2021 Outfielder Rankings - 5x5 Mixed Leagues

4 years ago by Daniel Fox

Link copied to clipboard!

We now move on to the outfielder position in our mixed-league rankings analysis series. If you missed them, here is our review of Catcher, First Base, Second Base, Third Base and Shortstop.

RotoBaller's rankers, JB Branson, Pierre Camus, Nick Mariano, and Ariel Cohen have updated our 2021 Mixed League rankings once more based on early spring training action.

You can also find our other draft rankings for all sorts of league formats, continually updated throughout the preseason, right here in our main fantasy baseball Rankings Wizard tool. Also, make use of all our premium resources with our MLB Draft Kit.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball lineup tools and weekly lineup resources:

2021 Fantasy Baseball Outfielder Rankings

In case you missed it, our very own "Big Pick Nick" Mariano was named the #1 overall most accurate industry expert ranker for the 2018 season, and Ariel Cohen was the top ranker in 2019. In addition, ATC Projections by Ariel Cohen were the #1 most accurate projections system in 2019. Be sure to follow their updated rankings and projections all season long!

Ranking	Tier	Player	Position
1	1	Ronald Acuna Jr.	OF
2	1	Juan Soto	OF
3	1	Mookie Betts	OF
4	1	Mike Trout	OF
5	1	Christian Yelich	OF
6	2	Cody Bellinger	1B/OF
7	2	Bryce Harper	OF
8	2	Eloy Jimenez	OF
9	2	Kyle Tucker	OF
10	3	Marcell Ozuna	OF
11	3	Luis Robert	OF
12	3	Whit Merrifield	2B/OF
13	3	George Springer	OF
14	3	Starling Marte	OF
15	3	Aaron Judge	OF
16	3	Yordan Alvarez	OF
17	4	Randy Arozarena	OF
18	4	Trent Grisham	OF
19	4	Michael Conforto	OF
20	4	Teoscar Hernandez	OF
21	4	Nick Castellanos	OF
22	5	J.D. Martinez	OF
23	5	Cavan Biggio	2B/3B/OF
24	5	Brandon Lowe	2B/OF
25	5	Austin Meadows	OF
26	5	Lourdes Gurriel Jr.	OF
27	5	Eddie Rosario	OF
28	5	Charlie Blackmon	OF
29	5	Jeff McNeil	2B/3B/OF
30	5	Alex Verdugo	OF
31	5	Tommy Pham	OF
32	5	Mike Yastrzemski	OF
33	5	Jorge Soler	OF
34	5	Wil Myers	OF
35	6	Dominic Smith	1B/OF
36	6	Byron Buxton	OF
37	6	Michael Brantley	OF
38	6	Joey Gallo	OF
39	6	Ramon Laureano	OF
40	6	Kyle Lewis	OF
41	6	Anthony Santander	OF
42	6	Ryan Mountcastle	1B/OF
43	6	Victor Robles	OF
44	6	Max Kepler	OF
45	6	Dylan Moore	2B/OF
46	7	Dylan Carlson	OF
47	7	Tommy Edman	2B/3B/SS/OF
48	7	Andrew McCutchen	OF
49	7	Nick Solak	2B/OF
50	7	AJ Pollock	OF
51	7	Trey Mancini	1B/OF
52	7	Clint Frazier	OF
53	7	Jesse Winker	OF
54	7	Kole Calhoun	OF
55	7	Leody Taveras	OF
56	7	Randal Grichuk	OF
57	7	Kyle Schwarber	OF
58	8	Ian Happ	OF
59	8	Hunter Dozier	1B/OF
60	8	Raimel Tapia	OF
61	8	Austin Hays	OF
62	8	Mark Canha	OF
63	8	Andrew Benintendi	OF
64	8	Brandon Nimmo	OF
65	8	Mitch Haniger	OF
66	8	J.D. Davis	3B/OF
67	8	Lorenzo Cain	OF
68	8	Jurickson Profar	2B/OF
69	8	Garrett Hampson	2B/SS/OF
70	8	David Peralta	OF
71	9	Victor Reyes	OF
72	9	Nick Senzel	OF
73	9	Aaron Hicks	OF
74	9	Jarred Kelenic	OF
75	9	Manuel Margot	OF
76	9	Alex Kirilloff	OF
77	9	Bryan Reynolds	OF
78	9	Daulton Varsho	C/OF
79	9	Adam Eaton	OF
80	9	Jon Berti	2B/OF
81	9	Alex Dickerson	OF
82	9	Scott Kingery	2B/OF
83	9	Chris Taylor	2B/SS/OF
84	10	Joc Pederson	OF
85	10	Corey Dickerson	OF
86	10	Willie Calhoun	OF
87	10	Austin Slater	OF
88	10	Josh Naylor	OF
89	10	Hunter Renfroe	OF
90	10	David Dahl	OF
91	10	Justin Upton	OF
92	10	Avisail Garcia	OF
93	10	Yasiel Puig	OF
94	10	Jo Adell	OF
95	10	Franchy Cordero	OF
96	10	Jackie Bradley Jr.	OF
97	11	Robbie Grossman	OF
98	11	Adam Duvall	OF
99	11	Jason Heyward	OF
100	11	Cristian Pache	OF
101	11	Stephen Piscotty	OF
102	11	Myles Straw	OF
103	11	Shogo Akiyama	OF
104	11	DJ Stewart	OF
105	11	Sam Hilliard	OF
106	11	Kike Hernandez	2B/OF
107	11	Roman Quinn	OF
108	11	Oscar Mercado	OF
109	11	Yoshi Tsutsugo	3B/OF
110	11	Jahmai Jones	OF
111	11	Tyler O'Neill	OF
112	12	Kevin Kiermaier	OF
113	12	Michael Chavis	1B/2B/OF
114	12	Kevin Pillar	OF
115	12	Andrew Stevenson	OF
116	12	JaCoby Jones	OF
117	12	Cedric Mullins II	OF
118	12	Harrison Bader	OF
119	12	Adam Engel	OF
120	12	Michael A. Taylor	OF
121	12	Miguel Andujar	3B/OF
122	13	Gregory Polanco	OF
123	13	Mike Tauchman	OF
124	13	Harold Ramirez	OF
125	13	Spencer Torkelson	1B/OF
126	13	Jared Oliva	OF
127	13	Monte Harrison	OF
128	13	Jose Marmolejos	OF
129	13	Edward Olivares	OF
130	13	Ian Desmond	OF
131	13	Jake Bauers	1B/OF
132	13	Jay Bruce	OF
133	13	Julio Rodriguez	OF
134	13	Marwin Gonzalez	1B/2B/3B/OF
135	13	Derek Fisher	OF
136	13	Ender Inciarte	OF
137	13	Nomar Mazara	OF
138	13	Nick Markakis	OF
139	13	Lewis Brinson	OF
140	13	Aristides Aquino	OF
141	13	Chas McCormick	OF
142	13	Jordan Luplow	OF
143	13	Tim Locastro	OF
144	13	Brett Gardner	OF
145	13	Taylor Ward	OF
146	13	Tony Kemp	2B/OF
147	13	Dexter Fowler	OF
148	13	Sam Haggerty	OF
149	13	Bradley Zimmer	OF
150	13	Ryan Braun	OF
151	13	Josh Lowe	OF
152	13	Adam Haseley	OF
153	13	Christin Stewart	OF
154	13	Josh Reddick	OF
155	13	Jake Cave	OF
156	13	Daniel Johnson	OF
157	13	Anthony Alford	OF
158	13	Jake Fraley	OF
159	13	Brandon Marsh	OF
160	13	Drew Waters	OF
161	13	Magneuris Sierra	OF
162	13	Cole Tucker	OF
163	13	Jarren Duran	OF
164	13	Taylor Trammell	OF
165	13	Mallex Smith	OF
166	13	Yairo Munoz	OF
167	13	Tyler Naquin	OF
168	13	Steven Souza Jr.	OF
169	13	Jose Martinez	1B/OF
170	13	Daz Cameron	OF
171	13	Lane Thomas	OF

Tier One

Three years ago, Ronald Acuna and Juan Soto emerged on the scene at two of the best rookies of all now. Now, they are arguably the two most valuable fantasy players in the league. Acuna gets the slight edge because of his advantage in baserunning (32 projected steals to 16 steals), but Soto, who is coming off an absurd 201 WRC+ season, has a strong argument as the best hitter in baseball.

Right behind them are Mookie Betts, who someone got better in his first season in Dodger Blue, setting a career-high in sweet spot percentage and home run rate. It's scary to think that Betts might still be improving, as his well-rounded game (Projected .297 avg, 35 HR, 20 SB) already made him one of the safest picks in baseball.

Once the unanimous best fantasy player in baseball, Mike Trout has slipped a bit due to less aggressive baserunning (just one steal last year) and a "down" 2020 (career-low 162 WRC+). That being said, Mike Trout is Mike Trout, and even in a down season, he still improved his exit velocity by almost 3 mph.

Finally in Tier 1 is Brewers right fielder Christian Yelich. Yelich had a pitiful 2020 season, but upon closer look, there are signs that it might have been a short season fluke. Like Trout, Yelich still managed to have a career-high exit velocity in a down season, a total that landed him in the 99 percentile among major league hitters. The culprit appears to be a career-high 30.8% strikeout rate and a wildly unlikely .259 BABIP. There are safer options available, but it's far more likely that Yelich's down season was more attributed to unluckiness and small sample size than an actual decline of skill.

Tier Two

The first three hitters in Tier 2 could all conceivably lead the MLB in home runs. Cody Bellinger's stock slipped a bit following a down 2020, but there's just too much talent there for him to slide even further. Bellinger's contact and strikeout rates barely moved, so the main culprit appears to be a .245 BABIP. Expect Bellinger to return to his MVP form this season.

Bryce Harper may never reach his 2015 MVP pinnacle again, but his ability to hit for power, get on base, and drive in runs will always make him a valuable fantasy player. Harper looked far more comfortable in year two in Philadelphia, increasing his walk rate by four percent and cutting his strikeout rate by nine. His best Philadelphia days may be in front of him.

One of the most hyped prospects of the past decade, Eloy Jimenez had a relatively disappointing debut in 2019, even though a 116 OPS+ is nothing to complain about. Last year, Jimenez made exactly the kind of strides you want to see in a young player: A lower strikeout rate, a nearly thirty-point increase in average, a higher average exit velocity, and a massive spike in home runs. His pitiful 5% walk rate leaves a lot to be desired and prevents him from being in that upper echelon of hitters, but if he's hitting 40 and 120 every year, I'm not sure fantasy players will mind too much.

Kyle Tucker is the first big surprise on this list, as he makes a Tier 2 appearance after just 108 up-and-down career major league games. It's easy to see where the hype comes from: He had nine homers and eight steals in just 58 games last year, and he will rack up the runs and RBIs in a stacked Astros lineup. There is elite potential here, but there's obvious risk to drafting him ahead of some of the established players we have in Tier Three.

Tier Three

First up in Tier Three is Marcell Ozuna, who turned the best season of his career into a contract extension with the Braves. Everything about his 2020 was promising: A career-high exit velocity and hard-hit percentage, both ranking in the top 5 percentile of all qualified hitters, a three percent increase in walk rate, and a massive power surge. Ozuna is only entering his age 30 season, and while he won't produce much value in the field or on the bases, there's no reason to believe he won't continue to produce MVP level offensive numbers for the foreseeable future.

Luis Robert didn't quite meet the massive and unfair expectations placed on him in his rookie season, but an above-average OPS and 20 combined home runs and steals showed his immense potential. To reach the top tier of outfielders, Robert needs to improve his terrible plate discipline, as he struck out nearly four times as often as he walked last year. Robert has the speed to be atop the steals leaderboards every year, but that skill is limited if his on-base percentage is hovering around .300. Even with his question marks, Robert's speed and power combo as well as the talent surrounding him in the White Sox lineup makes him a top-15 outfielder.

At this point of his career, you know exactly when you are getting out of Whit Merrifield: an average of around .280, around 12-15 home runs, and nearly 200 hits. The big question is whether he can continue his elite baserunning into his early 30s. Merrifield led the league in steals twice from 2017-2018 but was held to just 20 steals in 2019, his first season after turning 30. Merrifield's stealing ability is the difference between him being a solid, dependable mid-draft option and from him being one of the best fantasy outfielders in the game.

George Springer put together another fine campaign in 2020 and turned his 131 career OPS+ and reputation as the best active postseason hitter into a massive contract with the Blue Jays. Health is always the main concern with Springer: Entering his age 31 season, he's only played more than 140 games once. He is no longer any threat on the bases, and his average exit velocity last year was the worst of his career. Springer will always be a risky pick, but his elite power will always keep him near the top tier of outfielders.

Similar to Springer, Aaron Judge's value all comes down to health. He has not played more than 70 percent of his team's games since 2017 and has not reached the heights of his monstrous rookie season since. Last year was particularly concerning, as his exit velocity and barrel percentage fell by eight percent and four percent, respectively. Yes, you can chalk that up to small sample size and rib and calf injuries, but there is no denying that none of his rate stats have been the same since 2017. Don't fall for the name recognition: Aaron Judge should not be at the top of draft boards, and he has to prove he can be both healthy and productive before he moves out of Tier 3.

With all Marte went through last year on and off the field, it seems unfair to give him any serious evaluation of his 2020 performance. What he did prove is that he is still an elite 5-tool player, and while he doesn't possess the power of a Judge or Springer, he is a sneaky good pick at this point of the draft.

Yordan Alvarez is a player I really like at this spot. With all the controversy surrounding the Astros the last few years, it's easy to forget just how dominant he was in 2019. Alvarez wasn't just good for a rookie, he was the best hitter in baseball not named Mike Trout or Christian Yelich, as his OPS+ would have been third in the majors had he qualified. The advanced stats back it up: He was in the top 10 percentile in just about every batted ball category. His playoff performance left a lot to be desired and we only saw two games of him last year, but the player we saw in 2019 was a Tier 1 player, so to get him in this spot is an absolute steal. Assuming he is healthy, of course. Beware his positional eligibility, as he qualifies at DH/UTIL only in some formats.

Tier Four

What to make of Randy Arozarena? On one hand, he was excellent against major league pitching as a rookie during the regular season and then hit like Babe Ruth during the postseason. On the other hand, he was a 25-year-old career minor leaguer, and 43 games are far too small a sample to make an accurate judgment on what kind of player he will be moving forward. If you're willing to deal with the risk, Arozerana could turn out to be the steal of the draft. Or, he could be in minors by July.

Another risky player with a small sample size is Trent Grisham. Grisham showcased his flashy tools during the shortened season, reaching double digits in both home runs and steals. Likely leading off in a stacked Padres lineup, he will rack up runs, so even if he doesn't match his 122 OPS+ of 2020, his speed and on-base-skills make him a great option at this point of the draft.

Lost in the shuffle of more famous teammates Pete Alonso, Jacob deGrom and now Fransico Lindor, Michael Conforto is a damn good baseball player. There were only seven players with an on-base percentage higher than Conforto's last year, and only four of those seven could match his .412 on-base percentage. Hitting in an absolute stacked lineup, Conforto's ability to get on base and hit for power will make him one of the most valuable fantasy hitters in baseball.

Last year was Teoscar Hernandez's breakout season, as he set a career-high in average by 60 points and improved his already good home run rate from one every 16 at-bats to one every 11.8 at-bats. The advanced numbers back it up too: He was in the 98th percentile and 97th in expected slugging. He'll never walk much or provide and value on the bases, but his power in the Blue Jay's stacked lineup is too tantalizing to pass up.

For the first two weeks of the 2020 season, Nick Castellanos was the best player in baseball, hitting .340 with a 1.251 OPS over his first 14 games. For the remaining three-quarters of the season, however, he hit .190 with a .644 OPS. This is a concerning trend for a player who's really only had half a season of elite fantasy value in his entire career. He is also hitting in a lineup that was 24th in the majors in on-base percentage, which limits his ability to drive in his runs, his most valuable fantasy statistic. There are many more valuable players in Tier 4 than Castellanos.

Tier Five

Tier 5 is filled with bounce-back candidates and high-risk/ high reward players. The chief among them is J.D Martinez, the former best hitter in baseball who is now trying to recover from a disastrous 2020 season. Martinez showed an obvious decline in back speed last year, as evident by his nearly 13o point drop in batting average on fastballs, but he is just two years removed from a .304/.383/.557 season, so it's hard to completely give up one. Also trying to bounce back from a lost 2020 season is Austin Meadows, who battled through an injury-plagued campaign in which he hit just .204 with 4 home runs. The last time we saw Meadows play a full, healthy season, he was an All-Star, and at 26, his best baseball may be in front of him.

There are many players who caught my eye in Tier 5. I really like Jeff McNeil at this spot. He's had an on-base percentage above .380 in each of the last three years, and with all the talent he is surrounded by in the Mets lineup, he will rank near the top of the NL in runs scored. Mike Yastrzemski is another player I like here. Because of the team he plays for and the lack of flash in his game, he flies under the radar, but he was an absolute superstar last year. Just to put his excellence in context: His 165 OPS+ was higher than all the hitters in Tier 2.

Jorge Soler is one of the most interesting players on this list. He famously set the Royals home run record in 2019 but fell off the table in 2020. Nothing really changed in his underlying statistics besides a slight increase in strikeout rate, however, so he is a strong bounce-back candidate. If you are looking for a cheap power source, Soler is the way to go.

Then there are the players I don't love taking at this spot. One of those players is Charlie Blackmon. His exit velocity and hard-hit percentage were in the bottom 20 percent of hitters, and after his smoking hot, BABIP induced start, he hit just .216 with a .610 OPS. This all resulted in the worst season of his career, and at 34, it's clear his best days are behind him.

Alex Verdugo is a player who is much more valuable in real life than in fantasy. His defense, intensity, and arm make him an All-Star caliber player, but he doesn't hit for enough power or steal enough bases to provide any significant fantasy value. Eddie Rosario is another player I wouldn't draft at this spot. In today's game, there are a million hitters you can get who can give you a cheap 20 home runs, and Rosario doesn't get on base enough, steal enough bases, hit for a high enough average, or play in a good enough offense to warrant anything more than a backup selection.

Tier Six

Two defense-first players lead the Tier 6 pack, as Ramon Laureano and Byron Buxton are both more valuable in real life than fantasy. Buxton is the riskier pick, as he has only played more than 100 games once in his career, but he provides more power and baserunning ability than Laureano. Even during his struggles last year, Laureano still managed to put together a .338 on-base percentage, and he is just one year removed from hitting .288 with 24 home runs and 13 steals.

Another player whose main value lies on defense is Victor Robles, but his offensive ability is far behind Laureano and Buxton. Robles doesn't hit for average or power, and while he can steal the occasional base, his sub .300 on-base percentage limits that skill.

For a player who actually provides value on offense, look at Ryan Mountcastle. The former top prospect excelled in his rookie season, hitting .333 with a 140 OPS+. 53 games are too small a sample size to make any grand judgments, and his batted ball rates don't quite back up the standard numbers, but Mountcastle is a solid bet to hit in the high .200s with 20-25 home runs.

At this point, we know who Joey Gallo is: He'll hit home runs, hit some more home runs, and provide literally nothing else. Not only does he not hit for average or steal bases, but his average and supporting cast are so weak that it hampers his ability to drive in runs despite his massive power.

Dominic Smith and Anthony Santander are two players looking to build on breakout 2020 campaigns. Smith is the player I like more going forward, as he's shown a more consistent ability to hit for average and get on base. He also hits the ball much harder than Santander. He was in the 66th percentile in exit velocity and 83rd percentile in hard-hit percentage, while Santander was just 45th and 38th respectively. This is not to say Santander is a bad player. He made a clear effort in 2020 to get the ball in the air, increasing his launch angle by almost 10 points, and it resulted in a massive spike in home run rate. He doesn't have much help in the lineup, but playing time is guaranteed and if you can get a guy with a .575 slugging percentage at this stage of the draft, you're not complaining.

Max Kepler is someone I like at this spot. He had a disappointing season last year, but his xBA was in line with his breakout 2019 season, where he hit 36 home runs and 98 RBI. With the amount of talent surrounding him in the Twins lineup, his floor is 30 home runs and 100 RBI, making one of the safest picks at this stage of the draft.

An absolute sleeper in Tier 6 in Kyle Lewis' Mariners teammate, Dylan Moore. There's not much to go one, but he's shown a clear ability to hit for power and steal bases at the big league level, the starter kit for a valuable fantasy player.

A player I don't like is Michael Brantley. He is only middle of the pack in terms of exit velocity and hard-hit percentage, making him extremely reliant on BABIP luck. He doesn't hit for power and he doesn't steal bases, and at 33, his best days are behind him. Grab him for the floor he provides in average and RBI but the upside isn't there.

Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy baseball app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, sleepers, prospects & more. All free!

More Fantasy Baseball Advice

A Year to Remember: Hitters Who Had Career Years in 2024

Top Fantasy Baseball Hitting Prospects for 2025 Redraft Leagues

2025 Fantasy Baseball Pitcher Draft Value Picks - Septembers To Remember

A Year To Remember: Pitchers Who Had Career Years In 2024

Hitters - A September To Remember

Fantasy Baseball Closer Depth Charts - MLB Bullpens and Saves

Fantasy Baseball Prospect Risers - Arizona Fall League Standouts

Steamer Surprises: Projection Values For 2025 Fantasy Baseball

First Base Risers, Fallers, Buys, and Sells for Dynasty Fantasy Baseball

Lessons Learned For Fantasy Baseball 2025

Forgot Password

POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

2021 Outfielder Rankings - 5x5 Mixed Leagues

2021 Fantasy Baseball Outfielder Rankings

Tier One

Tier Two

Tier Three

Tier Four

Tier Five

Tier Six

More Fantasy Baseball Advice

POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Josh Jacobs2 hours ago

De'Von Achane2 hours ago

Jahmyr Gibbs3 hours ago

Jonathan Kuminga3 hours ago

Ben Simmons3 hours ago

Dorian Finney-Smith4 hours ago

Dennis Schröder4 hours ago

Trendon Watford4 hours ago

Jaxon Smith-Njigba4 hours ago

Ziaire Williams4 hours ago

Gardner Minshew II4 hours ago

Jalen Suggs4 hours ago

Malik Monk4 hours ago

Cade Cunningham4 hours ago

Ja Morant5 hours ago

Karl-Anthony Towns5 hours ago

Wendell Carter Jr.5 hours ago

Herbert Jones5 hours ago

Josh Jacobs5 hours ago

Yves Missi5 hours ago

Isaac Okoro5 hours ago

Romeo Doubs5 hours ago

Dejounte Murray6 hours ago

CJ McCollum6 hours ago

Anthony Cirelli6 hours ago

Bryce Young6 hours ago

Seth Jarvis6 hours ago

Karel Vejmelka6 hours ago

T.J. Hockenson6 hours ago

Joseph Woll6 hours ago

Pyotr Kochetkov6 hours ago

Jordan Addison6 hours ago

Austin Ekeler6 hours ago

Dylan Samberg7 hours ago

David Montgomery7 hours ago

Kirill Kaprizov7 hours ago

Bucky Irving7 hours ago

Aaron Jones7 hours ago

Daniel Gafford7 hours ago

Terry McLaurin7 hours ago

Rhamondre Stevenson7 hours ago

Austin Ekeler7 hours ago

Drake Maye7 hours ago

Sam Darnold7 hours ago

Alexandre Sarr7 hours ago

Nico Collins7 hours ago

Houston Texans8 hours ago

Caris LeVert9 hours ago

Jimmy Butler9 hours ago

Ilya Sorokin16 hours ago

Artemi Panarin16 hours ago

Connor McDavid16 hours ago

Juuse Saros16 hours ago

Roman Josi16 hours ago

Sidney Crosby16 hours ago

Volkan Oezdemir1 day ago

MMA1 day ago

MMA1 day ago

Gabriella Fernandes1 day ago

Deiveson Figueiredo1 day ago

Petr Yan1 day ago

Kirill Kaprizov1 day ago

Auston Matthews1 day ago

Max Domi1 day ago

Jakub Vrana1 day ago

Alex Pietrangelo1 day ago

William Eklund1 day ago

RANKINGS

RANKINGS