X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Just the Worst: Starting Pitchers

Nicklaus Gaut looks at some of the most disappointing fantasy baseball starting pitchers from the early rounds to see if they are getting any closer to meeting their preseason expectations.

After living through the bouncy-ball, home run-a-palooza for the last few seasons, 2021 has brought with it pitching dominance not seen since guys named Noodle Hahn and Snake Wiltse were pitching dead balls for 300+ innings.

However, not every pitcher has seen great results with the new baseball that 2021 has wrought, and you don't have to go down the spring's ADP too far before tripping over some deadweight that may be anchoring your team to the bottom of the standings.

Early round players falling flat are always a disappointment but it's a real stomach punch when it's one of your aces doing the tripping. That's obviously because of what their performance does to your stats but early pitchers failing is even worse considering that those picks will generally define the flow of your draft. IE. If you went with a "pocket aces" strategy (let's say Lucas Giolito and Aaron Nola, for argument's sake) and then loaded up on a long string of bats, there is even more pressure on those aces to carry the weight of your pitching staff's freight.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball lineup tools and resources:

 

The Bad

I'm not exactly mad, just disappointed. Isn't that worse, though? These are the starters who haven't broken your team, returning positive, or nearly positive value so far in 2021. It's just that they were drafted to be so much more. And now that we're almost a third of the way into the season, fantasy managers need to make decisions about how to fix their pitching woes if their pocket aces have played more like a deuce.

Lucas Giolito, CHW ($6.2, SP 46)

2021: 55.2 IP - 4 W - 66 SO - 4.04 ERA - 1.17 WHIP

I mean, Lucas Giolito hasn't been a disaster, save for a couple of blowups but his $6.2 in value through 10 starts (SP 46) isn't exactly inspiring from someone who, on average, was the sixth pitcher being drafted.

Giolito's changeup is still magical and his fastball, while not as good as last season (-0.9 RV per 100 pitches), is still a positive pitch (-0.3 RV/100), getting elite rise (1.7 inches more than the average four-seamer thrown at similar velocity and movement) and above-average break (0.7 inches more than average). The big disappointment has been his slider.

It's not that the slider was great before but it was at least an average offering to go with the plus combo of his fastball and changeup, posting a +0.2 RV/100 in 2020 and -0.1 RV/100 in 2019. However, it's down to a +2.0 RV/100 in 2021 and may be contributing to his ongoing home run problem (1.46 HR/9 in 2021, up from 1.00 HR/9 in 2020 and 1.22 HR/9 in 2019). Giolito's nine home runs allowed in 2021 have been evenly split across his pitch mix, with three each coming off of his fastball, changeup, and slider. But he only uses the slider 17.3% of the time, while using his fastball and changeup a combined 82.7%. That works out to one home run per 116 changeups and one per 145 fastballs...And one for every 54 sliders.

The slider is the least-used of Giolito's repertoire but it used to be a bigger put-away pitch, with a 26.8% PutAway% in 2019. However, that dropped to 19.2% in 2020 and currently sits at 15.4% in 2021. He's not using it more for a good reason, as batters fear it less and are making more contact. Its 18.9% SwStr% in 2021 is virtually the same as in 2020 but is down from 22.3% in 2020, while his 35.2% Whiff% is also an all-time low, down from 52.6% Whiff% in 2020, and 41.8% Whiff% in 2019.  And the swing rate against his slider is also an all-time high; it has a 53.7% Swing% in 2021, up from 42.5% in 2020, and 46.9% in 2019.

A change in shape might be making Giolito's slidepiece go rusty, the velocity is up a tick from previous seasons (86 mph in 2021, 84.9 mph in 2020, 84.6 mph in 2019), with the faster pitch getting three fewer inches of drop and 1.3 fewer inches of break. Thrown primarily to right-handers, these changes are leaving a lot more sliders in the middle of the plate.

Here it was in 2020:

And in 2021:

Once again, here he was in 2020, with the slider in yellow, the changeup in green, and the four-seamer in red:

And 2021:

The slider needs some tweaking but that might already be happening. In his last two starts (MIN, STL), Giolito has pitched a combined 14 innings, allowing just two earned runs while striking out 16, with a season-high 20.7% slider usage. Batters posted a 26.2% SwStr% and 47.8% Whiff% against it in those two starts, garnering just two hits and a .137 xwOBA, with locations that were a lot less meaty. Remember his heat map from earlier?

Here it is from those two starts:

Those rostering Giolito probably only need to bury their disappointment for a little while longer, as the ace is already turning things around and will face two of the worst teams in baseball for his next two starts, lined up to face Baltimore and Detroit at home.

 

Aaron Nola, PHI ($5.8, SP 48)

2021: 59.1 IP - 3 W - 70 SO - 3.94 ERA - 1.13 WHIP 

A lot of fantasy players entered 2021 with Aaron Nola as their presumed SP 1 or as the second bullet in their pocket-aces strategy. Things have been ho-hum, at best but perhaps that ho-hum designation has less to do with talent and is more simply a problem of misplaced expectations.

Nola's 3.94 ERA isn't exactly terrible and is backed by evaluators that speak both to more success in the future and a bit of unluckiness in the past, with a 2.98 FIP, 3.32 xFIP, and 3.18 SIERA. And a 1.13 WHIP and 28.5% K% aren't anything to sneeze at but they aren't the 33.2% K% and 1.08 WHIP from 2020.

I'm not saying the elevated strikeout rate from 2020 was an illusion but it is the outlier when looking at Nola's career:

Season G IP SO K%
2015 13 77 68 21.4%
2016 20 111 121 25.1%
2017 27 168 184 26.6%
2018 33 212 224 27.0%
2019 34 202 229 26.9%
2020 12 71 96 33.2%
2021 10 59 70 28.5%

Batters are missing less, with a 28.1% Whiff% that's down three points from 2020, and a 12.5% SwStr% that's down a point (but still up from 11.0% in 2019). They're also swinging more overall, evidenced by Nola's career-high 49.3% Swing %, but most directly on pitches in the zone, with his 66.4% Zone Swing% (up from 60.6% in 2020 and 58.8% in 2019) and 73.2% Meatball Swing% (up from 66.1% in 2020 and 67.7% in 2019) both tracking at new career highs. But they're also not chasing the cheese; Nola's 30.2% Chase% may not be a career-low but it's the lowest since 2018 and is down from 36.5% in 2020.

Translation? Batters are being fooled less and are more than content to wait for Nola to come back over the plate before they pounce. And he's giving them plenty of opportunities to do so; his 52.7 Zone% (44.0% in 2020, 46.2% in 2019) is a career-high, and his 7.6% Meatball% (5.4% in 2020, 5.8% in 2019) is the highest since 2018.

Looking at his individual pitches, Nola has a couple of culprits in terms of his decrease in whiffery. His changeup has dropped from a 19.7% SwStr% and 36.0% Whiff% in 2020, to a 16.2% SwStr% and 25.7% Whiff% in 2021, while his vaunted curveball has seen even bigger drops. It had a 22.5% SwStr% and 41.8% Whiff% in 2020 but is down to a 15.5% SwStr% and 33.6% Whiff% in 2021. Remember that SwStr% is the number of whiffs divided by the number of pitches thrown, while Whiff% takes out the batter's decision to offer at the pitch,  measuring just the number of whiffs divided by the number of swings. Drops in either aren't great but I find decreases in SwStr% to be more troubling, as it is telling you not only how much batters whiff but how often they're enticed to swing in the first place.

The changeup may not have seen as big of a whiff drop as his curveball but going back to batters being willing to wait for something over the plate, it might be a big part of the problem. Its run value per 100 pitches has gone from a -0.7 RV/100 in 2019 and 2020, to a 1.9 RV/100 in 2021, rising from a .249 wOBA and .331 wOBAcon in 2020 to a .293 wOBA and .442 wOBAcon in 2021.

Care to guess which of the following heat maps is from 2020, and which is from 2021?

A?

Or B?

The final trouble lurking is that Nola is apparently a fly-ball pitcher now? At least, all of the career-highs and lows in his batted-ball data below is showing hitters having an easier time elevating:

Season Launch Angle GB % FB % Top% Under%
2015 9.4 49.8 18.3 37.1 20.1
2016 6.0 56.9 14.1 40.4 16.5
2017 9.0 50.4 21.8 35.6 23.1
2018 9.1 52.4 17.7 40.4 23.1
2019 9.2 50.9 20.7 37.2 18.8
2020 8.6 49.4 13.7 38.1 20.2
2021 12.7 41.7 28.2 28.8 28.8

Even with the troubles in his changeup and curveball, I'm still not that down on Nola. But I also wasn't just that high on him in the first place, at least relative to his draft price, with Nola having a 23 ADP in NFBC heading into 2021, on average coming in as the 8th pitcher being taken. It goes back to the bigger problem with expectations. I'll happily slot Nola in as a yearly top-20 pitcher, with his excellent strikeout rate and propensity to pile up innings making him a safe bet for a high floor; the problem is letting last year's 33% K% trick you into thinking he's a top-10 starter. He's not. And that's okay! I have zero exposure to him this year but you best believe I'm starting to sniff around the unhappy managers who drafted him as their SP 1 and are ready to make a change.

 

And The Ugly

These are the team breakers, as their combination of staff-anchoring draft capital and numbers that look like they've pitched every game in Colorado have made them totally unbeatable. And by unbeatable, I mean your opponents.

Let's first fulfill my legal obligation to start any list of bad pitchers with Luis Castillo, who was drafted as a top-10 pitcher but is quite literally the least valuable pitcher, according to the FanGraphs auction calculator, with his -$26.4 earned in a 12-team league coming in dead last. You might as well have been starting Mitch Keller.

Things are so bad that the fantasy crowd went wild after he only allowed three runs in five innings versus the Giants on May 18, striking out a season-high 11 batters. He's back!... Until he allowed five earned runs in five innings versus the Brewers in his last start, striking out five and walking four.

Castillo's evaluators say he hasn't been as bad as his no-good, rotten 7.61 ERA says he's been, with a 4.77 FIP and 4.44 xERA, while his 4.08 xFIP and 4.36 SIERA point to better times ahead. The most troubling thing, however, is how his elite strikeout rate (28.9% K% in 2019, 30.5% in 2020) has up and disappeared, posting just a 19.9% K% over his first 10 starts, with an 11.3% SwStr% that's down from 15.4% in 2020. And his once showpiece changeup, formerly adept at getting whiffs and poor contact, is now pairing with his sinker to form one of the worst combos in baseball.

Given his current status of being a high-level hot mess, I have no desire to go out of my way to buy low on Castillo; I'm only in the game if I know his owner is someone is sick and tired of the scourge of Luis Castillo being on their team. If you're in a league with this person, you know exactly what I'm talking about. If I can get him for a big bargain, say as the stapler onto a deal with bigger principles, I'm in. But I'm not getting near him without the big discount because until Castillo gets his changeup ironed out (+2.1 RV/100 in 2021, up from -0.7 RV/100 in 2020, and -2.7 RV/100 in 2019), there's no guarantee he'll turn it around.

Kenta Maeda has made a lot of problems for himself, with a 4.98 xERA and 5.10 FIP that say he's deserved every bit of his 5.26 ERA over his first starts, pitching just 37 innings, with a 1.57 WHIP (down from 0.75 WHIP in 2020), and his 19.4% K% is down 13-points from last season. And now he's back to the IL, with his groin continuing to cause him issues.

Maeda has many issues but let's focus on the slider, a former whiff machine, posting a 25.2% SwStr% in 2018, 22.3% SwStr% in 2019, and 19.7% SwStr% in 2020. The usage is at an all-time high but the whiffs have dropped again, with a career-low 15.2% SwStr% and 27.5% Whiff% (also a career-low), while batters have posted a .408 wOBA and .330 xwOBA against it - both are also career-worst marks.

I'll take any deal if it's good enough but I'm certainly not targeting Maeda. He'll be better than the pile he's been so far but he's on a bad team, is older than you think (33-years-old), and doesn't have a long track record as a full-time starter. That and a lingering groin issue just make too many variables for me to want to mess around with.

Welcome to my personal nightmare, as I finally decided to buy into Kyle Hendricks and am just getting smacked around by a guy who was supposed to be boring but safe. And yet, here we are. According to the auction calculator, Hendricks has been the SP 115, with four wins, a 4.74 ERA, and a 1.50 WHIP over his first 49.1 IP. Just like we all imagined.

The good news is that Hendricks has pitched much better since allowing seven earned runs to Atlanta on April 28 - which was his second seven-run outing versus Atlanta in as many weeks - allowing just one earned run in three of his last four starts, allowing 4 ER to the Pirates in the other. And while his line versus Pittsburgh was bad, most of the damage was done by a bevy of weak singles. He'll get a chance for revenge in his next start, lined up to face the Pirates on the road before heading home for a matchup versus the Padres.



Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy baseball app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, sleepers, prospects & more. All free!



More Fantasy Baseball Advice




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Ar'Darius Washington

Goes on PUP List
Lamar Jackson

to be Even Better in 2025?
Tre Harris

Agrees to Terms on Rookie Deal
Justin Herbert

Off to Good Start at Training Camp
Jameson Williams

Earning Rave Reviews from Lions Coaches
Christian Mahogany

Expected to Start for Lions
Zach Allen

an Extension Candidate in Denver?
Zaire Franklin

May Miss Start of Training Camp
Portland Trail Blazers

Damian Lillard Returning to Portland
Mason Taylor

to Play "Crucial" Role in Jets' Offense
Paul Skenes

Pirates Could Preserve Paul Skenes in Second Half
T.J. Watt

Once Again Becomes Highest-Paid Non-QB
RJ Harvey

Reaches Agreement on Four-Year Rookie Contract
Rashee Rice

Chiefs Believe Rashee Rice Will Receive Two- to Four-Game Suspension
Brooks Barnhizer

Grabs 19 Points, Nine Boards in Summer League Win
Jack Kiser

Inks Rookie Deal With Jaguars
Mike Green

Expected to Sign Rookie Deal with Ravens on Thursday
Mike Williams

Retiring After Eight NFL Seasons
Jeremiah Fears

Scores 22 Points in Summer League Loss to Thunder
Jordan Addison

Pleads Guilty to Lesser Offense, Gets Fine and Probation
Jordan Mims

Titans Add Backfield Depth With Jordan Mims
Isaiah Collier

Collects 17 Points In Summer League Win
Anthony Richardson Sr.

Believed to be Recovered From Shoulder Injury
Najee Harris

Chargers Place Najee Harris on NFI List
Caleb Houstan

Joins Hawks
Shemar Turner

Bears, Shemar Turner Agree to Terms on Rookie Deal
AJ Johnson

Erupts for 25 Points in Summer League Loss
Rashee Rice

Sentenced to Jail Time and Five-Year Probation, Likely to Face Suspension
Washington Wizards

Leaky Black Logs Double-Double in Loss to Jazz
Connor Norby

Undergoes Surgery, Expected to Miss 6-8 Weeks
Trey Alexander

Tallies 25 Points in Losing Effort
Johni Broome

Records Second Consecutive Double-Double
Jahmir Young

Has Historic Summer League Outing
Rob Dillingham

Plays Big Role in Wednesday's Win
Tyrese Proctor

Erupts for 35 Points Against Kings
Cody Williams

Leads Jazz to Victory Against Wizards
LeBron James

Mavs Not Interested in "Gutting its Roster" For LeBron James
Josh Hart

Undergoes a Procedure on Right Finger
Jake Burger

Goes on 10-Day Injured List With Quad Strain
Sal Frelick

Dealing With Grade 1 Hamstring Strain, TBD for Start of Second Half
Chris Sale

Plays Catch
Los Angeles Clippers

Bradley Beal Heading to Los Angeles to Join Clippers After Contract Buyout
Rayan Rupert

Scores 24 Points in Summer League Win
Derik Queen

Collects Third Consecutive Double-Double in Summer League Loss
GG Jackson II

Records 13 Points in Summer League Action on Tuesday
Johni Broome

Logs Double-Double Against Wizards
DaRon Holmes II

Records Double-Double in Summer League Loss to Raptors
Kyle Schwarber

Named All-Star Game MVP
Harris English

Takes Stellar 2025 Performance to The Open Championship
Aldrich Potgieter

Seeks Better Result in Northern Ireland
Cameron Young

Likely to Hang Around at The Open Championship
Cameron Smith

Just Trying to Make the Cut at Royal Portrush
Jordan Spieth

Is Jordan Spieth Still a Natural for Links Style Golf?
Patrick Reed

a Viable Option at The Open Championship
PGA

Sungjae Im Wants to Rebound from Last Experience at Royal Portrush
Xander Schauffele

Looks to Defend His Claret Jug at Royal Portrush
Tony Finau

Trying to Turn Tide at Royal Portrush
Daniel Brown

Seeks a Rebound at The Open Championship
Rory McIlroy

Will be the Most Watched Player This Week at Royal Portrush
Daniel Berger

Trending Poorly as The Open Championship Looms
Clayton Kershaw

Retires Both Batters In ASG Appearance
Eugenio Suárez

Eugenio Suarez Hit In Pinky In All-Star Game, X-Rays Negative
MLB

NL All-Stars Win On Tie-Breaker Home Run Swing-Off
Robert MacIntyre

Hoping to Bounce Back at Open Championship
Shane Lowry

Hopes to Repeat at Royal Portrush
Brian Harman

Hopes to Rekindle Some Magic at the 153rd Open
UTA

Michael Carcone Returns to Utah on One-Year Contract
Bowen Byram

Signs Two-Year Deal with Sabres
Morgan Barron

Jets Re-Sign Morgan Barron for Two Years
PGA

Chris Gotterup Punches Ticket to Royal Portrush With Win at Scottish Open
Bryson DeChambeau

Hopes to Reverse Links Golf Struggle at the 153rd Open
Keegan Bradley

Needs to Find The Weekend at Royal Portrush for Ryder Cup Hopes
Oneil Cruz

Ties Home Run Derby Distance Record
Cal Raleigh

Wins 2025 Home Run Derby
Justin Thomas

Finishes Tied For 22nd at Genesis Scottish Open
Scottie Scheffler

Finishes Tied For Eighth at Genesis Scottish Open
Jon Rahm

Finishes in Second at LIV Andalucia
Tallison Teixeira

Suffers First-Round TKO
Derrick Lewis

Scores First-Round TKO
Michael Lorenzen

Royals Put Michael Lorenzen on Injured List With Oblique Strain
Stephen Thompson

Loses Controversial Split Decision
Gabriel Bonfim

Wins Controversial Split Decision
Calvin Kattar

Gets Outclassed At UFC Nashville
Steve Garcia

Extends His Win Streak
Nate Landwehr

Gets Knocked Out
Morgan Charrière

Morgan Charriere Scores Third-Round Knockout
Austen Lane

Suffers Submission Loss
Vitor Petrino

Scores First-Round Submission In Heavyweight Debut
Tuco Tokkos

Earns His First UFC Win
Junior Tafa

Unsuccessful in his Light-Heavyweight Debut
Chase Elliott

Charges to A Finish of Third At Sonoma
Chase Briscoe

Finishes Second With his First Career Road-Course Top-Five at Sonoma
Christopher Bell

Rollercoaster Day Ends With Top-5 Finish at Sonoma
William Byron

Maintains the Regular-Season Points Lead
Kyle Busch

Earns A Hard-Fought Top-10 Finish At Sonoma
Alex Ovechkin

Not Thinking About Retirement
PIT

Penguins Acquire Arturs Silovs
NHL

Nikolai Kovalenko Returns to Russia
Yoshinobu Yamamoto

Tosses Gem Against Giants
Shota Imanaga

Shuts Down Yankees on Sunday
Nathan Eovaldi

Dominant Again in Seventh Win
Tyler Reddick

Evades Near Upset to Remain Alive in In-Season Challenge
Ty Gibbs

One of Three Tylers to Make In-Season Challenge Semifinals
Kyle Larson

Curiously Mediocre at Sonoma Before Late-Race Crash
NASCAR

John H. Nemechek Edges Out Teammate to Make In-Season Challenge Semifinal
Alex Bowman

Ty Dillon Bumps Alex Bowman to Advance to In-Season Challenge Semifinal
Chicago White Sox

Billy Carlson Goes 10th Overall to White Sox
Cincinnati Reds

Steele Hall Selected Ninth by Cincinnati
Toronto Blue Jays

Blue Jays Select JoJo Parker with Eighth Overall Pick
Miami Marlins

Marlins Select Aiva Arquette With Seventh Overall Pick
Pittsburgh Pirates

Pirates Select Seth Hernandez with Sixth Overall Pick
Kyle Stowers

Punishes Former Team with Three-Homer Game
Shane Van Gisbergen

Can Anyone Beat Shane van Gisbergen at Sonoma?
Tyler Reddick

Better at Sonoma Than Record Shows
Chase Elliott

a Prime DFS Option at Sonoma
Michael McDowell

Struggling a Bit at Sonoma
NASCAR

Christopher Bell Has Never Finished Better Than Ninth at Sonoma
Ryan Blaney

Has Top-10 Upside at Sonoma
NASCAR

Sunday at Sonoma Will Likely Be a Long Race for Bubba Wallace
Kyle Larson

Is A Likely Top-Five Contender for Sonoma
Ryan Preece

Points Position Could Affect Race at Sonoma
Todd Gilliland

Struggling to Find Speed at Sonoma
Ty Gibbs

May be an Underrated Favorite to Compete for the Win at Sonoma
Erik Karlsson

Open to Move Away From Pittsburgh
Zach Hyman

Hopes to be Ready for Start of Next Season
SJ

Jeff Skinner Joins Sharks on One-Year Contract
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF