X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Compare Any Players
News and Alerts

Titanic Disappointment - Will Ryan Tannehill Help Tennessee?

The Tennessee Titans benched starting quarterback Marcus Mariota in favor of backup QB Ryan Tannehill. Eric Samulski examines the move from a fantasy football perspective to determine if wide receivers like Corey Davis, A.J. Brown, or Adam Humphries have sleeper value on waivers.

In the midst of being shutout by the Denver Broncos on Sunday, Tennesse Titans coach Mike Vrabel made a move that many casual NFL fans had been expecting for the past few weeks: he decided to give Ryan Tannehill a shot at quarterback instead of Marcus Mariota.

While Tannehill wasn't noticeably better on Sunday, throwing a crucial pick and the end of the game, it's time for us to start wondering whether Titans fantasy players would be better suited with Tannehill under center for the rest of the season.

In other words, is there hope for players like Corey Davis, A.J. Brown, Delanie Walker, and others?

Be sure to check all of our fantasy football rankings for 2025:

 

Is Tannehill Actually Better Than Mariota?

Tannehill has been better so far this season in an incredibly small sample size. He has a 64.2 PFF grade to Mariota's 63.7, but on pass plays only Tannehill grades out at 67.2 to Mariota's 62.9. The truth is that both Tannehill and Mariota have had their struggles this season and during their NFL careers.

Since being a first-round pick in 2013, Tannehill was given the reins of the Miami Dolphins offense, throwing for 111 touchdowns and 62 interceptions, while compiling a 74.1% adjusted completion percentage - a Pro Football Focus stat that measures completion percentage based on the factors a quarterback can control (so not drops).

Tannehill had thrown for over 4,000 yards in 2014 and 2015 and seemed to be making real progress before suffering an injury in 2016 that kept him out for the entire 2017 season. When he came back in 2018, he seemed to be visibly rusty, and the team he returned to had lost a good deal of talent. He also injured his shoulder last year, playing through it for many weeks, and finishing with only 11 games played.

Needless to say, Tannehill's upward trajectory was derailed by those injuries and he found himself on the outside in Miami.

Meanwhile, Mariota has never quite blossomed with the Titans. He's a cautious passer who doesn't take many risks. He's never thrown for more than 3,500 yards in a season and has a career 76 touchdowns to 44 interceptions.

You can see Mariota's turnover-averse ways in the diagram below:

As you can see, Tannehill will take more chances with the football. He's thrown an average of 54 deep passes per season since entering the league; although, he only threw 35 in 2018 while playing with a shoulder injury. He had thrown 66 deep passes per season in his first three seasons. Mariota has thrown an average of 49 per season.

Tannehill taking more chances also means more mistakes. As a result, the offense will likely have shorter drives and potentially less sustained production. That's a worry for the players like Derrick Henry, Adam Humphries or Delanie Walker, who require sustained opportunity for their production.

Additionally, according to Pro Football Focus, Tannehill is a significantly better passer in a clean pocket than Mariota. In 2016, when Tannehill was fully healthy, he had a passer rating of 116.6 in a clean pocket, while Mariota had one that fell way below at 78.2. In 2018, when Tannehill was just back off a major injury and on a much worse team, he still had a better passer rating in a clean pocket: 100.7 to 97.5.

The only issue is that Tennessee currently has the 31st-ranked offensive line when it comes to pass protection, according to Football Outsiders. When under pressure, Mariota has been the consistently superior quarterback. Here are his numbers: 

Here are Tannehill's numbers:

It's interesting to note that both quarterbacks have actually been above league average when facing pressure, except for Tannehill's rookie year and rough 2016 season. But if Mariota is the better quarterback under pressure, and Tennessee has been letting up a lot of pressure, then a move to Tannehill wouldn't necessarily seem to be a positive for the Titans.

Given their history, it may prove to be more of a neutral move, if it wasn't for one final stat.

A bigger concern for the Titans players with Mariota under center is that he has been consistently less productive than Tannehill in the red zone over his career. A lot of that has to do with Mariota's risk-averse style. He usually doesn't make costly mistakes, but he also doesn't capitalize on the opportunities.

Notice how the last two years, Mariota's red zone touchdown percentage has been 10.% and 13.6% when the league average last year was 22.1%. Meanwhile, Tannehill's touchdown percentage last year was 29.6%, and he is consistently above the league average in touchdown percentage during his career.

Tannehill's passer rating in the red zone suffers because he will make mistakes. Last year he had an interception percentage of 3.7% in the red zone when the league average was 2%. He's been at 3% or over in three years, while Mariota was at 0% in every year but last year.

In the end, it seems like Mariota may give the Titans the best chance to win because their strong defense doesn't require gaudy point totals, but Tannehill may be the best bet for fantasy options.

 

Does a QB Change Impact The Titans' Run-Heavy Approach?

At the end of the day, the quarterback change doesn't mean much for the Titans running game. Tennesse's strong defense still figures to keep them in games, which means that they can still employ a run-heavy attack. The team currently throws on only 56% of their plays, which is good for the eighth fewest in the league. Their defense has also yet to allow over 20 points, which means they will likely be able to continue to feature a running game that will be led by Derrick Henry.

However, Tannehill's turnover problems could lead to more points for the opponent's, which could lead to more negative game scripts and chances for Dion Lewis to be a factor.

If you look at the heat map below, you'll see that Tannehill isn't great in the short passing game, but he grades out above-average at passes behind the line of scrimmage, meaning swing passes and dump-offs to his running backs. The Throws By Route chart on the right shows that his passer rating is relatively high on these throws, and he seems to love short passes out to the right, his throwing side, which accounts for 21% of his total throws.

On the other hand, Mariota is far less accurate in these situations. His passer rating is below Tannehill's on the short-yardage passes, and he seems to throw them less often.

With his turnover-prone ways and fondness for line of scrimmage passing, Tannehill's presence could be a slight boost for Dion Lewis, but I wouldn't be downgrading Derrick Henry too much in a system that will still feature him a good deal.

 

Which Wide Receiver Would Benefit the Most?

In order to get a better gauge of which wide receiver might benefit from a switch to Tannehill, let's look at the accuracy of each quarterback when throwing certain routes.

In looking at the numbers, you actually see just how similar both quarterbacks are. They have essentially the same percentages on the screen and swing passes, and both are very similar on the horizontal and vertical leads - neither of which is appealing based on their accuracy percentages.

In fact, Tannehill is worse on the deep passes and similar to Mariota in underneath passes. Given that we saw his passer rating be higher than Mariota before, we have to assume his inferior accuracy when throwing short is offset by more completions on more passes in that area of the field. His lower accuracy on deep passes would be more of a factor if Mariota actually threw deep, but since he seems less inclined to do that on a regular basis, his superior accuracy to Tannehill doesn't really help him.

As evidenced by the graph below, the area in which Tannehill is more accurate that Mariota is between 0-19 yards from the line of scrimmage.

If we're expecting progress in the 0-19 yards range then the two people who stand to benefit most from that are Delanie Walker and Adam Humphries since they run their routes closest to the line of scrimmage. A.J. Brown leads the team with an 11.8 average depth of target. Corey Davis is next with 10.8, then Delanie Walker comes in with an aDOT of seven, and Adam Humphries has six yards per target.

However, we also have to keep in mind that fantasy football is not real football - as anybody who has watched Jameis Winston play quarterback can attest to. Let's look again at that turnover worthy play chart from earlier:

You notice Mariota slightly left of the middle in the top-left quadrant, avoiding turnover-worthy play. He's a safe quarterback who won't turn the ball over, but also doesn't take chances. We discussed his aversion to the deep pass a few times. Tannehill, alone there in the lower left, loves to take chances. He doesn't hit on them often, but look at the other QBs closest to him last season: Cam Newton, Jameis Winston, Lamar Jackson. All quarterbacks with huge fantasy upside.

Now, I'm not saying that Tannehill will have that upside, but I am saying that he is clearly going to take shots down the field. If you're a big-play target at wide receiver, all you need is for one of those shots to connect and you've made your fantasy production. That's why we need to look again at A.J. Brown's team-leading aDOT.

What all of this says to me is that Delanie Walker and Adam Humphries may raise their floor a bit with Tannehill at quarterback, but we're talking about a run-heavy offense still, so you're looking at five to seven targets over the middle of the field from a quarterback who is still just slightly above league-average accuracy in those areas. For me, that's not enough to get excited about in regards to Humphries (more on Walker below).

I will allow myself to get a little excited about A.J. Brown. Here we have a young receiver with dynamic talent who has already shown he can break big plays. He's running the deepest routes with a shift to a quarterback that will take foolish chances down the field. This makes Brown an intriguing bench stash in 12+ team leagues and a name to watch in 10-team leagues. The Titans figure to only really be able to support one fantasy-viable wide receiver with how little they throw the ball, so I would lean more to Brown, which means I still have little interest in Corey Davis unless I'm in a truly deep league.

 

Is Delanie Walker Still The Main Target?

Heading into this week, Walker leads the team with 18.8% of the overall targets. Granted, it's only a slight lead on Adam Humphries and Corey Davis, who both have 16.4%, but Walker also leads the team with 33% of the red zone targets.

As mentioned above, Walker sees a minor rise to his floor with Tannehill as the starter. He's only blocking 4.5% of the time, which is a low number that should have us excited about his production in the passing game; yet, he has only run 106 routes, which is 19th at the position behind Jordan Akins, Jason Witten, and Nick Vannett. This has capped his fantasy ceiling.

However, the tight end position has been such a dumpster fire that Walker is still the 11th ranked tight end in half-PPR formats. What's more, we already mentioned that Tannehill has a higher touchdown percentage in the red zone than Mariota, which is an area of the field where Delanie Walker shines. In fact, Tannehill has thrown 84 career touchdowns to nine interceptions in the red zone; Mariota has thrown 51 career red-zone touchdowns.

Given that Delanie Walker isn't blocking much, and Tannehill will look to be more aggressive in the red-zone, I think the quarterback switch is a net positive for Walker, who is still the team's best red-zone option and could see more touchdowns with Tannehill under center. That would make it easy for him to entrench himself as a weekly top-10 option with the upside to reach into the top seven at the position.

More Fantasy Football Analysis




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Value Picks
Compare Any Players
News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Sergei Bobrovsky

Returns To Winning Ways
Anton Lundell

Earns Two Points Monday
Ryan Gerard

Going For A Texas Trifecta Of Sorts
Brandon Hagel

Departs Loss Early
Joe Highsmith

Hoping To Make More Putts In Texas
Eric Cole

Expecting Big Things In Texas
Brian Campbell

May Go Under The Radar At CJ Cup
Los Angeles Chargers

Tre Harris Expected To Fill X Role For Chargers
Los Angeles Chargers

Quentin Johnston Needs To Earn His Spot In Training Camp
Los Angeles Chargers

Hassan Haskins The Leader For No. 3 RB Job
Los Angeles Chargers

Chargers Plan For 1-2 Punch At RB With Omarion Hampton, Najee Harris
New England Patriots

Patriots View TreVeyon Henderson As A Three-Down Back
Cleveland Browns

Browns View Quinshon Judkins As A Potential Bell-Cow Back
Seattle Seahawks

Seahawks Plan To Develop Jalen Milroe As A QB
Tennessee Titans

Titans Unlikely To Pick Up Treylon Burks' Fifth-Year Option
Cleveland Browns

Browns Apply Unrestricted Free-Agent Tender To Elijah Moore
Cleveland Browns

Browns Agree To One-Year Deal With Diontae Johnson
Dallas Cowboys

Cowboys Could Reunite With Amari Cooper
Pittsburgh Steelers

Steelers Sign Robert Woods To One-Year Deal
Jimmy Butler III

Officially Active For Game 4
Isaiah Stewart

Uncertain For Game 5
Michael Porter Jr.

Expected To Play In Game 5
Brandon Nimmo

Has Career Game
Russell Westbrook

Questionable For Tuesday Night
Tyler Glasnow

Going On The Injured List
Jaylen Brown

Back On The Injury Report
Jrue Holiday

Out Again On Tuesday Night
Bennedict Mathurin

Questionable For Game 5
Damian Lillard

May Not Play Next Season
Luis Arraez

Expected To Return On Tuesday
Johnathan Kovacevic

To Remain Out Tuesday
Brenden Dillon

Unavailable Tuesday
Luke Hughes

Not Ready To Return For Game 5
Darius Garland

Remains Out On Monday
Ross Colton

Remains Out On Monday
Oskar Bäck

Oskar Back Returns To Stars Lineup Monday
Miro Heiskanen

To Miss Game 5
Jordan Westburg

Placed On Injured List
Anthony Cirelli

Good To Go For Game 4
Cleveland Browns

Browns Decline Kenny Pickett's Fifth-Year Option
New York Giants

Giants Won't Pick Up Evan Neal's Fifth-Year Option
Carolina Panthers

Panthers Pick Up Fifth-Year Option On Ikem Ekwonu
Philadelphia Eagles

Dallas Goedert Could Remain An Eagle
Dallas Cowboys

Dallas Could Still Add Wide Receiver Help Prior To 2025 Season
Cleveland Browns

Shedeur Sanders Struggled During Pre-Draft Process
Buffalo Bills

Elijah Moore Visiting With Bills
Jacksonville Jaguars

Emmanuel Ogbah Signs With Jaguars
New Orleans Saints

Derek Carr Undergoes MRI Exam
William Byron

Ends With A Strong Top-Five Finish At Talladega
Ryan Blaney

Bad Luck Continues With Talladega Crash
Kyle Larson

Has A Career-Best Performance At Talladega
Ian Machado Garry

Gets Back On Track With UFC Kansas City Win
Brad Keselowski

Talladega Run Ends Early After Crashing
Carlos Prates

Suffers His First UFC Loss
Zhang Mingyang

Still Undefeated In The UFC
Anthony Smith

Retires After UFC Kansas City Loss
Giga Chikadze

Takes Unanimous Decision Loss
Giga Chikadze

Takes Unanimous-Decision Loss
David Onama

Extends Win Streak At UFC Kansas City
Michel Pereira

Drops Decision At UFC Kansas City
Abus Magomedov

Extends His Win Streak
Nicolas Dalby

Gets Finished For The First Time
Randy Brown

Gets Back In The Win Column
Ikram Aliskerov

Gets First-Round TKO Finish At UFC Kansas City
Andre Muniz

Gets TKO'd At UFC Kansas City
Ivan Demidov

Has Historic Outing In Game 4
Timo Meier

Records Two Points Sunday
Andrei Svechnikov

Nets Hat Trick In Game 4 Win
Leon Draisaitl

Caps Off Four-Point Effort With First Postseason Overtime Goal
Connor Hellebuyck

Gets Pulled Again
Alexandre Carrier

Fails To Finish Game 4
Tyler Tucker

Makes Early Exit Sunday
Chase Elliott

Recovers from Speeding Penalty to Finish Fifth
Joey Logano

Finishes Last at Talladega After Disqualification for Missing Spoiler Brace
Ryan Preece

Loses Talladega Race First in Photo Finish Then in Post-Race Inspection
NASCAR

Poor Toyota Strategy Arguably Cost Bubba Wallace Winning Chances at Talladega
Christopher Bell

Unhurt After Hard Contact with Inside Retaining Wall
Joe Ryan

Posts Stellar Outing
Jaylen Brown

Available For Game 4
Nick Lodolo

Throws Seven Scoreless Innings
Tyler Glasnow

Removed Early On Sunday
Darius Garland

Questionable For Game 4
Jaden Ivey

Making Progress
Frederik Andersen

Exits Game 4 With Injury
Jake Neighbours

Shines On Sunday With Three Points
Jordan Binnington

Makes 30 Saves In Game 4 Victory
Patrik Laine

Not Expected To Play In Game 4
Tarik Skubal

Racks Up 11 Strikeouts
Luke Weaver

In Line To Get The Bulk Of Save Opportunities Moving Forward
Devin Williams

Removed From Closer Role
Chase Elliott

Is One OF The Top Overall DFS Picks Of The Week
Joey Logano

Could Joey Logano Finish A Race With A Top Finish At Talladega?
NASCAR

DFS Players Should Like Bubba Wallace For Talladega This Week
Christopher Bell

Should DFS Players Roster Christopher Bell At Talladega?
Austin Cindric

Is Austin Cindric Worth Rostering For Talladega DFS Lineups?
Shane Van Gisbergen

Is A Solid, Safe, DFS Choice For Talladega Lineups
Austin Dillon

Is Austin Dillon A Viable DFS Play At Talladega This Week?
Josh Berry

Qualifies Too High At Talladega To Be Worth Rostering In DFS
Michael McDowell

Should DFS Players Take A Shot On Michael McDowell At Talladega?
Noah Gragson

Could Be A Sneaky DFS Play For Talladega
Denny Hamlin

Probably Qualified Too Well for DFS Consideration
Kyle Larson

Increasingly Undervalued Due to His Crashing, but Still a Great DFS Option
Austin Hays

Smacks Two Homers On Saturday
Jorge Polanco

Goes Deep Twice On Saturday
Eugenio Suárez

Eugenio Suarez Hits Four Homers On Saturday
Framber Valdez

Tosses Complete Game In A Loss To The Royals
Jackson Chourio

Nearly Hits For The Cycle
Jimmy Butler III

Ruled Out On Saturday
Isaiah Stewart

Questionable For Sunday's Game
Jaylen Brown

Questionable For Game 4
Logan Evans

To Make MLB Debut On Sunday
Jrue Holiday

Won't Play On Sunday
Logan Gilbert

Heading To 15-Day Injured List
Mitchell Robinson

Questionable For Game 4 Versus Detroit
Michael Porter Jr.

Available On Saturday Night
Russell Westbrook

Won't Suit Up For Game 4
Ryan Mountcastle

Adley Rutschman, Ryan Mountcastle Not In Game 1 Lineup
Darius Garland

Won't Suit Up For Game 3
Darius Garland

Unavailable For Pregame Warmup
MLB

Yankees and Blue Jays Postponed On Saturday
Jordan Beck

Power Surge Continues, Homers Twice On Friday
Devin Williams

Blows Save On Friday, Yankees Make Temporary Move At Closer
Carlos Prates

Looks To Remain Undefeated In The UFC
Ian Machado Garry

Set For UFC Kansas City Main Event
Zhang Mingyang

Scheduled For Co-Main Event
Anthony Smith

Set For His Final UFC Bout
David Onama

Set For Featherweight Bout
Giga Chikadze

Looks To Bounce Back
Abus Magomedov

Looks For His Third Consecutive Win
Michel Pereira

Returns To Action At UFC Kansas City
Cam Davis

Looking For Better Fortunes At TPC Louisiana
Adam Svensson

Making Third Apperence At Zurich Classic
Max Greyserman

Aiming For Similar Success At TPC Louisiana
Lee Hodges

A High-Upside Player In New Orleans
PGA

Nico Echavarria Looks To Ride Off Of Elite Putting In New Orleans
Gary Woodland

A Player Worth Watching In New Orleans
Max McGreevy

Returns To The Zurich Classic Of New Orleans
Rasmus Hojgaard

In Search Of Consistency Ahead Of Zurich Classic
Sam Stevens

A Boom-Or-Bust Candidate In New Orleans
Nicolai Hojgaard

Looking To Turn Season Around At Zurich Classic
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF