X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Compare Any Players
News and Alerts

Disaster Recovery Week 5 - Studs Turned Duds

Welcome to Disaster Recovery, where each week I'll examine why your studs played like duds. This isn't a place to find out why you should have benched a player for somebody on your bench. Disaster Recovery is to examine the guys who you didn't think twice about benching, and deciding if you should be panicking at all about their value moving forward.

The players covered in this column will usually have to be in the RotoBaller top-10 at their respective positions, but it may vary depending on the status of the players each week.

Week 5 saw plenty of studs play like studs, but we did see some surprisingly poor performances from some of this season's best fantasy options.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy football rankings for 2025:

 

Week 5 Duds

Todd Gurley (RB, LAR) (#4 RB)

What Happened: Gurley ran 14 times for 43 yards and added two receptions for seven yards in a low-scoring loss to the Seahawks.

How Did It Happen: Gurley came close to scoring a touchdown early in the game, but Earl Thomas swatted the ball out of hands and through the back of the end zone, resulting in a safety. Gurley didn't receive as much volume as he usually does and the Rams offense was finally slowed down after four impressive showings to open the season.

Panic Meter: LowTodd Gurley had 596 total yards and seven total touchdowns in his first four games this season. He was due for a dud at some point. His 16 touches this week was his lowest of the season. Even with Tavon Austin rushing for a touchdown out of the backfield, owners should not be concerned about Gurley's volume moving forward. He's going to get fed. I'm not sure how often he'll be able to replicate what he did over the last two weeks, but numbers closer to the first two weeks of the season are very doable as the season moves along. There's no reason to panic on Todd Gurley.

 

Jordy Nelson (WR, GB) (#2 WR)

What Happened: Nelson caught two of his four targets for 24 yards and a touchdown.

How Did It Happen: Nelson was held out of the final drive due to an injury evaluation, paving the way for Davante Adams to score the game winning touchdown. His four targets are his lowest in almost a year, excluding Week 2 of this season. Even in a bad game, Nelson still managed to save himself from complete disaster by scoring a late game touchdown.

Panic Meter: Low. Similar to Gurley, Nelson was due for a slow game, but the fact that he was held out of the final drive due to an injury gives me a little pause. Nelson missed almost the entirety of the Packers' Week 2 matchup due to a thigh injury and is only two years removed from missing the entire 2015 season. He's a 32 -year-old playing in his 10th NFL season. By no means am I benching a healthy Nelson, but we need to hope that this week's injury is just a minor tweak and nothing that will continue to nag him as the season moves along.

 

Mike Evans (WR, TB) (#1 WR)

What Happened: Evans caught five of his eight targets for 47 yards on Thursday night.

How Did It Happen: Four different Tampa Bay players caught five passes and eight total players had receptions in Week 5. Winston was giving everybody a shot, and Evans found himself sharing the workload with a couple different guys.

Panic Meter: Medium. The good news is that even in a game where DeSean Jackson and Cameron Brate both received nine targets, Evans still managed to get eight passes thrown his way. He's yet to receive less than eight targets in a game this season. He's going to have a nice floor moving forward.

Here's the bad news: Mike Evans is on pace for 1,000 yards and eight touchdowns this season. That's fine for a normal receiver, but not for a guy who was viewed as a consensus first round pick. Evans has failed to eclipse 70 yards in each of his past three games. He hasn't crossed the 100 yard mark or had multiple touchdowns in his last nine games. He's never a bad play due to his high floor and his red zone capabilities, but it doesn't look like he's going to be the dominant WR1 most expected him to be.

 

Carlos Hyde (RB, SF) (#8 RB)

What Happened: Hyde ran eight times for 11 yards and added a reception for seven yards in Week 5.

How Did It Happen: Backup Matt Breida took the bulk of the carries, running 10 times for 49 yards in addition to 22 yards receiving. Hyde was banged up entering the game, but both Hyde and Kyle Shanahan insisted that he was healthy, with Shanahan saying that he chose to ride the hot hand in Week 5.

Panic Meter: Medium. I'm cautiously optimistic on this whole situation. Hyde has ran well for the most part this season. His monster performances in Weeks 2 and 3 show that he can be a RB1 at times. Even as Matt Breida's carries rise, Kyle Shanahan managed his timeshare running backs well in Atlanta, and I find it hard to believe that Hyde wouldn't play the Devonta Freeman role should they split the carries a bit this season. Hyde was the only 49er running back to receive a carry inside the five, and I still believe he'll receive the goal line touches all season long. The only reason the concern here is medium is because games like this have happened to Shanahan's starting running backs in the past. Hyde's upside is still too high for him to be benched in most leagues.

 

More Week 6 Lineup Prep




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Compare Any Players
News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Gleyber Torres56 mins ago

Homers, Departs Early With Side Injury
Josh Jung1 hour ago

Pulled Early On Friday With Neck Stiffness
Orlando Arcia4 hours ago

Resting On Friday
Jake Rogers4 hours ago

Heading To The Bench
Miguel Amaya4 hours ago

Taking A Seat On Friday
Kyle Freeland5 hours ago

Tosses Six Scoreless Innings
Detroit Lions5 hours ago

Lions Re-Sign Kayode Awosika
Kameron Misner5 hours ago

Smacks Walk-Off Homer
Irvin Charles5 hours ago

Jets Re-Sign Irvin Charles
Green Bay Packers5 hours ago

Kristian Welch Signs With Green Bay
Pittsburgh Steelers5 hours ago

Jeremiah Moon Heading To Pittsburgh
Teagan Quitoriano5 hours ago

Falcons Sign Teagan Quitoriano
6 hours ago

Tetairoa McMillan Scheduled To Visit With Panthers
Baltimore Ravens6 hours ago

Ravens Reach Three-Year Contract Extension With John Harbaugh
Duncan Robinson6 hours ago

To Miss Third Straight Game Due To Back Issue
Andrew Wiggins6 hours ago

Will Not Play On Saturday
Cole Anthony6 hours ago

Doubtful To Play On Saturday
Walker Kessler6 hours ago

Misses Friday's Game
Payton Pritchard6 hours ago

Iffy For Saturday's Action
Alexander Canario6 hours ago

Mets Designate Alexander Canario For Assignment
Jayson Tatum6 hours ago

Ready To Return To Action Saturday
Tyrese Maxey7 hours ago

To Miss At Least Two More Games
Giannis Antetokounmpo7 hours ago

Available Against Knicks
Matt Moore7 hours ago

Opening Season On Seven-Day Injured List
Stephen Curry7 hours ago

Expected To Play Friday
Tyler Wade7 hours ago

San Diego Designates Tyler Wade For Assignment
Pavel Buchnevich7 hours ago

Expected To Return On Saturday
Austin Reaves7 hours ago

Listed As Questionable For Saturday
Michael Fulmer7 hours ago

Starting Season In Triple-A Rotation
Kaiden Guhle7 hours ago

Back In Action Friday
Oscar Colás7 hours ago

Oscar Colas Clears Waivers, Opening Campaign At Triple-A
Cole Sillinger7 hours ago

Returns To Blue Jackets Lineup
Clayton Kershaw7 hours ago

To Face Hitters On Saturday
Patrick Corbin7 hours ago

Rangers Option Patrick Corbin To Triple-A
Alex Pietrangelo7 hours ago

To Miss At Least Two More Games
Rui Hachimura7 hours ago

Not Listed On Injury Report For Saturday
Brewer Hicklen7 hours ago

Tigers Acquire Brewer Hicklen From Brewers
Andrei Svechnikov7 hours ago

Returns To Action Against Canadiens
Will Smith8 hours ago

Taking A Seat On Friday
Brad Marchand8 hours ago

Ready For Panthers Debut On Friday
Josh Lowe8 hours ago

Departs Early On Friday With Oblique Discomfort
Ja Morant8 hours ago

Questionable For Saturday Night
Brandon Pfaadt8 hours ago

Diamondbacks Sign Brandon Pfaadt To Five-Year Extension
Noah Clowney8 hours ago

Won't Play On Friday Night
Ziaire Williams8 hours ago

Available On Friday
Jake LaRavia8 hours ago

Will Be Re-Evaluated In 7-10 Days After Injuring Left Thumb
Trendon Watford8 hours ago

