X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Greg Bird Rankings Debate - Comparing RotoBaller's Rankers

As we move closer and closer to the start of the regular season, our writers are still vigorously debating each other's preseason rankings.

In this space, we'll hear from rankers with the biggest differences of opinion on a well-known player and have them defend their position against each other.

Today, the subject of discussion is Yankees first baseman Greg Bird. Nick Mariano loves the profile, the park, and the lineup, while Kyle Bishop has serious concerns about Bird's durability and batting average downside. Is Bird truly the word? Read on, and decide for yourself.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball draft tools and resources:

 

2018 Draft Rankings Debate - Greg Bird

Ranking Tier Player Position Kyle Nick Pierre Jeff Harris Bill
132 9 Greg Bird 1B 175  108 136 146 142 111

 

Nick Mariano's Ranking: #108 overall

Oh, Kyle. I thought you studied Bird Law? According to Erik Boland of Newsday, Yankees manager Aaron Boone sees Bird as an “impact middle of the order hitter." I realize the ankle-that-would-not-heal malady of 2017 really sucked the wind out of his sails, but once healthy, he posted a sturdy .253/.316/.575 slash line with eight homers and 25 RBI in 98 plate appearances down the stretch.

This came despite a horrid .230 BABIP that may not rise much due to defenses shifting into his ridiculous pull-happy nature, but Yankee Stadium was crafted for lefty swingers to beat any shift that isn’t legally allowed to place defenders in the stands. Now, I’m not expecting him essentially hit eight dingers a month and totally replicate the power or else I’d have his 40-plus homer butt well inside my top-100, so we’re not just blindly extrapolating the pop.

But we’re not ignoring it, either. Bird has shown a history of pulling the ball in the air throughout his professional career. He put up a fly-ball rate north of 55 percent between High- and Double-A in 2014 with a combined pull rate of nearly 50 percent. 2015 saw fly-ball rates around 45-50 percent and pull rates between 38-44 percent at Double-A, Triple-A and the Majors.

He was born to hit in Yankee Stadium, let alone in an era where the “fly-ball revolution” is being rewarded beyond comprehension. With ground-ball rates hovering a little north of 30 percent, I’m not going to weigh him down for the shift defense as much as I do for others. And I know he hits righties better, but that momentous homer off of Andrew Miller in the ALDS and hitting 5 HRs with a .257 average in 70 ABs vs. LHP during the regular season showed promise. The overall .938 OPS in 41 postseason ABs was lovely to see as well.

Is this about the injuries then? I know the torn labrum in ‘16 was awful and the ankle injury that ruined his ‘17 is worrisome, but right outside of my top-100 is where I’m happy to introduce some risk for upside. He also has a career 10.9% walk rate in 348 plate appearances, so he’ll get on base enough to get his counting stats up beyond his own homers. As of March 12, Fangraphs projects the 2018 Yankees to score 5.3 runs per game -- tied with the Astros for the best in the bigs. Hitting in the middle of this lineup all year practically provides one with a free voucher for 180 R+RBI. Starlin Castro had 129 in just 112 games last year. Didi Gregorius had 160 in 136 games.

And with Giancarlo Stanton in town, you can truly utilize “Stanton Like My Daddy” puns with Birdman on your roster. That’s why we draft guys, right?

 

Kyle's Ranking: #175 overall

Nick, you and I both know that bird law in this country - it’s not governed by reason. As such, I’m afraid I can’t take your advice into cooperation...Filibuster.

But seriously folks, nobody questions Bird’s pop. He’s gone deep 20 times in just 348 MLB plate appearances and posted an 18.4 HR/FB% after producing similar rates in the minor leagues. Projections all have him around 30 homers over a full season. Trouble is, yes, injuries. Bird hasn’t yet shown that he can stay healthy and productive for a full slate of games. This isn’t new, either - it’s always been a problem since he became a pro. Bird has only managed to eclipse 550 PA once, and that was way back in 2013 at A-ball. Nick would have you draft him as though this hardly mattered. Why take Bird just outside the top 100 when you can land the similarly-projected and super-durable Carlos Santana almost 70 picks later? You’re paying a premium for a buzzy player who carries fairly significant downside risk given his injury history and limited track record. That dog won't hunt, monsignor.

Bird’s profile certainly meshes well with Yankee Stadium, but his pull-happy, >60% airball approach and lack of foot speed means you’re almost definitely looking at a .250 average as the best case scenario. And for all the rosy thoughts about Bird potentially hitting cleanup in that fearsome Bombers lineup, any sort of extended slump - the kind that low-contact sluggers like Bird are particularly prone to - will see him bumped down in the order just like last season.

Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’ll just regress, because I feel I’ve made myself perfectly redundant.

 

More 2018 MLB Ranking Debate Articles




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Tim Anderson4 hours ago

Debuts In Outfield On Wednesday
Nick Fortes5 hours ago

Exits Early On Wednesday
Benny Montgomery5 hours ago

Rockies Send Benny Montgomery, Sterlin Thompson To Minor-League Camp
Chris Godwin5 hours ago

Patriots Could Get Involved With Chris Godwin
Mike Gesicki5 hours ago

Bengals Want To Bring Back Mike Gesicki
New Orleans Saints5 hours ago

Chase Young To Draw Interest In Free Agency
Emiliano Teodo5 hours ago

Strikes Out The Side To Earn The Save On Wednesday
Durham Smythe5 hours ago

Bears Targeting Durham Smythe
Detroit Tigers5 hours ago

Tigers Sign Jack Dunn To Minor-League Deal
Chase Burns6 hours ago

Reassigned To Minor-League Camp After Strong Debut
Salvador Perez6 hours ago

Suffers Eye Laceration On Wednesday
New England Patriots6 hours ago

Alex Austin Returning To Patriots
Seattle Seahawks6 hours ago

Ernest Jones IV Undergoes Knee Surgery
Russell Wilson6 hours ago

Reunion Between Russell Wilson, Pete Carroll Is Unlikely
Los Angeles Chargers6 hours ago

Chargers Release Joey Bosa
LeBron James7 hours ago

Likely To Play Thursday
Luka Dončić7 hours ago

Luka Doncic Expected To Play On Thursday
Austin Reaves7 hours ago

On Track To Play Thursday
Nicolas Batum7 hours ago

Moves Into Starting Five
Deni Avdija7 hours ago

Won't Return On Wednesday
Los Angeles Rams7 hours ago

Rams Release Tre'Vius Tomlinson
OG Anunoby7 hours ago

Tagged As Questionable For Thursday
Mitchell Robinson8 hours ago

Could Miss Thursday's Game
Los Angeles Rams8 hours ago

Brian Allen Announces His Retirement
Precious Achiuwa8 hours ago

Questionable For Thursday
Cooper Kupp8 hours ago

Still Unlikely Cooper Kupp Returns To Rams
Tank Dell8 hours ago

Set For His Second Knee Surgery
Miami Dolphins8 hours ago

Dolphins Restructure Bradley Chubb's Contract
Justin Edwards8 hours ago

Uncertain For Thursday's Matchup In Boston
Paul George8 hours ago

Questionable Thursday In Boston
Aaron Gordon8 hours ago

Out Again On Wednesday Night
Santi Aldama8 hours ago

Sidelined Wednesday Against The Thunder
Nikola Jokić8 hours ago

Nikola Jokic Will Play Versus Sacramento
Ja Morant8 hours ago

Will Play Against Oklahoma City
Tyrese Maxey9 hours ago

Will Not Play Thursday Against Boston
Fred VanVleet9 hours ago

Listed As Out Thursday Against New Orleans
Tyrese Haliburton9 hours ago

On The Injury Report For Thursday
Zeke Nnaji9 hours ago

Active Wednesday Night Against Sacramento
Vlatko Čančar9 hours ago

Vlatko Cancar Available To Play Wednesday
Christian Scott9 hours ago

Set To Throw On Monday
Cole Anthony9 hours ago

Questionable Versus The Bulls
Peyton Watson9 hours ago

Will Play Wednesday Against Sacramento
Mitchell Parker9 hours ago

Has Stiffness In Neck
DL Hall9 hours ago

Hits 60-Day Injured List
Korey Lee9 hours ago

Exits Wednesday's Contest Early
Adam Frazier9 hours ago

Battling Back Soreness
Ben Casparius10 hours ago

Could Make Opening Day Roster
Ezequiel Tovar10 hours ago

Leaves After Getting Hit By Pitch
Sam Darnold10 hours ago

Titans Will Have Interest In Sam Darnold
Mattias Ekholm10 hours ago

Iffy For Thursday Due To Illness
NFL11 hours ago

Cam Ward Considered The Consensus No. 1 QB
Steven Lorentz11 hours ago

Back In Action Wednesday
Oliver Bjorkstrand11 hours ago

Lightning Acquire Oliver Bjorkstrand
Yanni Gourde11 hours ago

Returns To Tampa Bay
Cleveland Browns11 hours ago

Joel Bitonio Will Return In 2025
DK Metcalf11 hours ago

Chargers Could Go After DK Metcalf
Vitek Vanecek11 hours ago

Moves To Florida
Philadelphia Eagles11 hours ago

Eagles Re-Sign Zack Baun To Three-Year Deal
Jack Hughes11 hours ago

Undergoes Shoulder Surgery, Done For The Season
Andrew Kittredge12 hours ago

Undergoes MRI Exam
Gunnar Henderson12 hours ago

Has Intercostal Strain; O's Hopeful He'll Be Ready For Opening Day
Corbin Carroll13 hours ago

Close To Returning
Dak Prescott13 hours ago

Cowboys Restructure Dak Prescott's Deal
Las Vegas Raiders13 hours ago

Raiders Sign Alex Cappa On Wednesday
Las Vegas Raiders13 hours ago

Raiders Sign Maxx Crosby To Three-Year Extension
Jordan Montgomery14 hours ago

To Pitch In Spring Game On Friday
Jakub Vrana14 hours ago

Capitals Place Jakub Vrana On Waivers
Edwin Arroyo14 hours ago

Cam Collier Assigned To Minor-League Camp
FLA14 hours ago

Jesse Puljujarvi Inks One-Year Deal With Florida
Grayson Rodriguez14 hours ago

Experiences Drop In Velocity
Quinn Hughes14 hours ago

Not Playing On Wednesday
Erik Miller14 hours ago

Returning To Cactus League Action On Friday
Igor Shesterkin14 hours ago

Starting On Wednesday
Michael Rasmussen14 hours ago

Cleared To Return On Thursday
Martin Necas14 hours ago

Playing Through Illness
Sahith Theegala16 hours ago

Looking To Keep Spark From Last Event Alive At Bay Hill
Robert MacIntyre16 hours ago

An Interesting Play At Arnold Palmer Invitational
Max Homa16 hours ago

Hoping His Course History At Bay Hill Can Help Turn Season Around
Tommy Fleetwood16 hours ago

Looking To Get Back Into Good Graces At Bay Hill
Michael Kim16 hours ago

One Of The Hottest Players In Golf Heading To Bay Hill
Xander Schauffele17 hours ago

Making Long-Awaited Start Since Rib Injury At Bay Hill
Sepp Straka17 hours ago

Needs Accuracy At Arnold Palmer Invitational
Collin Morikawa17 hours ago

Looking For Better Form On And Around The Greens At Bay Hill
Justin Rose17 hours ago

May Be Worth Avoiding This Week
Maverick McNealy17 hours ago

Tries To Go One Step Further At Bay Hill
Shane Lowry18 hours ago

Has Potential To Contend At Bay Hill
PGA18 hours ago

Sungjae Im Trying To Snap Out Of Golfing Funk
Jacob Bridgeman18 hours ago

Looking To Build Off Momentum At Arnold Palmer Invitational
Joe Highsmith18 hours ago

Steps Up After Cognizant Classic Win
Max Greyserman18 hours ago

Be Wary Of Max Greyserman At Bay Hill
Davis Thompson19 hours ago

Very Iffy For Arnold Palmer Invitational
Tony Finau19 hours ago

And Bay Hill Could Be A Battle
Cam Davis20 hours ago

A Question Mark Heading To Arnold Palmer
Sam Burns20 hours ago

Could Stick Around At Arnold Palmer
J.J. Spaun20 hours ago

Could See Success At Bay Hill
PGA20 hours ago

Byeong Hun An Seeks Answers And May Not Find Any
Thomas Harley21 hours ago

Lifts Dallas Over New Jersey
Mackenzie Blackwood21 hours ago

Stands Tall In Victory
Nikita Kucherov21 hours ago

Leads The Way On Tuesday
Ryan O'Reilly21 hours ago

Busy On Tuesday
SJ22 hours ago

Will Smith Tallies Goal, Assist In Victory
Dougie Hamilton22 hours ago

Sustains Lower-Body Injury
Vitek Vanecek1 day ago

Will Be Held Out Of Tuesday's Action
Jake Evans1 day ago

Inks Extension With Canadiens
Darnell Nurse1 day ago

Rejoins Oilers Lineup Tuesday
MMA3 days ago

Asu Almbayev Gets TKO'd At UFC Vegas 103
Manel Kape3 days ago

Gets TKO Win At UFC Vegas 103
Julian Marquez3 days ago

Loses Fourth Fight In A Row
Kyle Busch3 days ago

Falls Short Of Victory At COTA While Finishing Fifth
Kyle Larson3 days ago

Has A Day To Forget At COTA On Sunday
Cody Brundage3 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Tyler Reddick3 days ago

Continues His Top-10 Streak At COTA With Third-Place Finish
NASCAR3 days ago

Bubba Wallace Has An Eventful Day At COTA That Ends In 20th-Place Finish
Esteban Ribovics3 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 103
Noah Gragson3 days ago

Scores His First Career Road Course Top-10 Finish At COTA
Nasrat Haqparast3 days ago

Extends Win Streak At UFC Vegas 103
William Gomis3 days ago

Takes Split-Decision Loss
Hyder Amil3 days ago

Remains Undefeated
Sam Patterson3 days ago

Extends Win Streak To Three
Danny Barlow3 days ago

Suffers First Career Loss At UFC Vegas 103
Christopher Bell3 days ago

Wins At COTA, Ready To Keep Adding To It
Chris Buescher3 days ago

Finishes Seventh At COTA, Sees Room For Improvement
Todd Gilliland3 days ago

Nabs First Top-10 Finish Of Season After Bumpy COTA Race
Chase Elliott3 days ago

Recovers From Lap 1 Spinout To Finish Fourth
William Byron3 days ago

In Battle Between Last Two Race Winners, William Byron Comes Up Short
Shane Van Gisbergen3 days ago

Shane van Gisbergen Dominates First Two Stages But Fades In Third Stage
AJ Allmendinger3 days ago

A.J. Allmendinger Runs Well At Austin Until Late-Race Collapse
Alex Bowman3 days ago

Recovers From COTA Penalty To Finish Ninth
Tyler Reddick4 days ago

Wins Pole At COTA, Looking To Become First Repeat Winner
Chase Elliott4 days ago

Will Be A Top Threat For The Win At COTA
Shane Van Gisbergen4 days ago

Shane van Gisbergen the Favorite to Win at COTA
Kyle Larson4 days ago

Is One Of The Top Favorites To Win At COTA
Christopher Bell4 days ago

Will Be A Fantastic DFS Play For COTA Lineups
AJ Allmendinger4 days ago

Struggling At COTA Despite Strong Practice Speeds
Austin Cindric4 days ago

Is One Of The Top DFS Recommendations For COTA Lineups
Connor Zilisch4 days ago

Making Cup Series Debut This Weekend
MMA6 days ago

Asu Almbayev Looks To Remain Undefeated In The UFC
Manel Kape6 days ago

Looks To Win Back-To-Back Fights
Julian Marquez6 days ago

In Dire Need Of Victory
Cody Brundage6 days ago

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Esteban Ribovics6 days ago

Looks For His Fourth UFC Win
Nasrat Haqparast6 days ago

An Underdog At UFC Vegas 103
William Gomis6 days ago

A Favorite At UFC Vegas 103
Hyder Amil6 days ago

Looks To Remain Undefeated
Sam Patterson6 days ago

Opens Up UFC Vegas 103 Main Card
Danny Barlow6 days ago

Looks To Extend Win Streak
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF