X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Mark Trumbo Rankings Debate: Comparing RotoBaller's Rankers

It's the fantasy baseball draft season. To us baseball nerds, few things are more exciting than arguing about player rankings. Today, we'll discuss and compare Mark Trumbo's RotoBaller staff rankings. He was ranked No. 51 overall by Jeff Kahntroff, and No. 136 by Brad Johnson.

Throughout this series, we'll be using our February Staff Rankings to debate where to draft certain players. In cases where our writers had discrepancies, we've asked them to explain their rankings. These debates will provide us with some well-rounded analysis, and help identify undervalued/overvalued draft picks.

Editor's note: Check out our previous rankings debates on Jose RamirezTrea TurnerJ.D MartinezNelson Cruz, Jose AbreuBryce HarperCarlos Martinez, Kyle SchwarberJonathan VillarKenta MaedaAndrew McCutchenGregory Polanco, Marcus Stroman, Jackie Bradley, Xander Bogaerts. and Kendrys Morales.

 

2017 Draft Rankings Debate: Mark Trumbo

Jeff Kahntroff's Rankings Analysis

His Overall Ranking: 51

Mark Trumbo is one of the big proponents of the new swing technology allowing hitters to work on perfecting their launch angle and exit velocity. He has spoken about how the more aggressive version of him is a better player, and thus much of what may seem like a lucky 2017 is actually the result of a lot of hard work and conscious decisions. Moreover, many who have seen homer spikes after changing their launch angles have seen that power spike stick (e.g. Matt Carpenter). Trumbo’s likely will too.

Thus, I believe this “breakout” was a real result rather than chance. I also believe that he did not have a major second half “dropoff” as many are suggesting. Yes, he did hit .288/28/55/68/1 vs .214/19/39/40/1, but let’s compare the underlying numbers:

BB% K% BABIP FB% Hard-hit % Pull %
1st Half 6.9 26.4 .327 43.1 38.3 41.9
2nd Half 8.6 24.3 .216 43.1 40.5 42.1

 

Trumbo was much unluckier in the second half. But even his second-half 162-game pace was .214/43/88/90/0. Considering the low BABIP and the fact that the entire Orioles’ offense struggled in the second half (5.08 runs per game before the break, and 4.03 after), a .250/40/90/100/2 line seems reasonable to me as the average and run production will likely rebound. Taking out any personal bias by using his 2016 numbers and 2017 Steamer projections only, let’s compare Trumbo to a few players Brad has ranked way ahead of him:

Player (Brad’s Rank) 2016 Steamer 2017 162-game pace
Mark Trumbo (136) .256/47/94/108/2 .259/38/89/107/2
Carlos Santana (79) .259/34/89/87/5 .254/24/104/89/7
Adrian Gonzalez (102) .285/18/69/90/0 .263/24/80/91/1
Kole Calhoun (109) .271/18/91/75/2 .262/23/90/83/5
Jackie Bradley Jr. (101) .267/26/94/87/9 .261/19/79/78/8
Average (98) .271/24/86/85/4 .260/23/88/85/5
Difference (+38) -.015/+23/+8/+23/-2 -.001/+15/+1/+22/-3

 

Do you really want to draft guys 38 spots higher who put up significantly worse lines in 2016 and who Steamer projects to put up significantly worse stats again in 2017? Obviously not. This is a case of Trumbo being ranked far below worse players. Many may discount what Trumbo did because of his right field defense and baserunning. But those shouldn’t affect your fantasy valuation.

 

Brad Johnson's Rankings Analysis

His Overall Ranking: 136

Let's play a little Player A and Player B. One of these guys only played about half a season so I've normalized everything to 650 plate appearances.

HR/650 PA BB% K% FB% Pull% Hard Hit%
Player A 46 7.6 25.5 43.1 42 39.3
Player B 39 6.3 21.6 45.1 41.9 36.6

 

Player A is Trumbo. Player B was ranked 285 by Jeff and 217 by me. It's Phillies first baseman Tommy Joseph. Trumbo and Joseph were the same player last season. I've highlighted fly ball percentage, pull rate, and hard hit rate because they correlate very strongly with home run ability. And they tend to be fairly consistent year-to-year. If nothing changes, both are low OBP, 35 to 45 home run threats.

Trumbo is entering his age 31 campaign with just one season of high quality production. He's not without risk of collapse or serious regression. I buy his power as legitimate - I predicted him to lead the league in home runs in 2015 (drat, missed by a year). However, there are a lot of ways for a bad bodied, no defense slugger to turn pumpkin. For example, any kind of injury, age related decline in bat speed, or even more mundane causes.

By comparison, Joseph, 25, missed a ton of development time and has a lot more room to improve. With that comes downside risk. Because he doesn't have the established track record of hitting for power, we can't assume he'll maintain his 18.9 percent HR/FB ratio. I expect him to, but there's less certainty than with Trumbo. In short, Joseph is the more volatile asset. He should be going after Trumbo in drafts.

However, it's hard to justify Jeff's spread - he's taking Joseph 234 picks after Trumbo. Jeff highlighted some players I'd take ahead of Trumbo, and I stand by those picks. While those guys may not have 40 home run potential, they're much more reliable. I'd rather take a higher floor athlete in the mid-rounds and draft Trumbo's clone at the end.

With all that said, after closer examination, I was probably a little harsh in my ranking of Trumbo. I'll be moving him (and Joseph) up my draft board a couple dozen spots.




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Andrew Benintendi26 mins ago

Feeling "Really Good"
Bilal Coulibaly30 mins ago

Could Miss Rest Of Season
Paul George50 mins ago

Assessing Options With Surgery Possible
Stone Smartt1 hour ago

Jets Sign Stone Smartt To One-Year Deal
Houston Texans1 hour ago

Texans Acquire Ed Ingram From Vikings
Trevor Story2 hours ago

Takes Part In Simulated Game On Thursday
Rafael Devers2 hours ago

Doesn't Mind Serving As DH
Tyler Stephenson2 hours ago

Going For MRI Exam
Brandon Woodruff2 hours ago

To Make Spring Debut On Sunday
Ronald Acuña Jr.2 hours ago

Ronald Acuna Jr. Could Return In Early- To Mid-May
Los Angeles Chargers2 hours ago

Chargers Adding Defensive Lineman Naquan Jones
Spencer Strider2 hours ago

Could Rejoin The Rotation In Late April
Daulton Varsho2 hours ago

Throwing Up To 105 Feet
Max Scherzer3 hours ago

Should Be Back On The Mound Soon
Los Angeles Chargers3 hours ago

Chargers Signing Da'Shawn Hand To One-Year Deal
Edward Cabrera3 hours ago

Leaves Early On Thursday With Blister Issue
Washington Commanders3 hours ago

Sheldon Day Re-Signing With Commanders
K.J. Osborn3 hours ago

Heading Back To Washington
Harrison Bryant3 hours ago

Landing In Philadelphia
Brandon Allen3 hours ago

Joining Titans Quarterback Room
Ivan Barbashev3 hours ago

Returning On Thursday
Kenny Pickett3 hours ago

Views Himself As Browns Starter
Igor Shesterkin3 hours ago

Starting On Thursday
Neal Pionk3 hours ago

Misses Second Straight Practice
Nikolaj Ehlers4 hours ago

Does Not Practice On Thursday
Andrei Svechnikov4 hours ago

Doubtful For Friday
Nikita Kucherov4 hours ago

A Game-Time Call On Thursday
Noah Brown4 hours ago

Returning To Washington On One-Year Deal
Raheem Mostert4 hours ago

Raiders Signing Raheem Mostert To One-Year Deal
Cincinnati Bengals4 hours ago

Teams Finding Bengals' Asking Price On Trey Hendrickson To Be "Ridiculous"
New England Patriots5 hours ago

Patriots Plan To Release David Andrews
New Orleans Saints5 hours ago

Saints Give Isaac Yiadom A Three-Year Deal
Mason Rudolph5 hours ago

Back In The Steel City
Lucas Giolito5 hours ago

Will Begin Season On Injured List
Cody Bradford5 hours ago

To Start On Injured List
Jacob deGrom5 hours ago

Scratched Due To Stomach Virus
Marcus Semien5 hours ago

Back On Thursday
Brett Baty5 hours ago

Could Open The Year At Second Base
Sean Manaea5 hours ago

Resumes Throwing
Brandon Nimmo6 hours ago

Back In Spring Lineup On Thursday
CJ Abrams6 hours ago

Back In Thursday's Lineup
Lucas Giolito7 hours ago

Has Low-Grade Hamstring Strain
Cooper Kupp7 hours ago

Seahawks Interested In Cooper Kupp
Ke'Bryan Hayes8 hours ago

Resumes Full Baseball Activities
Brandin Podziemski8 hours ago

Out On Thursday
Jeff McNeil8 hours ago

Suffers Low-Grade Oblique Strain
Yves Missi8 hours ago

Questionable Thursday
Kelly Olynyk8 hours ago

Misses Second Consecutive Game Thursday
Josh Giddey8 hours ago

Will Be "Out For A Little Bit"
Lonzo Ball8 hours ago

Unlikely To Play Thursday
Bilal Coulibaly8 hours ago

Unavailable Thursday
Malcolm Brogdon9 hours ago

Remains Out Against Pistons
Brandon Montour10 hours ago

Scores Twice In Victory
Dylan Guenther10 hours ago

Nets Game-Winner Over Anaheim
Elias Pettersson11 hours ago

Tallies Goal, Assist On Wednesday
Patrick Kane11 hours ago

Leads The Way Over Buffalo
Elias Pettersson11 hours ago

Sustains Injury On Wednesday
Jacob Bryson11 hours ago

Exits Early On Wednesday
NFL18 hours ago

Shemar Stewart To Visit With Falcons
San Francisco 49ers18 hours ago

Juan Thornhill To Visit With 49ers On Thursday
Russell Wilson18 hours ago

To Visit With Giants On Friday
Aaron Rodgers19 hours ago

Vikings Not Ruling Out Adding Aaron Rodgers
Tennessee Titans19 hours ago

Titans Sign Dre'Mont Jones To One-Year Deal
Mikael Backlund19 hours ago

Sustains An Upper-Body Injury Wednesday
Joey Daccord19 hours ago

Looks To End Losing Streak Against Canadiens
Patrik Laine19 hours ago

Returns To Action Wednesday
Noah Clowney19 hours ago

Questionable Versus The Bulls
Mattias Janmark19 hours ago

Misses Practice Due To Illness
Mattias Ekholm20 hours ago

To Miss Three-Game Road Trip
TOR20 hours ago

Chris Tanev Could Return To Action Thursday
ANA20 hours ago

Ville Husso Starts For Ducks Wednesday
Domantas Sabonis20 hours ago

May Return To Kings Lineup Thursday
Rudy Gobert20 hours ago

Suiting Up Against Nuggets
Aaron Gordon20 hours ago

Ruled Out Against Timberwolves
Jamal Murray20 hours ago

Upgraded To Available Wednesday
Nikola Jokić20 hours ago

Nikola Jokic Available Wednesday
Matisse Thybulle21 hours ago

Available For Season Debut Wednesday Night
Robert Williams III21 hours ago

Ready For Action Against Knicks
Jerami Grant21 hours ago

Out Against Knicks
Damian Lillard21 hours ago

Probable For Thursday's Action
Giannis Antetokounmpo21 hours ago

Likely To Play Against Lakers
Luka Dončić21 hours ago

Luka Doncic Listed As Questionable For Thursday
Jakub Dobes1 day ago

Starting On Wednesday
Karel Vejmelka1 day ago

Facing Anaheim On Wednesday
Jacob Bridgeman1 day ago

Use Caution For Jacob Bridgeman At TPC Sawgrass
Nicolai Hojgaard1 day ago

Looks To Stay Consistent Heading Into PLAYERS Championship
Karl Vilips1 day ago

Makes PLAYERS Championship Debut After First PGA Tour Win
Taylor Pendrith1 day ago

A Sneaky Play At TPC Sawgrass
Sahith Theegala1 day ago

Out Of Form Ahead Of The PLAYERS Championship
Matt Fitzpatrick1 day ago

A Shaky Play Heading Into PLAYERS
Scottie Scheffler1 day ago

Eyeing Three-Peat At TPC Sawgrass
Aldrich Potgieter1 day ago

A Risky Play At TPC Sawgrass
Si Woo Kim1 day ago

Looks To Keep Building Momentum At The PLAYERS
Denny McCarthy1 day ago

Looks To Continue Solid Play At TPC Sawgrass
Collin Morikawa2 days ago

Poised For Another Strong Performance At TPC Sawgrass
Robert MacIntyre2 days ago

A Risky Play With Upside At The PLAYERS Championship
Jordan Spieth2 days ago

Looking To Change Fortunes At TPC Sawgrass
Cameron Young2 days ago

Avoid Cameron Young At The PLAYERS Championship
Michael Kim2 days ago

Continues Incredible Form Ahead Of The PLAYERS Championship
Justin Thomas2 days ago

Looking For More Magic At TPC Sawgrass
Xander Schauffele2 days ago

Continues Competitive Return At The Players Championship
Rory McIlroy2 days ago

Looks To Reverse Recent History At TPC Sawgrass
PGA2 days ago

Victor Hovland Looking To Find Form At The PLAYERS Championship
Brian Harman2 days ago

A Sleeper Pick At The PLAYERS Championship
Min Woo Lee2 days ago

A Hard Name To Trust At The Players Championship
Tyler Reddick3 days ago

Power-Steering Failure Foils Tyler Reddick's Bid For Potential Victory
William Byron3 days ago

Recovers From Being Trapped A Lap Down To Finish Sixth
Josh Berry3 days ago

Gives Wood Brothers Team Best Run Since 2021
Alex Pereira3 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC 313
Magomed Ankalaev3 days ago

Becomes The New UFC Light-Heavyweight Champion
Justin Gaethje3 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Rafael Fiziev3 days ago

Loses Third Fight In A Row
Ignacio Bahamondes3 days ago

Gets Submission Win At UFC 313
Christopher Bell3 days ago

Scores His Third Consecutive Victory Of The Season At Phoenix
Kyle Larson3 days ago

Strong Phoenix Performance Falls Short Of Victory
Chris Buescher3 days ago

Quietly Earns A Top-Five Finish At Phoenix
Alex Bowman3 days ago

Leaves Phoenix With His Best Finish At The Site Since 2016
Zane Smith3 days ago

Quietly Nabs His First Phoenix Top-10 Finish
Jalin Turner3 days ago

Retires After UFC 313 Loss
Iasmin Lucindo3 days ago

Gets Dominated At UFC 313
Amanda Lemos3 days ago

Dominates At UFC 313
King Green3 days ago

Gets Knocked Out At UFC 313
Mauricio Ruffy3 days ago

Scores Highlight-Reel Knockout
Chase Elliott4 days ago

Is Chase Elliott Worth Rostering At Phoenix This Week For DFS?
Joey Logano4 days ago

Will Be A Top Contender To Win At Phoenix
Denny Hamlin4 days ago

Is Difficult to Recommend As A DFS Option
Carson Hocevar4 days ago

Is Not An Ideal Driver To Add To Phoenix DFS Lineups
Brad Keselowski4 days ago

Is A Solid DFS Choice For Phoenix Lineups
Austin Cindric4 days ago

Could Be Worth Using In Phoenix Tournament Lineups
Kyle Busch4 days ago

Should Fantasy Players Roster Kyle Busch At Phoenix?
Michael McDowell4 days ago

Is Michael McDowell Worth Rostering For Phoenix DFS Lineups?
Ty Gibbs4 days ago

Is A DFS Recommendation Despite Inconsistent Track History At Phoenix
Austin Dillon4 days ago

Is Austin Dillon Worth Rostering In DFS For Phoenix This Week?
Cole Custer4 days ago

Is An Underrated DFS Value Pick For Phoenix Lineups
Tyler Reddick4 days ago

DFS Value Likely Hinges On How Much He Leads
Chase Briscoe4 days ago

Despite Strong Phoenix Record, Chase Briscoe Qualifies Inexplicably Poorly
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF