RADIO
As fantasy football enthusiasts gear up for another exhilarating season, the search for rookie talent is always a tempting venture. However, caution must be exercised amidst the excitement of potential breakout stars, especially regarding rookie wide receivers. While some first-year players may dazzle with their athleticism and potential, others may struggle to acclimate to the complexities of the NFL, leaving fantasy managers disappointed.
In this article, we examine five rookie wide receivers who, despite their hype, may not provide the fantasy value managers seek, urging caution before investing valuable draft capital. By scrutinizing factors such as team dynamics, offensive schemes, and preseason performances, fantasy managers can make informed decisions to avoid potential busts.
Through careful analysis, we aim to illuminate five rookie wide receivers whose fantasy prospects may not live up to the hype. We provide valuable insight to help fantasy managers avoid potential draft-day regrets. These players won't necessarily have bad seasons, but they look like they will be overvalued in fantasy drafts. Let's dive in!
Be sure to check all of our fantasy football rankings for 2025:- 2025 fantasy football rankings (redraft)
- Dynasty fantasy football rankings
- 2025 NFL rookie fantasy football rankings
- Best ball fantasy football rankings
- Quarterback fantasy football rankings
- Running back fantasy football rankings
- Wide receiver fantasy football rankings
- Tight end fantasy football rankings
Rome Odunze - Chicago Bears
Current ADP: WR36
The rookie wide receiver was drafted ninth overall in this year's NFL Draft after playing four seasons at the University of Washington, where he totaled 1,640 yards and 13 touchdowns during his final season with the Huskies. Odunze will now be paired up with rookie quarterback Caleb Williams and running alongside superstars D.J. Moore and Keenan Allen. The addition of Odunze introduces some volatility into things, but will there be enough room for him to excel in Year 1?
Odunze will be a fantastic wide receiver in the league and should be valued in dynasty or keeper leagues. Still, for redraft purposes, Odunze should be a wideout to avoid due to the number of mouths that the rookie quarterback will need to feed. Allen and Moore will outproduce the rookie, but that won't mean Odunze won't develop into something special. We can return to the Odunze conversation in 2025, but for the 2024 season, he won't be more than a flex play unless injuries provide him with more opportunity.
.@RomeOdunze: "I don’t know who’s going to be able to stop us with so many weapons." 🔥 pic.twitter.com/3tyiDiOlea
— Chicago Bears (@ChicagoBears) May 9, 2024
Brian Thomas Jr. - Jacksonville Jaguars
Current ADP: WR44
Brian Thomas Jr. was drafted with the 23rd overall pick after spending three seasons with LSU. This past year, he collected 1,177 yards and 17 touchdowns. Thomas Jr. was selected by Jacksonville, where he will catch passes from promising quarterback Trevor Lawrence.
However, Thomas Jr. presents a cautionary tale rather than a promising prospect regarding fantasy football. Despite his athleticism and potential, Thomas is in a murky situation, tethered to a team with uncertainties surrounding its offensive consistency. Moreover, the competition for targets in his offense could limit his opportunities for meaningful fantasy production. Thomas will be competing for targets with superstar Christian Kirk, who saw 85 targets in 12 games played, not to mention the addition of former Buffalo Bills wideout Gabe Davis.
While Thomas may possess raw talent, the risks associated with investing in this rookie receiver in an unstable environment outweigh the potential rewards, making him a player to avoid in fantasy drafts this season. The best scenario for Thomas could be a less productive version of last year's Calvin Ridley, but I don't see the rookie filling Ridley's shoes in Year 1.
Adonai Mitchell - Indianapolis Colts
Current ADP: WR60
Adonai Mitchell was drafted in the second round with the 52nd pick after spending his last season with the Texas Longhorns, where he recorded 845 yards and 11 touchdowns. Mitchell was excellent in the red zone last year, but how will he be with a quarterback who prefers to tuck and run? The WR's fantasy football value in 2024 appears uncertain at best. While his athleticism and skill set are undeniable, Mitchell faces significant hurdles that could hinder his fantasy production.
He's entering a crowded wide receiver corps on a team known for spreading the ball around, potentially limiting his target share. Michael Pittman Jr. and Josh Downs were excellent for Indianapolis last season, making Mitchell third on the depth chart in this wide receiver room. Not to mention quarterback Anthony Richardson and Jonathan Taylor will be used heavily, as the run game will be a massive part of their offense.
Without a clear path to significant playing time and with numerous question marks surrounding his situation, fantasy managers would be wise to steer clear of investing in Mitchell for the upcoming season. There are more mouths to feed and likely fewer opportunities for that feeding.
This is AWESOME!
A behind-the-scenes look at the Indianapolis Colts selecting Texas WR Adonai Mitchell in the 2024 NFL Draft. pic.twitter.com/5Mq5m5fE72
— Kyle Yates (@KyleYNFL) May 2, 2024
Xavier Legette - Carolina Panthers
Current ADP: WR69
Ricky Pearsall - San Francisco 49ers
Current ADP: WR71
Ricky Pearsall was drafted with the 31st pick in the NFL Draft after spending three seasons with Arizona State and the last two seasons with Florida. In his final season with the Gators, Pearsall caught 65 passes for 965 yards and four touchdowns.
Pearsall should feel fortunate for being drafted by such a powerhouse team, but the opportunity for him to succeed in his rookie season may be slim. Starting with the quarterback play, Brock Purdy has provided nothing but inconsistency with his wide receivers. Pearsall will serve behind star players Deebo Samuel, George Kittle, Christian McCaffrey, Brandon Aiyuk (for now), and Jauan Jennings.
Pearsall could be an option for dynasty-formatted leagues, but for redraft, he's a rookie I would avoid in my 2024 draft.
"Winners and losers because of the Ricky Pearsall pick..." pic.twitter.com/kRe09nQ0xG
— Fantasy Footballers (@TheFFBallers) May 8, 2024
Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App
Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy football app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, rankings, starts/sits & more. All free!
More Fantasy Football Analysis
