X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Fantasy Baseball Strategy: Don't Pay (Too Much) For Saves

This isn’t the hottest of takes here, as the SAGNOF (Saves Ain’t Got NO Face) school of thought has had a steady stream of followers for quite a few years now. It’s a little more complicated than that of course, as this isn’t simply about the straight up value of taking a closer early on.

There’s the opportunity cost of the starting pitcher or batter that you passed on in order to secure that closer and get those precious saves. Look, I know, closers aren’t the only ones who get hurt or lose their jobs, but boy howdy if they don’t lead the charge with it relative to the amount of closers you start the year with (we’ll say 35, accounting for a few “battles”).

Editor's note: Make sure you bookmark our 2017 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard. Our rankings assistant tool combines all our staff's ranks in one place. You can easily filter and export all sorts of rankings and tiers - mixed leagues, points leagues, AL/NL only, top prospects, dynasty ranks, and more.

 

What You Lose When Paying For Saves

Perhaps you think that this is more of a reason to pay for those top flight closers, and get yourself an Aroldis Chapman, Craig Kimbrel, or Kenley Jansen type of guy. There is validity to that strategy, but the opportunity cost of doing so can really leave you behind the eight ball when it comes to hitting categories if you pass on a top-flight bat. I'd rather tangle with the FAAB and Waiver Wire crazes and attempt to get out ahead of the next great situation (skills over roles), rather than trying to build up a top hitter out of that same player pool.

Looking at last year in the middle of March, right in the thick of draft season, we still had Glen Perkins and Ken Giles as very respectable mid-tier options. We know these scenarios didn’t play out so well for those who bought in on them. These are just a few examples.

When all was said and done last year, Jeurys Familia led the league with 51 saves, followed by Mark Melancon, Kenley Jansen and Zach Britton with 47. Close behind were Sam Dyson with 38, and Alex Colome and Jeanmar Gomez with 37 each. None of Dyson, Colome or Gomez were the closer heading into the year, but it wasn’t long before they took over and ran away with the role.

Then there were guys like Roberto Osuna who, while drafted, emerged as a top flight RP with 36 saves and is now a top 10 RP in 2017. There was Ryan Madson who had 30, and Jeremy Jeffress who had 27. Out of the 30 teams in the MLB, over 10 experienced major closer upheaval at some point during the year in 2016.

Now it would be foolish to expect any supreme amount of consistency in exact closer turnover rate, as hindsight bias and gambler’s fallacies could drive us into oblivion if we rely too much on any one piece of information. That said, the volatility of the closer position is undeniable, and while you might not want to go place bets in Vegas on how many closers will lose their jobs by the end of the year, there is a great chance that the number will be in the double-digits.

 

Know (and Minimize) the Risks

The truth is that the closers and relievers that you’re going to snag late in drafts will have plenty of risk to them. Whether that be related to their job security, performance on the mound, injury history, and so on, there will be risk. The point is that now instead of drafting Wade Davis, you can get a Chris Davis or Matt Carpenter. Instead of Osuna or Kimbrel, you can get Hanley Ramirez or Mark Trumbo.

Move down the ADPs futher. Instead of Ken Giles or Cody Allen, you can take a shot on Jose Bautista or Danny Salazar. Replacing a mediocre closer is usually much easier than replacing a solid corner infielder. This is only one strategy of course, but it is an extremely valid one that requires diligence and savvy speculating on those “next men up” relievers. Do not read this as a "you should punt saves" piece, but there is a strong case for not ponying up with top or even mid-round picks, and at least not more than once. Build a solid foundation, and leave the riskiest position for your picks that cost the least.

Understandably, it isn’t as palatable in leagues with shallower rosters as carrying a few relievers who could enter the ninth in the near-future can really hamstring you in the present. This doesn’t invalidate the disadvantage you can give yourself in missing those mid-round positional players though, which goes double for the elite guys where you’re passing up hitters or starting pitchers in the top 100.

Also, don't discount the elite RPs who are slated to be setup men, like Andrew Miller and Dellin Betances.  Miller, Tyler Thornburg, Dan Otero, Nate Jones and Ryan Dull are all examples of RPs who should be rostered in deep leagues, whether or not holds are a category. The sparkly ratios they can produce make them as valuable as most mediocre closers, and if the guy in front of them goes down, they become elite closer options.




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Malcolm Brogdon13 mins ago

Out Of Action For Friday
Jabari Smith Jr.16 mins ago

Ready To Return On Friday
Michael Toglia17 mins ago

Says He's An Everyday Player
Dwight Powell25 mins ago

Doubtful To Return Friday
Charlie Morton34 mins ago

Under The Weather
P.J. Washington36 mins ago

Questionable Friday Against The Pelicans
Albert Suárez40 mins ago

Albert Suarez To Start Grapefruit League Opener
Kevin Love41 mins ago

Out Friday Versus Raptors
Tyler Herro53 mins ago

Likely Good To Go On Friday
Paul Goldschmidt55 mins ago

To Play In Spring Opener On Friday
Ian Hamilton1 hour ago

Faces Live Hitters
Jarred Vanderbilt1 hour ago

Ruled Out Thursday
Jakob Poeltl1 hour ago

Ruled Out For Friday Versus Heat
Landen Roupp1 hour ago

To Start Cactus League Opener On Saturday
Tyler Fitzgerald1 hour ago

Resumes Baseball Activities
Norman Powell1 hour ago

Is Questionable Thursday Against The Bucks
Bobby Miller1 hour ago

Struck By Comebacker In Cactus League Opener
Bobby Portis1 hour ago

Suspended 25 Games
Aaron Judge1 hour ago

To Be Held Out Of Spring Games Until March 1
LeBron James2 hours ago

Uncertain For Thursday
Spencer Steer2 hours ago

To Start Throwing Soon
Luka Dončić2 hours ago

Luka Doncic Ruled Out Thursday
Eury Pérez2 hours ago

Eury Perez Placed On 60-Day Injured List
Mark Williams2 hours ago

Unavailable On Thursday
LaMelo Ball2 hours ago

Will Not Play Thursday In Denver
Paul Blackburn2 hours ago

Throws To Hitters
Adam Macko2 hours ago

Has Knee Surgery
Dylan Floro3 hours ago

Joins A's
Luis Arraez3 hours ago

Thumb Injury A Thing Of The Past
Adolis García3 hours ago

Adolis Garcia Enters 2025 With New Swing
Josh Hader3 hours ago

Looking To Simplify His Movements, Bolster Changeup
NFL3 hours ago

Doug Nussmeier Officially Lands Saints Offensive Coordinator Job
Shohei Ohtani3 hours ago

To Remain Dodgers Leadoff Hitter
Las Vegas Raiders3 hours ago

Offensive Lineman Jon Feliciano Calls It A Career
Zach Penrod3 hours ago

Dealing With Elbow Soreness
Philadelphia Eagles4 hours ago

Cam Jurgens Undergoes Back Procedure
Quinn Priester4 hours ago

To Start Grapefruit League Opener On Saturday
Lucas Giolito4 hours ago

To Throw Live Batting Practice Soon
Victor Wembanyama4 hours ago

Expected To Miss Rest Of Season
Kyle Lowry5 hours ago

Sidelined On Thursday
Eric Gordon5 hours ago

Won't Play On Thursday
Justin Edwards5 hours ago

Ruled Out For Thursday
Xavier Tillman Sr.6 hours ago

Out On Thursday
Gerald Everett7 hours ago

Unlikely To Stick Around With Bears
Miles Sanders7 hours ago

Panthers Likely To Cut Miles Sanders
Buffalo Bills7 hours ago

Bills Must Do Something About Von Miller's Contract
Baltimore Ravens7 hours ago

Marcus Williams Expected To Be Cut
Atlanta Falcons7 hours ago

Falcons Could Cut David Onyemata To Get Younger Up Front
Arizona Cardinals8 hours ago

Jalen Thompson A Potential Cap Casualty
Stefon Diggs8 hours ago

Texans Open To Bringing Stefon Diggs Back
Scoot Henderson9 hours ago

Listed As Questionable For Thursday
Jerami Grant9 hours ago

Questionable Thursday
Jared Spurgeon10 hours ago

Battling Illness
Nico Hischier10 hours ago

Targeting Saturday Return
Thatcher Demko10 hours ago

Deemed Week-To-Week
Kirill Marchenko10 hours ago

Could Return On Saturday
Adam Lowry11 hours ago

Set To Return On Saturday
Charlie McAvoy11 hours ago

Develops Shoulder Infection
Seattle Seahawks18 hours ago

Ernest Jones IV Not In Play For Franchise Tag
Los Angeles Rams18 hours ago

Rams Unlikely To Use Franchise Tag On Alaric Jackson
New Orleans Saints18 hours ago

Paulson Adebo A Long Shot To Receive Franchise Tag
Keenan Allen20 hours ago

Bears Likely To Let Keenan Allen, Teven Jenkins Walk In Free Agency
New England Patriots20 hours ago

Patriots Release Sione Takitaki
Keith Kirkwood20 hours ago

Ravens Re-Sign Keith Kirkwood
Darius Slayton22 hours ago

Won't Be Franchise-Tagged
Dallas Cowboys22 hours ago

Cowboys Unlikely To Franchise Tag Osa Odighizuwa
Jacksonville Jaguars22 hours ago

Jaguars GM Job Could Be Ian Cunningham's To Lose
Jameson Williams1 day ago

Won't Face Discipline From NFL For Carrying Unlicensed Weapon
Philadelphia Eagles1 day ago

Eagles Promote Kevin Patullo To Offensive Coordinator
PGA1 day ago

Kris Ventura A Strong Value Pick At The Mexican Open
Sam Ryder1 day ago

A Player To Watch At The Mexican Open
Aldrich Potgieter1 day ago

An Intriguing Option At The Mexican Open
Mac Meissner1 day ago

Looking To Regain Form At The Mexican Open
PGA1 day ago

K.H. Lee A Player To Avoid At The Mexican Open
Stephan Jaeger1 day ago

Aims For Consistency At Mexican Open
Nicolai Hojgaard1 day ago

Poised For Strong Performance At Mexican Open
Joel Dahmen1 day ago

Difficult To Trust At Mexican Open
Michael Thorbjornsen2 days ago

Looks To Get Things Going In The Right Direction At Mexico Open
Davis Riley2 days ago

An Unlikely Candidate For Success At Mexico Open
Luke List2 days ago

A Risky Play With Upside At Mexican Open
Carson Young2 days ago

A Volatile Option At Mexican Open
Ryan Fox2 days ago

A Boom-Or-Bust Play At Mexican Open
Alex Smalley2 days ago

A Solid Play At Mexican Open
Kevin Yu2 days ago

A Risky Play With Upside At Mexican Open
Taylor Moore2 days ago

An Intriguing Option At Mexican Open
Rasmus Hojgaard2 days ago

Eyeing A Major Bounce-Back At Mexican Open
Michael Kim2 days ago

Looks To Keep Momentum Going At Mexican Open
Sam Stevens2 days ago

Continues His Excellent 2025 Season At Genesis Invitational
Patrick Rodgers2 days ago

Finishes Tied For Third At Genesis Invitational
Thorbjorn Olesen2 days ago

Makes First PGA Tour Start In 2025 At Mexico Open
Nathan MacKinnon3 days ago

Pots Two Goals In Monday's Win
Sam Reinhart3 days ago

Dishes Out Three Assists Against Finland
Lucas Raymond3 days ago

Tries To Extend Point Streak Against USA
William Byron3 days ago

Trusts His Instinct To Win Second Straight Daytona 500
Jake Guentzel3 days ago

Looks To Extend Multi-Point Streak Monday
Jimmie Johnson3 days ago

Has Unexpected Emotions After Podium Finish At Daytona 500
Jake Oettinger3 days ago

Starts Against Sweden
John Hunter Nemechek3 days ago

Gets First Career Top-Five Finish At Daytona 500
Jake Sanderson3 days ago

Slots Into Team USA Lineup
Matthew Tkachuk3 days ago

Ruled Out Monday
Gregory Rodrigues3 days ago

Gets TKO'd At UFC Vegas 102
Jared Cannonier3 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Nazim Sadykhov3 days ago

Remains Undefeated In The UFC
Ismael Bonfim3 days ago

Suffers Fifth Career Loss At UFC Vegas 102
Rodolfo Vieira3 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 102
Andre Petroski3 days ago

Extends His Win Streak
Ryan Blaney3 days ago

Strong Daytona 500 Performance Falls Short Of Victory
Kyle Larson3 days ago

Continues To Struggle At Daytona After Underwhelming Result
Chase Briscoe3 days ago

Scores First Top-Five Finish With Joe Gibbs Racing At Daytona 500
Tyler Reddick3 days ago

Quietly Finishes The Daytona 500 As The Runner-Up
Ross Chastain3 days ago

Daytona 500 Effort Ends In An Early Crash
Adam Wilsby3 days ago

Signs Two-Year Extension With Nashville
Filip Gustavsson3 days ago

Feeling Better, Expected To Be Available On Monday
Kevin Lankinen3 days ago

Starting On Monday
Cale Makar3 days ago

Viewed As Game-Time Call
Matthew Tkachuk3 days ago

Being Evaluated
Connor Matthews3 days ago

Gets Knocked Out At UFC Vegas 102
Jose Miguel Delgado3 days ago

Jose Delgado Gets Quick Win In Debut At UFC Vegas 102
Dylan Budka3 days ago

Suffers First-Round Knockout Loss At UFC Vegas 102
Edmen Shahbazyan3 days ago

Gets Knockout Win At UFC Vegas 102
Calvin Kattar3 days ago

Suffers Fourth Straight Loss At UFC Vegas 102
Youssef Zalal3 days ago

Gets Decision Win At UFC Vegas 102
Denny Hamlin4 days ago

Fights For The Win But Gets Eliminated In Last-Lap Crash
Austin Cindric4 days ago

Has Best Run At Daytona 500 Until Last-Lap Crash
Justin Allgaier4 days ago

Earns First Top-10 Finish Since 2015
Martin Truex Jr4 days ago

.'s Sour Luck Continues With Early Daytona 500 Crash
Helio Castroneves4 days ago

Eliminated From Daytona 500 In Crash With Teammate
Joey Logano4 days ago

May Be A Favorite To Find The Front At Daytona, But What About For DFS?
Denny Hamlin4 days ago

Is Denny Hamlin Worth Rostering For Daytona Lineups?
Chase Elliott4 days ago

Could Chase Elliott Be Worth Rostering At Daytona This Week?
Ryan Blaney4 days ago

Should DFS Players Trust Ryan Blaney This Week At Daytona?
Alex Bowman4 days ago

Will Be One Of The Best DFS Plays Of The Week For Daytona
Brad Keselowski4 days ago

Is A DFS Lock For Daytona Lineups
Ross Chastain5 days ago

Has A Real Shot Of Winning But Should Be Avoided For DFS
Chris Buescher5 days ago

Undervalued For The Win At Daytona
Patrik Laine5 days ago

Collects Two Assists Saturday
Mikael Granlund5 days ago

Pots Overtime Winner Against Sweden
Filip Gustavsson5 days ago

Battling An Illness
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF