RADIO
Indianapolis Colts wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr., San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Ricky Pearsall, Minnesota Vikings wide receiver Jordan Addison, Chicago Bears wide receiver Keenan Allen, and Cincinnati Bengals wide receiver Tee Higgins are five wideouts who are on many fantasy football rosters this season.
If you have any of these players in any of your leagues, you may be wondering if starting them in Week 12 is a good idea. This piece will break down which decision you should make for each player and support that choice with solid data and facts.
So, which ones should you fire up, and which ones should stay in the garage?
Should I Start Michael Pittman Jr. for Fantasy Football?
He hasn't looked the same this season, and he's been dealing with a nagging back injury, so that could explain why. Strangely, he's still playing. The team spent a significant draft pick on WR Adonai Mitchell in the 2024 NFL Draft, Josh Downs is playing very well, and even Alec Pierce has had some big moments.
Anthony Richardson is fantasy QB4 in Week 11 (MNF pending) —-
his receivers..
Josh Downs WR11
Alec Pierce WR38
Michael Pittman WR41Ol AR5 dropped the kinda dime pieces most dudes can only see on social media
pic.twitter.com/Jfpj66NKmT— Lawrence Jackson Jr. (@LordDontLose) November 18, 2024
Most of his struggles could be chalked up to his injury and the inconsistent play of his quarterback, Anthony Richardson. But A-Rich had the best game of his career in Week 11. MPJr. caught five of his eight targets for just 46 yards. Mitchell should probably take his role and he should be placed on injured reserve.
The team was considering doing it earlier in the season, but Pittman played anyway and has continued to play through the injury to middling results. It's hard to recommend starting him when he's not 100%. It's not clear how healthy he truly is.
Should I Start Ricky Pearsall for Fantasy Football?
No. The absence of tight end George Kittle (hamstring) seemed to allow the opposing Seattle Seahawks defense in Week 11 to limit both Pearsall and Deebo Samuel Sr., and both had dud performances in that game. Pearsall was targeted just twice and didn't catch either of his passes.
Ricky Pearsall saw his route share fall to 62% in Week 11, his lowest mark of the season. He only had one target and didn't catch it.
— JJ Zachariason (@LateRoundQB) November 18, 2024
He didn't run as many routes or play as many offensive snaps as he did in his other games. In much more important news, his quarterback, Brock Purdy (shoulder), is suffering from a shoulder ailment that could affect his status for Week 12. If Purdy doesn't play or isn't 100%, there's not much reason to start Pearsall.
It will take a few more weeks with a healthy Purdy to evaluate the rookie wideout, which isn't fun. For now, leave him on your benches, and he's a drop candidate. The return of running back Christian McCaffrey, who is a target hog, could mean Pearsall has very few decent games for the rest of the season.
The 49ers offensive line hasn't been playing well, either, so Purdy has been pushed to get the ball out quickly, and dump-off passes to McCaffrey are a perfect way to move the chains while he's under duress. That doesn't bode well for the team's WRs or TEs.
Should I Start Jordan Addison for Fantasy Football?
Minnesota Vikings wide receiver Jordan Addison (leg) dealt with cramping in the fourth quarter of his Week 11 game and was pulled from the contest and didn't return. He had a great game, mostly due to an impressive catch-and-run touchdown of 47 yards in the first quarter.
Jordan Addison with the TOUCHDOWN🔥
— PlayerProfiler (@rotounderworld) November 17, 2024
Addison is another boom-or-bust fantasy option -- he's scored 15 or more PPR fantasy points in three of his games this season, yet has four games of under seven points. That makes him tough to trust as a starter outside of deeper leagues. His bust games are pretty terrible fantasy-wise.
The problem is target competition -- he has to compete with WR Justin Jefferson (one of the best receivers in the league) and TE T.J. Hockenson, who's fantastic in his own right, though probably not 100% due to his torn ACL last year. Addison's limited targets mean he needs a touchdown to have a good game.
You can't count on touchdowns consistently on a team with so many good options in the passing game. Addison is a WR3/flex option in leagues with 14 or more teams.
Should I Start Keenan Allen for Fantasy Football?
No. Despite four straight games with six or more targets, Allen has failed to score more than 10 PPR fantasy points in all but one of his games this season. If he doesn't get a touchdown, he's probably not having a good fantasy day. The vet's highest receiving yard total of 2024 is just 44 yards.
Keenan Allen
OutHesi at the breakpoint to freeze his cover defender before accelerating out.
Has been elite at using tempo to create separation throughout his career. pic.twitter.com/LAqptAGHyB
— Mike Vannucci (@WRCoachVannucci) November 19, 2024
He's 32 years old, so slowing down at some point was inevitable. And he has a rookie quarterback in Caleb Williams who's had a poor season. He's also competing with DJ Moore and Rome Odunze for passing-game work, and both of them have outproduced him so far this season.
Allen is probably on his way out, and he's been unproductive despite playing over 90% of the team's snaps over the last four games. There isn't much that's holding him back that will improve or let up over time, so it's safe to leave him on your bench and look elsewhere for production.
Should I Start Tee Higgins for Fantasy Football?
There may be a planet where it's not a good idea to start Higgins, but it's not this one. He's an elite receiver, and despite his problems dealing with a multitude of injuries, he's been elite when he's been on the field. He scored 29.8 PPR fantasy points against the Los Angeles Chargers in Week 11.
Targets in the six games Tee Higgins has played this season:
* Tee Higgins 58
* Ja’Marr Chase 49 pic.twitter.com/ScJhRG5kAt— Adam Levitan (@adamlevitan) November 18, 2024
It doesn't hurt to have one of the NFL's best quarterbacks, Joe Burrow, throwing to you. It also doesn't hurt to have one of the NFL's best wideouts, Ja'Marr Chase, drawing coverage away from you. It especially doesn't hurt to be on a team with a terrible defense that forces its offense to throw the ball often to play both catch and catch-up.
You cannot bench Higgins if you are a serious fantasy manager. He's a must-start for the rest of the season (when he plays, of course).
Popular Week 12 Searches - Start/Sit Comparisons
Below are some popular Week 12 searches and comparisons from our Who To Start tool for Michael Pittman Jr., Ricky Pearsall, Jordan Addison, Keenan Allen, Tee Higgins compared to others. You can also use the free Who Should I Start tool to run your own start/sit comparisons, up to four players at once:
Michael Pittmanjr or Quentin Johnston
Zay Flowers or Tee Higgins
Jordan Addison or Christian Watson
Nick Westbrookikhine or Ricky Pearsall
Wandale Robinson or Jordan Addison
Michael Pittmanjr or Wandale Robinson
Rashod Bateman or Ricky Pearsall
Tee Higgins or Jayden Reed
Xavier Worthy or Keenan Allen
Christian Watson or Keenan Allen
Michael Pittmanjr or Keenan Allen
Adam Thielen or Keenan Allen
Jaylen Warren or Jordan Addison
Keenan Allen or Romeo Doubs
Keenan Allen or Wandale Robinson
Jordan Addison or Romeo Doubs
Michael Pittmanjr or Rome Odunze
Michael Pittmanjr or Xavier Worthy
Ricky Pearsall or Alec Pierce
Ricky Pearsall or Nick Westbrookikhine
Tyler Lockett or Michael Pittmanjr
Adam Thielen or Jordan Addison
Christian Watson or Jordan Addison
DeVonta Smith or Michael Pittmanjr
Dj Moore or Michael Pittmanjr
Dontayvion Wicks or Tee Higgins
Jaylen Waddle or Michael Pittmanjr
Jordan Addison or DeMario Douglas
Jordan Addison or Tank Dell
Jordan Addison or Wandale Robinson
Jordan Addison or Xavier Worthy
Keenan Allen or Jaylen Warren
Rashod Bateman or Michael Pittmanjr
Ricky Pearsall or Romeo Doubs
Romeo Doubs or Michael Pittmanjr
Tee Higgins or DeAndre Hopkins
Alec Pierce or Ricky Pearsall
Dj Moore or Tee Higgins
Jalen Coker or Ricky Pearsall
Jameson Williams or Keenan Allen
Jaylen Waddle or Jordan Addison
Marquez Valdesscantling or Ricky Pearsall
Michael Pittmanjr or Jordan Addison
Rashod Bateman or Keenan Allen
Ricky Pearsall or Joshua Palmer
Rome Odunze or Keenan Allen
Trey Benson or Ricky Pearsall
Wandale Robinson or Michael Pittmanjr
Wandale Robinson or Ricky Pearsall
Xavier Worthy or Ricky Pearsall
Christian Kirk or Michael Pittmanjr
Courtland Sutton or Keenan Allen
Davante Adams or Tee Higgins
Deandre Hopkins or Keenan Allen
Demario Douglas or Michael Pittmanjr
Demario Douglas or Ricky Pearsall
Jauan Jennings or Ricky Pearsall
Jaylen Warren or Ricky Pearsall
Jordan Addison or Alec Pierce
Jordan Addison or Jaylen Waddle
Jordan Addison or Rashod Bateman
Jordan Addison or Roschon Johnson
Jordan Addison or Will Dissly
Josh Downs or Jordan Addison
Josh Downs or Michael Pittmanjr
Josh Downs or Ricky Pearsall
Josh Downs or Tee Higgins
Kareem Hunt or Tee Higgins
Keenan Allen or Audric Estime
Keenan Allen or Darius Slayton
Keenan Allen or Jordan Addison
Keenan Allen or Marvin Harrisonjr
Keenan Allen or Ricky Pearsall
Keenan Allen or Trey Benson
Keenan Allen or Tyler Lockett
Michael Pittmanjr or Christian Watson
Michael Pittmanjr or Jalen McMillan
Noah Brown or Ricky Pearsall
Quentin Johnston or Jordan Addison
Quentin Johnston or Keenan Allen
Quentin Johnston or Michael Pittmanjr
Quentin Johnston or Ricky Pearsall
Ricky Pearsall or Christian Watson
Ricky Pearsall or Jaylen Warren
Ricky Pearsall or Jordan Addison
Ricky Pearsall or Quentin Johnston
Rome Odunze or Jordan Addison
Rome Odunze or Michael Pittmanjr
Romeo Doubs or Keenan Allen
Romeo Doubs or Ricky Pearsall
Tee Higgins or DK Metcalf
Tucker Kraft or Ricky Pearsall
Tyler Lockett or Keenan Allen
Xavier Legette or Ricky Pearsall
Xavier Worthy or Jordan Addison
Adam Thielen or Michael Pittmanjr
Alec Pierce or Keenan Allen
Alec Pierce or Michael Pittmanjr
Amonra Stbrown or Michael Pittmanjr
Austin Ekeler or Keenan Allen
Austin Ekeler or Ricky Pearsall
CeeDee Lamb or Tee Higgins
Christian Watson or Michael Pittmanjr
Christian Watson or Ricky Pearsall
Courtland Sutton or Jordan Addison
Courtland Sutton or Ricky Pearsall
Dandre Swift or Michael Pittmanjr
Dandre Swift or Tee Higgins
Darius Slayton or Michael Pittmanjr
Darnell Mooney or Tee Higgins
Deandre Hopkins or Tee Higgins
Demario Douglas or Keenan Allen
Devaughn Vele or Jordan Addison
Devaughn Vele or Keenan Allen
Devon Achane or Jordan Addison
Dj Moore or Jordan Addison
Dj Moore or Keenan Allen
Dk Metcalf or Tee Higgins
Garrett Wilson or Tee Higgins
Hunter Henry or Jordan Addison
Isaiah Likely or Keenan Allen
Jakobi Meyers or Michael Pittmanjr
Jalen Mcmillan or Ricky Pearsall
Jauan Jennings or Jordan Addison
Javonte Williams or Keenan Allen
Jaxon Smithnjigba or Keenan Allen
Jaxon Smithnjigba or Michael Pittmanjr
Jayden Reed or Keenan Allen
Jayden Reed or Tee Higgins
Jaylen Waddle or Ricky Pearsall
Jaylen Warren or Keenan Allen
Jaylen Warren or Michael Pittmanjr
Jonathon Brooks or Ricky Pearsall
Jordan Addison or Adam Thielen
Jordan Addison or Audric Estime
Jordan Addison or Cam Akers
Jordan Addison or Deandre Hopkins
Jordan Addison or Jauan Jennings
Jordan Addison or Noah Brown
Jordan Addison or Quentin Johnston
Jordan Addison or Rome Odunze
Jordan Addison or Trey McBride
Jordan Addison or Tucker Kraft
Jordan Addison or Tyler Lockett
Jordan Addison or Xavier Legette
More Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 16? Marvin Harrison Jr., Josh Downs, Romeo Doubs
Whether you drafted a player in the early rounds, picked them up off waivers and held on to them while getting multiple solid games out of them, or just grabbed a player out of desperation due to lack of depth from being in a deep league or having a bunch of injuries, it's not fun […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 16? Darnell Mooney, Amari Cooper, Deebo Samuel
There's an interesting (actually, miserable) tier of wide receivers in the league this year that have dropped absolute duds in some weeks. Some more often than others. Still, it makes it much more difficult to stomach starting players in must-win matchups when they've goose-egged you before or had low-scoring single-digit performances. Atlanta Falcons wide receiver […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 16? D'Andre Swift, Zach Charbonnet, Kendre Miller
It's never fun to see running backs put up big games and have multiple high-scoring efforts in fantasy football, only to see them inexplicably regress at some point in the season. If you have a player like this and you've made it this far in the playoffs, it can be confusing who to start. Fortunately, […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 16? Matthew Stafford, Anthony Richardson, Baker Mayfield
Los Angeles Rams quarterback Matthew Stafford, Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson, and Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Baker Mayfield are three signal-callers rostered in most fantasy leagues. The mercurial and heavily matchup-dependent nature of QB scoring leads to weekly troubles with deciding who to start. So let's help you decide who to put in your starting […]
Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 16? Aaron Rodgers, Kyler Murray, Sam Darnold
We are only a few days away from fantasy football championship week. That means you can be sure that fantasy owners everywhere are going through their lineups with a fine-toothed comb. Quarterbacks are always essential to a high-scoring fantasy week. Picking the right signal-caller can give your team the advantage you need. Several quarterbacks that […]
Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App
Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy football app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, rankings, starts/sits & more. All free!
