X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

2016 Fantasy Baseball Rankings: Starting Pitcher (Part 2)

We're back again for part two of the first look into our starting pitcher rankings. Brad, Max, Kyle, and I just love baseball so much that we can't stay away from it. Just to remind you all, our rankings were submitted on December 6th before the Hot Stove went berserk and caused this late December heat wave to ripple out (seriously, here in NY it's about to be 70 degrees on Christmas Eve). We are here to dive into the deeper portion of the starting pitcher rankings, and with so many names to drill through, well those numbers are going to start to stretch apart.

There are so many metrics and things that people can attach themselves to when it comes to pitchers. Some owners are going to look at a pitcher's strikeouts, their walks, their groundball rate, the percentage of sliders thrown, the velocity of their changeup compared to their fastball, the amount of innings they threw last year, the projected defenders that should be backing him up, the ballpark they play in, and so on. Each ranker, each owner, each projection system will weigh each of these factors differently. There’s plenty to look at here, so let’s get back to it.

Be sure to also check out all of our 2016 fantasy baseball rankings articles. We have rankings and tiers across all positions, for MLB prospects, and for dynasty/keeper leagues.

 

2016 Fantasy Baseball Rankings: Starting Pitcher

Lance McCullers is an interesting guy to look at, as Kyle has him at 29, Brad at 34, he’s 41 for me, and Max buried him at 51. He didn’t have a conventional year by any means, being pulled up and thrown into the fire early in May (with great results). His first half ERA was 2.52, whereas his second half was 3.96. To be fair, most of the damage came in a horrible August start at Texas where he was shelled for six earned in one third of an inning. Outside of that he only had one start where he gave up more than three earned runs. He will now come into the year with a clear spot in the rotation and with an arm that has some innings under it.

Joe Ross is reportedly one of the top options to fill one of two vacant spots in the Nationals’ 2016 rotation, and it’s hard to imagine they don’t look his way. He’s got an electric fastball, pitches in the NL East, and looked just fine in his limited duty for the Nationals last year (5-5 with a 3.64 ERA in 76.2 IP). This must be why Max, Kyle, and I have him right around 40th in our rankings, but Brad has the haterade flowing, putting him at 89th. Perhaps he is the voice of reason here. Expectations might be too high for a guy who doesn’t have a spot in the rotation yet, for a guy who hasn’t pitched even half a year of major league ball yet. This ties in well with Steven Matz, who everyone but Brad has at around 40 as well (he has him at 64). You can certainly get a sense of our styles and leanings from our rankings.

Shelby Miller is another guy who has some separation between rankings. Max and I have him at 34 and 36, respectively, while Brad and Kyle peg him at 51 and 54. These rankings were made before Miller was traded to the Diamondbacks, but it’s interesting all the same regarding a guy who really grew last year. How much of it was genuine and how much regression should we expect? The answers from each of us are clearly reflected in the rankings. I can't speak for Brad and Kyle but I can see how the modest strikeout rate (7.50 K/9) and still too high walk rate (3.20 BB/9) is cause enough for some pause here (along with a 4.16 SIERA). I personally just really liked how he incorporated a cutter into his arsenal and saw his ground ball rate go from being in the high 30s all the way to 47.7%. Couple this with a jump in soft contact going from 16.4% to 21.3%. I think he still has room to grow, and right around 36 makes me feel as though the risk is worth the upside.

Who else might be fun enough to investigate here? Andrew Cashner is an interesting name, he has Brad and I pegging him right at 50, with Max high on him at 37 and Kyle low on him at 69. Let's look under the hood a bit at what might be driving the narratives. Okay obviously he finished with a 6-16 record, but we know that doesn't really speak to much. His strikeouts went up from a 6.79 K/9 (good) but his walks ballooned up as well (2.12 to a 3.22 BB/9...yikes). His BABIP went from .274 in 2014 to .330 in 2015 (it was .269 in 2013) and his strand rate was zapped, falling from 75.3% to 65.6%. So it looks like he certainly ate some bad luck, but he also created his own misfortune in loading the bases more. His FIP jumped from 3.09 in 2014 to 3.85 in 2015, and that's pretty much what I'm expecting for 2016. Cut down on those walks young man.

Taijuan Walker also draws the spotlight with Kyle ranking him at 44 and Brad pegging him at 70 (I have him at 56 and Max has him at 67). He had a healthy K/9 (8.33) and an acceptable BB/9 (2.12), but his HR/9 was a pretty darn high 1.33 (as evidenced by his xFIP being 3.82 versus a FIP/ERA of 4.07/4.56). He's young so there isn't a big sample size to draw on, but you've got to think that home run number stabilizes a bit, especially pitching in Seattle. He's got a vicious fastball and if he can improve on his changeup usage then that really be a solid "Year 2" leap for Walker.

Nathan Eovaldi has a range of 47-75, and while I'm checking in at 65 on him I'll probably bump him up a bit next month. The question with him is whether he can truly develop that splitter into an out pitch or not. I believe that introducing it really helped his soft contact rate go from 15.9% in 2014 all the way to 21.2% in 2015. His ground ball rate also went from 44.8% to 52.2%. That fastball is never going to really have a significant amount of movement, but if he can find something off speed to consistently pair with a fastball that he can locate and a catcher that can frame well in Brian McCann, he could look a lot more like his FIP of 3.42 from 2015 rather than his ERA of 4.20. Sort of like how we pointed out how removing Felix Hernandez's best start would result in a prettier picture, if you take away Eovaldi's worst start of the year (eight earned in two thirds of an inning against the Marlins) his ERA comes down to 3.75. The home park will never do him any favors, but I think he deserves some more love than he gets - though perhaps his stellar looking 14-3 record will prop him up in the wrong way.

There are tons of names to choose from, and if you have any further questions on anyone feel free to reach out to any of us via Twitter or catch us in the chat! As always, here are our complete rankings for reference:

 

Starting Pitcher Rankings for 2016 Fantasy Baseball

Name Brad Max Kyle Nick Composite
Clayton Kershaw 1 1 1 1 1
Max Scherzer 3 2 2 2 2.25
Chris Sale 4 3 3 3 3.25
Jake Arrieta 2 4 4 4 3.5
Zack Greinke 5 5 9 5 6
Jose Fernandez 7 6 7 6 6.5
Jacob deGrom 10 8 5 7 7.5
David Price 9 7 6 8 7.5
Dallas Keuchel 6 9 11 9 8.75
Madison Bumgarner 11 11 10 10 10.5
Felix Hernandez 8 10 18 11 11.75
Gerrit Cole 14 14 8 13 12.25
Chris Archer 15 13 12 14 13.5
Corey Kluber 13 12 14 16 13.75
Noah Syndergaard 12 15 17 18 15.5
Matt Harvey 17 16 15 15 15.75
Stephen Strasburg 18 22 13 12 16.25
Carlos Carrasco 16 17 16 20 17.25
Jon Lester 19 21 19 25 21
Cole Hamels 24 24 21 19 22
Yu Darvish 25 19 22 22 22
Sonny Gray 22 18 24 24 22
Johnny Cueto 20 25 20 26 22.75
Carlos Martinez 21 27 23 23 23.5
Tyson Ross 23 23 26 32 26
Danny Salazar 27 26 25 27 26.25
Masahiro Tanaka 39 20 30 21 27.5
Francisco Liriano 26 30 28 29 28.25
Marcus Stroman 30 32 27 28 29.25
Jordan Zimmermann 28 28 33 34 30.75
Michael Wacha 37 29 35 30 32.75
Adam Wainwright 40 36 41 17 33.5
Luis Severino 29 31 43 33 34
Scott Kazmir 36 33 37 39 36.25
Jose Quintana 31 41 31 45 37
Michael Pineda 52 35 32 31 37.5
Garrett Richards 38 38 39 37 38
Jake Odorizzi 32 42 38 42 38.5
Lance McCullers 34 51 29 41 38.75
Patrick Corbin 43 46 34 35 39.5
Shelby Miller 51 34 54 36 43.75
John Lackey 33 48 56 44 45.25
Steven Matz 64 39 40 39 45.5
Gio Gonzalez 44 45 50 46 46.25
Alex Cobb 41 43 46 58 47
Justin Verlander 45 49 51 43 47
Hyun-Jin Ryu 42 44 45 59 47.5
Yordano Ventura 40 47 53 52 48
Jeff Samardzija 35 60 48 49 48
Collin McHugh 46 50 52 51 49.75
Clay Buchholz 53 53 49 48 50.75
Joe Ross 89 40 36 38 50.75
Jaime Garcia 48 52 64 40 51
Hisashi Iwakuma 55 55 42 53 51.25
Andrew Cashner 50 37 69 50 51.5
Raisel Iglesias 60 58 47 47 53
James Shields 61 41 58 54 53.5
Drew Smyly 66 46 57 55 56
Taijuan Walker 70 67 44 56 59.25
Eduardo Rodriguez 58 57 62 62 59.75
Kyle Hendricks 62 63 55 60 60
Brett Anderson 57 56 70 61 61
Wei-Yin Chen 54 54 72 64 61
Nathan Eovaldi 47 74 60 65 61.5
Robbie Ray 56 69 61 63 62.25
Carlos Rodon 71 68 59 57 63.75
Andrew Heaney 59 65 65 68 64.25
Julio Teheran 63 61 74 66 66
Jason Hammel 72 70 63 71 69
Aaron Nola 68 62 73 75 69.5
Jimmy Nelson 69 66 76 67 69.5
Anibal Sanchez 67 78 67 69 70.25
Marco Estrada 65 64 77 76 70.5
Ian Kennedy 77 75 78 72 75.5
Alex Wood 81 77 68 81 76.75
Anthony DeSclafani 86 91 66 70 78.25
Kevin Gausman 83 76 79 84 80.5
Henry Owens 88 71 91 74 81
Trevor Bauer 95 72 85 83 83.75
Mike Fiers 71 93 75 97 84
Mike Leake 84 80 87 88 84.75
Ervin Santana 80 86 99 80 86.25
Jesse Hahn 105 59 109 79 88
Derek Holland 73 85 97 100 88.75
Edinson Volquez 82 83 94 98 89.25
Erik Johnson 101 82 90 89 90.5
Taylor Jungmann 109 90 88 85 93
Mat Latos 112 95 82 86 93.75
Ubaldo Jimenez 90 98 93 95 94
Chris Heston 106 87 101 82 94
Jerad Eickhoff 96 99 95 87 94.25
James Paxton 85 102 96 96 94.75
Jake Peavy 111 96 84 93 96
Phil Hughes 110 89 103 92 98.5
J.A. Happ 92 71 78 ---
Erasmo Ramirez 94 80 73 ---
Nate Karns 79 83 91 ---
Wade Miley 74 97 92 ---
Kyle Gibson 75 100 99 ---
Tyler Duffey 78 81 111 ---
Yovani Gallardo 91 88 102 ---
Zack Wheeler 104 84 105 ---
Josh Tomlin 87 101 108 ---
Chris Tillman 92 103 115 ---
Rubby de la Rosa 100 100 104 ---
Danny Duffy 107 102 114 ---
Kris Medlen 73 89 ---
Drew Hutchison 81 77 ---
Rick Porcello 76 98 ---
Jesse Chavez 86 94 ---
Joe Kelly 79 110 ---
Daniel Norris 97 104 ---
Nicholas Tropeano 93 112 ---
Matt Shoemaker 94 113 ---
Jonathan Gray 99 108 ---
CC Sabathia 108 116 ---
Hector Santiago 114 119 ---
Wily Peralta 115 105 ---
Chase Anderson 113 107 ---
Matt Cain 90 ---
Jeremy Hellickson 98 ---
Matt Boyd 102 ---
R.A. Dickey 106 ---
Mike Foltynewicz 106 ---
Jorge de la Rosa 107 ---
Brett Oberholtzer 116 ---
Trevor May 117 ---
Doug Fister 118 ---
Martin Perez 120 ---

 

MLB & Fantasy Baseball Chat Room

[iflychat_embed id="c-12" hide_user_list="yes" hide_popup_chat="no" height="400px"]

 




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Daily Stats & Leaders
All Pitcher Matchups
Compare Any Players
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Austin Reaves7 mins ago

Ready To Go For Game 1
NFL9 mins ago

Bills Release Armani Rogers, Branson Deen
Luka Dončić13 mins ago

Luka Doncic Removed From Injury Report
Brandon Young17 mins ago

Set To Make MLB Debut On Saturday
LeBron James21 mins ago

Listed As Probable For Game 1
Ben Sheppard27 mins ago

Probable For Saturday's Game 1
Jacob Lopez28 mins ago

Recalled From Triple-A
NFL30 mins ago

Kolton Miller Absent From Raiders' Voluntary Offseason Program
Kevin Durant33 mins ago

To Houston Already Losing Steam
Matt Canterino45 mins ago

Twins Designate Matt Canterino For Assignment
Lauri Markkanen47 mins ago

Wants To Stay With The Jazz
NFL54 mins ago

Ross Blacklock Let Go By New York
Mickey Gasper55 mins ago

Sent To Triple-A St. Paul
Bennedict Mathurin1 hour ago

Expected To Play In Game 1 Saturday
Nicky Lopez1 hour ago

Designated For Assignment
Josh Smith1 hour ago

Still Out Of Lineup Friday Night
Pascal Siakam1 hour ago

Available For Playoff Opener
Zach Neto1 hour ago

Reinstated From Injury List, Will Make Season Debut Friday
Tyrese Haliburton1 hour ago

Returning From Two-Game Absence Saturday
Cade Cunningham1 hour ago

Available For Game 1 Against Knicks
Shohei Ohtani1 hour ago

Out Of Friday's Lineup For Birth Of First Child
Josh Hart2 hours ago

Back In Knicks Lineup Saturday
Eugenio Suárez2 hours ago

Eugenio Suarez Hits Grand Slam In Friday Afternoon's Loss
OG Anunoby2 hours ago

Good To Go For Game 1
Ian Happ2 hours ago

Hits Grand Slam In Massive Day At The Plate
Jalen Brunson2 hours ago

Available For Saturday's Game 1
Jazz Chisholm Jr.2 hours ago

Suspended For One Game, Will Appeal And Is Playing Friday
Karl-Anthony Towns2 hours ago

Returning To Action Saturday
Kyle Tucker2 hours ago

Hits Go-Ahead Homer In Cubs Win
Pelle Larsson2 hours ago

Good To Go Friday
Nikola Jović2 hours ago

Nikola Jovic Available Friday
Carson Kelly2 hours ago

Crushes Two Homers In Crazy Cubs Win
Trae Young2 hours ago

Officially Active On Friday
Giannis Antetokounmpo2 hours ago

Not On Game 1 Injury Report
NFL2 hours ago

Raiders Considering Drafting A Quarterback
Damian Lillard2 hours ago

Officially Out For Game 1
Irv Smith2 hours ago

Sticking With Texans
Ryan Lindgren3 hours ago

Set To Return Saturday
NFL3 hours ago

Texans Expected To Draft Wide Receivers
Greg Dortch3 hours ago

Returning To Cardinals
Josh Manson3 hours ago

Available For Game 1
Mark Andrews3 hours ago

Could Be Traded Soon
Ondrej Palat3 hours ago

To Return For Start Of Playoffs
David Savard3 hours ago

Will Retire After Playoffs
Gavin Sheets3 hours ago

In Padres Lineup Against Astros
NFL3 hours ago

Raiders, Falcons Could Have Interest In Jalen Ramsey
Robert Thomas3 hours ago

Good To Go Saturday
Shea Langeliers3 hours ago

Back In Lineup On Friday
Matthew Tkachuk3 hours ago

Expected To Return For Game 1
3 hours ago

Raiders Are High On Ashton Jeanty
Alex Verdugo3 hours ago

Hitting Leadoff In Season Debut On Friday
Jason Robertson3 hours ago

Considered Week-To-Week
Rome Odunze4 hours ago

To Hopefully Get More Involved
Dylan Moore4 hours ago

Not In Lineup On Friday
NFL4 hours ago

Dolphins Could Draft A Quarterback
Parker Meadows4 hours ago

Cleared To Begin Throwing Program
James Cook4 hours ago

Could Stay Away From Voluntary Workouts
Chandler Simpson4 hours ago

Called Up By Rays
Alex Bregman5 hours ago

Back From Paternity Leave
Noah Davis5 hours ago

Dodgers Recall Noah Davis From Triple-A
Pelle Larsson8 hours ago

Upgraded To Probable Against Hawks
Kevin Love8 hours ago

Away From The Team For Personal Reasons
Leon Draisaitl11 hours ago

Wins First Rocket Richard Trophy
Nikita Kucherov11 hours ago

Bags Third Art Ross Trophy
Bryan Rust11 hours ago

Scores Twice In Season-Ending Win
Igor Shesterkin12 hours ago

Shuts Out Lightning With 27 Saves
Dylan Cozens12 hours ago

Picks Up Three Points In Regular-Season Finale
Matvei Michkov12 hours ago

Caps Off Rookie Campaign With Three-Point Effort
Brady Tkachuk12 hours ago

Makes Early Exit For Precautionary Reasons
Jake Tonges20 hours ago

Signs Exclusive-Rights Tender
Denver Broncos20 hours ago

Broncos To Focus On RB Position In Next Week's Draft
Drew Lock20 hours ago

Sam Howell, Drew Lock Expected To Compete For Backup Job
New York Giants21 hours ago

Giants Leaning Toward Taking Best Player Available At No. 3
New Orleans Saints21 hours ago

Ryan Ramczyk Announces His Retirement
Buffalo Bills21 hours ago

Tre'Davious White Reunites With Buffalo
Aaron Rodgers21 hours ago

Willing To Play For $10 Million A Year
Jakob Chychrun1 day ago

Returns Against Penguins
Rasmus Andersson1 day ago

Out Against Kings
Jonathan Huberdeau1 day ago

Sits Out Regular-Season Finale
Ryan Pulock1 day ago

Out On Thursday
Jake Sanderson1 day ago

Back In Action Thursday
Thomas Chabot1 day ago

To Be Rested Against Hurricanes
Claude Giroux1 day ago

Active On Thursday
Dallas Cowboys1 day ago

Cowboys Add Hakeem Adeniji To Offensive-Line Room
Lucas Glover2 days ago

Looks To Rebound After Poor Performance
Daniel Berger2 days ago

Looking To Continue Solid Play At RBC
Sepp Straka2 days ago

Looking To Bounce Back At RBC
Justin Thomas2 days ago

Looking To Shake Off Poor Masters At RBC Heritage
Xander Schauffele2 days ago

Still Looking For Year's First Win At RBC Heritage
Maverick McNealy2 days ago

Is An Intriguing Play At RBC Heritage
Shane Lowry2 days ago

Looks To Shake Off Poor Masters Sunday At RBC Heritage
Will Zalatoris2 days ago

Eyes A Bounce-Back At RBC Heritage
Gary Woodland2 days ago

Could Add Some Surprise At Hilton Head
Sam Burns2 days ago

Hoping For Better Times At RBC Heritage
Sahith Theegala2 days ago

Still Trying To Put It All Together
Aaron Rai3 days ago

Might Be That Guy For Hilton Head
Robert MacIntyre3 days ago

All Or Nothing At RBC Heritage
Tom Hoge3 days ago

Still Playing Solid Heading To Hilton Head
Nick Dunlap3 days ago

Continues To Have Rough Stretch
Keegan Bradley3 days ago

Looks To Move On From Masters Performance
Matt Fitzpatrick3 days ago

A Boom-Or-Bust Option At RBC Heritage
Patrick Cantlay3 days ago

A Strong Play At RBC Heritage
Jordan Spieth3 days ago

Targets Another Strong RBC Heritage Showing
Collin Morikawa3 days ago

Eyeing Victory At RBC Heritage
Max Homa3 days ago

Breaks Through At The Masters
Alexander Volkanovski4 days ago

Reclaims Featherweight Title
Diego Lopes4 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC 314
Paddy Pimblett4 days ago

Remains Undefeated In The UFC
Michael Chandler4 days ago

Suffers TKO Loss
MMA4 days ago

Patricio Freire Gets Dominated In His UFC Debut
Yair Rodriguez4 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Bryce Mitchell4 days ago

Gets Submitted At UFC 314
Jean Silva4 days ago

Gets Submission Win At UFC 314
Dominick Reyes4 days ago

Wins Third Fight In A Row
Austin Dillon4 days ago

Nabs His First Top-10 Finish Of The 2025 Season At Bristol
Ryan Blaney4 days ago

Bold Strategies Fall Flat, Still Musters A Top-Five Finish At Bristol
Christopher Bell4 days ago

Finishes In The Top 10 After Falling Back Midway At Bristol
Ty Gibbs4 days ago

Earns His First Top-Five Finish Of The 2025 Season At Bristol
Chase Briscoe4 days ago

Quietly Scores First Career Top-Five Finish At Bristol
William Byron5 days ago

Denny Hamlin Cuts Into William Byron's Points Lead
William Byron5 days ago

Makes Best Of His Mediocre Qualifying Run With Sixth-Place Finish
Alex Bowman5 days ago

Despite Engine Failure, Alex Bowman's Improved Speed Looks Promising
NASCAR5 days ago

A.J. Allmendinger Enters Playoff Picture With Surprise Bristol Top-10 Finish
Kyle Larson5 days ago

Will Compete For The Win At Bristol
Chase Elliott6 days ago

Is One Of The More Favorable DFS Options Available For Bristol
William Byron6 days ago

Is A Solid DFS Option For Bristol Lineups
Tyler Reddick6 days ago

Could Tyler Reddick Be A Sneaky DFS Option For Bristol?
NASCAR6 days ago

Is Bubba Wallace Worth Rostering For Bristol This Week?
Ross Chastain6 days ago

Could Ross Chastain Be A Worthy DFS Choice For Bristol?
Carson Hocevar6 days ago

Is Carson Hocevar Worth Rostering For Bristol DFS Lineups?
NASCAR6 days ago

Should Fantasy Managers Avoid Rostering A.J. Allmendinger In DFS For Bristol?
Ryan Preece6 days ago

Is Ryan Preece Worth Rostering For Bristol Lineups?
Austin Dillon6 days ago

May Be One Of The Top Value Options For Bristol DFS This Week
Noah Gragson6 days ago

Should DFS Players Consider Noah Gragson For Bristol Lineups?
Riley Herbst6 days ago

Is In Play For Bristol DFS Lineups
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF