Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 12? D'Andre Swift, Justice Hill, Zach Charbonnet

Who should I start for Week 12? Fantasy football outlooks for D'Andre Swift, Justice Hill, Zach Charbonnet. Our expert fantasy football start 'em, sit 'em picks.

Week 12 is shaping up to be one of the toughest weeks of the fantasy football season, with six teams on bye and rosters stretched to the limit. Success this week will hinge on finding value in players who might not typically make your starting lineup but have the potential to step up when it matters most. It’s all about maximizing matchups and uncovering those hidden gems that could make a difference.

This week, we’re focusing on D'Andre Swift, Justice Hill, and Zach Charbonnet—three running backs in very different situations but with intriguing potential for Week 12. Whether Swift’s dynamic dual-threat ability, Hill’s role as a pass-catching weapon, or Charbonnet’s upside despite limited touches, each brings a mix of risk and reward that fantasy managers need to weigh carefully heading into this crucial slate of games.

With so many reliable options unavailable this week, balancing consistency with upside is the key. Swift, Hill, and Charbonnet each offer unique paths to fantasy production depending on your league format and roster needs. Whether you’re fighting for a playoff spot or solidifying your dominance, let’s dive into what these three backs bring to the table for Week 12.

Should I Start D'Andre Swift for Fantasy Football?

D’Andre Swift’s grip on the Bears’ backfield appears to be slipping. According to Derek Brown of FantasyPros, last week, Swift played just 54% of the snaps and handled 59% of the rushing plays but only 29% of the red zone work. Meanwhile, Roschon Johnson saw a 71% snap rate inside the red zone, and if that trend continues, it could spell trouble for Swift’s touchdown upside moving forward.

Despite these concerns, Swift is still the RB19 in fantasy, averaging 18.3 touches and 87.8 total yards per game. In Week 11, he posted a solid 16 touches for 84 total yards.

Giants WR Malik Nabers (groin), Bears RB D’Andre Swift (groin) and Bears WR Keenan Allen (ankle) – all of whom are listed as questionable – all have said they plan to play Sunday.

— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) November 24, 2024

Given the other two running backs in this article, Swift is probably still the best pick of the three for fantasy in Week 12.

Should I Start Justice Hill for Fantasy Football?

Justice Hill suffered a concussion and couldn't suit up for practice on Thursday of this week. He's got some serious pass-catching chops, but given the fact this is Derrick Henry's backfield, Hill's upside remains limited.

Ravens RB Justice Hill is currently the #1 ranked receiving back in the league, per PFF.

Through 11 weeks:
- 31 targets
- 30 receptions
- 300 receiving yards
- 9.7 yards per reception
- 2 TD pic.twitter.com/HseQJXKqOx

— Ravens Nation 𝙇𝙄𝙑𝙀 (@LIVERavenNation) November 22, 2024

Hill has seen double-digit touches in just one game this season. He is a valuable handcuff but nothing more in fantasy at this stage.

Should I Start Zach Charbonnet for Fantasy Football?

Zach Charbonnet has seen the Seattle Seahawks backfield completely taken over by fellow teammate Kenneth Walker III. Despite the two backs having nearly similar draft capital, KWIII is clearly the lead back in Seattle.

🏈NFL Week 12 Play

Kenneth Walker O 62.5 Rush Yds
(-110)

Walker has not been his most efficient self this year but the OL is getting healthier and he loves facing this team.

He’s over in each of his last 4 games facing them head to head. This team still struggles facing the… pic.twitter.com/L8obYt58IJ

— GOATEDGambler77🐐 (@GGambler77) November 24, 2024

Charbs saw double-digit touches twice in Weeks 2-3 while KWIII was sidelined, but since Week 10, he's largely taken a backseat. "Charbs" hasn't seen double-digit touches in a game since Week 3 of the 2024 NFL season and remains nothing more than a handcuff at this point. Despite the uncertainty, Swift is guaranteed to see the most touches of the three backs in Week 12. Always follow the volume.

Popular Week 12 Searches - Start/Sit Comparisons

Below are some popular Week 12 searches and comparisons from our Who To Start tool for D'Andre Swift, Justice Hall, Zach Charbonnet compared to others. You can also use the free Who Should I Start tool to run your own start/sit comparisons, up to four players at once:

Najee Harris or Dandre Swift
Bucky Irving or Dandre Swift
Chuba Hubbard or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Rachaad White
Aaron Jones or Dandre Swift
Zach Charbonnet or Justice Hill
Dandre Swift or Austin Ekeler
Dandre Swift or Kareem Hunt
Jauan Jennings or Dandre Swift
Rhamondre Stevenson or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Bucky Irving
Dandre Swift or Najee Harris
Dandre Swift or Tony Pollard
Dandre Swift or Javonte Williams
Tyrone Tracyjr or Dandre Swift
Roschon Johnson or Zach Charbonnet
Audric Estime or Zach Charbonnet
Zach Charbonnet or Audric Estime
Zach Charbonnet or Cam Akers
Cedric Tillman or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Calvin Ridley
Nick Chubb or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Cedric Tillman
Dandre Swift or Jk Dobbins
Dandre Swift or Tyrone Tracyjr
Brian Robinsonjr or Dandre Swift
Kareem Hunt or Dandre Swift
Raheem Mostert or Zach Charbonnet
Devin Singletary or Zach Charbonnet
Audric Estime or Zach Charbonnet
Austin Ekeler or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Chuba Hubbard
Dandre Swift or Jonathan Taylor
Dandre Swift or Rhamondre Stevenson
Dandre Swift or Terry McLaurin
DeAndre Hopkins or Dandre Swift
Gus Edwards or Zach Charbonnet
Jaylen Warren or Zach Charbonnet
Jk Dobbins or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Marvin Harrisonjr
Dandre Swift or Travis Etiennejr
Kyren Williams or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Courtland Sutton
Dandre Swift or DJ Moore
Dandre Swift or Jameson Williams
Dandre Swift or Jerry Jeudy
Dandre Swift or Jk Dobbins
Dandre Swift or Ladd McConkey
Dandre Swift or Nick Chubb
Dandre Swift or Quentin Johnston
Justice Hill or Zach Charbonnet
Zach Charbonnet or Ameer Abdullah
Alexander Mattison or Zach Charbonnet
Calvin Ridley or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Brian Robinsonjr
Dandre Swift or DeVonta Smith
Devonta Smith or Dandre Swift
Jaxon Smithnjigba or Dandre Swift
Josh Downs or Dandre Swift
Ladd Mcconkey or Dandre Swift
Marvin Harrisonjr or Dandre Swift
Tony Pollard or Dandre Swift
Zach Charbonnet or Roschon Johnson
Zay Flowers or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or James Conner
Dandre Swift or Josh Jacobs
Dandre Swift or Mike Evans
Dandre Swift or Rico Dowdle
James Conner or Dandre Swift
Jerome Ford or Zach Charbonnet
Tj Hockenson or Dandre Swift
Trey Benson or Zach Charbonnet
Tyrone Tracyjr or Dandre Swift
Zach Charbonnet or Jerome Ford
Zach Charbonnet or Trey Benson
Cam Akers or Zach Charbonnet
CeeDee Lamb or Dandre Swift
Courtland Sutton or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Austin Ekeler
Dandre Swift or Breece Hall
Dandre Swift or David Montgomery
Dandre Swift or George Pickens
Dandre Swift or Josh Downs
Dandre Swift or Michael Pittmanjr
Dandre Swift or Quentin Johnston
Dandre Swift or Roschon Johnson
Dandre Swift or Tony Pollard
Dandre Swift or Trey McBride
DK Metcalf or Dandre Swift
Jayden Reed or Dandre Swift
Nick Chubb or Zach Charbonnet
Rhamondre Stevenson or Dandre Swift
Rome Odunze or Zach Charbonnet
Roschon Johnson or Zach Charbonnet
Tank Dell or Dandre Swift
Zach Charbonnet or Cam Akers
Zach Charbonnet or Jonathon Brooks
Zach Charbonnet or Trey Benson
Aaron Jones or Dandre Swift
Audric Estime or Zach Charbonnet
Audric Estime or Zach Charbonnet
Bucky Irving or Dandre Swift
Cam Akers or Dandre Swift
Chuba Hubbard or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Aaron Jones
Dandre Swift or Aaron Jones
Dandre Swift or AJ Dillon
Dandre Swift or Audric Estime
Dandre Swift or Calvin Ridley
Dandre Swift or Cooper Kupp
Dandre Swift or Courtland Sutton
Dandre Swift or Deebo Samuel
Dandre Swift or Jahmyr Gibbs
Dandre Swift or Jamaal Williams
Dandre Swift or Jayden Reed
Dandre Swift or Jaylen Warren
Dandre Swift or Jaylen Warren
Dandre Swift or Jk Dobbins
Dandre Swift or Kareem Hunt
Dandre Swift or Kareem Hunt
Dandre Swift or Malik Nabers
Dandre Swift or Nico Collins
Dandre Swift or Noah Brown
Dandre Swift or Rome Odunze
Dandre Swift or Tony Pollard
Dandre Swift or Tyrone Tracy
Dandre Swift or Wandale Robinson
Dandre Swift or Xavier Worthy
Dandre Swift or Zach Ertz
Dandre Swift or Zach Ertz
Deebo Samuelsr or Dandre Swift
Devon Achane or Dandre Swift
Jameson Williams or Dandre Swift
Jaylen Waddle or Dandre Swift
Jaylen Warren or Dandre Swift
Jaylen Warren or Zach Charbonnet
Jk Dobbins or Dandre Swift
Joe Mixon or Dandre Swift
Jonathon Brooks or Dandre Swift
Kareem Hunt or Zach Charbonnet
Kayshon Boutte or Zach Charbonnet
Kyren Williams or Dandre Swift
Ladd Mcconkey or Dandre Swift
Malik Nabers or Dandre Swift
Nick Chubb or Dandre Swift
Quentin Johnston or Zach Charbonnet
Rachaad White or Dandre Swift
Rhamondre Stevenson or Zach Charbonnet
Rico Dowdle or Dandre Swift
Tony Pollard or Dandre Swift
Tyjae Spears or Zach Charbonnet
Tyrone Tracyjr or Dandre Swift
Tyrone Tracyjr or Dandre Swift
Tyrone Tracyjr or Dandre Swift
Zach Charbonnet or Jaylen Warren
Zach Charbonnet or Rachaad White
Zach Charbonnet or Raheem Mostert
Zach Charbonnet or Ty Chandler
Zach Charbonnet or Tyjae Spears
Aaron Jones or Dandre Swift
Aaron Jones or Dandre Swift
Alexander Mattison or Dandre Swift
Ameer Abdullah or Zach Charbonnet
Anthony Richardson or Zach Charbonnet
Audric Estime or Zach Charbonnet
Breece Hall or Dandre Swift
Brian Robinsonjr or Dandre Swift
Brock Bowers or Dandre Swift
Bucky Irving or Dandre Swift
Bucky Irving or Dandre Swift
Bucky Irving or Zach Charbonnet
Cade Otton or Dandre Swift
Calvin Ridley or Dandre Swift
Cedric Tillman or Dandre Swift
Cedric Tillman or Dandre Swift
Cedric Tillman or Dandre Swift
Cedric Tillman or Dandre Swift
Chris Olave or Dandre Swift
Christian McCaffrey or Dandre Swift
Chuba Hubbard or Dandre Swift
Cooper Kupp or Dandre Swift
Cooper Rush or Dandre Swift
Dandre Swift or Alexander Mattison
Dandre Swift or Audric Estime
Dandre Swift or Brian Robinsonjr
Dandre Swift or Bucky Irving
Dandre Swift or Bucky Irving
Dandre Swift or Bucky Irving
Dandre Swift or Bucky Irving
Dandre Swift or Bucky Irving
Dandre Swift or Bucky Irving
Dandre Swift or Bucky Irving
Dandre Swift or Cade Otton
Dandre Swift or Calvin Ridley
Dandre Swift or Cedric Tillman
Dandre Swift or Cedric Tillman
Dandre Swift or Chuba Hubbard
Dandre Swift or Chuba Hubbard
Dandre Swift or Chuba Hubbard
Dandre Swift or Chuba Hubbard
Dandre Swift or Chuba Hubbard
Dandre Swift or Courtland Sutton
Dandre Swift or David Montgomery
Dandre Swift or David Njoku
Dandre Swift or Dj Moore
Dandre Swift or Dj Moore
Dandre Swift or Dj Moore
Dandre Swift or Dk Metcalf
Dandre Swift or Isiah Pacheco
Dandre Swift or Jakobi Meyers
Dandre Swift or Jauan Jennings
Dandre Swift or Jauan Jennings
Dandre Swift or Jayden Reed
Dandre Swift or Jayden Reed
Dandre Swift or Jaylen Waddle
Dandre Swift or Jaylen Warren
Dandre Swift or Jaylen Warren
Dandre Swift or Jk Dobbins
Dandre Swift or Jk Dobbins
Dandre Swift or Jk Dobbins
Dandre Swift or Jk Dobbins
Dandre Swift or Jk Dobbins
Dandre Swift or Jonathan Taylor
Dandre Swift or Jonathon Brooks
Dandre Swift or Josh Downs
Dandre Swift or Josh Jacobs
Dandre Swift or Kareem Hunt
Dandre Swift or Kareem Hunt
Dandre Swift or Kareem Hunt
Dandre Swift or Kareem Hunt
Dandre Swift or Kyren Williams
Dandre Swift or Marvin Harrisonjr
Dandre Swift or Mike Evans
Dandre Swift or Najee Harris
Dandre Swift or Najee Harris
Dandre Swift or Najee Harris
Dandre Swift or Quentin Johnston
Dandre Swift or Quentin Johnston
Dandre Swift or Rachaad White
Dandre Swift or Rachaad White
Dandre Swift or Raheem Blackshear
Dandre Swift or Rhamondre Stevenson
Dandre Swift or Rhamondre Stevenson
Dandre Swift or Rome Odunze
Dandre Swift or Rome Odunze
Dandre Swift or Rome Odunze
Dandre Swift or Roschon Johnson
Dandre Swift or Roschon Johnson
Dandre Swift or Tank Dell
Dandre Swift or Tank Dell
Dandre Swift or Tee Higgins
Dandre Swift or Tony Pollard
Dandre Swift or Tony Pollard
Dandre Swift or Tony Pollard
Dandre Swift or Tony Pollard
Dandre Swift or Tony Pollard
Dandre Swift or Travis Kelce
Dandre Swift or Tyjae Spears
Dandre Swift or Zach Charbonnet
Dandre Swift or Zack Moss
Dandre Swift or Zamir White
Dandre Swift or Zay Flowers
Darius Slayton or Zach Charbonnet
Davante Adams or Dandre Swift
Deebo Samuelsr or Dandre Swift
Devon Achane or Dandre Swift
Devon Achane or Zach Charbonnet
Devonta Smith or Dandre Swift
Devonta Smith or Dandre Swift
Devonta Smith or Dandre Swift
Devonta Smith or Dandre Swift
George Kittle or Dandre Swift
George Kittle or Dandre Swift
George Kittle or Dandre Swift
Isaiah Likely or Zach Charbonnet
Isiah Pacheco or Zach Charbonnet
Jake Moody or Dandre Swift
Jakobi Meyers or Dandre Swift
Jalen Tolbert or Zach Charbonnet
James Conner or Dandre Swift
Jameson Williams or Zach Charbonnet
Jauan Jennings or Dandre Swift
Javonte Williams or Dandre Swift
Jaylen Waddle or Zach Charbonnet
Jerome Ford or Dandre Swift
Jerome Ford or Zach Charbonnet
Jerry Jeudy or Dandre Swift
Jk Dobbins or Dandre Swift
Jk Dobbins or Dandre Swift
Jk Dobbins or Dandre Swift
Jk Dobbins or Dandre Swift
Jk Dobbins or Dandre Swift
Joe Mixon or Dandre Swift
Jonathan Taylor or Dandre Swift
Jonathan Taylor or Dandre Swift
Jonathan Taylor or Dandre Swift
Jonathan Taylor or Dandre Swift
Jonathan Taylor or Zach Charbonnet
Jonathon Brooks or Zach Charbonnet
Jonnu Smith or Dandre Swift
Jordan Addison or Zach Charbonnet
Josh Jacobs or Zach Charbonnet
Kareem Hunt or Dandre Swift
Kenneth Gainwell or Zach Charbonnet
Kenneth Walkeriii or Dandre Swift
Ladd Mcconkey or Dandre Swift
Michael Pittmanjr or Zach Charbonnet
Michael Wilson or Zach Charbonnet
Najee Harris or Dandre Swift
Najee Harris or Dandre Swift
Najee Harris or Dandre Swift
Najee Harris or Zach Charbonnet
Nick Chubb or Dandre Swift
Rhamondre Stevenson or Dandre Swift
Rome Odunze or Dandre Swift
Rome Odunze or Dandre Swift
Romeo Doubs or Zach Charbonnet
Roschon Johnson or Zach Charbonnet
Tank Dell or Zach Charbonnet
Terry Mclaurin or Dandre Swift
Tony Pollard or Dandre Swift
Tony Pollard or Zach Charbonnet
Trey Benson or Zach Charbonnet
Trey Benson or Zach Charbonnet
Trey Benson or Zach Charbonnet
Trey Mcbride or Dandre Swift
Tyjae Spears or Dandre Swift
Tyler Allgeier or Zach Charbonnet
Tyrone Tracyjr or Dandre Swift
Tyrone Tracyjr or Dandre Swift
Tyrone Tracyjr or Dandre Swift
Xavier Legette or Zach Charbonnet
Zach Charbonnet or Audric Estime
Zach Charbonnet or Bucky Irving
Zach Charbonnet or Cooper Rush
Zach Charbonnet or Denver Broncos
Zach Charbonnet or Devin Singletary
Zach Charbonnet or Devin Singletary
Zach Charbonnet or Devin Singletary
Zach Charbonnet or Drake Maye
Zach Charbonnet or Gus Edwards
Zach Charbonnet or Javonte Williams
Zach Charbonnet or Jaylen Warren
Zach Charbonnet or Jerome Ford
Zach Charbonnet or Jordan Mason
Zach Charbonnet or Michael Pittmanjr
Zach Charbonnet or Najee Harris
Zach Charbonnet or Nick Westbrook
Zach Charbonnet or Rashod Bateman
Zach Charbonnet or Rhamondre Stevenson
Zach Charbonnet or Rome Odunze
Zach Charbonnet or Roschon Johnson
Zach Charbonnet or Roschon Johnson
Zach Charbonnet or Sterling Shepard
Zach Charbonnet or Sterling Shepard
Zach Charbonnet or Tony Pollard
Zach Charbonnet or Tyler Lockett
Zach Charbonnet or Will Dissly
Zach Charbonnet or Xavier Legette
David Montgomery or Dandre Swift

More Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks

Fact or Fiction: Fantasy Football Outlooks for Drake Maye, Javonte Williams, Rome Odunze, Hunter Renfrow, Brock Wright

Welcome back to our fantasy football series Fact of Fiction as we head into Week 3 of the NFL season. Week 2 of the NFL season is behind us, and we saw a few surprising performances last week, like Patriots quarterback Drake Maye finishing as a top-5 fantasy QB. Is this the start of something […]

Justin Carter September 17, 2025

RJ Harvey - Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks for Week 3 (2025)

BALLER MOVE: Start in 12-14 Team Leagues POSITIONAL VALUE: Low-end RB3/FLEX ANALYSIS: Denver Broncos rookie running back RJ Harvey has had a slow start to his NFL career. After competing for the starting job alongside veteran J.K. Dobbins during training camp, the coaching staff has opted to lean on the more experienced back through the opening […]

Andy Smith September 16, 2025

TreVeyon Henderson - Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks for Week 3 (2025)

BALLER MOVE: Start in 12+ Team Leagues POSITIONAL VALUE: Low-end RB3/FLEX ANALYSIS: The New England Patriots bolstered their running back room in the second round of the draft by selecting top prospect TreVeyon Henderson out of Ohio State. While the former Buckeye flashed immense upside during the preseason, Henderson has seen his workload monitored during […]

Andy Smith September 16, 2025

Courtland Sutton - Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks for Week 2 (2025)

BALLER MOVE: Start in all leagues POSITIONAL VALUE: Upside WR2 ANALYSIS: Denver Broncos wide receiver Courtland Sutton was one of the few bright spots in the Denver offense this weekend. Despite picking up the victory over the Tennessee Titans, the Broncos struggled to find much rhythm in the passing game. However, Sutton was still able […]

Andy Smith September 14, 2025

Michael Pittman Jr. - Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks for Week 2 (2025)

BALLER MOVE: Start in 12+ team leagues POSITIONAL VALUE: WR3/FLEX ANALYSIS: The Indianapolis Colts enjoyed an impressive start to the 2025 season. In their Week 1 victory, their offense, led by former Giants QB Daniel Jones, looked unstoppable as they scored 33 points against the Dolphins. During this contest, top wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr. […]

Andy Smith September 14, 2025