Will Brandon Aiyuk or Deebo Samuel Be Traded Before Week 1? 2024 Fantasy Football Outlook

As fantasy football managers, we live for the NFL offseason drama and speculation. One of the hot topics buzzing in the fantasy football world is whether the San Francisco 49ers will trade one of their star receivers, Brandon Aiyuk, or Deebo Samuel Sr.

With both players showcasing immense talent and contributing significantly to the team's success, the possibility of a trade could shake up the fantasy landscape.

Let’s dive into the numbers, the logic, and the potential outcomes to see which receiver, if any, might be on the move.

• Quarterback fantasy football rankings
• Running back fantasy football rankings
• Wide receiver fantasy football rankings
• Tight end fantasy football rankings
• Kicker fantasy football rankings
• FLEX fantasy football rankings
• Defense (D/ST) fantasy football rankings
• Superflex fantasy football rankings
• IDP fantasy football rankings
• Dynasty fantasy football rankings

The Case for Trading Brandon Aiyuk

Aiyuk has solidified himself as a crucial part of the 49ers' offense. In the 2023 season, he posted nearly 1,342 yards and seven touchdowns, establishing himself as the team’s WR1. Aiyuk's route running and ability to make big plays down the field are invaluable, especially in an offense that often relies on the run game and short passes. 

Aiyuk's contract situation throws a wrench into the equation. Entering the final year of his rookie deal, an extension seems logical, but whispers of discontent haven't gone unheard. Yet, the 49ers might consider trading him to address the potential cap hit, other roster needs or to acquire more draft capital. Given his impressive stats, Aiyuk could command a significant return, potentially benefiting the 49ers in the long run.

A trade could also boost Aiyuk's fantasy value. Imagine him in a pass-heavy offense with a high-volume quarterback – his numbers could skyrocket. For fantasy managers, this potential move could transform Aiyuk from a solid WR2/WR3 into a bona fide WR1 in the right situation.

76-YARD TOUCHDOWN. PURDY TO AIYUK 🔥

pic.twitter.com/EPkRlxwbMv

— 49ers on NBCS (@NBCS49ers) November 19, 2023

The Case for Trading Deebo Samuel

Samuel, the 49ers' dynamic playmaker, is a fantasy manager's dream when healthy. His unique receiving and rushing capabilities make him a dual threat on the field. In the 2023 season, despite battling injuries, Samuel still managed to rack up 1,117 yards from scrimmage and 12 total touchdowns.

Samuel’s versatility is reflected in his play - he is a menace in open space. However, his physical play style also makes him prone to injuries, which is a concern for both the 49ers and fantasy managers. Trading Samuel could allow the 49ers to mitigate injury risks while capitalizing on his high trade value.

Moreover, Samuel’s role as a hybrid receiver/running back might not be sustainable in the long term. If traded to a team that uses him more traditionally as a receiver, his fantasy value could stabilize with less injury risk, making him a safer, albeit less explosive, fantasy asset.

Great run by Deebo Samuel for 6! pic.twitter.com/KpF2LJjdDe

— Your News About National Football. (@TheNFLNewspaper) September 17, 2023

The Verdict: Will the 49ers Trade Aiyuk or Samuel?

Here's the truth: a trade involving either receiver is unlikely. The 49ers, perennial contenders, know their value in this dynamic duo. Aiyuk's extension talks might take some time, but reports suggest both sides are optimistic.

For fantasy managers, the takeaway is this: monitor the situation, but don't overreact. Aiyuk could see a slight boost in a new system, but Deebo's fantasy floor remains enticing. Regardless, both players are talented enough to maintain value in the 49ers' offense. Keep an eye on training camp reports and preseason usage, but for now, focus on building a well-rounded roster.

More Fantasy Football Analysis