Araujo3 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Mauricio Ruffy3 days ago

Extends His Win Streak To Six
Nick Martinez4 days ago

Signs Qualifying Offer With Reds
4 days ago

Luis Severino Likely To Decline Qualifying Offer From Mets
James Llontop4 days ago

Loses Clear-Cut Decision In Thrilling Fight At UFC 309
Paul Craig4 days ago

Loses Decision At UFC 309
Bo Nickal4 days ago

Remains Undefeated With Lackluster Performance At UFC 309
Stipe Miocic4 days ago

Retires After UFC 309 Loss
Jon Jones4 days ago

Gets TKO Win At UFC 309 To Defend Heavyweight Title

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP