The Cleveland Browns will welcome their bitter divisional rivals, the Pittsburgh Steelers, to Huntington Bank Field in Cleveland for their first matchup of the season. The Steelers have streaked to a dominant 8-2 record while the Browns are incredibly unlikely to make the playoffs at 2-8.
Regardless of their fortunes as a team this year, Cleveland has three players that are rostered in most fantasy leagues and are being considered for fantasy football starting lineups this week -- quarterback Jameis Winston, running back Nick Chubb, and tight end David Njoku.
So which of these guys should you put in your starting lineups?
Should I Start Jameis Winston for Fantasy Football?
While Winston has scored 23.6, 13.1, and 26.6 fantasy points in his last three contests, he'll face an extremely tough Steelers defense that's stymied opposing quarterbacks to the tune of 11.5 FPTs per game. In addition, the weather is projected to be ugly come game time.
It's 34 degrees; going to snow#Browns are 2-8, facing the Steelers who will most likely kick their ass
It's 8am; there are people in line for Muni Lot
Can say a lot about this town, we are a loyal bunch even when we shouldn't be
— Matt Fontana (@MattFontana83) November 21, 2024
As the weather forecast becomes clearer, his range of outcomes in fantasy becomes murkier. It could be tough sledding for the 10th-year pro, and he's a midrange QB2 who should be started in superflex/2QB leagues but can be avoided in 1QB leagues for now.
Should I Start Nick Chubb for Fantasy Football?
The Steelers aren't as brutal against the run as they are against the pass, but Chubb has been decidedly far less than stellar in his action this season since returning from a season-ending knee injury in 2023. He's averaged just under 3.1 yards per carry, scored only one touchdown, and not rushed for over 52 yards in a game yet.
Im dead serious when I say 24 is so close to breaking one- the cuts, the vision, the burst
Sunday he had his best yards per carry (4.5) of the season
Tomorrows weather calls for heavy rain & 16mph winds
Its the Nick Chubb revenge game, light the bat signal#Browns #DawgPound pic.twitter.com/rZ6eSOY8px
— Mac🦬 (@tha_buffalo) November 20, 2024
"Batman" as he's known, will likely improve each week, though, and even if he's 80% of the player he once was, he can have a solid game. The Browns run-blocking has left something to be desired, but it'll at least be a positive game script (hopefully) for No. 24, due to the awful weather. He's a RB3/FLEX play in non-PPR leagues.
In PPR, there are likely better options.
Should I Start David Njoku for Fantasy Football?
Njoku is probably a fine starter due to lack of depth overall at the position, but it's difficult to recommend him as a high-end option. The weather issues could lead Winston to prefer shorter passes, which would be well suited for Njoku to create mismatches with the linebackers and get a decent number of targets.
David Njoku is averaging 16.9 PPR points per game since the Amari Cooper trade.
— JJ Zachariason (@LateRoundQB) November 18, 2024
It's hard to ignore his production since wide receiver Amari Cooper was traded to the Buffalo Bills, though. Njoku has certainly benefitted from Cleveland being such a pass-heavy team under Winston, though. He's a decent starting option for fantasy football, but it wouldn't make much sense to expect high-end TE1 numbers from him this week.
Popular Week 12 Searches - Start/Sit Comparisons
Below are some popular Week 12 searches and comparisons from our Who To Start tool for Nick Chubb, David Njoku, Jameis Winston compared to others. You can also use the free Who Should I Start tool to run your own start/sit comparisons, up to four players at once:
David Njoku or Jonnu Smith
David Njoku or Cade Otton
Anthony Richardson or Jameis Winston
Cade Otton or David Njoku
Jameis Winston or Russell Wilson
David Njoku or Zach Ertz
Nick Chubb or Bucky Irving
Jameis Winston or Drake Maye
David Njoku or Will Dissly
David Njoku or Hunter Henry
Kareem Hunt or Nick Chubb
Drake Maye or Jameis Winston
Jameis Winston or Caleb Williams
Nick Chubb or Cedric Tillman
Tj Hockenson or David Njoku
Rico Dowdle or Nick Chubb
Austin Ekeler or Nick Chubb
Bucky Irving or Nick Chubb
Javonte Williams or Nick Chubb
Russell Wilson or Jameis Winston
Jameis Winston or Anthony Richardson
Jameis Winston or Cj Stroud
Nick Chubb or Isiah Pacheco
Nick Chubb or Kareem Hunt
Nick Chubb or Najee Harris
Nick Chubb or Rachaad White
Nick Chubb or Rico Dowdle
Caleb Williams or Jameis Winston
Cedric Tillman or Nick Chubb
David Njoku or DeVonta Smith
David Njoku or Mark Andrews
David Njoku or Tj Hockenson
Jameis Winston or Tommy Devito
Jameis Winston or Will Levis
Nick Chubb or Javonte Williams
Nick Chubb or Jaylen Warren
Rico Dowdle or Nick Chubb
Will Dissly or David Njoku
Christian Watson or Nick Chubb
Cj Stroud or Jameis Winston
George Kittle or David Njoku
Jameis Winston or Drake Maye
Jameis Winston or Matthew Stafford
Jayden Reed or Nick Chubb
Jk Dobbins or Nick Chubb
Kyle Pitts or David Njoku
Nick Chubb or Keenan Allen
Nick Chubb or Tank Dell
Tyrone Tracyjr or David Njoku
Tyrone Tracyjr or Nick Chubb
Aaron Jones or Nick Chubb
Baker Mayfield or Jameis Winston
Brock Purdy or Jameis Winston
Cade Otton or Nick Chubb
CeeDee Lamb or Nick Chubb
Chuba Hubbard or Nick Chubb
Cj Stroud or Jameis Winston
Dallas Goedert or David Njoku
Darius Slayton or Nick Chubb
David Njoku or Cade Otton
David Njoku or Dallas Goedert
David Njoku or Javonte Williams
David Njoku or Kareem Hunt
David Njoku or Sam LaPorta
David Njoku or Tucker Kraft
Evan Engram or David Njoku
Geno Smith or Jameis Winston
George Kittle or David Njoku
Jameis Winston or Tua Tagovailoa
Jauan Jennings or Nick Chubb
Jaylen Warren or Nick Chubb
Jerry Jeudy or David Njoku
Jk Dobbins or Nick Chubb
Josh Downs or Jameis Winston
Josh Downs or Nick Chubb
Khalil Shakir or Nick Chubb
Marvin Harrisonjr or Nick Chubb
Matthew Stafford or Jameis Winston
Nick Chubb or Audric Estime
Nick Chubb or Austin Ekeler
Nick Chubb or Cameron Dicker
Nick Chubb or Christian Watson
Nick Chubb or Chuba Hubbard
Nick Chubb or Courtland Sutton
Nick Chubb or Marvin Harrisonjr
Nick Chubb or Nick Westbrook
Nick Chubb or Rhamondre Stevenson
Nick Chubb or Tee Higgins
Nick Chubb or Tony Pollard
Nick Chubb or Trey Benson
Nick Chubb or Xavier Worthy
Quentin Johnston or Nick Chubb
Rachaad White or Nick Chubb
Rhamondre Stevenson or Nick Chubb
Russell Wilson or Jameis Winston
Taysom Hill or David Njoku
Trey McBride or David Njoku
Tucker Kraft or David Njoku
Aaron Jones or Nick Chubb
Alexander Mattison or Nick Chubb
Anthony Richardson or Jameis Winston
Audric Estime or Nick Chubb
Bo Nix or Jameis Winston
Brock Bowers or David Njoku
Bucky Irving or Nick Chubb
Caleb Williams or Jameis Winston
Calvin Ridley or David Njoku
Cedric Tillman or David Njoku
Cedric Tillman or Nick Chubb
Chuba Hubbard or Nick Chubb
Courtland Sutton or Nick Chubb
David Njoku or Brian Robinsonjr
David Njoku or Bucky Irving
David Njoku or Cedric Tillman
David Njoku or Dallas Goedert
David Njoku or DeAndre Hopkins
David Njoku or DJ Moore
David Njoku or Elijah Moore
David Njoku or Isaiah Likely
David Njoku or Jerry Jeudy
David Njoku or Jonnu Smith
David Njoku or Kareem Hunt
David Njoku or Quentin Johnston
David Njoku or Rico Dowdle
David Njoku or Rome Odunze
David Njoku or Sam Laporta
David Njoku or Tj Hockenson
David Njoku or Travis Kelce
David Njoku or Trey Mcbride
David Njoku or Tucker Kraft
David Njoku or Tyrone Tracyjr
Dawson Knox or David Njoku
Deebo Samuelsr or Nick Chubb
Devonta Smith or David Njoku
Dj Moore or Nick Chubb
Drake Maye or Jameis Winston
Elijah Moore or Nick Chubb
Geno Smith or Jameis Winston
Hunter Henry or David Njoku
Hunter Henry or Nick Chubb
Jahmyr Gibbs or Nick Chubb
Jalen McMillan or David Njoku
Jameis Winston or Anthony Richardson
Jameis Winston or Caleb Williams
Jameis Winston or Daniel Jones
Jameis Winston or Drake Maye
Jameis Winston or Gardner Minshewii
Jameis Winston or Jaylen Warren
Jameis Winston or Patrick Mahomes
Jameis Winston or Russell Wilson
Jameis Winston or Sam Darnold
Jameis Winston or Tommy Devito
Jameis Winston or Tony Pollard
Jameis Winston or Tua Tagovailoa
Jameis Winston or Will Levis
James Conner or Nick Chubb
Jameson Williams or Nick Chubb
Jared Goff or Jameis Winston
Jauan Jennings or David Njoku
Jauan Jennings or Nick Chubb
Javonte Williams or Nick Chubb
Jaylen Waddle or Nick Chubb
Jerry Jeudy or Nick Chubb
Jk Dobbins or David Njoku
Johnny Wilson or Jameis Winston
Jonathan Taylor or Nick Chubb
Jonathon Brooks or Nick Chubb
Jonnu Smith or David Njoku
Jordan Addison or Nick Chubb
Jordan Love or Nick Chubb
More Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 12? Jaylen Warren, Jerome Ford, Pat Freiermuth
Cleveland Browns running back Jerome Ford, Pittsburgh Steelers running back Jaylen Warren, and Steelers tight end Pat Freiermuth are three players that aren't the most exciting starting options heading into Week 12. However, injuries and deeper leagues exist, so they're very much in play for starting roles on some fantasy football rosters. They'll play tonight […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 12? Isiah Pacheco, Kareem Hunt, Rhamondre Stevenson, Rico Dowdle, Javonte Williams
It's a great feeling to have players who are sure-fire starters every week and rack up huge point totals regularly. However, most teams aren't loaded with premier top-10 players at their positions. Most teams' RB2 and RB3/FLEX players have plenty of variability in their weekly scoring. There are also changes that shake up many backfields […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 12? Russell Wilson, Najee Harris, George Pickens
The Pittsburgh Steelers will play the Cleveland Browns tonight on Thursday Night Football, and three of their players have been fantasy contributors in many managers' starting lineups this season. Quarterback Russell Wilson, wide receiver George Pickens, and running back Najee Harris are three hot names in fantasy football so far. They've enjoyed varying degrees of […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 12? Nick Chubb, David Njoku, Jameis Winston
The Cleveland Browns will welcome their bitter divisional rivals, the Pittsburgh Steelers, to Huntington Bank Field in Cleveland for their first matchup of the season. The Steelers have streaked to a dominant 8-2 record while the Browns are incredibly unlikely to make the playoffs at 2-8. Regardless of their fortunes as a team this year, […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 12? D.J. Moore, Mike Evans, Tank Dell
Deciding who to start in your fantasy football lineup can make or break your week, especially with the fantasy playoffs just around the corner. Wide receivers like D.J. Moore, Mike Evans, and Tank Dell have intriguing potential but carry varying risk levels based on matchups, target shares, and team dynamics. Fantasy managers are curious about whether […]
Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App
Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy football app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, rankings, starts/sits & more. All free!