TAP FOR 6 MONTHS OF PREMIUM FREE 💰
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

2016 Fantasy Baseball Tiered Rankings: Relief Pitching (January)

Welcome back RotoBallers to the end of our second round of 2016 fantasy baseball rankings. We'll take a look at relief pitching in this final segment, from closers to holders.

Saves are always a volatile category for fantasy owners, with the selection after the first few tiers leaving much to be desired in either performance or job security. But that doesn't mean there isn't value to be found. Think of Brad Boxberger and his AL-leading 41 saves, Jeurys Familia, Luke Gregerson, Hector Rondon, Shawn Tolleson. These players were available for cents on the dollar on draft day and were all valuable pieces to any winning roster.

This round of rankings features seven of our experts. They are Brad Johnson, Max Petrie, Kyle Bishop, Harris Yudin, Jeff Kahntroff, Bill Dubiel, and Nick Mariano. Assume a standard 5x5 redraft league when reading. And don't forget to also check out our 2016 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard. In case you missed it, we've been churning out dynasty rankings, keeper values, and top MLB prospect rankings for the 2016 fantasy baseball season. Let's get to it.

 

2016 Fantasy Baseball Rankings: Relief Pitching

Tier One

You know what you're getting with this quartet, and so will your auction budget on draft day. Wade Davis led all relievers in ERA (0.94) and BAA (.143). His fastball did most of the work - it ranked as the third among relievers. Aroldis Chapman led all relievers with a 15.79 K/9 rate and now joins a loaded  Yankee bullpen. How stacked you ask? Andrew Miller and Dellin Betances finished second and third in K/9 behind Chapman. The Yankees should have no problem getting Chapman the ball with a lead. Kenley Jansen was dominant after returning from injury; his 36.0% K-BB% and 0.78 WHIP led all relievers.

Tier Two

I was this close to placing Britton in Tier One. He led all relievers in xFIP (1.75), GB rate (79.1%), and soft contact (34.0%). My concern is save opportunities from Britton in 2016 considering the Orioles inability to build a strong rotation.

Trevor Rosenthal secured 48 saves in 2015 (2nd among RP) despite of a .337 BABIP. Look for Rosenthal to have another great year.

Familia was a great example of not paying for saves. Ranking closer to 20th in 2015, he finished third in saves (43) and seventh in ERA (1.85) among RP. Ken Giles finished sixth in ERA (1.80) and will have a full-year in the closer role for a contending Astros squad. Don't let him slip in drafts.

Tier Three

Mark Melancon led all RP in saves (51) and his cutter graded out as the best among relievers. He has a 1.86 ERA over his last three seasons with Pittsburgh.

Cody Allen loves his curveball, and for good reason. He threw it 37.0% of the time (first among RP) and it was third best among relievers (first among closers).

David Robertson's 3.41 ERA isn't pretty at first glace, but a peek at his xFIP (2.27 - third among RP) hints that he was the victim of bad defense. He was one of two pitchers (Jansen) with a K/9 above 12.0 and a BB/9 below 2.0.

Glen Perkins 32 saves and low walk rate (1.58 BB/9) are appealing, but his 1.42 HR/9 was worst among current closers. I would much rather pay for the trio mentioned in this tier before Perkins.

Tier Four

Boxberger led the AL with 41 saves, but his high HR rate (1.29 HR/9) and BB% (11.8%) leave much to be desired. The one positive is Jake McGee is no longer a threat to claim the role.

Huston Street's 40 saves were fifth among RP, but he saw increases in his fly ball rate, HR/FB%, and hard contact. His slider is still nasty; his 8.2 wSL finished seventh among RP.

Rondon deserves more love than he's received to this point. His 1.10 ERA after the All-Star break led all closers. The Cubs are going to be competitive once again in 2016 and Rondon should be a lock for 30+ saves.

Miller is downright filthy, but the lack of a closing role hinders his value. Miller had the top performing slider for a reliever.

Tier Five

These rankings were submitted before the news broke that Carter Capps would compete for the closer role with A.J. Ramos, or they would likely be flipped. Ramos' issues with location (3.33 BB/9) may open the door for Capps. Hopefully we have a better understanding of the situation come draft day, but for now I'd target Capps. If Capps qualified, his 16.84 K/9 would have been tops among relievers while his 1.10 ERA was behind only Davis. If he becomes the closer, he launches to Tier Two.

K-Rod kept on trucking in 2015; he had 38 saves (T-7th among RP) while his changeup graded at 17.8 wCH and he threw it 42.0% of the time, both tops among relievers.

The same issue for Miller applies to Betances; excellent pitcher, no closer duties. Betances' 1.50 ERA was second among RP.

Jonathan Papelbon isn't going to win Teammate of the Year anytime soon, but he's still a viable closer. His fastball has diminished in the past few seasons and is closer to 91 than 94, which is why he's in Tier Four. Roberto Osuna was excellent serving as the Blue Jays closer, but the acquisition of Drew Storen hinders his value until roles are sorted out.

Tier Six

Brad Ziegler had 30 saves while throwing smoke and mirrors. His 4.76 K/9 was easily the lowest among closers. Jason Grilli should be ready by Spring Training after suffering a torn Achilles. He had 24 saves before the injury, although the Braves have not confirmed whether there will be an open competition with Arodys Vizcaino.

Tolleson is an intriguing closer to target later in your drafts. His 22 saves after the All-Star break were tops among relievers, and he'll have the role all season in Texas.

Santiago Casilla had 38 saves last season, but he probably raised your blood pressure in the process. His walk rate rose (3.57 BB/9) and his groundball rate plummeted ten points (46.5%). Tread carefully.

If Sean Doolittle's shoulder holds up, he has a great chance at 30 saves this year. He's a personal favorite that can be found in the bargain bin come draft day. Steve Cishek had a terrible first half with Miami but rebounded nicely in St. Louis (1.94 ERA in second half) and will open the season as Seattle's closer.

McGee was recently traded to Colorado for Corey Dickerson and is in line to compete for the closer role with Jason Motte. McGee has the tools to succeed in the closer role, but his low ground ball rate (38.9%) could spell trouble in the thin air of Coors. The trade happened after we submitted our rankings.

Tier Seven

David Hernandez will close for Philadelphia and has a heavy fastball that sits at 94 MPH. He needs to work on the long balls (1.60 HR/9) if he's going to survive in the bandbox that is Citizens Bank Park.

Will Smith will close in Milwaukee, but I would look elsewhere; his 37.2% hard contact rate was worst among relievers. Hoover will probably replace Chapman in Cincinatti, but his questionable control (11.8% BB rate) makes it difficult to trust him. Darren O'Day would replace Zach Britton should an injury occur, a role he would succeed in. His 1.52 ERA was third among relievers.

Kelvin Herrera continues to be an X-factor in the Royals bullpen. His 98.1 mph fastball was second behind only Chapman. Herrera would become a must-own if Davis suffered an injury. Gregerson's 42.0% O-Swing% led all relievers, although his value takes a hit with Giles' arrival. He'd be the next man up in Houston.

Tier Eight

Nothing to see here for closer duties, but there's plenty of handcuffs to consider. I mentioned Hoover in the previous paragraph closing for the Reds, but Jumbo Diaz profiles better for the role. His 97 mph heater was equal to Craig Kimbrel's fastball. Another hard thrower is Hunter Strickland. He posted the best results with his fastball while his 0.86 WHIP was tied for third. He's the closer in waiting for San Francisco.

Cishek is expected to close in Seattle, but Joaquin Benoit has the better arsenal. He features three plus pitches and had a 2.34 ERA.

 

Relief Pitcher Rankings for 2016 Fantasy Baseball

Rank Tier Name Brad Max Kyle Nick Harris Jeff Bill
1 1 Aroldis Chapman 4 1 1 3 1 4 1
2 1 Wade Davis 3 3 2 1 3 1 2
3 1 Craig Kimbrel 1 2 4 4 2 3 3
4 1 Kenley Jansen 2 4 3 2 4 2 4
5 2 Zach Britton 5 5 9 6 5 6 5
6 2 Ken Giles 7 6 5 9 9 5 9
7 2 Jeurys Familia 10 8 6 5 8 7 8
8 2 Trevor Rosenthal 8 9 8 8 6 8 6
9 3 David Robertson 11 7 7 7 11 9 10
10 3 Cody Allen 6 11 10 10 10 10 15
11 3 Mark Melancon 9 10 11 11 7 12 12
12 3 Glen Perkins 13 14 13 17 13 13 11
13 4 Andrew Miller 12 26 14 20 12 11 7
14 4 Brad Boxberger 17 13 19 12 14 14 13
15 4 Huston Street 19 16 12 13 18 16 14
16 4 Hector Rondon 14 12 16 18 20 17 16
17 4 A.J. Ramos 16 19 18 14 27 15 17
18 5 Dellin Betances 15 24 15 21 17 20 18
19 5 Francisco Rodriguez 20 15 22 15 22 19 20
20 5 Roberto Osuna 20 20 22 15 21 19
21 5 Jonathan Papelbon 21 17 17 19 23 18 22
22 5 Carter Capps 18 27 21 16 16 32 26
23 6 Santiago Casilla 24 21 28 25 19 25 21
24 6 Shawn Tolleson 32 18 24 26 24 24 24
25 6 Brad Ziegler 26 29 27 29 26 26 29
26 6 Jake McGee 23 32 23 28 29 33 27
27 6 Sean Doolittle 36 22 29 30 21 30 -
28 6 Arodys Vizcaino 25 25 26 24 39 35 23
29 6 Jason Grilli - 30 - - - 27 -
30 6 Steve Cishek 27 31 35 34 25 22 -
31 7 Drew Storen 22 23 25 27 28 34 30
32 7 David Hernandez 37 28 31 33 41 23 -
33 7 Luke Gregerson - 42 - 23 32 41 28
34 7 Will Smith - 33 - - 38 29 -
35 7 Jason Motte - 36 - - - 31 -
36 7 Carson Smith - 38 34 32 33 40 25
37 7 Darren O'Day 28 47 30 31 34 39 32
38 7 JJ Hoover - 34 - 38 40 28 -
39 7 Kelvin Herrera - 35 - - - - -
40 7 Hunter Strickland - 40 32 37 - 37 -
41 7 Joakim Soria 30 43 - - 36 43 31
42 8 Kevin Siegrist 35 48 - - 31 - -
43 8 Joaquin Benoit - 37 - 40 - 38 -
44 8 Tony Watson - 39 33 - 43 42 -
45 8 Tyler Clippard 33 50 - - 35 - -
46 8 Sergio Romo - 41 - 36 - 45 -
47 8 Drew Pomeranz - 45 - - 30 47 -
48 8 Tom Wilhelmsen 31 51 - - 37 49 -
49 8 Ryan Madson 38 52 - - 45 36 -
50 8 Brandon Maurer - 54 - - 42 44 -
51 8 Jumbo Diaz - 44 - 39 - 46 -
52 8 Kevin Jepsen 34 49 - - - 50 -
53 8 Koji Uehara - 46 - - 44 - -
54 8 Seung-Hwan Oh - 53 - 35 - 48 -
55 8 Chad Qualls - 55 - - - - -

 

MLB & Fantasy Baseball Chat Room

[iflychat_embed id="c-12" hide_user_list="yes" hide_popup_chat="no" height="400px"]

 




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Mike Conley

Sits Out Thursday's Game
Cason Wallace

Returns to Thunder Lineup
Rudy Gobert

Available Against Thunder
Collin Gillespie

Returns From One-Game Absence
Jonas Valančiūnas

Jonas Valanciunas Ready to Take on Nets
Jamal Murray

Active Against Nets
Brandon Williams

Available Against Hornets
Klay Thompson

Back in Action Thursday
Grant Williams

Won't Play Against Mavericks
Brandon Miller

Ready to Continue Hot Streak Thursday
Kel'el Ware

Good to Go Against Bulls
Alperen Sengün

Alperen Sengun Available Against Hawks
Norman Powell

Ready for Action Thursday
Tyler Herro

Davion Mitchell Remain Out Thursday
Jalen Smith

Available Thursday Night
Tre Jones

Remains Out Against Heat
Josh Giddey

Won't Play Thursday
Dennis Schröder

Zach LaVine Coming Off the Bench Thursday, Dennis Schroder Starts
Malik Monk

Out Thursday
Joel Embiid

Ready to Face Kings
Quentin Grimes

Misses Second Straight Game
Ryan McDonagh

Ready to Rejoin Lightning Lineup
Logan Thompson

Unavailable Thursday
Dylan Guenther

Misses Second Consecutive Game
Shayne Gostisbehere

Ready to Face Mammoth
Anton Lundell

Out Thursday
Elias Lindholm

Won't Play Against Flyers
Evgeni Malkin

Good to Go Thursday
Kirk Cousins

Falcons Expected to Release Kirk Cousins
Chase Brown

Working on Extension With Bengals
Michael Penix Jr.

Hopes to be Ready for Week 1
Isaac Paredes

Not a Lock for Opening Day Lineup?
Dalton Kincaid

Doesn't Need Offseason Surgery
Josh Allen

Undergoes Foot Surgery
Josh Allen

on Crutches, Wearing Walking Boot
Corbin Carroll

a Top Fantasy Outfielder After Joining 30-30 Club
Jonah Tong

Won't Pitch in the World Baseball Classic
CFB

Michigan RB Bryson Kuzdzal Withdrawing from Transfer Portal
James Reimer

Stops Avalanche Wednesday Night
Tim Stützle

Tim Stutzle Collects Two Points Against Avalanche
Ondrej Palat

Enjoys Multi-Point Debut With Islanders
Zach Werenski

Has Fifth Multi-Point Outing of the Month
Travis Konecny

Questionable for Thursday
Rasmus Ristolainen

Doesn't Finish Wednesday's Loss
Blake Coleman

Out Until Olympic Break
Aaron Judge

Appears to be Past his Elbow Issues
Bo Nix

Expected to Resume Training in 4-6 Weeks
Dan Vladar

Returns to Flyers Crease
Denton Mateychuk

Back in Action Wednesday
Stephen Halliday

Unavailable Versus Avalanche
Ross Colton

Won't Play Wednesday
Devon Toews

Still Out Wednesday
Simon Holmstrom

Expected to Return Wednesday
Ryan Pulock

a Game-Time Call Wednesday
Michael Penix Jr.

Thinks he'll be Ready by April
Evan Carter

Establishes a Goal to Steal 30 Bases
Edouard Julien

Traded to the Rockies
Cleveland Browns

Browns Hiring Todd Monken as Next Head Coach
Sahith Theegala

Off to Much Better 2026 Start
Gary Woodland

an Intriguing Option at Torrey Pines This Week
CJ Abrams

Giants Offer "Aggressive Pitch" for CJ Abrams
Andrew Putnam

Hopes to Keep Momentum Rolling This Week
Matthieu Pavon

Seeks to Return to 2024 Form at Torrey Pines
Luke List

Still Looking For Birdies at Torrey Pines
Jake Knapp

Faces Stiff Challenge at Farmers Insurance Open
Rasmus Hojgaard

Needs to Play Better at Torrey Pines
Christiaan Bezuidenhout

Could Struggle at Farmers Insurance Open
J.J. Spaun

A Steady Option At Farmers Insurance Open
Andrew Novak

Looking For More Success At Torrey Pines
Denny McCarthy

A Wild Card At Farmers Insurance Open
Max Homa

Looks To Keep Resurgence Going At Torrey Pines
Joe Highsmith

Struggling Heading Into Torrey Pines
Wyndham Clark

Looks To Carry Momentum Into Farmers Insurance Open
Tony Finau

Aims To Turn Things Around At Torrey Pines
Akshay Bhatia

Looks to Bounce Back at Torrey Pines
Paul Goldschmidt

Yankees Expressing Interest in Re-Signing Paul Goldschmidt
Bo Bichette

Won't Play in World Baseball Classic
NFL

Bill Belichick Won't be First-Ballot Hall of Famer
Carlos Correa

Won't Play for Puerto Rico in World Baseball Classic
Si Woo Kim

Looks to Continue Incredible Run at Torrey Pines
Jason Day

has a Good Chance to Keep Momentum This Weekend
Keegan Bradley

has Good Course History at Torrey Pines
Billy Horschel

Isn't a Great DFS Option at Torrey Pines
Aaron Rodgers

Mike McCarthy Says he Wants Aaron Rodgers to Return
Will Zalatoris

Has a Shot to Challenge at the Farmers Insurance Open
Drake Maye

Expected to be Fine for Super Bowl
Tennessee Titans

Titans Set to Hire Brian Daboll as New Offensive Coordinator
Buffalo Bills

Bills Promote Joe Brady to Head Coach
CFB

Quarterback Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi Signs with Michigan
CFB

Darian Mensah Reaches Settlement with Duke, Expected to Land at Miami
Eugenio Suárez

Eugenio Suarez Not Drawing Interest on Open Market?
Shedeur Sanders

Named as Pro Bowl Replacement
Framber Valdez

Among Many High-End Pitchers on Free-Agent Market
Jose Altuve

Won't Participate in World Baseball Classic
Harrison Bader

Agrees With Giants on Two-Year Deal
Paddy Pimblett

Drops Decision
Justin Gaethje

Becomes the New Interim-Lightweight Champion
Song Yadong

Suffers Unanimous Decision Loss
MMA

Sean O'Malley Gets Back In The Win Column
Waldo Cortes-Acosta

Extends His Win Streak
Derrick Lewis

Suffers Second-Round TKO Loss
Los Angeles Chargers

Chargers Officially Hire Mike McDaniel as Offensive Coordinator
Nathan Eovaldi

Doesn't Expect Any Limitations in Spring Training
Jaxon Smith-Njigba

Dominates in NFC Championship Game Win
Matthew Stafford

Plans to Return in 2026
CFB

Arthur Smith to Become Ohio State's Offensive Coordinator
Bo Nix

Sidelined for 12 Weeks With Broken Ankle
Jose Altuve

to Mainly Play Second Base
Yu Darvish

Considering Retirement
Pittsburgh Steelers

Steelers Finalizing Deal to Make Mike McCarthy Their Head Coach
José Ramírez

Jose Ramirez Signs Seven-Year Extension With Guardians

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP