X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Fantasy Baseball Strategy: Don't Pay (Too Much) For Saves

This isn’t the hottest of takes here, as the SAGNOF (Saves Ain’t Got NO Face) school of thought has had a steady stream of followers for quite a few years now. It’s a little more complicated than that of course, as this isn’t simply about the straight up value of taking a closer early on.

There’s the opportunity cost of the starting pitcher or batter that you passed on in order to secure that closer and get those precious saves. Look, I know, closers aren’t the only ones who get hurt or lose their jobs, but boy howdy if they don’t lead the charge with it relative to the amount of closers you start the year with (we’ll say 35, accounting for a few “battles”).

Editor's note: Make sure you bookmark our 2017 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard. Our rankings assistant tool combines all our staff's ranks in one place. You can easily filter and export all sorts of rankings and tiers - mixed leagues, points leagues, AL/NL only, top prospects, dynasty ranks, and more.

 

What You Lose When Paying For Saves

Perhaps you think that this is more of a reason to pay for those top flight closers, and get yourself an Aroldis Chapman, Craig Kimbrel, or Kenley Jansen type of guy. There is validity to that strategy, but the opportunity cost of doing so can really leave you behind the eight ball when it comes to hitting categories if you pass on a top-flight bat. I'd rather tangle with the FAAB and Waiver Wire crazes and attempt to get out ahead of the next great situation (skills over roles), rather than trying to build up a top hitter out of that same player pool.

Looking at last year in the middle of March, right in the thick of draft season, we still had Glen Perkins and Ken Giles as very respectable mid-tier options. We know these scenarios didn’t play out so well for those who bought in on them. These are just a few examples.

When all was said and done last year, Jeurys Familia led the league with 51 saves, followed by Mark Melancon, Kenley Jansen and Zach Britton with 47. Close behind were Sam Dyson with 38, and Alex Colome and Jeanmar Gomez with 37 each. None of Dyson, Colome or Gomez were the closer heading into the year, but it wasn’t long before they took over and ran away with the role.

Then there were guys like Roberto Osuna who, while drafted, emerged as a top flight RP with 36 saves and is now a top 10 RP in 2017. There was Ryan Madson who had 30, and Jeremy Jeffress who had 27. Out of the 30 teams in the MLB, over 10 experienced major closer upheaval at some point during the year in 2016.

Now it would be foolish to expect any supreme amount of consistency in exact closer turnover rate, as hindsight bias and gambler’s fallacies could drive us into oblivion if we rely too much on any one piece of information. That said, the volatility of the closer position is undeniable, and while you might not want to go place bets in Vegas on how many closers will lose their jobs by the end of the year, there is a great chance that the number will be in the double-digits.

 

Know (and Minimize) the Risks

The truth is that the closers and relievers that you’re going to snag late in drafts will have plenty of risk to them. Whether that be related to their job security, performance on the mound, injury history, and so on, there will be risk. The point is that now instead of drafting Wade Davis, you can get a Chris Davis or Matt Carpenter. Instead of Osuna or Kimbrel, you can get Hanley Ramirez or Mark Trumbo.

Move down the ADPs futher. Instead of Ken Giles or Cody Allen, you can take a shot on Jose Bautista or Danny Salazar. Replacing a mediocre closer is usually much easier than replacing a solid corner infielder. This is only one strategy of course, but it is an extremely valid one that requires diligence and savvy speculating on those “next men up” relievers. Do not read this as a "you should punt saves" piece, but there is a strong case for not ponying up with top or even mid-round picks, and at least not more than once. Build a solid foundation, and leave the riskiest position for your picks that cost the least.

Understandably, it isn’t as palatable in leagues with shallower rosters as carrying a few relievers who could enter the ninth in the near-future can really hamstring you in the present. This doesn’t invalidate the disadvantage you can give yourself in missing those mid-round positional players though, which goes double for the elite guys where you’re passing up hitters or starting pitchers in the top 100.

Also, don't discount the elite RPs who are slated to be setup men, like Andrew Miller and Dellin Betances.  Miller, Tyler Thornburg, Dan Otero, Nate Jones and Ryan Dull are all examples of RPs who should be rostered in deep leagues, whether or not holds are a category. The sparkly ratios they can produce make them as valuable as most mediocre closers, and if the guy in front of them goes down, they become elite closer options.




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Player Comparisons
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Geno Smith21 mins ago

"Up In The Air" For Week 16 With Knee Injury
Denver Broncos9 hours ago

Broncos Defense Comes Up Big Again With Pick-Six, Four Turnovers
Josh Jacobs10 hours ago

’ Touchdown, 136 Total Yards Lift Packers In Week 15 Victory
Romeo Doubs10 hours ago

A Two-Score Return For Romeo Doubs In Packers Victory
Saquon Barkley10 hours ago

Hindered By Undisclosed Injury, Held To 74 Scrimmage Yards
Geno Smith11 hours ago

Questionable To Return On Sunday Night
Denver Broncos12 hours ago

Patrick Surtain II Injures Ankle In Win Over Indy
Jerry Jeudy12 hours ago

Goes For 108 Yards In Week 15
Hunter Henry12 hours ago

Delivers Low Yardage Total In Loss To Cardinals
CeeDee Lamb12 hours ago

Clears 100 Yards In Week 15
Rico Dowdle12 hours ago

Smashes Career-High Again
James Cook12 hours ago

Runs For 100 Yards, Scores Twice In Detroit
Pittsburgh Steelers12 hours ago

T.J. Watt Suffers Low-Ankle Injury In Loss To Philadelphia
Ty Johnson12 hours ago

Bills Lean On Ty Johnson Through The Air In Win Over Detroit
Alvin Kamara12 hours ago

Gets In The End Zone But Leaves With Injury
Drake Maye13 hours ago

Impressive In Week 15 Loss
Josh Allen13 hours ago

Goes Nuclear Again, Post-Game X-Rays Come Back Clean
Adrian Yanez13 hours ago

Falls Short At UFC Tampa
Patrick Mahomes13 hours ago

Picks Up Potential High-Ankle Sprain In Win
Daniel Marcos13 hours ago

Remains Undefeated After UFC Tampa
Vitor Petrino13 hours ago

Gets Finished Again At UFC Tampa
Dustin Jacoby13 hours ago

Pulls Off Stunning Knockout At UFC Tampa
Billy Quarantillo13 hours ago

Gets KO'd At UFC Tampa
Sam LaPorta13 hours ago

Busy In Week 15 Loss
Cub Swanson13 hours ago

Pulls Off Upset At UFC Tampa
Mike Evans13 hours ago

Posts Outstanding Performance In Week 15
Jahmyr Gibbs13 hours ago

Scores Two Touchdowns In Week 15
Jack Flaherty14 hours ago

Viewed As "Fallback" Option For Baltimore
Jesper Wallstedt16 hours ago

Starts For Wild Sunday
Artemi Panarin16 hours ago

Out On Sunday
Scott Perunovich16 hours ago

Back For Blues Sunday
Brandon Saad16 hours ago

Re-Enters Blues Lineup Sunday
Anthony Stolarz17 hours ago

Placed On Injured Reserve
Bo Horvat17 hours ago

Battling A Lower-Body Injury
LeBron James18 hours ago

Might Return On Sunday Night
Deandre Ayton18 hours ago

Won't Play On Sunday Night
Scottie Barnes18 hours ago

Goes Through A "Light Workout" On Sunday
Jared McCain2 days ago

Out Indefinitely
De'Anthony Melton2 days ago

On The Move To Brooklyn
Dennis Schröder2 days ago

Dennis Schroder Heading To Golden State
Tyler Toffoli2 days ago

In Danger Of Missing Saturday's Game
SJ2 days ago

Will Smith Back In Sharks Lineup Saturday
Dustin Wolf2 days ago

Takes On Prolific Panthers Saturday
Andrei Kuzmenko2 days ago

Will Not Play On Saturday
Jesús Luzardo2 days ago

Cubs Showing Interest In Jesus Luzardo
Kevin Lankinen2 days ago

Unavailable On Saturday
Elias Lindholm2 days ago

Good To Go Saturday
Cam Fowler2 days ago

Blues Pick Up Cam Fowler In Trade With Ducks
Jalen Johnson2 days ago

Will Suit Up For Saturday's Game
Bogdan Bogdanovic2 days ago

Playing Against Milwaukee
Trae Young2 days ago

Available On Saturday
Khris Middleton2 days ago

Active Versus Atlanta
Giannis Antetokounmpo2 days ago

Good To Go Against Atlanta
Kevin Huerter2 days ago

Suffers Another Shoulder Injury
2 days ago

Pistons Waiving Paul Reed
Paolo Banchero2 days ago

Spotted Shooting On Saturday
Nolan Arenado2 days ago

Astros Serious About Trading For Nolan Arenado
Jeffrey Springs2 days ago

A's Acquire Jeffrey Springs From Rays
Samuel Ersson2 days ago

Faces Wild On Saturday
Marc-Andre Fleury2 days ago

In Wild Net For Saturday's Matchup
Linus Ullmark2 days ago

Records 10th Career Shutout
Nick Jensen2 days ago

Continues Prolific Month In Friday's Win
Shane Pinto2 days ago

Ends Dry Spell With Two-Goal Effort
Evan Bouchard2 days ago

A Game-Time Call On Saturday
Donovan Clingan3 days ago

Returning On Friday
Bradley Beal3 days ago

Downgraded To Out
Jamal Murray3 days ago

Upgraded To Available
Christian Braun3 days ago

To Play On Friday
Aaron Gordon3 days ago

Available On Friday
Joel Embiid3 days ago

Won't Return On Friday
Bradley Beal3 days ago

Now Questionable Versus Utah
Christian Walker3 days ago

Seattle Would "Love" To Sign Christian Walker
Carson Kelly3 days ago

Agrees To Two-Year Contract With Cubs
Houston Astros3 days ago

Cam Smith Traded To Houston
Hayden Wesneski3 days ago

Shipped To Houston
Alec Martinez3 days ago

Added To Injured Reserve
Anthony Stolarz3 days ago

Day-To-Day With A Lower-Body Injury
Isaac Paredes3 days ago

Shipped To Houston
Kyle Tucker3 days ago

Cubs Acquire Kyle Tucker From The Astros
Kyle Tucker3 days ago

Cubs Close To Acquiring Kyle Tucker From The Astros
Nestor Cortes3 days ago

Traded To The Brewers
Adrian Yanez3 days ago

An Underdog At UFC Tampa
Daniel Marcos3 days ago

Looks To Remain Undefeated At UFC Tampa
Vitor Petrino3 days ago

Looks To Return To Win Column At UFC Tampa
Dustin Jacoby3 days ago

A Big Underdog At UFC Tampa
Cub Swanson3 days ago

Searching For 30th Career Win At UFC Tampa
Billy Quarantillo3 days ago

Faces A Legend At UFC Tampa
Devin Williams3 days ago

Traded To The Yankees
Joaquin Buckley3 days ago

Looks For His Sixth Win In A Row
Colby Covington3 days ago

Looks To Get Back In The Win Column
Bruno Silva3 days ago

Looks To Extend His Win Streak
Manel Kape3 days ago

A Favorite At UFC Tampa
Tuco Tokkos3 days ago

Looks For His First UFC Win
Navajo Stirling3 days ago

Set To Make His UFC Debut
Kyle Bradish4 days ago

Begins Throwing Program
Nolan Arenado4 days ago

Would Approve Of Trade To The Bronx
Francisco Lindor4 days ago

Back Injury In The Rearview Mirror
Rafael Devers4 days ago

Red Sox Prepared To Keep Rafael Devers At Third Base
Cody Bellinger4 days ago

Yankees Targeting Cody Bellinger
Pete Alonso4 days ago

Mets Still Trying To Bring Back Pete Alonso
Corbin Burnes4 days ago

Giants The Favorites To Land Corbin Burnes
Brenton Doyle4 days ago

Rockies Plan To Hit Brenton Doyle At Leadoff

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP