X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Lessons Learned For Fantasy Baseball 2025

Chas McCormick - Fantasy Baseball Rankings, Draft Sleepers, MLB News

Welcome back to the Lookahead; this week we apply lessons from 2024 to our 2025 draft prep.

One of the primary, overarching goals with this column is simple: how can we improve as fantasy players? Just as a shop owner doesn’t know what to order next without taking inventory, so too should we reflect on past fantasy experiences to avoid making the same mistakes again. What did we miss about certain players, and why? And how can these lessons inform future decisions?

Today we’ll examine a few players that let us down this past season and identify similar players who could be landmines in 2025.


Zach Gelof, 2B - Oakland Athletics

This one is relatively straightforward. Some of my favorite analysts emphasize a batter’s ability to make contact, but I was convinced that superlative contact quality (e.g. hard hit, barrels) could override swing-and-miss. For example, Bryce Harper and Rafael Devers had well below-average contact rates, ergo Gelof could likewise succeed.

It turns out Gelof is not in the class of those guys as far as hitting the ball hard consistently; I was led astray by his 11% barrel and 41% hard-hit rates in 2023. After all, he hit .267 and went 14/14 in just 69 games. Hence, I equated Gelof to Matt McLain lite, except Gelof was going much later in drafts.

There was just one problem: contact quantity. McLain made contact far more often (85% zone and 75% overall, per Sports Info Solutions), supporting his batting average. Gelof meanwhile was near the bottom of the majors in both, with just 75% zone and 68% overall contact rates in 2023. I didn’t expect a great average but thought he’d be able to repeat something close to .250 based on his Statcast readings.

Gelof still provided power and speed in 2024, but he wasn’t able to successfully overcome his contact deficiencies, destroying our batting averages by hitting .211. His marginally acceptable 27% strikeout rate ballooned to an unmanageable 34%:

Moreover, Gelof’s contact quality dipped too, down to 9% barrel and 37% hard hit rates. Pitchers had a book on him now and exploited his dubious swing decisions.

There’s another lesson here: don’t be too quick to buy into small sample excellence, especially when there are warning signs that could collapse the whole profile. Having learned the hard way, I previously wrote about three 2024 small sample standouts who could be “next year’s Gelof.” 

2025 Version: Connor Norby (Nice run of late-season power but 12th percentile contact rate, 33% strikeouts, and 18% SwStr)


Brandon Drury, UT - Los Angeles Angels

This one was a little trickier to figure out. Drury appeared pretty safe for boring but solid production, coming off two seasons of a .260+ batting average and 26+ HR. His playing time was safe on a thin Angels team. He was 31 and played at least 125 games in both 2022 and 2023. He was cheap in drafts too, and a nice fallback option for middle or corner infield in the later rounds.

Well, all of Drury’s believers were treated to a dreary letdown: he began slowly, dealt with a hamstring strain in mid-April, and was just awful when he did play: his .169/.242/.228 line added up to a 34 wRC+, by far the worst in MLB (min. 300 PA). He went from 14% above league average to 66% below.

The thing is, Drury didn’t have a complete collapse in contact or strikeout rate. He just stopped hitting the ball hard consistently (-2 mph average exit velocity) and stopped hitting it in the air, with an absurd 57% ground ball rate, up 15% from 2023.

We still couldn’t explain why Drury was so bad. Yes, he had the hammy and dealt with a migraine, but we didn’t learn the main culprit until after the season: Drury revealed in late September he had changed his swing entering the season, ironically to get to more power.

Clearly, there were factors here we couldn’t have known beforehand, but Drury had also shown consistently solid production for only two seasons. The lesson here: approach late-career breakouts with caution and low expectations.

2025 Version: Jurickson Profar (By far a career year at 30. He added bulk and hard-hit rate, so he may have a new level now, just don’t overpay for it.)

 

Chas McCormick, OF - Houston Astros

This one hurts. I was all about drafting Chas, but like Drury, McCormick broke out at a relatively advanced age (28) in 2023, hitting .273 with 22 homers and 19 steals in just 115 games.

Even before then, he’d flashed good quality of contact with 10%-barrel rates the prior two seasons, primarily against lefties. In 2023 he showed he could hit righties well enough to play every day.

Or so we thought. McCormick was given a shot as a regular in 2024...and posted a .576 OPS over 94 games. Yes, he suffered a hamstring injury in April, missed three weeks, and ended with a hand fracture in mid-September. However, he wasn’t good before, during or after the injuries. From opening day to the hammy issue: .602 OPS. After returning from the hammy until the hand injury: .564 OPS.

Despite owning lefties in prior seasons, he had a worse OPS versus them (.550) than against righties (.590).

It’s possible McCormick just started slowly and the hammy bothered him even after the IL stint. But as with Gelof, McCormick has always walked a fine line between dubious contact quantity (80% career) and solid quality (10% barrel). Well, as the playing time went up his zone contact plummeted to 76% and he chased and whiffed more (16% SwStr).

McCormick is a combination of lessons, from extrapolating small sample performance to waving away his own org’s reticence to trust him to dismiss possible contact issues that could sink the profile.

2025 Version: Jo Adell (15th percentile contact% and OPS dropped 24 points with full-season PT)


Luis Campusano, C - San Diego Padres

It’s a familiar story in that Campusano had only shown us a small stretch of good performance, hitting .319 (.305 xBA) with seven home runs over 49 games in 2023. But unlike some of these other misses, Campusano had shown elite contact ability, with 91% zone and 84% overall that year. I was convinced he could give our fantasy teams an average boost as a C2 while possibly expanding the power output.

It seems the Padres believed the same, as Campusano opened as their No. 1 backstop. It did not go well. He was one of the worst defensive catchers (-13 OAA) and didn’t hit for power or average, batting .227 with 8 HR in 91 games. He did suffer a thumb injury in late June but hadn’t produced much before that either (.653 OPS, five HR).

In Campusano’s case, the skills he’d shown before didn’t degrade completely; he still boasted above-average contact and chase rates. He just didn’t hit the ball as hard consistently, with his hard hit dropping from 41% to 34% and his already middling barrels from 7% to just 4%.

The Padres eventually lost patience and sent Campusano to the minors while elevating Kyle Higashioka, a much better fielding catcher who also happened to be barreling at the plate.

Again, we have a short sample all-star who couldn’t maintain his performance into a new season. The other Campusano lesson is the importance of defense: unless a defensively limited player is mashing, he has no margin for error to sustain playing time. I’ll be taking catching and fielding metrics into greater account going forward.

2025 Version: Ryan Jeffers (-7 OAA, Hard Hit fell from 43% to 34% with full PT)

 

Nick Pivetta, SP - Boston Red Sox

Pivetta was not a complete disaster like some of the above players, but he left us wanting…again. Perhaps this lesson is more about us than the player.

Pivetta is an enticing pitcher because he regularly sits near the top of metrics we value, especially K-BB%: in 2023 he ranked 8th at 22.7%, between Freddy Peralta and Chris Sale (min. 100 IP).

He also breaks stuff models, sitting 10th that season in Stuff+ and 12th in Pitching+, per FanGraphs. His second half was even better, ranking second and top six respectively in each metric. Based on these numbers, many drafters thought Pivetta could be their SP3 or SP4 with upside.

Here’s the thing: in 2024 Pivetta ranked 10th in K-BB% and fourth in Stuff+. Pretty great! However, his ERA sat north of 4 for the fourth straight season (4.14). Not terrible, but not helpful either. He finished as the 68th-best starter, earning $4. That’s not even an SP5 in a 12-team league.

Pivetta’s approach of challenging hitters high in the zone to induce whiffs also makes him a heavy fly ball pitcher (48%), which wouldn’t be so bad except it’s led to extreme home runs: career 15.5% HR/FB% is well above the league average of 11%. You may want to blame this on his home venue, as Fenway is a great hitter's park.

However, Pivetta was worse on the road, with a 4.42 ERA versus 3.86 at home and far more home runs allowed as well (18% HR/FB% to 11%). Look, Nicky P gave us a boatload of strikeouts (172) and a boost in WHIP (1.13). This wasn’t a total miss. But it does warn us against focusing on certain metrics to the exclusion of others.

For example, xFIP normalizes homers allowed to league average and has always liked Pivetta about a half-run better than FIP (or ERA) does. When a player has established a statistical baseline over multiple seasons, we should probably just trust his actual numbers.

2025 Version: Taj Bradley (career 17% HR/FB% and xFIP half to full run better than FIP; a nice upside play but draft SP depth around him)



Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy baseball app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, sleepers, prospects & more. All free!






POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Cam Whitmore28 mins ago

Considered Questionable For Wednesday
Ryan Rollins36 mins ago

Continues To Sit Wednesday
Kevon Looney44 mins ago

Expected To Return On Wednesday
Kyle Anderson54 mins ago

Questionable For Wednesday
Miles McBride1 hour ago

Remains On The Shelf Wednesday
Norman Powell1 hour ago

Will Not Play On Wednesday
Connor Bedard1 hour ago

Ends Drought With Two Assists
Sam Reinhart2 hours ago

Pushes Point Streak To 11 Games
Mark Scheifele2 hours ago

Celebrates Ninth Career Hat Trick
Evan Bouchard2 hours ago

Rocks Senators With Three-Point Period
Connor McDavid2 hours ago

Nets Two Goals During Three-Point Night
NHL2 hours ago

Nicholas Paul Exits Early With Injury Tuesday
Zach Hyman2 hours ago

Sits Out Third Period Versus Senators
10 hours ago

Guardians' Stephen Vogt Named AL Manager Of The Year
Milwaukee Brewers10 hours ago

Pat Murphy Named NL Manager Of The Year
Bradley Beal13 hours ago

Still Out On Wednesday Evening
Jusuf Nurkic13 hours ago

Questionable Versus The Knicks
Anthony Davis13 hours ago

Will Play Against The Jazz
Stephen Curry13 hours ago

Back On The Injury Report For Wednesday
Jalen Johnson13 hours ago

Questionable Versus Golden State
Ben Sheppard14 hours ago

Considered Questionable For Wednesday
Jalen Green15 hours ago

Uncertain For Wednesday’s Game
Myles Turner15 hours ago

Considered Questionable For Wednesday
Cam Thomas15 hours ago

Will Not Play Tuesday
Giannis Antetokounmpo15 hours ago

Listed As Probable For Wednesday
Marcus Smart15 hours ago

Ruled Out For Tuesday
Cam Thomas15 hours ago

Is Questionable For Tuesday
Anfernee Simons15 hours ago

In Danger Of Missing Another Game
Deandre Ayton15 hours ago

Considered Doubtful For Wednesday
Kyle Lowry15 hours ago

To Miss Next Three Games
Jonas Brodin16 hours ago

Returns To Action
Joel Eriksson Ek16 hours ago

Returns To Wild Lineup
16 hours ago

Nick Pivetta Declines Boston's Qualifying Offer
Robert Thomas16 hours ago

Back For Blues Tuesday
Jose Siri16 hours ago

Mets Acquire Jose Siri From The Rays
Alexander Romanov16 hours ago

Rejoins Islanders Lineup
Brayden Point17 hours ago

Ready To Return Versus Penguins
Conor Garland17 hours ago

A Game-Time Call Tuesday
J.T. Miller17 hours ago

Takes Indefinite Leave For Personal Reasons
Jake Ferguson17 hours ago

"Will Be Hard-Pressed" To Play In Week 12
Alex Ovechkin17 hours ago

Considered Week-To-Week
Cooper Rush17 hours ago

Will Start In Week 12
Brandin Cooks17 hours ago

Cowboys Hoping Brandin Cooks Returns This Week
20 hours ago

Phillies To Meet With Juan Soto
20 hours ago

Luis Severino Rejects Qualifying Offer From Mets
Aaron Rodgers20 hours ago

' Status With Jets In Doubt For 2025?
20 hours ago

Willy Adames Declines Brewers Qualifying Offer
20 hours ago

Teoscar Hernandez Declines Qualifying Offer From Dodgers
20 hours ago

Juan Soto Declines Yankees' Qualifying Offer
New York Jets22 hours ago

Jets Fire GM Joe Douglas
Travis Konecny1 day ago

Stretches Point Streak To Seven Games
Sam Montembeault1 day ago

Records 30-Save Shutout Versus Oilers
William Eklund1 day ago

Scores Twice In Overtime Victory
Brett Leason1 day ago

Tallies Three Points In Win Over Stars
Brock McGinn1 day ago

Exits Win With Injury
Alex Ovechkin1 day ago

Evaluated For Leg Injury
Luke Schoonmaker1 day ago

Commands 10 Targets Amidst Teammate's Injury
CeeDee Lamb1 day ago

Remains Productive Despite Loss
Houston Texans1 day ago

Texans D/ST Finds End Zone In Victory At Dallas
Joe Mixon1 day ago

Extends Hot Streak Against Cowboys
Luis Gil2 days ago

Wins AL Rookie Of The Year Award
Jake Ferguson2 days ago

Won't Return On Monday
Paul Skenes2 days ago

Named 2024 NL Rookie Of The Year
Brock Purdy2 days ago

Day-To-Day With Shoulder Soreness
George Kittle2 days ago

Expected To Practice On Wednesday
CeeDee Lamb2 days ago

Officially Active On Monday Night
Nico Collins2 days ago

Won't Face Playing-Time Restrictions On Monday Night
New York Giants2 days ago

Brian Daboll On The Hot Seat In New York?
Brady Singer2 days ago

Reds, Royals Discussing Jonathan India, Brady Singer
Gardner Minshew II2 days ago

Raiders Sticking With Gardner Minshew II At QB
2 days ago

Sean Manaea To Reject Mets' Qualifying Offer
Dak Prescott2 days ago

Heading To Injured Reserve
2 days ago

Braves Have Interest In Walker Buehler
Isiah Pacheco2 days ago

Andy Reid On Isiah Pacheco: "We'll See How He Does In Practice"
2 days ago

Astros Interested In Willy Adames
Gabe Davis2 days ago

Won't Return In 2024
Mike Evans2 days ago

Seen At Practice On Monday
CeeDee Lamb2 days ago

Tracking Towards Playing On Monday Night
Charles Oliveira2 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Michael Chandler2 days ago

Gets Dominated At UFC 309
Karine Silva2 days ago

Suffers Her First UFC Loss
Viviane Araujo2 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Mauricio Ruffy2 days ago

Extends His Win Streak To Six
Nick Martinez3 days ago

Signs Qualifying Offer With Reds
3 days ago

Luis Severino Likely To Decline Qualifying Offer From Mets
James Llontop3 days ago

Loses Clear-Cut Decision In Thrilling Fight At UFC 309
Paul Craig3 days ago

Loses Decision At UFC 309
Bo Nickal3 days ago

Remains Undefeated With Lackluster Performance At UFC 309
Stipe Miocic3 days ago

Retires After UFC 309 Loss
Jon Jones3 days ago

Gets TKO Win At UFC 309 To Defend Heavyweight Title
Grayson Rodriguez5 days ago

Orioles Optimistic Grayson Rodriguez Will Have A Full Spring Training
5 days ago

Red Sox Have Productive Meeting With Juan Soto
Michael Chandler5 days ago

Set For A Rematch At UFC 309
Charles Oliveira5 days ago

A Favorite At UFC 309
Viviane Araujo5 days ago

An Underdog At UFC 309
Karine Silva5 days ago

Looks To Extend Her Win Streak
Mauricio Ruffy5 days ago

Looks For His Second UFC Win
Jett Williams5 days ago

Suffers Sprained Ankle In AFL
James Llontop6 days ago

A Big Underdog At UFC 309
Paul Craig6 days ago

Looks To Snap Losing Skid At UFC 309
Bo Nickal6 days ago

Puts Undefeated Record On The Line At UFC 309
Stipe Miocic6 days ago

Ends Layoff At UFC 309
Jon Jones6 days ago

Defends Heavyweight Title At UFC 309
Tampa Bay Rays6 days ago

Rays To Play Home Games In 2025 At Steinbrenner Field

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

MORE RECENT ARTICLES

 

Video: Week 12 Must-Start Defense (D/ST) Streamers - 2024 Fantasy Football Start/Sit Analysis

We're back and dropping fire content for Week 12! Check out our top 2024 fantasy football must-start Defenses (D/ST) and be prepared to dominate your matchups! LaQuan Jones discusses his top "Must Start" Defense (D/ST) streamers that have the potential to be game-changers in Week 12, as well as some defenses that you might want […]


D'Andre Swift - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injuries

Fantasy Football Trade Targets - Buy/Sell For Week 12 Including Josh Downs, T.J. Hockenson, Bucky Irving, D'Andre Swift

For many fantasy football gamers, the end of Week 11 marked the last opportunity to make trades ahead of the fantasy playoffs. However, there are plenty of leagues that have a later deadline and some that have no deadline at all. This is especially true of dynasty leagues, and while this week's column will still […]


Justin Herbert - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

Fantasy Football Matchups We Love - Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks for Week 12 Include Bo Nix, De'Von Achane, Quentin Johnston, Calvin Ridley, more

It seems as though fantasy managers were either incredibly disappointed or incredibly excited in Week 11. The output was modest for most players. However, if you had a monopoly on a select few players such as Cooper Kupp, Taysom Hill, or the Detroit Lions, you likely won your week. With the fantasy playoffs roughly three weeks […]


Christian McCaffrey - Fantasy Football Rankings, DFS and Betting Picks, NFL Injury News

Fantasy Football Matchups to Target, Avoid (Week 12) - Offensive Line Champs and Chumps

11 weeks have come and gone in the NFL season, which means the fantasy playoffs are just around the corner. Whether you are at the top of the standings or fighting for a playoff spot, Week 12 will feature a unique challenge. Six teams are on bye in Week 12, forcing fantasy managers to get […]


Darnell Mooney - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, Waiver Wire Pickups

Fantasy Football WR Injury Reports: Week 12 Updates For Darnell Mooney, Gabe Davis, Mike Evans, Adam Thielen

The season's (first) biggest bye week has arrived. Six teams (Falcons, Bills, Bengals, Jaguars, Saints, Jets) get a week off. That makes it more important for fantasy football that the wide receivers scheduled to play do so. To keep close tabs on all of the news across the NFL, make sure to favorite or bookmark […]


George Pickens - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL injury News

Steelers vs. Browns TNF Start 'Em, Sit 'Em: Jameis Winston, Nick Chubb, David Njoku, Jerry Jeudy, Russell Wilson, Najee Harris, George Pickens

The Week 12 Thursday Night Football game between two bitter AFC North rivals (Cleveland Browns and Pittsburgh Steelers) is not likely to end up like the Thursday night game from two weeks ago when two different AFC North teams (Bengals and Ravens) battled to a 35-34 shootout. Somewhere deep in the charter of the Pittsburgh […]


Isiah Pacheco - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Rookies

Fantasy Football Injury Reports For NFL RBs: Week 12 Updates for Isiah Pacheco, Tyjae Spears, Jonathon Brooks, Miles Sanders

Below is our fantasy football injuries report for running backs in Week 12, as of November 20. The injury statuses for various NFL running backs are up in the air for Week 12, including Isiah Pacheco, Tyjae Spears, Jonathon Brooks, and Miles Sanders. As the fantasy football season continues, every decision, transaction, and lineup change […]


Taysom Hill - Fantasy Football Rankings, Waiver Wire Pickups, Draft Sleepers

Fantasy Football Risers and Fallers - Week 12

Week 11 of the 2024 season is in the books. That means another week of cold, hard data to analyze. We’ll try not to overreact, but instead, use logic and reasoning as the foundation for our decision-making in the weeks ahead. Each week, we’ll take a look back at the previous week to see if […]


Jonnu Smith - Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

Fact or Fiction: Fantasy Football Outlooks for Anthony Richardson, Jerry Jeudy, Nick Westbrook-Ikhine, Taysom Hill, Jonnu Smith

Week 11 of the NFL is behind us, and it's time to look ahead to next week's action. There were some surprising performances in the 11th week of the season, but were those surprising performances a sign of things to come for players? Every week, I'll examine five NFL players whose numbers from the previous […]


Ladd McConkey - Fantasy Football Rankings, Rookies, Draft Sleepers, NFL Injury News

Fantasy Football WR Sleepers: Smash Spots for Week 12 include Courtland Sutton, Josh Downs, Terry McLaurin, Ladd McConkey

Welcome to the first bye-pocalypse of the season. We have the Bengals, Bills, Falcons, Jaguars, Jets, and Saints all on bye. Do not panic; there are always great WRs to start! Last week, none of our selections found the end zone. However, they put up decent yardage. Highlighted by CeeDee Lamb going eight receptions for […]


Jaxon Smith-Njigba Fantasy Football Rankings, Draft Sleepers, Waiver Wire Pickups

High-Value Touches and Opportunities - Fantasy Football Underperformers, Overperformers (Week 12)

Welcome back, RotoBallers, to my weekly series, "High-Value Touches and Opportunities" for Week 12 of the 2024 fantasy football season. We're nearly a month before the fantasy football playoffs begin, depending on if leagues go through Week 17 or 18. It's crunch time, and we'll want to pay attention to the news, noise, and trends, […]


TJ Watt - IDP, Pittsburgh Steelers, DST, Defense, Fantasy Football Def

Week 12 IDP Rankings for Fantasy Football (2024) - Defense Positional Rankings for LB, DL, DB

Week 12 is an appropriate time for fantasy and NFL general managers to take stock. Is their team a real contender, a pretender, or are you comfortably in the basement? Those in the basement of dynasties may be looking to tank for better picks, while those in redraft leagues may still want to win enough […]


Top Fantasy Football D/ST Rankings (Weeks 12, 13, 14, 15) - Defense Streamers and Starts

Welcome, RotoBallers, to our fantasy football D/ST streamers and starts for Weeks 12, 13, 14, and 15 -- looking at the next four weeks and identifying the best D/ST matchups. Picking up defenses in advance that have a great upcoming schedule is a strategy that most fantasy managers should be using at this point of the season.  […]