X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Q&A: Who are the two best keepers of: McCutchen, Weaver, Bumgarner and Bruce

Question Submitted to RotoBaller >>

Name: Steven

Fantasy Baseball Question: Which two guys should I keep out of these 4: Weaver, Bumgarner, McCutchen, Bruce?

Player Pool: Mixed

# of Teams: 11-13

League Info and Categories: Weekly Points League. Pitching weighted toward IP, W/L and K. Hitting weighted toward OPS. Overall elite pitchers more valuable than elite hitters.

Roster Positions: No CI or MI. 3 OF Shallow Hitting and DEEP Pitching.

League Host: Yahoo!

 


RotoBaller Detailed Analysis >>

Hi Steven,

Thanks for your question. We haven't gotten a points league question yet! It always makes for an interesting analysis angle.

Even in a points league where pitchers are more valuable than hitters, McCutchen MUST BE one of your two keepers. Here's a guy who may still have more growth before hitting his prime, and though his BA will surely regress, his OPS should rise as his power continues to develop.

The other easy choice is letting Bruce go. In a H2H league, he can be borderline cancerous. Sure, he'll single-handedly win you 2 weeks throughout the year, but he is SO damn streaky that he will also act as a blackhole on your OF all the other weeks. Consistency is a really significant factor in this kind of format, and Jay Bruce is simply not yet consistent enough on a weekly basis to warrant keeping him.

That said, the REAL choice comes down to Bumgarner vs. Weaver. This is a really tough choice, buddy. Weaver was ranked eighteenth overall and the sixth best SP (5x5 rankings) in 2012. And in a points league where Pitcher Losses are a factor, Weaver was probably even better than that for you. Bumgarner was the fourteenth best SP and ranked 42 overall in 5x5. That is still fairly elite. He had a very respectable record at 16-11 but with fewer losses, he certainly would've cracked the top-ten SP list. So, you have two bona fide aces on your hands. Let's dig a little deeper and see if we can picture what 2013 has in store:

Weaver's ridiculous 20-5 record will come down to Earth; considering that he only threw 188 IP, there is a substantial amount of good luck in that record. His K-Rate has fallen big-time, to below the average for the top-100 SP-- in a league where Ks equal points, this points to trouble ahead. One other worrisome statistic is his .240 BABIP. A fly ball pitcher like Weaver can sustain a fairly low BABIP, but .240 is crazy-low, especially considering his fairly high line-drive % (21.1). Weaver's BABIP will likely regress to the .260-.270 range, which means more hits, in turn leading to more runs. All together, I think a line of 17-8 with 160 K and a 3.5 ERA is much more realistic expectation than a repeat of his eye-popping 2012.

Madison Bumgarner, conversely, is on the rise. His K-BB ratio is elite (18th overall) and will improve even further. His IP totals have been rising and he could easily surpass the 210 mark this year. If that happens, he'll also pass the 200 K mark for the first time in his career. Unlike Weaver (an extreme fly-ball pitcher), Bumgarner keeps the ball on the ground at a high rate, which is a much more reliable way to control run-scoring. San Francisco is always a good ball club, so Bumgarner should be good for a pretty similar record to last year's 16-11. Perhaps most significantly, he's only 22 years old, and he already has TWO high-end seasons under his belt. That is nasty! A reasonable projection for the Giants' young gun is a line of 16-9, 200 K and a 3.4 ERA.

 


YOUR ANSWER! >>

In summary, while McCutchen over Bruce is an easy call, Bumgarner vs. Weaver is much more difficult. In the end, I would go with Bumgarner for the following reasons: age, NL pitcher, K potential in a fantasy league format where points are tied to Ks, Weaver's diminishing Ks / huge IP totals of recent years, and the fact that sometimes you've just gotta go with your gut. Weaver is the EASY choice to make, but my gut is telling me he's in for a decline while Bumgarner is just about to take his game to the elite level.

 


Hope this was helpful and thanks for your submission!

- The RotoBaller Staff




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Brayan Bello1 hour ago

To Make Another Rehab Start On Sunday
1 hour ago

Kyle McCord Rising Up Draft Boards?
1 hour ago

Ashton Jeanty To Raiders Continues To Gain Steam
Ketel Marte1 hour ago

Diamondbacks Working On Extension For Ketel Marte
2 hours ago

Emeka Egbuka To Fall To Round 2?
Los Angeles Rams2 hours ago

Rob Havenstein Expected To Be Ready For Training Camp
Frankie Montas2 hours ago

Playing Catch From 60 Feet
Trea Turner2 hours ago

Returns To Wednesday's Lineup
Max Scherzer2 hours ago

Hopes To Resume Throwing On Friday
DL Hall2 hours ago

Scheduled To Throw A Bullpen On April 15
Aaron Ashby2 hours ago

Set To Throw Bullpen April 11
Derek Hill3 hours ago

Remains Out With Back Tightness
Jack Leiter3 hours ago

Removed From Wednesday's Start With A Blister
Michael Soroka3 hours ago

Listed As Sunday's Starter
Esteury Ruiz3 hours ago

Dodgers Acquire Esteury Ruiz
Kristian Campbell3 hours ago

Red Sox Sign Kristian Campbell To Eight-Year, $60 Million Extension
Cleveland Browns3 hours ago

Mike Hall Likely To Miss Offseason Program After Having Knee Surgery
New England Patriots4 hours ago

Christian Barmore Expected To Be Ready For Offseason Workouts
4 hours ago

Saints Expected To Visit With Quinn Ewers
Jake Moody4 hours ago

49ers To Bring In Competition For Jake Moody
Pittsburgh Steelers4 hours ago

Steelers In Play To Draft A Running Back
Tobias Myers4 hours ago

To Make First Rehab Start On Tuesday
Aaron Civale4 hours ago

To Throw Off A Mound On Saturday
Miami Marlins4 hours ago

Maximo Acosta Stellar In First Taste Of Triple-A
Christian Yelich5 hours ago

Out Wednesday Against Lefty
Bryan Reynolds5 hours ago

Dealing With Triceps Soreness
Luinder Avila5 hours ago

Strikes Out 11 In Second Triple-A Start
Alexis Díaz5 hours ago

Alexis Diaz To Begin Rehab Assignment This Weekend
Andrew Abbott5 hours ago

To Make Another Rehab Start On Sunday
James Triantos5 hours ago

Productive At The Start Of Triple-A Regular Season
Green Bay Packers6 hours ago

Packers Not Ruling Out Jaire Alexander Returning
Tennessee Titans6 hours ago

No. 1 Overall Pick Might Not Be For Sale
Kenny Pickett6 hours ago

Browns Feel Good About QB Situation, Kenny Pickett
Cleveland Browns7 hours ago

Browns Unlikely To Trade Up To No. 1 Overall For Cam Ward
Cincinnati Bengals7 hours ago

Bengals Still Working On Contract Extension With Trey Hendrickson
Dyami Brown7 hours ago

Jaguars Intrigued By Dyami Brown's Potential
Pittsburgh Steelers7 hours ago

All Options On The Table For Steelers At Quarterback
Jordan Mason7 hours ago

To Factor Into Short-Yardage, Goal-Line Situations
Bennedict Mathurin8 hours ago

Iffy For Wednesday
Joe Milton III8 hours ago

Patriots Have Received Multiple Trade Inquiries For Joe Milton III
Myles Turner8 hours ago

May Miss Another Game Wednesday
Al Horford8 hours ago

Considered Doubtful Wednesday
Jrue Holiday8 hours ago

Questionable For Wednesday's Game
Kristaps Porzingis8 hours ago

Listed As Questionable For Wednesday
Jaylen Brown8 hours ago

Could Remain On The Shelf Wednesday
Cade Cunningham8 hours ago

Likely Out For Fifth Straight Game
Anthony Davis9 hours ago

Probable Wednesday
Evan Bouchard10 hours ago

Tallies Two Assists In Victory
Jake Guentzel10 hours ago

Tallies Goal, Assist In Victory
Kirill Marchenko10 hours ago

Scores Hat Trick On Tuesday
Tage Thompson10 hours ago

Stays Hot On The Scoresheet
Lane Hutson11 hours ago

Dishes Out Three Helpers In Overtime Victory
Alex Ovechkin11 hours ago

Tallies Two Points In Victory
Cameron Young15 hours ago

A Player To Avoid At Valero Texas Open
Kurt Kitayama15 hours ago

In Search Of Consistency At Valero Texas Open
Si Woo Kim16 hours ago

Looking To Bounce Back At Valero Texas Open
Evan Engram17 hours ago

Sean Payton Excited About Evan Engram In Joker Role
Caleb Williams17 hours ago

To Spend More Time Working Under Center
Tom Hoge17 hours ago

Looking To Build Off Strong Performance At The PLAYERS Championship
Daniel Jones18 hours ago

Anthony Richardson, Daniel Jones To Split First-Team Reps This Offseason
Matt Fitzpatrick20 hours ago

Looking For Consistency At Valero Texas Open
Corey Conners20 hours ago

Continues Strong Form Ahead Of Valero Texas Open
Patrick Cantlay21 hours ago

Eyeing Victory At Valero Texas Open
Gary Woodland21 hours ago

Showing Great Form Ahead Of Valero Texas Open
Akshay Bhatia21 hours ago

Aiming For Repeat At Valero Texas Open
Alejandro Tosti21 hours ago

A Volatile Choice At TPC San Antonio
Guerschon Yabusele22 hours ago

Out Against Knicks
Karl-Anthony Towns22 hours ago

Sits Out Tuesday's Game
Jevon Carter22 hours ago

Ruled Out Tuesday
Dalen Terry22 hours ago

Unavailable Against Raptors
Julian Phillips22 hours ago

Out On Tuesday
Jalen Smith22 hours ago

Available Against Raptors
Lonzo Ball22 hours ago

Still Out On Tuesday
Kevin Huerter23 hours ago

Cleared For Tuesday's Matchup
Josh Giddey23 hours ago

Will Play On Tuesday
Dalano Banton23 hours ago

Starting Against The Hawks
Royce O'Neale23 hours ago

Unavailable Against Bucks
Jerami Grant23 hours ago

Out Again On Tuesday
Bradley Beal23 hours ago

Out On Tuesday
Jimmy Snuggerud23 hours ago

Ready For NHL Debut Tuesday
Jacob Trouba23 hours ago

Set To Rejoin Ducks Lineup Tuesday
Troy Terry24 hours ago

On Track To Play Tuesday
Jonathan Marchessault24 hours ago

Remains Out Against Blue Jackets
Alex Laferriere24 hours ago

Expected To Return On Tuesday
Luke Schenn24 hours ago

A Game-Time Decision Tuesday
Dante Fabbro1 day ago

Returns Against Predators
Olli Määttä1 day ago

Olli Maatta A Game-Time Call On Tuesday
Jordan Greenway1 day ago

Remains Sidelined On Tuesday
Jordan Staal1 day ago

Doubtful For Wednesday
Matt Roy1 day ago

Not Traveling With Team
Josh Norris1 day ago

Not Traveling With The Team On Tuesday
Brady Tkachuk1 day ago

Not Playing On Tuesday
Jordan Spieth1 day ago

Needs To Find Consistency At TPC San Antonio
Jake Knapp1 day ago

Making First Appearance At Valero Texas Open
Michael Kim1 day ago

Looking To Find The Magic Again In San Antonio
Tommy Fleetwood1 day ago

Is Nearly A Must-Play At Valero Texas Open
Tony Finau1 day ago

Hoping For Better Approach Play In San Antonio
Eric Cole1 day ago

Trending In Right Direction Ahead Of Valero
Casey DeSmith1 day ago

Sharp In Monday's Victory
Mason Marchment1 day ago

Tallies Two Helpers On Monday
Sam Stevens2 days ago

Enjoys Nice Result In Houston
PGA2 days ago

J.T. Poston Seeks To Contend At Valero Texas Open
Denny McCarthy2 days ago

Keeps Making Cuts But Needs To Make More Putts
Brian Harman2 days ago

Off To A Subpar 2025 So Far
Ryan Preece2 days ago

Has Three Straight Top-10 Finishes For First Time In His Career
NASCAR2 days ago

Bubba Wallace After Third-Place Finish At Martinsville: "What a Great Day"
Todd Gilliland2 days ago

Has Mistake-Free Day At Martinsville, Grabs Another Top-10 Finish
Brandon Moreno2 days ago

Wins Back-To-Back Fights
Steve Erceg2 days ago

Losses Third Consecutive Fight
Drew Dober2 days ago

Gets Knocked Out At UFC Mexico City
Manuel Torres2 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Harry Hall2 days ago

Bounces Back In Houston Last Week
CJ Vergara2 days ago

Gets Submitted
Édgar Cháirez2 days ago

Edgar Chairez Gets Submission Win At UFC Mexico City
Vince Morales2 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC Mexico City
Raul Rosas Jr.2 days ago

Gets Decision Win At UFC Mexico City
Saimon Oliveira2 days ago

Still Winless In The UFC
David Martinez2 days ago

Wins His UFC Debut
Kevin Borjas2 days ago

Earns His First UFC Win
Ronaldo Rodríguez2 days ago

Ronaldo Rodriguez Suffers His First UFC Loss
Christopher Bell2 days ago

Powers His Way To A Second-Place Finish At Martinsville
Chase Elliott2 days ago

Strong Martinsville Performance Ends With A Top-Five Finish
Kyle Larson2 days ago

Collects A Top-Five Finish At Martinsville
William Byron2 days ago

Places 22nd After Struggles At Martinsville
Joey Logano2 days ago

Claims His First 2025 Top-10 Finish After Up-And-Down Performance
Tyler Reddick2 days ago

Fails To Place In The Top 10 At Martinsville
Denny Hamlin3 days ago

Silences Doubters After Crew-Chief Change
Ty Gibbs3 days ago

Earns Best 2025 Finish At Martinsville Despite Failing Cool Suit
Ross Chastain3 days ago

Has A Great Day At Martinsville
Chase Briscoe3 days ago

Has Solid Run At Martinsville
Erik Jones3 days ago

Disqualified At Martinsville For Weight Violation
Josh Berry3 days ago

Has Top-10 Upside At Martinsville
Joey Logano3 days ago

Don't Overlook Joey Logano This Weekend
Ryan Preece3 days ago

Could Get First Three-Race Top-10 Streak Of His Career
Chase Elliott3 days ago

Looking To Continue Great Runs At Martinsville
Christopher Bell3 days ago

Wins Pole At Martinsville, But Can He Stay Up There?
Ryan Blaney3 days ago

Fast In Practice But Skeptical About Car
Denny Hamlin3 days ago

New Crew Chief Has Terrible Martinsville Record
Steve Erceg5 days ago

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Brandon Moreno5 days ago

A Favorite At UFC Mexico City
Manuel Torres5 days ago

Set For Co-Main Event
Drew Dober5 days ago

An Underdog At UFC Mexico City
Joe Pyfer5 days ago

Looks To Win Back-To-Back Fights
Kelvin Gastelum5 days ago

Set For Middleweight Matchup
Vince Morales5 days ago

In Dire Need Of Victory
Raul Rosas Jr.5 days ago

Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Saimon Oliveira5 days ago

Looks For His First UFC Win
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF