There must truly be nothing fantasy football managers love more than trying to choose a kicker to start in the playoffs. It's so difficult to predict their production, and choosing the wrong one can get you eliminated from contention, which is also awesome.
Buffalo Bills kicker Tyler Bass, Minnesota Vikings kicker Will Reichard, and Tampa Bay Buccaneers kicker Chase McLaughlin are three guys of whom no one has any idea who will score more points.
We'll do our best to try to help, though.
Should I Start Tyler Bass for Fantasy Football?
Bass, the No. 9 kicker on the season, scored 14 points in his team's win over the Detroit Lions. But he's made under 81% of his field-goal tries this season. He's attempted a ton of FGs and extra points, and the high-powered offense he operates in drives most of his value. But the Bills play the New England Patriots in Week 16.
Tyler Bass' kick is NO GOOD from 24 yards out 😱 pic.twitter.com/L7qn6vWZHy
— NFL on CBS 🏈 (@NFLonCBS) December 15, 2024
He also continues to make awful misses. Predicting how the game will go can give you a decent rough estimate of how a kicker will do ... sort of. Buffalo should build an early lead, then grind down the clock as much as possible and dominate the time of possession. That's what the Bills offensive coordinator wants to do, anyway.
He's a solid start simply due to the number of opportunities he gets, but this should be one of his lower-scoring games.
Should I Start Will Reichard for Fantasy Football?
Richard is a great player to start. Unlike Bass, the Vikings kicker is extremely accurate. He shook off the post-injury absence rust last week and nailed three FGs and three XPs.
Will Reichard nails a 52 yarder pic.twitter.com/ThtjjKqYNG
— Bama NFL 🎄 (@TheBamaNFL) December 17, 2024
His upside may be limited, as the game against Seattle should feature at least light rain. But Minnesota has a great offense that's afforded the highly accurate kicker plenty of opportunities to score. Fire him up.
Should I Start Chase McLaughlin for Fantasy Football?
McLaughlin has been a tough player to figure out. He operates in a great offense, but there are many games where he just doesn't attempt enough field goals to finish with a good fantasy score.
Chase McLaughlin wins it for the @Buccaneers! pic.twitter.com/Weqhj4aDvc
— NFL (@NFL) December 2, 2024
But this is a simple decision. He's the sixth-highest-scoring fantasy football kicker this season, and he's on a great offense. So, you should start him. More data would only serve to distract you from the important things here.
Popular Week 16 Searches - Start/Sit Comparisons
Below are some popular Week 16 searches and comparisons from our Who To Start tool for Tyler Bass, Will Reichard, Chase McLaughlin compared to others. You can also use the free Who Should I Start tool to run your own start/sit comparisons, up to four players at once:
Kaimi Fairbairn or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Bates or Chase Mclaughlin
Cameron Dicker or Chase Mclaughlin
Justin Tucker or Chase Mclaughlin
Cameron Dicker or Tyler Bass
Wil Lutz or Will Reichard
Justin Tucker or Tyler Bass
Wil Lutz or Chase Mclaughlin
Brandon Mcmanus or Will Reichard
Brandon Mcmanus or Tyler Bass
Chase Mclaughlin or Tyler Bass
Tyler Bass or Chase Mclaughlin
Chris Boswell or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Bates or Tyler Bass
Tyler Bass or Will Reichard
Chris Boswell or Tyler Bass
Cameron Dicker or Will Reichard
Kaimi Fairbairn or Tyler Bass
Harrison Butker or Chase Mclaughlin
Brandon Aubrey or Tyler Bass
Cameron Dicker or Tyler Bass
Jason Sanders or Tyler Bass
Brandon Aubrey or Tyler Bass
Justin Tucker or Will Reichard
Chase Mclaughlin or Will Reichard
Harrison Butker or Tyler Bass
Harrison Butker or Will Reichard
Jason Sanders or Will Reichard
Chris Boswell or Tyler Bass
Kaimi Fairbairn or Tyler Bass
Wil Lutz or Chase Mclaughlin
Will Reichard or Tyler Bass
Jake Bates or Will Reichard
Wil Lutz or Tyler Bass
Brandon Mcmanus or Chase Mclaughlin
Chad Ryland or Chase Mclaughlin
Cole Kmet or Tyler Bass
Jake Bates or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Moody or Will Reichard
John Bates or Will Reichard
Wil Lutz or Will Reichard
Younghoe Koo or Chase Mclaughlin
Cade York or Will Reichard
Cameron Dicker or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Elliott or Will Reichard
Jake Moody or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Moody or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Moody or Tyler Bass
Jason Sanders or Tyler Bass
Joshua Karty or Tyler Bass
Nick Folk or Tyler Bass
Anders Carlson or Chase Mclaughlin
Brandon Mcmanus or Will Reichard
Chad Ryland or Tyler Bass
Chase Mclaughlin or Tyler Bass
Harrison Butker or Will Reichard
Jake Bates or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Bates or Tyler Bass
Jake Elliott or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Elliott or Will Reichard
Jake Moody or Tyler Bass
Jake Moody or Tyler Bass
Jason Sanders or Will Reichard
Jason Sanders or Will Reichard
Kaimi Fairbairn or Tyler Bass
Kaimi Fairbairn or Will Reichard
Will Reichard or Tyler Bass
Will Reichard or Tyler Bass
Brandon Aubrey or Chase Mclaughlin
Brandon Aubrey or Chase Mclaughlin
Brandon Aubrey or Tyler Bass
Brandon Mcmanus or Tyler Bass
Brandon Mcmanus or Tyler Bass
Brandon Mcmanus or Will Reichard
Cameron Dicker or Tyler Bass
Cameron Dicker or Tyler Bass
Cameron Dicker or Tyler Bass
Cameron Dicker or Tyler Bass
Cameron Dicker or Tyler Bass
Cameron Dicker or Will Reichard
Cameron Dicker or Will Reichard
Chad Ryland or Chase Mclaughlin
Chad Ryland or Will Reichard
Chase Mclaughlin or Chase Mclaughlin
Chase Mclaughlin or Chase Mclaughlin
Chase Mclaughlin or Tyler Bass
Chase Mclaughlin or Will Reichard
Chase Mclaughlin or Will Reichard
Chase Mclaughlin or Will Reichard
Chase Mclaughlin or Will Reichard
Chase Mclaughlin or Will Reichard
Chase Mclaughlin or Will Reichard
Chris Boswell or Chase Mclaughlin
Chris Boswell or Chase Mclaughlin
Chris Boswell or Tyler Bass
Chris Boswell or Will Reichard
Chris Boswell or Will Reichard
Chris Boswell or Will Reichard
Chris Boswell or Will Reichard
Daniel Carlson or Chase Mclaughlin
Harrison Butker or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Bates or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Bates or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Bates or Chase Mclaughlin
Jake Bates or Tyler Bass
Jake Bates or Will Reichard
Jake Bates or Will Reichard
Jake Moody or Tyler Bass
Jake Moody or Tyler Bass
Jake Moody or Will Reichard
Jake Moody or Will Reichard
Jason Myers or Will Reichard
Jason Sanders or Will Reichard
Jerome Ford or Chase Mclaughlin
John Bates or Chase Mclaughlin
Joshua Karty or Will Reichard
Joshua Karty or Will Reichard
Justin Tucker or Chase Mclaughlin
Kaimi Fairbairn or Chase Mclaughlin
Kaimi Fairbairn or Chase Mclaughlin
Kaimi Fairbairn or Chase Mclaughlin
Kaimi Fairbairn or Tyler Bass
Kaimi Fairbairn or Tyler Bass
Kaimi Fairbairn or Tyler Bass
Kaimi Fairbairn or Will Reichard
Kaimi Fairbairn or Will Reichard
Kendre Miller or Chase Mclaughlin
Matt Gay or Tyler Bass
Matthew Wright or Will Reichard
Miles Sanders or Chase Mclaughlin
Najee Harris or Chase Mclaughlin
Pat Freiermuth or Will Reichard
Pittsburgh Steelers or Tyler Bass
Riley Patterson or Will Reichard
Tj Hockenson or Tyler Bass
Tyler Bass or Chase Mclaughlin
Tyler Bass or Chase Mclaughlin
Tyler Bass or Will Reichard
Wil Lutz or Chase Mclaughlin
Wil Lutz or Chase Mclaughlin
Wil Lutz or Tyler Bass
Will Reichard or Chase Mclaughlin
Will Reichard or Tyler Bass
Will Reichard or Tyler Bass
Will Reichard or Tyler Bass
Will Reichard or Tyler Bass
Will Reichard or Tyler Bass
Younghoe Koo or Will Reichard
More Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 16? Tyjae Spears, Ameer Abdullah, Isaiah Davis
Tennessee Titans running back Tyjae Spears, Las Vegas Raiders running back Ameer Abdullah, and New York Jets running back Isaiah Davis (back) are options you can look into starting if you need them. They've produced well at some point this season. With injuries to key players like New Orleans Saints RB Alvin Kamara (groin), many […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 16? DeMario Douglas, Jalen Coker, Marquez Valdes-Scantling
New England Patriots wide receiver DeMario Douglas, Carolina Panthers wide receiver Jalen Coker, and New Orleans Saints wide receiver Marquez Valdes-Scantling are three WRs you could consider putting in your starting lineups this week. You may not be excited about having any of the three on any of the spots on your rosters unless you're […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 16? Tyreek Hill, DK Metcalf, Jayden Reed
Even in the fantasy playoffs, starting your high-end players can be quite challenging. In this piece, we will analyze three wide receivers who were once considered top options but have been disappointing as of late. Tyreek Hill, DK Metcalf, and Jayden Reed have all flashed WR1 potential this season but have become rather hard to […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 16? Terry McLaurin, Cooper Kupp, Adam Thielen
In the fantasy playoffs, it is crucial to consider all aspects of a player's outcome before locking them in your lineup. In this piece, we will look at three proven wide receivers who have a wide range of outcomes in Week 16. Terry McLaurin has emerged as a legit WR1 but faces a tough Philadelphia […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 16? Bucky Irving, Jerome Ford, Rico Dowdle
In the fantasy playoffs, it is crucial to make the tough calls when setting your lineup. In this piece, we will look at three running backs who all carry solid RB2 upside in Week 16. Rookie Bucky Irving has taken the lead in the Tampa Bay backfield but has dealt with numerous lingering injuries. Jerome […]
Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App
Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy football app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, rankings, starts/sits & more. All free!