Fantasy Basketball Punting: Common Issues

One strategy that's often employed by fantasy basketball drafters is punting, which is essentially ignoring certain categories in a category-based fantasy league in order to bolster your chances at winning other categories.

For example, taking a bad free throw shooter who is elite at rebounds and blocks can help you win those two categories on a consistent basis, even while he hurts your shot at winning free throw percentage.

But while punting is a good strategy in the abstract, it can definitely be misused. Keep reading to see some common issues with punting.

Misunderstanding What Punting Is

An important thing that punting is not: It is not you saying "well, I'm committing to losing 22 weeks of rebounding and am going to value rebounding exactly zero percent."

You aren't trying to lose. Ideally, you'll occasionally win at rebounding! Punting isn't about committing to losing at anything. Instead, it's about deemphasizing a category when you build your personal list of who to draft.

Let's take rebounding as an example. Rudy Gobert led the NBA in rebounds last year at 14.7 per game. It was his third season in a row to average at least 13.5 boards per contest.  Let's say you decide to punt rebounding (even though you should probably be punting something like blocks or steals of free throw percentage, ideally). That doesn't mean that you're throwing Gobert on some "do not draft" list.

What it means is that in your personal calculus of what you value and how you'll be fighting for the other categories, rebounding isn't taken into account, which means Gobert's value for you personally takes a drop. But he's still Rudy Gobert, and he helps you in a lot of ways, so you might still draft him!

But if you're punting rebounds, someone like Andre Drummond doesn't give you enough in other categories to really make him worth a pick, so he's probably a player that you won't draft under most, if not all, circumstances.

So, don't think of it as "I am going to lose this category and don't have interest in players who could help me win it." Instead, think of it as "I am probably going to lose this category, but my main concern is drafting guys who help me in all those other categories."

Getting Stuck In Your Punt Strategy

Let's say you do a 12-team draft, and let's say the other 11 owners all decide to also punt certain categories.

You should be willing to change things up. Take risks. Use your contingency plans.

If you notice that other owners are making draft picks that signal they're running a certain punt build that you were considering, be open to changing things.

To that end, one thing you can do early in your draft is to take some well-rounded players in those first couple of rounds who can be used as pivots. Don't lock yourself into a punt build until the third or fourth round, at which point you have some information at your disposal about how players who might have committed immediately to a punt build are doing things and you can make your adjustments.

Punting Multiple Categories

Some people are very good at punting and they'll implement a multi-category punt, punting on two categories that go hand-in-hand in order to maximize their ability to compete in the remaining categories.

Punting In A Points League

You don't need to punt in a points league. You can, I guess, but since the goal in a points league is to score as many fantasy points as you can, you don't really need to say "okay, I'll punt on getting rebounds so I can get steals instead," because you're ultimately just trying to get a bunch of fantasy points. Sure, some players are undervalued or overvalued because of their level of production, but your goal is to score as many points as you can, so taking a guy who has a poor free throw percentage might help you get more points from his rebounding, but you're still missing out on points from his free throw percentage, you know?

That's not to say you shouldn't take categories into account in a points league. Every player is good at certain things, and you might well think that ignoring them being bad at one certain thing is a good way of you building a team with the guys you want. Fine. But that's not really punting, and you aren't really getting an advantage like you will in a category league.