X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Compare Any Players
News and Alerts

Disaster Recovery Week 16 - Studs Turned Duds

Welcome to Disaster Recovery, where each week I'll examine why your studs played like duds. This isn't a place to find out why you should have benched a player for somebody on your bench. Disaster Recovery is to examine the guys who you didn't think twice about benching, and deciding if you should be panicking at all about their value moving forward.

The players covered in this column will usually have to be in the RotoBaller top-10 at their respective positions, but it may vary depending on the status of the players each week.

With most teams playing in championship games in Week 16, the duds stung more than usual. Here are a few of the worst plays from Week 16 and how owners still playing into Week 17 should feel.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy football rankings for the 2025 playoffs:

 

Week 16 Duds

DeVonta Freeman (RB, ATL) (#11 RB)

What Happened: Freeman ran 11 times for 36 yards and caught two passes for 20 yards in a loss to New Orleans.

How Did It Happen: The Saints made it a point to shut down the Falcons run game and succeeded. Since Atlanta found themselves playing from behind the entire game, there was no reason to force the run and only ran the ball 20 times on the day. Freeman only ran the ball twice in the final 23 minutes of the game.

Panic Meter: Low. Freeman came on strong over the last two games and likely was a big part of his owners making to the title game. This is a painful dud from Freeman in the most crucial point in the season, but I'm still plugging him into my Week 17 lineup. The Falcons will be fighting for their lives in Week 17, and they'll need all they can get from Freeman.

 

Kenyan Drake (RB, MIA) (#10 RB)

What Happened: Drake ran 13 times for 57 yards and failed to catch a pass in Miami's loss to the Chiefs.

How Did It Happen: Honestly, bad play-calling. Drake has been red hot in recent weeks and Jay Cutler hasn't been red hot in recent years. The Dolphins never found themselves in an insurmountable hole until very late in the game. So why did Jay Cutler throw the ball 38 times, and why did Drake only run 13 times when he was averaging 4.4 yards per rush? It was a puzzling game for Miami.

Panic Meter: Low. Drake tore up defenses in the three previous weeks, and still put up decent rushing numbers despite his lack of touches. Miami should feed him in Week 17 to assure themselves that he can be their feature back moving forward. He remains a solid play against the Bills in Week 17.

 

Adam Thielen (WR, MIN) (#6 WR)

What Happened: Thielen caught two of his six targets for just 24 yards in a win at Green Bay.

How Did It Happen: Thielen and Case Keenum failed to connect on his lone deep ball target. Minnesota got out to a quick 10-0 lead and played this game pretty conservatively. Keenum channeled his inner Fisherball and rekindled the magic of his 2016 season, going 14 for 25 with 139 yards and a touchdown. Thielen wasn't needed in this one.

Panic Meter: Medium. Amazingly enough, Minnesota still hasn't clinched a first round bye despite owning the tie-breaker with New Orleans and Los Angeles. Anyone who can look past Thielen's dreadful past two weeks shouldn't hesitate to play him as the Vikings still have something to play for.

 

Brandin Cooks (WR, NE) (#8 WR)

What Happened: Cooks caught just two of his five targets for 19 yards in a win over Buffalo.

How Did It Happen: It wasn't a huge passing day for Buffalo and Cooks fell victim of it. Dion Lewis carried the New England offense, running 24 times for 129 yards and catching all five of his targets for 24 yards. Lewis scored two touchdowns on the day and stole the thunder from the rest of the Patriots offense. Cooks wasn't needed in this victory.

Panic Meter: High. I've included Cooks in this column many this season, but he normally gets brushed off. But we can't brush off the fact that Cooks is averaging just two receptions for 34 yards over his last four games, and three have been complete duds. Cooks seemed solid for his ADP until recent weeks. He hasn't had a dominant game since Week 12. Given Cooks hasn't been a consistent option over the last four games, it is hard to trust him for a championship matchup in a game that isn't that important for New England.

 

More Week 17 Lineup Prep




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Compare Any Players
News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Ricky Stenhouse Jr4 hours ago

a Great Place Differential Play This Weekend
Justin Haley4 hours ago

Has Been Very Respectable at Atlanta Since The Repave
Mark Andrews5 hours ago

A Potential Salary Cap Casualty?
Norman Powell5 hours ago

On The Injury Report For Sunday
Kawhi Leonard5 hours ago

Could Miss Sunday's Game
P.J. Washington5 hours ago

Questionable Against The Warriors
Mark Canha5 hours ago

Joins Brewers On Minor-League Deal
Josh Hart5 hours ago

May Miss Another Game On Sunday
OG Anunoby5 hours ago

Questionable Against Boston
Cody Ware8 hours ago

Faster Than Some Big Names In Atlanta
Aaron Gordon8 hours ago

Set To Play Against The Lakers
LeBron James8 hours ago

Available Versus Denver
Ty Dillon8 hours ago

A Low-Tier Fantasy Option At Atlanta
BJ McLeod8 hours ago

Qualifies 38th For Ambetter Health 400 At Atlanta
Luka Dončić9 hours ago

Luka Doncic Cleared For Saturday Night
Hyeseong Kim9 hours ago

To See Work In Center Field
Nolan Arenado9 hours ago

Astros Rekindle Talks For Nolan Arenado
Michael Kopech9 hours ago

Throws Off The Mound
Brayan Bello9 hours ago

Still Not Throwing Bullpens
Blake Mitchell9 hours ago

Suffers Broken Hamate Bone
Andrés Muñoz9 hours ago

Andres Munoz Working On Changeup
Dante Fabbro11 hours ago

Back For Blue Jackets Saturday
Sean Durzi11 hours ago

Returns From 52-Game Absence
Matthew Tkachuk11 hours ago

Will Not Play Against Kraken
Jordan Eberle11 hours ago

Back In Action Saturday
Boone Jenner11 hours ago

Ready For Season Debut Against Blackhawks
Nico Hischier11 hours ago

Returns To Devils Lineup Saturday
Mika Zibanejad11 hours ago

Available Against Sabres
Igor Shesterkin11 hours ago

Good To Go Saturday
Lucas Sims13 hours ago

Set To Throw Batting Practice On Sunday
J.B. Bukauskas14 hours ago

Suffers Significant Lat Injury
Wilyer Abreu14 hours ago

Still Battling Illness
Brandon Sproat14 hours ago

Tinkering With Sinker
Kutter Crawford14 hours ago

In Doubt For Opening Day
Jesús Sánchez14 hours ago

Jesus Sanchez Could Be Limited To DH Early In The Season
Blake Perkins14 hours ago

Suffers Shin Fracture
Connor Norby15 hours ago

Eyeing 30 Home Runs
Spencer Strider15 hours ago

Throws Curveball In Bullpen Session
Taylor Trammell15 hours ago

Strains Calf
Victor Mesa Jr.15 hours ago

Has Tight Hamstring
Washington Commanders15 hours ago

Jonathan Allen Could Be Salary Cap Casualty
Donovan Solano15 hours ago

Expected To Join Camp On Saturday
Alex Cobb15 hours ago

Playing Catch
Treylon Burks15 hours ago

Could Use A Fresh Start Elsewhere
Tampa Bay Buccaneers15 hours ago

Jamel Dean A Cut Candidate For Buccaneers
Jarrett Allen15 hours ago

Set For An MRI, X-Rays Negative
Seattle Seahawks15 hours ago

Dre'Mont Jones' Cap Figure Is Untenable
Cam Thomas16 hours ago

Nearing A Return?
Maikel Garcia16 hours ago

Leading Off On Saturday
Pittsburgh Steelers16 hours ago

Steelers Could Be Looking To Replace Larry Ogunjobi
Philadelphia Eagles16 hours ago

Darius Slay Has Sixth-Highest Cap Hit For Eagles
Graham Gano16 hours ago

Could Be On His Way Out
Derek Carr16 hours ago

Saints Could Cut Derek Carr
Kendrick Bourne16 hours ago

Patriots To Move On From Kendrick Bourne?
Minnesota Vikings17 hours ago

Vikings Likely To Move On From Ed Ingram
Jason Sanders17 hours ago

Could Be A Cap Casualty
Cooper Kupp17 hours ago

Rams Could Cut Cooper Kupp
Los Angeles Chargers17 hours ago

Something Has To Give With Joey Bosa
EDM21 hours ago

Matt Savoie Set To Make Team Debut
SEA21 hours ago

Cale Fleury Promoted To NHL
Evander Kane21 hours ago

Resumes Skating
Sidney Crosby21 hours ago

A Game-Time Decision
Elias Pettersson21 hours ago

Considered Day-To-Day
Quinn Hughes21 hours ago

Not Expected To Play On Saturday
Jacksonville Jaguars1 day ago

Jaguars Hire James Gladstone As New General Manager
Donald Parham Jr.1 day ago

Steelers Sign Donald Parham Jr. To One-Year Deal
Philadelphia Eagles1 day ago

Nolan Smith Has Surgery For Torn Triceps Muscle
George Kittle1 day ago

Discussing Extension With 49ers
Matthew Stafford1 day ago

Rams Give Permission To Matthew Stafford's Agent To Talk To Other Teams
Patrick Williams1 day ago

To Miss At Least Two Weeks
Jarrett Allen1 day ago

Won't Return On Friday
Fred VanVleet1 day ago

Nearing Return
Josh Giddey1 day ago

Considered Probable For Saturday
Jalen Smith1 day ago

Unavailable Saturday
Jabari Smith Jr.1 day ago

Will Come Off The Bench On Friday
Nikola Vučević1 day ago

Nikola Vucevic Probable For Saturday
DaQuan Jeffries1 day ago

Remains Out On Saturday
Mike Conley1 day ago

Back In Action Friday
Mark Williams1 day ago

Removed From Injury Report
Rudy Gobert1 day ago

Will Not Play Against Rockets
Skyy Moore1 day ago

Could Be Salary Cap Casualty
Arizona Cardinals1 day ago

Cardinals Plan To Be Active In Free Agency
Henry Cejudo2 days ago

Set For Bantamweight Clash
Song Yadong2 days ago

Faces A Legend At UFC Seattle
Anthony Hernandez2 days ago

Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Brendan Allen2 days ago

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Jean Matsumoto2 days ago

Looks To Remain Undefeated
Rob Font2 days ago

An Underdog At UFC Seattle
Melsik Baghdasaryan2 days ago

Looks To Win Back-To-Back Fights
Jean Silva2 days ago

A Favorite At UFC Seattle
Alonzo Menifield2 days ago

Opens Up UFC Seattle Main Card
Julius Walker2 days ago

Makes His UFC Debut
Jeremy Lauzon2 days ago

Ruled Out For Rest Of Season
Kyle Connor2 days ago

Scratched On Thursday
Josh Morrissey2 days ago

Will Not Play On Thursday
Igor Shesterkin2 days ago

May Be Available Against Sabres
Bryan Rust2 days ago

Ready To Return To Penguins Lineup
Evgeni Malkin2 days ago

On Track To Return Saturday
Seth Jarvis2 days ago

Rejoins Canada's Lineup Thursday
PGA4 days ago

Kris Ventura A Strong Value Pick At The Mexican Open
Sam Ryder4 days ago

A Player To Watch At The Mexican Open
Aldrich Potgieter4 days ago

An Intriguing Option At The Mexican Open
Mac Meissner4 days ago

Looking To Regain Form At The Mexican Open
PGA4 days ago

K.H. Lee A Player To Avoid At The Mexican Open
Stephan Jaeger4 days ago

Aims For Consistency At Mexican Open
Nicolai Hojgaard4 days ago

Poised For Strong Performance At Mexican Open
Joel Dahmen4 days ago

Difficult To Trust At Mexican Open
Michael Thorbjornsen4 days ago

Looks To Get Things Going In The Right Direction At Mexico Open
Davis Riley4 days ago

An Unlikely Candidate For Success At Mexico Open
Luke List4 days ago

A Risky Play With Upside At Mexican Open
Carson Young4 days ago

A Volatile Option At Mexican Open
Ryan Fox4 days ago

A Boom-Or-Bust Play At Mexican Open
Alex Smalley4 days ago

A Solid Play At Mexican Open
Kevin Yu4 days ago

A Risky Play With Upside At Mexican Open
Taylor Moore4 days ago

An Intriguing Option At Mexican Open
Rasmus Hojgaard4 days ago

Eyeing A Major Bounce-Back At Mexican Open
Michael Kim4 days ago

Looks To Keep Momentum Going At Mexican Open
Sam Stevens4 days ago

Continues His Excellent 2025 Season At Genesis Invitational
Patrick Rodgers4 days ago

Finishes Tied For Third At Genesis Invitational
Thorbjorn Olesen4 days ago

Makes First PGA Tour Start In 2025 At Mexico Open
William Byron5 days ago

Trusts His Instinct To Win Second Straight Daytona 500
Jimmie Johnson5 days ago

Has Unexpected Emotions After Podium Finish At Daytona 500
John Hunter Nemechek5 days ago

Gets First Career Top-Five Finish At Daytona 500
Gregory Rodrigues6 days ago

Gets TKO'd At UFC Vegas 102
Jared Cannonier6 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Nazim Sadykhov6 days ago

Remains Undefeated In The UFC
Ismael Bonfim6 days ago

Suffers Fifth Career Loss At UFC Vegas 102
Rodolfo Vieira6 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 102
Andre Petroski6 days ago

Extends His Win Streak
Ryan Blaney6 days ago

Strong Daytona 500 Performance Falls Short Of Victory
Kyle Larson6 days ago

Continues To Struggle At Daytona After Underwhelming Result
Chase Briscoe6 days ago

Scores First Top-Five Finish With Joe Gibbs Racing At Daytona 500
Tyler Reddick6 days ago

Quietly Finishes The Daytona 500 As The Runner-Up
Ross Chastain6 days ago

Daytona 500 Effort Ends In An Early Crash
Connor Matthews6 days ago

Gets Knocked Out At UFC Vegas 102
Jose Miguel Delgado6 days ago

Jose Delgado Gets Quick Win In Debut At UFC Vegas 102
Dylan Budka6 days ago

Suffers First-Round Knockout Loss At UFC Vegas 102
Edmen Shahbazyan6 days ago

Gets Knockout Win At UFC Vegas 102
Calvin Kattar6 days ago

Suffers Fourth Straight Loss At UFC Vegas 102
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF