Sean Manaea 2025 Outlook: Boring Innings Eater: Nothing More, but Nothing Less
4 mins agoSean Manaea had one of his best seasons as a 31-year-old Met, going 12-6 with a 3.47 ERA over 181⅔ IP. His ERA estimators weren't quite as strong (4.04 xFIP, 3.75 xERA), and his 24.9% K% and 8.5% BB% were fine but slight regressions from 2023's 25.7% K% and 8.4% BB%. Manaea completely reinvented his pitch mix, throwing a new cutter 7.1% of the time and sinker 44.7% of the time instead of fastballs (56.2% in 2023, 11.3% last year) and changeups (17% to 11.8%). The resulting five-pitch mix lacks strikeout upside, especially since Manaea deemphasized his fastball's repertoire-leading 15.6% SwStr%. He'll also need his defense to keep his BABIP down (.245 last year, .284 career). The Mets overpaid to bring him back into the fold with a three-year, $75 million contract, but fantasy managers don't need to at an ADP of 184.95. Manaea is a safe choice for innings but a poor pick for upside, so your roster construction determines whether you should select him.