Will Play Against The Clippers
Dylan Moore8 hours ago

Back From Illness
LaMelo Ball8 hours ago

To Undergo Surgery
Seth Brown8 hours ago

Starting In Left Field Against Mariners
Jake McCarthy8 hours ago

Alek Thomas Making The Start Over Jake McCarthy On Friday
Max Strus8 hours ago

Out Versus Pistons On Friday
Ty Jerome9 hours ago

Unavailable For Friday's Matchup With Detroit
Las Vegas Raiders9 hours ago

Devin White Signs With Las Vegas
Lauri Markkanen9 hours ago

Sidelined Again On Friday
Daniel Jones9 hours ago

Gets Vote Of Confidence From Chris Ballard
Stefon Diggs10 hours ago

Looking Forward To Playing With Drake Maye
Steve Erceg13 hours ago

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Brandon Moreno13 hours ago

A Favorite At UFC Mexico City
Jacksonville Jaguars13 hours ago

Jaguars Cut Dieter Eiselen
Hunter Renfrow13 hours ago

Visits Panthers
Manuel Torres13 hours ago

Set For Co-Main Event
Drew Dober13 hours ago

An Underdog At UFC Mexico City
New England Patriots13 hours ago

Patriots Expected To Release Ja'Whaun Bentley
Joe Pyfer13 hours ago

Looks To Win Back-To-Back Fights
Kelvin Gastelum14 hours ago

Set For Middleweight Matchup
Vince Morales14 hours ago

In Dire Need Of Victory
Raul Rosas Jr.14 hours ago

Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Kansas City Chiefs14 hours ago

Chiefs Re-Sign Nazeeh Johnson
Saimon Oliveira14 hours ago

Looks For His First UFC Win
David Martinez14 hours ago

Set To Make His UFC Debut
Kevin Borjas14 hours ago

Set To Open Up UFC Mexico City Main Card
Ronaldo Rodríguez14 hours ago

Ronaldo Rodriguez Looks To Remain Undefeated In The UFC
Hunter Renfrow16 hours ago

Meeting With Raiders
16 hours ago

Kyle Williams Visiting With Handful Of Teams
NFL16 hours ago

Tush-Push Ban Is Gaining Momentum
Jaden Schwartz19 hours ago

Scores Twice On Thursday
Casey DeSmith19 hours ago

Stops 46 Shots Against Calgary
Matvei Michkov19 hours ago

Scores Twice, Adds Assist On Thursday
Nikita Kucherov19 hours ago

Tallies Four Points In Victory
Connor Zary19 hours ago

Departs Thursday's Game Early
Stephen Curry1 day ago

Questionable Against The Pels
Atlanta Falcons1 day ago

Falcons Agree With Kicker Lenny Krieg
1 day ago

Saints To Check Out Jaxson Dart's Pro Day
Matt Rempe1 day ago

Out Week-To-Week Due To Upper-Body Injury
Kyle Connor1 day ago

Expected To Be Available Friday
Mikael Backlund1 day ago

Ready To Return Thursday
Rasmus Andersson1 day ago

Good To Go Against Stars
Joel Kiviranta1 day ago

Misses Thursday's Game
Jason Zucker1 day ago

Unavailable Against Penguins
Evgeni Malkin1 day ago

Out On Thursday
Carolina Panthers1 day ago

Cade Mays Back With Panthers On One-Year Contract
Philadelphia Eagles1 day ago

Matt Pryor Agrees To One-Year Deal With Eagles
Leo Carlsson2 days ago

Scores Twice On Wednesday
Jake Oettinger2 days ago

Stops 41 Shots On Wednesday
Jason Robertson2 days ago

Scores Natural Hat Trick In Victory
Jhonattan Vegas2 days ago

Not A Good Play At Houston Open
Gary Woodland2 days ago

A Dark-Horse Candidate At Houston Open
Nick Taylor2 days ago

Keep An Eye On Nick Taylor At Houston Open
Mackenzie Hughes2 days ago

Avoid Mackenzie Hughes At Houston Open
Nicolai Hojgaard2 days ago

Looking To Rebound At Houston Open
Scottie Scheffler3 days ago

Returns To Houston Looking For Year's First Victory
Rory McIlroy3 days ago

Making Additional Start At Houston Open To Prepare For Augusta
Doug Ghim3 days ago

Looking For Iron Form In Houston
Aaron Rai3 days ago

Keep An Eye On Aaron Rai At Houston Open
Si Woo Kim3 days ago

Looks To Build On Recent History At Memorial Park
Harry Hall3 days ago

Looking For Consistency At Texas Children’s Houston Open
Harris English3 days ago

Looking To Build Off Solid Finish At The PLAYERS
Sahith Theegala3 days ago

A Risky Option At Texas Children’s Houston Open
Alex Smalley3 days ago

A Strong Play At Texas Children’s Houston Open
Michael Kim3 days ago

Bounces Back At Valspar Championship
PGA3 days ago

Sungjae Im Looking For Bounce-Back Performance At Texas Children’s Houston Open
Austin Eckroat3 days ago

A Player To Avoid At Texas Children's Houston Open
PGA3 days ago

Nico Echavarria A Volatile Option At Texas Children's Houston Open
Joe Highsmith3 days ago

Continues Post-Win Success And Is Looking For More In Houston
Adam Hadwin3 days ago

Far From Good Form As He Heads To Texas
Ben Griffin4 days ago

Looking For Consistency At Houston Open
Sean Brady4 days ago

Dominates At UFC London
MMA4 days ago

Leon Edward Dominated At UFC London
Carlos Ulberg4 days ago

Extends His Win Streak
Jan Blachowicz4 days ago

Outpointed At UFC London
Gunnar Nelson5 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC London
Kevin Holland5 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Molly McCann5 days ago

Retires After UFC London Submission Loss
Alexia Thainara5 days ago

Wins Her UFC Debut
Chris Duncan5 days ago

Gets Submission Win At UFC London
NASCAR5 days ago

Bubba Wallace Earns New Career-Best Finish At Homestead
Alex Bowman5 days ago

Falls Short Of Winning At Homestead
William Byron5 days ago

Has An Underwhelming Day At Homestead
Chris Buescher5 days ago

Earns A New Career-Best Finish At Homestead
Ryan Preece5 days ago

Scores His Second Consecutive Top-10 Finish Of 2025 At Homestead
Denny Hamlin5 days ago

Savvy Pit Strategy Helps Denny Hamlin Win Stage 2 At Homestead
Chase Briscoe5 days ago

Moves Above Playoff Cut Line With Fourth-Place Finish
Joey Logano5 days ago

Misses Top 10 Again After Pit-Road Spin
Tyler Reddick5 days ago

Underachieves But Still Finishes Eighth
Justin Haley5 days ago

Earns First Non-Drafting Oval Top-10 Finish For Spire Motorsports
Alex Bowman6 days ago

Earns First Non-Drafting Superspeedway Pole Since 2016
Denny Hamlin6 days ago

Poor Las Vegas Run Suggests He Might Be Overvalued For Homestead
Joey Logano6 days ago

Recent Homestead Record Misleading Due To Past Playoff Situations
Josh Berry6 days ago

Probably Needs To Lead To Have DFS Value
Daniel Suarez6 days ago

Poor Qualifying Makes Him A Strong DFS Option
Shane Van Gisbergen6 days ago

Likely Too Inexperienced To Gain Many Positions At Homestead
Austin Cindric6 days ago

Increased Staying Power In Races May Make Him More Valuable
Ricky Stenhouse Jr6 days ago

. Unlikely To Gain Enough Positions For DFS Value
NASCAR6 days ago

John Hunter Nemechek Delivers His Second-Best Qualifying Run At Homestead
Cole Custer6 days ago

Has Been Hapless At Homestead In Cup Series
JJ Yeley6 days ago

J.J. Yeley Needs Attrition To Gain Positions At Homestead
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF