X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Q&A: Who are the two best keepers of: McCutchen, Weaver, Bumgarner and Bruce

Question Submitted to RotoBaller >>

Name: Steven

Fantasy Baseball Question: Which two guys should I keep out of these 4: Weaver, Bumgarner, McCutchen, Bruce?

Player Pool: Mixed

# of Teams: 11-13

League Info and Categories: Weekly Points League. Pitching weighted toward IP, W/L and K. Hitting weighted toward OPS. Overall elite pitchers more valuable than elite hitters.

Roster Positions: No CI or MI. 3 OF Shallow Hitting and DEEP Pitching.

League Host: Yahoo!

 


RotoBaller Detailed Analysis >>

Hi Steven,

Thanks for your question. We haven't gotten a points league question yet! It always makes for an interesting analysis angle.

Even in a points league where pitchers are more valuable than hitters, McCutchen MUST BE one of your two keepers. Here's a guy who may still have more growth before hitting his prime, and though his BA will surely regress, his OPS should rise as his power continues to develop.

The other easy choice is letting Bruce go. In a H2H league, he can be borderline cancerous. Sure, he'll single-handedly win you 2 weeks throughout the year, but he is SO damn streaky that he will also act as a blackhole on your OF all the other weeks. Consistency is a really significant factor in this kind of format, and Jay Bruce is simply not yet consistent enough on a weekly basis to warrant keeping him.

That said, the REAL choice comes down to Bumgarner vs. Weaver. This is a really tough choice, buddy. Weaver was ranked eighteenth overall and the sixth best SP (5x5 rankings) in 2012. And in a points league where Pitcher Losses are a factor, Weaver was probably even better than that for you. Bumgarner was the fourteenth best SP and ranked 42 overall in 5x5. That is still fairly elite. He had a very respectable record at 16-11 but with fewer losses, he certainly would've cracked the top-ten SP list. So, you have two bona fide aces on your hands. Let's dig a little deeper and see if we can picture what 2013 has in store:

Weaver's ridiculous 20-5 record will come down to Earth; considering that he only threw 188 IP, there is a substantial amount of good luck in that record. His K-Rate has fallen big-time, to below the average for the top-100 SP-- in a league where Ks equal points, this points to trouble ahead. One other worrisome statistic is his .240 BABIP. A fly ball pitcher like Weaver can sustain a fairly low BABIP, but .240 is crazy-low, especially considering his fairly high line-drive % (21.1). Weaver's BABIP will likely regress to the .260-.270 range, which means more hits, in turn leading to more runs. All together, I think a line of 17-8 with 160 K and a 3.5 ERA is much more realistic expectation than a repeat of his eye-popping 2012.

Madison Bumgarner, conversely, is on the rise. His K-BB ratio is elite (18th overall) and will improve even further. His IP totals have been rising and he could easily surpass the 210 mark this year. If that happens, he'll also pass the 200 K mark for the first time in his career. Unlike Weaver (an extreme fly-ball pitcher), Bumgarner keeps the ball on the ground at a high rate, which is a much more reliable way to control run-scoring. San Francisco is always a good ball club, so Bumgarner should be good for a pretty similar record to last year's 16-11. Perhaps most significantly, he's only 22 years old, and he already has TWO high-end seasons under his belt. That is nasty! A reasonable projection for the Giants' young gun is a line of 16-9, 200 K and a 3.4 ERA.

 


YOUR ANSWER! >>

In summary, while McCutchen over Bruce is an easy call, Bumgarner vs. Weaver is much more difficult. In the end, I would go with Bumgarner for the following reasons: age, NL pitcher, K potential in a fantasy league format where points are tied to Ks, Weaver's diminishing Ks / huge IP totals of recent years, and the fact that sometimes you've just gotta go with your gut. Weaver is the EASY choice to make, but my gut is telling me he's in for a decline while Bumgarner is just about to take his game to the elite level.

 


Hope this was helpful and thanks for your submission!

- The RotoBaller Staff




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Jaylen Brown8 mins ago

Still Out On Wednesday
Jazz Chisholm Jr.9 mins ago

Could Be Moved Back To Second Base
14 mins ago

Astros Have Had "Productive" Talks With Alex Bregman
1 hour ago

Rangers Decline 2025 Option On Andrew Chafin
Zion Williamson1 hour ago

Could Miss Wednesday's Game
Jeremy Sochan2 hours ago

To Undergo Surgery
Camilo Doval2 hours ago

Generating Interest
Shohei Ohtani2 hours ago

Undergoes Arthroscopic Shoulder Surgery
Wendell Carter Jr.2 hours ago

To Miss Wednesday's Game
Ronald Acuña Jr.2 hours ago

Ronald Acuna Jr., Spencer Strider Not Expected To Be Ready By Opening Day
Nick Richards2 hours ago

To Miss Some Time
Bo Bichette2 hours ago

Not On The Trade Block
Tee Higgins2 hours ago

Picks Up Another DNP On Tuesday
Zach LaVine2 hours ago

Uncertain For Wednesday's Contest
Ryan Poehling2 hours ago

Out On Tuesday
Alexander Romanov3 hours ago

Remains Sidelined Tuesday
Artem Zub3 hours ago

Remains Out On Tuesday
Aaron Gordon3 hours ago

To Miss Multiple Weeks
Ty Dellandrea3 hours ago

Ready To Rejoin Action On Tuesday
Joel Embiid3 hours ago

Suspended Three Games
Jake Walman3 hours ago

Sits As Healthy Scratch On Tuesday
Brayden Point3 hours ago

Sits Out Tuesday's Game
Auston Matthews3 hours ago

Out On Tuesday
Chandler Phillips3 hours ago

Attempts To Keep Final-Round Form This Week
Brent Rooker3 hours ago

A's Planning To Keep Brent Rooker
Neal Shipley3 hours ago

Past Five Tournaments Make Him An Interesting DFS Option
Austin Eckroat4 hours ago

Wants To Shake Off Some More Rust In Mexico
Rico Hoey4 hours ago

Needs The Putter To Work In Mexico
J.J. Spaun4 hours ago

Tries To Keep Second Half Rolling In Mexico
Sam Stevens4 hours ago

Hopes To Continue Riding A Hot Putter In Mexico
Erik Van Rooyen4 hours ago

Erik van Rooyen Tries To Defend WWT Title
4 hours ago

Braves Interested In Nathan Eovaldi
Lucas Glover4 hours ago

Well-Rested Heading Into WWT Championship
Ben Griffin4 hours ago

Hopes To Continue Good Form In Mexico
Lamar Jackson5 hours ago

Will Play On Thursday Night
Keith Mitchell5 hours ago

An Unappealing Play At World Wide Technology Championship
Bryce Young5 hours ago

Panthers Keeping Bryce Young
Lamar Jackson6 hours ago

Not Taking Part In Tuesday's Practice
Doug Ghim6 hours ago

A Worthy Start This Week In Mexico
Los Angeles Dodgers7 hours ago

Dodgers Expected To Be Favorites To Land Roki Sasaki
Cameron Young7 hours ago

Making Spot Start In Mexico
Mike Williams7 hours ago

Steelers Trading For Mike Williams
7 hours ago

Cardinals Don't Extend Qualifying Offer To Paul Goldschmidt
Washington Commanders7 hours ago

Marshon Lattimore Traded To Washington
7 hours ago

Reds Give Nick Martinez A Qualifying Offer
7 hours ago

Christian Walker Receives Qualifying Offer From D-Backs
DK Metcalf7 hours ago

Seahawks Won't Be Trading DK Metcalf
Detroit Lions8 hours ago

Lions Acquire Za'Darius Smith From Browns
Dak Prescott8 hours ago

Likely To Go On Injured Reserve
9 hours ago

Dodgers Extend Qualifying Offer To Teoscar Hernandez
9 hours ago

Willy Adames Receives Qualifying Offer From Brewers
10 hours ago

Braves Give Max Fried A Qualifying Offer
10 hours ago

Anthony Santander Receives Qualifying Offer
Aaron Nesmith10 hours ago

Wearing A Walking Boot
10 hours ago

Orioles Extend Qualifying Offer To Corbin Burnes
Devin Vassell10 hours ago

To Remain On The Shelf During Road Trip
Aaron Gordon10 hours ago

Not Expected To Be Out Long-Term
Jonathan Mingo10 hours ago

Heading To Dallas
Brandin Podziemski10 hours ago

Limited On Monday Due To An Illness
Zack Moss10 hours ago

Expected To Miss The Rest Of The Season
Trae Young10 hours ago

Exits Early With Rib Injury
Jeremy Sochan11 hours ago

Suffers Thumb Injury On Monday
Anthony Davis11 hours ago

Has Been Dealing With Foot Issue Since Summer
Artturi Lehkonen11 hours ago

Will Make His Season Debut On Tuesday
Ilya Sorokin11 hours ago

Takes On Penguins Tuesday
Khalil Herbert11 hours ago

Bengals Acquiring Khalil Herbert From Bears
Jake Allen11 hours ago

Posts Second Shutout Of The Season
Jesper Bratt11 hours ago

Collects Two Points In Monday's Win
Adrian Kempe12 hours ago

Enjoys Another Multi-Point Outing
Darcy Kuemper12 hours ago

Continues Point Streak With A Shutout
DeAndre Hopkins16 hours ago

Scores Twice In Week 9 Win
Kareem Hunt16 hours ago

Finds The End Zone In Overtime
Travis Kelce16 hours ago

Catches 14 Passes In Week 9 Win
Cade Otton20 hours ago

Leads Tampa In Receiving In Week 9 Loss On Monday
20 hours ago

Pete Alonso Receives Qualifying Offer From Mets
20 hours ago

Clayton Kershaw Declines 2025 Option
Will Levis21 hours ago

Titans Hopeful Will Levis Will Return In Week 10
Tony Pollard21 hours ago

Titans Looking To Reduce Tony Pollard's Workload?
Dallas Cowboys22 hours ago

Micah Parsons Expected To Play In Week 10
Dereck Lively II23 hours ago

A Late Scratch On Monday
Amari Cooper23 hours ago

Listed As Day-To-Day
Joe Flacco23 hours ago

Named Week 10 Starter
Robert Williams III23 hours ago

Returning On Monday
Jordan Hawkins23 hours ago

Out Versus The Blazers
Zion Williamson23 hours ago

Sidelined Again Versus Portland
Rudy Gobert24 hours ago

Available For Minnesota On Monday
Immanuel Quickley24 hours ago

Still Out On Monday
1 day ago

Alex Bregman Given Qualifying Offer
Ryan Blaney1 day ago

Wins At Martinsville And Has Chance To Earn Second Straight Championship
Christopher Bell1 day ago

Penalized At Martinsville, Removed From Championship Four
Jake Allen1 day ago

Faces Oilers On Monday
BOS1 day ago

Tyler Johnson Signs One-Year Deal With Bruins
Zach Benson1 day ago

Considered "A Possibility" For Tuesday's Game
Artem Zub1 day ago

Logs Full Practice On Monday
Bryan Rust1 day ago

Will Join Penguins Road Trip
Juraj Slafkovsky1 day ago

Practices On Monday
Macklin Celebrini1 day ago

Ready To Return On Tuesday
Samuel Ersson1 day ago

Misses Monday Practice
Tyler Reddick1 day ago

Not A Factor At Martinsville And Looks Ahead To Phoenix
Kyle Larson1 day ago

Misses Advancing Through Playoffs Despite Top-Three Finish
Brad Keselowski1 day ago

Has A Solid Top-10 Performance At Martinsville
Chase Elliott1 day ago

Loses Out On Winning At Martinsville
Rose Namajunas1 day ago

Drops Decision Matchup
Erin Blanchfield1 day ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Dustin Stoltzfus1 day ago

Gets First-Round Knockout At UFC Edmonton
Marc-Andre Barriault1 day ago

Knocked Out At UFC Edmonton
Trevin Giles1 day ago

Losses Third Fight In A Row
Mike Malott2 days ago

Wins Decision At UFC Edmonton
NASCAR2 days ago

Speeding Penalty Foils Martin Truex Jr.'s Last Realistic Shot At Winning
Denny Hamlin2 days ago

Fails To Advance To Championship 4 But Runs Well
Shane Van Gisbergen2 days ago

Shane van Gisbergen Earns Best Oval Finish at Martinsville
William Byron2 days ago

Tentatively In Championship 4 Pending Ruling On Manufacturer Orders
MMA2 days ago

Ariane Lipski Submitted At UFC Edmonton
Jasmine Jasudavicius2 days ago

Gets Submission Win At UFC Edmonton
Caio Machado2 days ago

Still Winless In The UFC
Brendson Ribeiro2 days ago

Edges Out Split Decision At UFC Edmonton
Amir Albazi2 days ago

Falls Short At UFC Edmonton
Brandon Moreno2 days ago

Dominates At UFC Edmonton
Daniel Suarez3 days ago

Will Start 20th At Martinsville
Zane Smith3 days ago

Might Be An Underrated Value Play For Martinsville
Tyler Reddick3 days ago

Is A Top DFS Recommendation For Martinsville Lineups
Joey Logano3 days ago

Will Be One To Watch At Martinsville
Brad Keselowski3 days ago

Should DFS Players Rely On Brad Keselowski For Martinsville Lineups?
Carson Hocevar3 days ago

Is A Great DFS Option For All Martinsville DFS Lineups
Ty Gibbs3 days ago

Is Ty Gibbs Worth Rostering At Martinsville This Week For DFS?
Austin Cindric3 days ago

Could Have A Top-20 Performance At Martinsville
William Byron3 days ago

Might Be Usable Only In DFS Tournaments At Martinsville
Chris Buescher3 days ago

Should DFS Players Roster Chris Buescher At Martinsville?
Alex Bowman3 days ago

Expect A Solid Top-10 Performance From Alex Bowman At Martinsville
Rose Namajunas4 days ago

An Underdog At UFC Edmonton
Erin Blanchfield4 days ago

Returns At UFC Edmonton
Marc-Andre Barriault4 days ago

Dustin Stoltzfus Set To Face Marc-Andre Barriault At UFC Edmonton
Marc-Andre Barriault4 days ago

A Favorite At UFC Edmonton
Trevin Giles4 days ago

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Mike Malott4 days ago

Opens Up UFC Edmonton Main Card
Brendson Ribeiro5 days ago

Searching For 1st UFC Win At UFC Edmonton
Caio Machado5 days ago

Drops Down To Light Heavyweight At UFC Edmonton
Jhonata Diniz5 days ago

Gets Big Step-Up At UFC Edmonton

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP