X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

Incorporating a Shift Ban into Hitter Projections

Max Muncy - Fantasy Baseball Rankings, Draft Sleepers, MLB Injury News

With the announcement of a likely shift ban in 2023, fantasy baseball analysts ought to prepare.

Many good articles have been written about the shift ban recently, with most echoing the sentiment that the leaguewide impact will be modest. Further, it is conventional wisdom that pull-heavy lefthanders would benefit the most.

However, the size of the impact has yet to be estimated for particular players. This article aims to fill that gap.

Be sure to check all of our fantasy baseball draft tools and resources:

 

Previous Research on the Shift

In this article, the shift refers to a defensive alignment where three or more infielders are on one side of second base (other strategic shifts are ignored). A rigorous approach to measuring the impact of the shift, popularized by MLBAM Senior Data Architect, Tom Tango, is to first separate batters by handedness, then find each batter's wOBA with and without the shift when the bases are empty. Then, find the average effect of the shift on wOBA, weighting each batter's wOBA difference by plate appearances, either using the harmonized mean of plate appearances with and without the shift, or using plate appearances with or without the shift, whichever number is smaller.

I did this for 2015 to 2020 using Baseball Savant's Statcast Search, finding the bases empty shift hurts left-handed bats by 13 wOBA points on average relative to a standard defensive alignment (Tango found a 15 point effect in the same direction in a slightly different sample, capturing 2015 to the first half of 2020). One can take this method a step further and control for opposing pitcher, as Tango does, looking at the wOBA difference with and without the shift for each batter-pitcher matchup.

After controlling for pitcher, he finds a larger negative effect of the shift on left-handed bats of 24 wOBA points over the same sample. Alternatively, the shift does not appear to work against right-handed hitters. In the same sample as above, Tango finds the shift improves right-handed hitter production by 30 to 38 wOBA points. The right-handed hitter shift would likely 'ban' itself as more teams realize this.

Sam Sharpe continues Tango's work on researching the shift, finding a negative effect of 22 wOBA points against left-handed hitters across all base states (not just bases empty).

 

Incorporating Previous Research into wOBA Projections

To get a decent approximation of how banning the shift might impact each left-handed bat, I projected every left-handed hitter's wOBA with and without a hypothetical shift ban. Following a simple MARCEL approach, the projection captures the last four years of wOBA performance, weighted 5/4/3/2, from most to least recent season. It also adds 1,200 PA of regression to the mean (the mean is set at .317 wOBA). The "current" wOBA projection does not adjust for the shift ban.

To adjust each player's wOBA to account for a shift ban, I produced a second wOBA projection that adds 22 points to their historical wOBA in shifted PA (I took this number from Sharpe's study, which looks at the wOBA effect across all base states). Finally, I looked at the difference between each hitter's projected wOBA with and without the shift-ban adjustment. To get a rough idea of how much the shift ban would impact fantasy value, I used data from the FanGraphs auction calculator (default settings) to find that one additional point of projected wOBA improves a hitter's projected hitter rank by 1.5 spots (wOBA is not itself a category in standard formats, but as an all-in-one measure of offense, more wOBA is tantamount to more offensive production in the categories that do matter).

The table below shows the projections and improvement in hitter rank after incorporating the shift-ban adjustment.

As readers might have guessed, Joey Gallo is the biggest projected winner, though a lot of big names stand to benefit. Further, the benefits are neither massive nor trivial, with Gallo jumping 27 spots in projected hitter rank.

A weakness of the approach in this article is that it assumes each left-handed hitter is hurt by the same 22 wOBA points in their shifted plate appearances. This is an approximation, though probably a pretty decent one, as there is a lot of noise in looking at wOBA with versus without the shift for particular players. For instance, the table below shows a .003 correlation between hitter shift effects in adjacent seasons.

Further, depending on the form of the shift ban, these wOBA improvements may be overstated, as teams shift the third baseman and shortstop as close to second base as the new rules allow them to. These weaknesses leave room for future research.



Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy baseball app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, sleepers, prospects & more. All free!



More Fantasy Baseball Advice




POPULAR FANTASY TOOLS

Expert Advice
Articles & Tools
Import Your Leagues
Draft Rankings
Draft Simulator
Enter League Settings
Compare Any Players
Rookies & Call-Ups
24x7 News and Alerts

REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Precious Achiuwa11 mins ago

Out On Thursday
Mitchell Robinson16 mins ago

Active Against Lakers
OG Anunoby20 mins ago

Ready To Take On Lakers
Jordan Mason26 mins ago

Drawing Trade Interest
Alec Burks30 mins ago

Questionable For Friday Due To Back Issue
Jaime Jaquez Jr.35 mins ago

Questionable To Play On Friday
Kel'el Ware40 mins ago

Not Ready To Return Against Minnesota
Brandon Aiyuk41 mins ago

49ers Unlikely To Trade Brandon Aiyuk?
Andrew Wiggins46 mins ago

Iffy For Friday's Game
Sam Darnold50 mins ago

Vikings Continue To Want Sam Darnold Back
Tyler Herro52 mins ago

Considered Questionable For Friday
DK Metcalf58 mins ago

Seahawks Talking To A "Ton Of Teams" About DK Metcalf
Austin Reaves59 mins ago

Good To Go Thursday
Ben Simmons1 hour ago

Remains Out On Friday
Luka Dončić1 hour ago

Luka Doncic Upgraded To Available Thursday
Washington Commanders1 hour ago

Commanders Re-Sign Bobby Wagner
Derrick Jones Jr.1 hour ago

Returning On Friday
LeBron James1 hour ago

Cleared To Play Thursday
Kawhi Leonard1 hour ago

Available For Friday
Rudy Gobert1 hour ago

Questionable For Friday's Game
Zeke Nnaji1 hour ago

Expected To Play On Friday
Mike Conley1 hour ago

Ready To Return Friday
Aaron Gordon1 hour ago

Could Miss Friday's Game
Nikola Jokić2 hours ago

Nikola Jokic Uncertain For Friday
Bradley Beal2 hours ago

Tagged As Questionable For Friday
Karl-Anthony Towns2 hours ago

Available Thursday
Oscar Colás2 hours ago

Oscar Colas Exits On Thursday With Wrist Injury
Sean Reid-Foley2 hours ago

Clears Waivers
Carlos Estévez3 hours ago

Carlos Estevez Throws "Best" Bullpen Session
Alec Marsh3 hours ago

Facing Live Hitters On Sunday
Salvador Perez3 hours ago

Set To Return To Lineup On Friday
Evan Engram3 hours ago

Jaguars Release Evan Engram
Tyler O'Neill4 hours ago

Scratched With Rib-Cage Soreness
Curtis Mead4 hours ago

On A Tear In Spring Training
Dougie Hamilton4 hours ago

Remains Under Evaluation
Taylor Ward4 hours ago

Back In Thursday's Spring Lineup
Mattias Ekholm4 hours ago

John Klingberg Out Against Canadiens
Tyler Naquin4 hours ago

Guardians Re-Sign Tyler Naquin As A Pitcher
Brandon Tanev4 hours ago

Will Not Play On Thursday
Atlanta Falcons5 hours ago

Nate Landman Won't Receive Tender Offer From Falcons
Colton Parayko5 hours ago

To Miss Rest Of Regular Season
Cincinnati Bengals5 hours ago

Bengals Grant Trey Hendrickson Permission To Seek A Trade
Nico Sturm5 hours ago

Picked Up By Panthers
Christian Kirk5 hours ago

Texans Acquiring Christian Kirk From The Jaguars
Reilly Smith5 hours ago

Returns To Vegas
Jack Leiter5 hours ago

Showing Increased Velocity
Sean Burke5 hours ago

Expected To Be Part Of Rotation?
Junior Caminero5 hours ago

Probably "Day-To-Day"
Justin Steele5 hours ago

Scratched With Illness
Jac Caglianone6 hours ago

Could Play Outfield To Accelerate His MLB Debut
Grayson Rodriguez6 hours ago

Dealing With Triceps Soreness
Zebby Matthews6 hours ago

Leaves Outing On Thursday With Injury
Jordan Westburg6 hours ago

Returns To Spring Lineup
Seattle Seahawks7 hours ago

Seahawks Re-Sign Josh Jobe
Junior Caminero7 hours ago

Leaves Early With Back Tightness
Atlanta Falcons7 hours ago

Cornerback Dee Alford Will Hit The Open Market
Cristopher Sánchez7 hours ago

Cristopher Sanchez Adds Cutter, Throwing Harder
Minnesota Vikings7 hours ago

Theo Jackson Agrees To Two-Year Extension With Vikings
Tennessee Titans7 hours ago

Mike McCoy Joins Titans Coaching Staff
Sandy Alcantara7 hours ago

Will Be On Innings Limit Early On
Buffalo Bills7 hours ago

Mitch Morse Announces Retirement After 10 Seasons
Durham Smythe7 hours ago

Bears Officially Sign Durham Smythe
Matt McLain8 hours ago

Generating Buzz In Camp
Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen8 hours ago

Starting on Thursday
Mackenzie Blackwood8 hours ago

Facing Former Team On Thursday
Pittsburgh Steelers8 hours ago

Steelers, Cole Holcomb Agree To Revised Contract
Josh Manson8 hours ago

Returning On Thursday
Zane Gonzalez9 hours ago

Commanders Re-Sign Zane Gonzalez
Jason Zucker9 hours ago

Not Playing On Thursday
Michael Bunting9 hours ago

Not Expected To Play This Weekend
Brian Dumoulin9 hours ago

Traded To New Jersey
Tutu Atwell10 hours ago

Back With Rams On One-Year Deal
Tommy DeVito11 hours ago

To Sign His Tender This Weekend
Tee Higgins11 hours ago

Bengals Telling Teams Tee Higgins Isn't Available Via Trade
Deshaun Watson12 hours ago

Browns Restructure Deshaun Watson's Deal, Clear $35.8 Million In Cap Space
Vincent Desharnais15 hours ago

Shipped To San Jose
Adin Hill15 hours ago

Extends Winning Streak To Four Games
Luke Schenn15 hours ago

Thomas Novak, Luke Schenn Traded To Pittsburgh
Michael Bunting15 hours ago

Traded To Nashville
John Gibson15 hours ago

Exits Early On Wednesday
Thomas Chabot15 hours ago

Exits With Illness
Mattias Ekholm1 day ago

Iffy For Thursday Due To Illness
Steven Lorentz1 day ago

Back In Action Wednesday
Oliver Bjorkstrand1 day ago

Lightning Acquire Oliver Bjorkstrand
Sahith Theegala1 day ago

Looking To Keep Spark From Last Event Alive At Bay Hill
Robert MacIntyre1 day ago

An Interesting Play At Arnold Palmer Invitational
Max Homa1 day ago

Hoping His Course History At Bay Hill Can Help Turn Season Around
Tommy Fleetwood1 day ago

Looking To Get Back Into Good Graces At Bay Hill
Michael Kim1 day ago

One Of The Hottest Players In Golf Heading To Bay Hill
Xander Schauffele1 day ago

Making Long-Awaited Start Since Rib Injury At Bay Hill
Sepp Straka1 day ago

Needs Accuracy At Arnold Palmer Invitational
Collin Morikawa1 day ago

Looking For Better Form On And Around The Greens At Bay Hill
Justin Rose1 day ago

May Be Worth Avoiding This Week
Maverick McNealy1 day ago

Tries To Go One Step Further At Bay Hill
Shane Lowry1 day ago

Has Potential To Contend At Bay Hill
PGA1 day ago

Sungjae Im Trying To Snap Out Of Golfing Funk
Jacob Bridgeman1 day ago

Looking To Build Off Momentum At Arnold Palmer Invitational
Joe Highsmith1 day ago

Steps Up After Cognizant Classic Win
Max Greyserman1 day ago

Be Wary Of Max Greyserman At Bay Hill
Davis Thompson2 days ago

Very Iffy For Arnold Palmer Invitational
Tony Finau2 days ago

And Bay Hill Could Be A Battle
Cam Davis2 days ago

A Question Mark Heading To Arnold Palmer
Sam Burns2 days ago

Could Stick Around At Arnold Palmer
J.J. Spaun2 days ago

Could See Success At Bay Hill
PGA2 days ago

Byeong Hun An Seeks Answers And May Not Find Any
MMA3 days ago

Asu Almbayev Gets TKO'd At UFC Vegas 103
Manel Kape3 days ago

Gets TKO Win At UFC Vegas 103
Julian Marquez3 days ago

Loses Fourth Fight In A Row
Kyle Busch3 days ago

Falls Short Of Victory At COTA While Finishing Fifth
Kyle Larson3 days ago

Has A Day To Forget At COTA On Sunday
Cody Brundage3 days ago

Gets Back In The Win Column
Tyler Reddick3 days ago

Continues His Top-10 Streak At COTA With Third-Place Finish
NASCAR3 days ago

Bubba Wallace Has An Eventful Day At COTA That Ends In 20th-Place Finish
Esteban Ribovics3 days ago

Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 103
Noah Gragson3 days ago

Scores His First Career Road Course Top-10 Finish At COTA
Nasrat Haqparast3 days ago

Extends Win Streak At UFC Vegas 103
William Gomis3 days ago

Takes Split-Decision Loss
Hyder Amil3 days ago

Remains Undefeated
Sam Patterson4 days ago

Extends Win Streak To Three
Danny Barlow4 days ago

Suffers First Career Loss At UFC Vegas 103
Christopher Bell4 days ago

Wins At COTA, Ready To Keep Adding To It
Chris Buescher4 days ago

Finishes Seventh At COTA, Sees Room For Improvement
Todd Gilliland4 days ago

Nabs First Top-10 Finish Of Season After Bumpy COTA Race
Chase Elliott4 days ago

Recovers From Lap 1 Spinout To Finish Fourth
William Byron4 days ago

In Battle Between Last Two Race Winners, William Byron Comes Up Short
Shane Van Gisbergen4 days ago

Shane van Gisbergen Dominates First Two Stages But Fades In Third Stage
AJ Allmendinger4 days ago

A.J. Allmendinger Runs Well At Austin Until Late-Race Collapse
Alex Bowman4 days ago

Recovers From COTA Penalty To Finish Ninth
Tyler Reddick5 days ago

Wins Pole At COTA, Looking To Become First Repeat Winner
Chase Elliott5 days ago

Will Be A Top Threat For The Win At COTA
Shane Van Gisbergen5 days ago

Shane van Gisbergen the Favorite to Win at COTA
Kyle Larson5 days ago

Is One Of The Top Favorites To Win At COTA
Christopher Bell5 days ago

Will Be A Fantastic DFS Play For COTA Lineups
AJ Allmendinger5 days ago

Struggling At COTA Despite Strong Practice Speeds
Austin Cindric5 days ago

Is One Of The Top DFS Recommendations For COTA Lineups
Connor Zilisch5 days ago

Making Cup Series Debut This Weekend
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF