TAP FOR 6 MONTHS OF PREMIUM FREE 💰
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Reviewing Rick Lucks's Bold Predictions

What’s even more fun than making bold predictions? Looking back at the end of the season to see how good (or so, so hilariously bad) they were.

It's my turn to determine if my preseason picks make me a Champ or a Chump. I was terrible this year, so the answer is the latter.

Let's take a look at how awry these predictions were.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball draft tools and resources:

 

Rick Lucks' Bold Predictions for 2017

1. Chris Sale will finish with an ERA over 4.00

Yep, one of the worst calls is right here in the leadoff slot. My Sale pessimism was rooted in his declining K% (32.1% in 2015, 25.7% in 2016) that seemed to be the result of lower fastball velocity (94.5 mph to 93). He managed to reverse both trends in 2017, getting his fastball back (95 mph) and more Ks than ever before (36.2% K%). I was also concerned that Sale would not get the support in Boston that most were expecting, and he didn't (92 wRC+ as a team). He just had one of those magical seasons where team support is largely irrelevant. At least Corey Kluber is likely to beat him out for the Cy Young.

Verdict: F-

 

2. 2016's HR/FB will prove to be a blip as it regresses toward its historical norm

If anything on this list is worse than the Sale prediction, it's this one. Not only was 2017's league-wide HR/FB (13.7%) not closer to its historical norm, it was even higher than 2016's mark! This HR surge is legitimate, changing the way owners need to approach their drafts in 2018.

Verdict: F-

 

3. The Angels will win the AL West

The Angels were the last team eliminated from the AL Wild Card race, so I almost got partial credit here. Sadly I didn't, and the players I mentioned by name contributed almost nothing in fantasy this year. Both Cameron Maybin and Danny Espinosa finished the year in different uniforms, with Espinosa contributing -1 DRS at second base after I said he would form a BABIP-suppressing tandem with SS Andrelton Simmons. I projected Garrett Richards and Tyler Skaggs as the primary beneficiaries of this defense, and both missed significant time due to injury. Worst of all, I concluded the original analysis by throwing shade at the Astros. For the record, I still don't trust Carlos Correa or Dallas Keuchel.

Verdict: F

 

4. RA Dickey returns to fantasy relevance with a sub-3.50 ERA

Dickey finished with a 4.26 ERA. Atlanta's new park allowed nearly as many homers as his previous address (19 of Dickey's 26 HR came at home), preventing him from realizing the gains I thought he would in his return to the NL. His K% dropped (17.3% to 16.7%) and his wins held constant at 10, so Dickey's other statistics weren't great either. He was streamable at times thanks to the general collapse by mound men this year, but he fell well short of meeting this lofty prediction.

Verdict: D

 

5. Roman Quinn steals at least 40 bases

There was a lot to like in Quinn's profile before the season started, as he flashed the eye (20.3% chase rate) and GB% (56.8%) to get on base and start stealing (41-for-51 on SB attempts) in 2016. Sadly, a UCL injury to his left elbow limited him to just 197 PAs at Triple-A over the entirety of the 2017 season. At least it wasn't to his leg?

Verdict: F

 

6. The Colorado Rockies will finish top-15 in ERA

Colorado qualified for postseason play as I thought they would, but they were only 17th in ERA (4.51) in the process. Once again, the players I cited in the original analysis were much more problem than solution. Jon Gray and Chad Bettis missed significant time on the disabled list, and Tyler Anderson got lit up (4.81 ERA) despite solid peripherals (3.95 xFIP). Adam Ottavino was a disaster in the bullpen (5.06 ERA), and closer Greg Holland had a brutal second half (6.38 ERA). In retrospect, it's amazing that this was as close as it was considering everything that went wrong.

Verdict: C-

 

7. Travis Jankowski will steal at least 50 bases

Remember that Roman Quinn prediction? This was basically the same. Jankowski hit plenty of grounders (58.4% GB%) with a reasonable eye (22.1% chase rate) in 2016, making it logical to assume that he could reach base and steal at the MLB level. A right foot fracture limited him to 266 PAs in 2017, only 87 of which happened at the MLB level. The nature of his injury also makes you wonder whether the speed is coming back in the future, though his 13 steals in limited action across all levels is somewhat encouraging.

Verdict: F

 

8. Ryan Braun fails to hit 20 homers

I actually got one right! Braun's .305/.365/.538 line with 30 HR in 2016 screamed unsustainable, but he was largely drafted as though he was a lock to repeat it. His 25.1% FB% in 2016 was in slap hitter territory, but a ridiculous 28.8% HR/FB masked the issue. It fell to 17.3% in 2017, a rate that his slightly better FB% (31.9%) could not salvage from a fantasy perspective. A calf injury cost him a month of the season, but his .268/.336/.487 line with 17 big flies wasn't great even when he was on the field. Braun is a late round flyer at best next year.

Verdict: A

 

9. Cuban OF Yoelkis Cespedes will defect to the United States

This did not happen, and I'm not sure what else I can say about it. The younger Cespedes has a ton of raw ability, so it's still likely he ends up in the majors eventually.

Verdict: F-

 

10. Hector Neris is the best RP in fantasy

Neris seemed intriguing based on his 2.58 ERA, 31.1% K%, and 80 1/3 IP in 2016, especially since there wasn't a lot in front of him in Philadelphia's bullpen. He got the job early, recording his first save on April 20. Unfortunately, the Phillies provided him with few opportunities (26 saves total) and his 3.01 ERA and 26.9% K% were far from elite. Neris was not the best closer in the game. He was a viable one though, so you're probably not too angry with me if you drafted him late.

Verdict: B

Overall, I was probably a little too bold this year. Statcast seems ideally suited to this sort of exercise, so I'll incorporate it to significantly improve upon my .100 batting average next season.




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Jarrett Stidham

to Start AFC Championship Game
Zach Charbonnet

Questionable to Return Against 49ers
Atlanta Falcons

Falcons Hiring Kevin Stefanski as Head Coach
Jalen Williams

Ruled Out for Remainder of Meeting with Miami
Naz Reid

Won't Return on Saturday Night
Bo Nix

Suffers Broken Bone in Ankle, Done for Playoffs
Jalen Suggs

Out on Sunday Against Grizzlies
Santi Aldama

Questionable for Sunday's Matchup
Ja Morant

Listed as Probable for Sunday
Tari Eason

Listed as Questionable for Sunday
Herbert Jones

Ruled Out for Sunday
Rudy Gobert

Won't Play Saturday
Paul Reed

Available Saturday
Stephon Castle

is Available on Saturday
Ausar Thompson

Good to Go Against Pacers
Cade Cunningham

Cleared for Saturday's Action
Ziaire Williams

Still Out Sunday
Drake Powell

Won't Play Against Bulls
Green Bay Packers

Packers Sign Head Coach Matt LaFleur to Multi-Year Extension
Josh Giddey

Holds Doubtful Tag for Sunday's Game
Michael Porter Jr.

to Be Rested Sunday
Patrick Williams

Tagged as Questionable for Sunday
Ricky Pearsall

Active for Divisional Round
Sam Darnold

Officially Active for Saturday's Divisional Round Game vs. 49ers
Nikola Jović

Nikola Jovic Active Saturday
Isaiah Jackson

Will Play on Saturday
Tyler Herro

Out Saturday Night
Devin Booker

Cleared to Play on Saturday
William Carrier

Misses Fourth Consecutive Game
Shayne Gostisbehere

Remains Out Saturday
Jake Evans

Available Saturday
Teuvo Teravainen

Misses Second Straight Game
William Nylander

Out Against Jets
Pat Bryant

Won't Return on Saturday, Ruled Out with a Concussion
Tom Wilson

Could Be an Option Saturday
Leo Carlsson

Out for 3-5 Weeks After Thigh Procedure
Leon Draisaitl

Takes Leave of Absence
New York Giants

John Harbaugh, Giants Finalize Five-Year Deal
Aaron Rodgers

Not Expected to Return to Steelers in 2026
Atlanta Falcons

Kevin Stefanski the Favorite for Falcons Head-Coaching Job
Matt Boldy

Placed on Injured Reserve
Ross Colton

Good to Go Friday
Will Smith

Returns Against Red Wings
Shayne Gostisbehere

Out Friday
Brad Marchand

Remains Out Friday
Joel Armia

Returns From Five-Game Absence
Chris Kreider

a Game-Time Call Friday
Troy Terry

Cutter Gauthier Available Friday
Leo Carlsson

Sits Out Second Consecutive Game
CFB

Darian Mensah Entering Transfer Portal
Sam Darnold

Seahawks "Optimistic" That Sam Darnold Will Play on Saturday
Nico Collins

Officially Ruled Out for Divisional Round
Rome Odunze

Questionable for Divisional Round
J.T. Realmuto

Signs Three-Year Deal to Return to Phillies
Bo Bichette

Agrees to Three-Year Contract With Mets
CFB

Weber State Signs former Ohio State, Cal Quarterback Devin Brown
Bo Bichette

Phillies the "Overwhelming" Favorite to Sign Bo Bichette
Mark Scheifele

Leads Jets to Victory Thursday
Tage Thompson

Records Season-High Five Points Thursday
Jack Eichel

Notches Four Points Thursday
Ilya Sorokin

Shuts Out Oilers With 35 Saves
Josh Lowe

Angels Acquire Josh Lowe in Three-Team Trade
Kyle Tucker

Signs Four-Year Contract With Dodgers
Ricky Pearsall

Questionable to Play on Saturday Night
Sam Darnold

Questionable With Oblique Injury, Expected to Play
Clayton Kershaw

to Pitch for Team USA in World Baseball Classic
Patrick Mahomes

Says Rehab Going "Great," Goal is 2026 Week 1 Return
Nico Collins

a "Long Shot" to Play in Divisional Round
CFB

Auburn, Ohio State the Lead Suitors for Kyle Parker
CFB

Oregon QB Transfer Bryson Beaver Linked to Georgia, Kentucky
CFB

Jake Merklinger Commits to UConn
New York Giants

John Harbaugh Finalizing Deal With Giants
Ben Griffin

Looks To Stay Hot In 2026
New York Giants

Giants Making "Massive Push" to Hire John Harbaugh on Wednesday
Ranger Suárez

Ranger Suarez Agrees to Five-Year Deal With Red Sox
CFB

Dante Moore Not Entering 2026 NFL Draft, Will Return to Oregon
NFL

Mike Tomlin Doesn't Plan to Coach in 2026
CFB

FBS Coaches Unanimously Vote to Expand Redshirt Eligibility to Nine Games
CFB

Ohio State Transfer Mylan Graham Signs with Notre Dame
CFB

Caden Durham Withdraws from Transfer Portal, Will Stay at LSU
Jordan Spieth

Perhaps the Most Intriguing Player at Sony Open
Aaron Rai

Looking For Putting Confidence at Waialae Country Club
Collin Morikawa

Isn't The Safe Play He Used to Be Ahead of Sony Open
Kurt Kitayama

Needs His Putting to Turn Around For Success at Year's First Event
Ryan Weathers

Yankees Add Rotation Depth, Acquire Ryan Weathers in Four-Player Deal
CFB

Georgia Tech the Favorite to Land Justice Haynes?
Nolan Arenado

Cardinals Trade Nolan Arenado to Diamondbacks
Tom Kim

Desperately Needs a Solid Week at Sony Open
Billy Horschel

Hoping For a Fast Start to New Season at Sony Open
Corey Conners

Looks to Have a Return to Form in 2026
PGA

Chris Gotterup a Decent Play at Sony Open
Gary Woodland

Could Prosper at the Sony Open
Keith Mitchell

Unlikely to Contend at Sony Open
Robert MacIntyre

Looking for a Good Performance at the Sony Open
Michael Kim

Hopes to Start Sony Open Better This Week
Tom Hoge

Tries to Erase Poor 2025 Second Half in Hawaii
Brian Harman

Seeks Fresh Start in Hawaii
Eric Cole

Looks to Last Year for Success at Sony Open
Daniel Berger

Starts Off 2026 at Sony Open
Kyle Tucker

Mets Meet With Kyle Tucker
Brooks Koepka

Officially Returning To PGA Tour
CFB

Georgia Lands Kentucky Transfer Dante Dowdell
CFB

Sam Leavitt Expected to Sign with LSU
CFB

Dylan Raiola Commits to Oregon
CFB

Isaiah Horton Landing with Texas A&M

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP