👉 TAP TO SAVE 50% WITH CODE SPRING
X
Lost password?

Don't have an account?
Gain Access Now

X

Receive free daily analysis

NFL
NBA
NHL
NASCAR
CFB
MLB
MMA
PGA
ESPORTS
BETTING

Already have an account? Log In

X

Forgot Password


Champ or Chump: What to Make of Pomeranz, Beltran, and Lucroy

The non-waiver trade deadline has officially passed, and baseball fans were treated to a number of last second deals. Unfortunately for my purposes, most of them are RPs that I evaluate by whether they get saves. Washington's Mark Melancon and Chicago's Aroldis Chapman earn Champ tags from me as they figure to continue earning saves.

Chumps include Texas's Jeremy Jeffress, new Yankee Tyler Clippard, and Chicago's Joe Smith, all of whom had at least a share of saves before being dealt. Andrew Miller fits in here as well, as he is looking at the short side of a platoon with incumbent Cody Allen at best. I know that elite RPs can "improve your ratios," but their IP totals are so small that one bad outing can ruin all of the good they do. With so much volatility and few wins or saves, I'd rather stream SPs. A few non-bullpen pieces were also moved, and three such AL players are below. I'll hit the NL next week. For now, let's take a closer look at Drew Pomeranz, Carlos Beltran, and Jonathan Lucroy.

Editor's Note: RotoBaller offers the best Premium MLB Subscription - only $14.99 for the rest of season (plus playoffs), or less than 25 cents a day. All the tools you need to help win your seasonal and daily leagues: daily DFS Cheat Sheets, Lineup Picks, Expert Lineups, Stacks and Avoids. Plus advanced tools for Hitter & Pitcher Streamers, Matchup Ratings, and Under-the-Radar Surgers for AVG, HR, Ks, plus

 

The Fantasy Jury Is Out

Drew Pomeranz (SP, BOS)

The owner of a 3.09 ERA and 27% K%, Pomeranz has been a revelation for the San Diego Padres Notebook" href="http://www.rotoballer.com/mlb-fantasy-news/?team=SD">Padres and fantasy owners alike this season. The Padres flipped him to Boston, which figures to provide the run support to drastically improve his current 8-9 record. Good move for fantasy owners, right?

A peek under the hood reveals a 3.74 xFIP, suggesting that Pomeranz's shiny surface stats should not be trusted. His 79.3% strand rate is significantly higher than his career 73.1% mark, while a .253 BABIP seems low even for a guy with a history of suppressing BABIP (.273 career). Optimists may see the high K% as legitimizing the career best strand rate and blindly trust the pitcher's BABIP suppressing skills, but I wouldn't.

A 27% K% is great, and a great K% can certainly elevate strand rate. However, I do not trust the strikeouts to continue. Pomeranz's K% spike is rooted in a pitch selection change that cuts down on 4-seamers (58.5% last year to 35.7% this) in favor of more knucklecurves (30.7% to 40.1%) and a brand new changeup (1.2% to 9.6%). By SwStr%, the change (14.8%) and K-Curve (12.7%) are the best in Pomeranz's arsenal, so a K% uptick makes sense.

Neither offering is a true wipeout pitch, though. The SwStr% numbers are good not great, and their respective chase rates (33.3% and 31.3%) are nothing special. The heater's 9.4% SwStr% is good, but it was over 14% last year. 27% is an exceptional K%, but it is not backed by exceptional stuff. Regression to last year's good not great 23% rate seems likely, reducing some of Pomeranz's fantasy appeal.

The change in pitch selection also makes Pomeranz susceptible to the long ball. The new changeup boasts an excellent triple slash line against of .132/.250/.395, but is also allowing fly balls that clear the fence at a high rate (57.7% FB%, 20% HR/FB). This suggests that the pitch is still a work in progress despite some encouraging signs. The fastball's 46.8% FB% and 17.6% HR/FB also suggest that it can be hittable. Overall, Pomeranz has an 11.7% HR/FB that does not figure to improve in a hitter's park with AL rules.

Pomeranz has an ability to limit BABIP, some of which is reflected in an ability to limit LD% (19.1% career). His current 15.6% mark, however, seems too low to sustain even for him. His FB% against is steady relative to last year (36.3% last year to 36.9% this), but his IFFB% has declined significantly (17.4% to 11.7%). This suggests more well struck airborne contact, a recipe for the gopheritis described above. A lower than average BABIP should be expected going forward, but it will probably be higher than .253.

Pomeranz is also walking more guys this year, as last year's 8.7% rate has ballooned to 10.5%. This would be acceptable if the K% surge depended on an offering with a low Zone%, but Pomeranz lacks that type of pitch. Recency bias doesn't help Pomeranz in this regard either, as he walked six in his most recent start. I hate walks and Pomeranz issues a bunch.

In conclusion, Pomeranz is not as good as his surface stats suggest. The move to Boston should produce more Ws, but otherwise figures to hurt him due to the hitter friendly ballpark with a DH. He's rosterable in standard leagues, but miscast as anything more than a back end starter.

Verdict: Chump

 

Carlos Beltran (OF, TEX)

Beltran continues to age like a fine wine, compiling a .302/.341/.547 line with 23 dingers in his age 39 season. He has been solid in recent years, but his power had notably dropped off from his prime years. In fact, this is his first plus power season since 2012.

Beltran's 40.7% FB% is a slight decrease relative to last year's 42.9%, but remains high enough to support a strong HR pace. That's the good news. The bad is that his HR/FB has spiked to 18.7% after hovering around 11% since 2012. I can't find a reason Beltran can sustain this. He is pulling a good number of his flies (32.5%), a significant improvement over last year's 28.1% mark. However, he pulled a massive 36.4% of his flies in 2014 without recovering his vintage power numbers. His IFFB% has also surged from 7.6% last year to 12.2% this year, suggesting less authoritative airborne contact.

Beltran's strong batting average is also the result of a .318 BABIP that I'm not sure he can sustain. Both his grounders (.264) and liners (.776) are significantly overperforming their career averages (.244 and .711 respectively). The ground balls are particularly puzzling, as Beltran has clearly lost several steps from his prime. Optimists may point to positive regression for his current 19.2% LD% as a BABIP booster, but it is far from guaranteed with a career 19.8% rate.

On the bright side, Beltran is completely shift proof despite his power. He's hitting .347 against it versus .284 without it, and his 60.3% Pull% on ground balls is not too bad for a power bat. This suggests that Beltran can be expected to produce a league average BABIP, even if his current rate is mostly batted ball luck.

Beltran's floor is also aided by his destination, as Arlington should help him as much as Yankee Stadium did while the Rangers Notebook" href="http://www.rotoballer.com/mlb-fantasy-news/?team=TEX">Rangers support him with a stronger lineup. He's hit third in each game since the trade, suggesting that Beltran will retain his premium slot in the order. Furthermore, the team's roster construction allows Beltran to DH regularly, hopefully allowing his 39 year old body to withstand the rigors of the dog days of summer. I'm projecting declines for Beltran's average and power, but he should still be plenty usable in all formats as a solid bat with some pop and a great situation around him.

In terms of plate discipline, Beltran's 31.6% O-Swing% would be the worst of the slugger's borderline Hall of Fame career. It is still a league average mark, so it is not as if he's hopeless. His SwStr% is also up slightly (7.4% to 8.5%), but the drop off is entirely outside of the zone (70.6% O-Contact% last year, 66.5% this.) His Z-Contact% remains a robust 91%, allowing him to post a strong 18% K%.

Beltran has one of the best SB success rates in MLB history, but has not attempted to steal since 2014. His current line has benefited from both BABIP and HR/FB luck, but the regression should not be too steep. He'll remain a competent bat in a great hitting situation, accruing PAs as a DH while qualifying as an outfielder in all fantasy formats. I also love his style, so he gets a Champ tag.

Verdict: Champ

 

Jonathan Lucroy (C, TEX)

After universally disappointing owners with a .264/.326/.391 line with seven big flies in 415 PAs last year, Lucroy has returned to the elite with a .296/.357/.483 line, 14 homers, and five steals this year. I said he may not be traded last week, and he ends up traded twice, vetoing a deal to Cleveland before heading to Texas. Go figure.

It was probably a good move for him. Like Yankee Stadium, Miller Park is great for power hitters. Like Beltran, Lucroy isn't likely to miss it with his new Arlington address. Milwaukee's lineup gets ugly halfway through, but Texas is deep in quality offensive options. That depth impacts Lucroy more than Beltran, as he has hit sixth since the trade - a far cry from Beltran's coveted third slot. He should still generate his fair share of counting stats.

Lucroy's power disappeared last year due to a 29.4% FB%, only 14.1% of which were pulled. Lucroy's career FB% is a much healthier 35.6%, a number his current 36.9% closely resembles. His HR/FB has also improved to 13.6% from 7.6% last year. I'm usually skeptical of such spikes from established hitters, but Lucroy is pulling flies for the first time in his career.

His Pull% on flies is 26.2%, a substantial improvement over last year's mark and the 16.9% figure that preceded it. His career rate is 20.9%, propped up by numbers from earlier in his career. This change, coupled with the fact that a 13.6% HR/FB is really not that high for a guy with a bandbox home park, suggest to me that a 20+ home run pace can safely be expected moving forward.

I am a little more skeptical of Lucroy's batting average. His .335 BABIP seems very high for a catcher, as both his grounders (.264) and liners (.712) are performing better than usual (career .235 and .692, respectively). His 23.7% LD% also seems inflated, but Lucroy's career 22.8% mark and the fact that he has not posted a number worse than league average since 2010 suggest that a plus LD% is part of Lucroy's skill set. I expect a .315 BABIP or so moving forward.

Lucroy's K% has increased three years running, going from 10.8% in 2014 to 15.4% last year to 18.6% so far this season. The latest uptick is the result of a career worst 7.8% SwStr%, itself the work of a Z-Contact% that has fallen from 93.5% to 89%. Despite the use of negative sounding words, all of Lucroy's plate discipline numbers remain strong. His 8.8% BB% is also solid. These may reflect the first signs of the aging process, but Lucroy should still have a couple strong seasons left in him.

You can find problems with any player's profile, if you look hard enough. I recommend not doing so for Lucroy, as catchers are absolutely terrible this year. Lucroy's 119 wRC+ (all encompassing offensive metric where 100 is average) immediately becomes the best in the AL at the position, supplanting Brian McCann's 103 wRC+. McCann is deeply flawed at this stage of his career, and besides him only Salvador Perez (102) and Kurt Suzuki (102 in just 265 PAs) are above average in the AL. MLB as a whole adds only Wilson Ramos and Buster Posey above Lucroy.

Lucroy's five swipes are attached to zero CS, so there is no reason for him to stop running a little. If nothing else, his friskiness on the basepaths suggest that he feels healthy. A healthy Lucroy is a productive Lucroy, among the best fantasy assets at his position.

Verdict: Champ

 

Live Expert Q&A Chats - Every Weekday @ 1 PM and 6 PM EST (DFS)

Fantasy Baseball Chat Room

[iflychat_embed id="c-55" hide_user_list="yes" hide_popup_chat="no" height="400px"]

 


Check out RotoBaller's entire fantasy baseball waiver wire pickups and sleepers list, updated daily!




REAL-TIME FANTASY NEWS

Matthew Stafford

Signs One-Year Extension with Rams
Evan Mobley

Fills the Box Score in Game 2 Loss
James Harden

Held to Two Assists Thursday
Donovan Mitchell

Leads Cavaliers in Scoring in Game 2 Defeat
Karl-Anthony Towns

Records Double-Double in Game 2 Win
Sebastian Aho

Picks Up an Assist in Series-Opening Loss
Mikal Bridges

Adds 19 Points as Knicks Grab 2-0 Lead
Jalen Brunson

Hands Out 14 Assists in Game 2 Win
Seth Jarvis

Needs 33 Seconds to Score in Game 1 Loss
Josh Hart

Erupts for Playoff Career-High 26 Points in Game 2
Jaccob Slavin

Struggles in Game 1 Against Canadiens
Jakub Dobes

Sharp in Game 1 Victory
Cole Caufield

Bags Two Points in Impressive Road Win
Juraj Slafkovsky

Opens Conference Finals With Three-Point Performance
Nick Suzuki

Notches Three Assists in Game 1 Win Over Hurricanes
Ronald Acuña Jr.

Ronald Acuna Jr. Exits Early, X-Rays Come Back Negative
Jrue Holiday

Wants to Stay in Portland
Ayo Dosunmu

Timberwolves Hope to Bring Back Ayo Dosunmu
Dylan Harper

Considered Questionable for Friday Night
De'Aaron Fox

Listed as Questionable for Game 3
Jalen Williams

Questionable for Game 3 Against Spurs
Alex Tuch

Hopes to Remain in Buffalo
Sidney Crosby

Wants to Play for "as Many Years as Possible"
Troy Terry

Could Miss Start of Next Season Due to Hip Surgery
Arber Xhekaj

Scratched for Game 1 of Eastern Conference Finals
Jakub Dobes

Seeks More Success Against Hurricanes
Frederik Andersen

Looks to Stay Undefeated Thursday
Calvin Ridley

Not Taking Part in OTAs as Value Continues to Plummet
Carnell Tate

Receiving Early Buzz at OTAs
Ashton Jeanty

Bigger Role Could be Coming for Ashton Jeanty in Year 2
Robby Snelling

Will Undergo Tommy John Surgery
Malik Nabers

' Goal is to be Ready for Start of the Season
De'Von Achane

Dealing With Injury at OTAs?
Dalton Kincaid

Says he Feels "Really Good"
Keenan Allen

Door isn't Closed for Keenan Allen in Los Angeles
Ty Simpson

Does Ty Simpson Have First-Round Appeal in Rookie Drafts?
Fernando Mendoza

Working Behind Other QBs
Cam Ward

is "Perfectly Healthy"
James Cook III

Absent From OTA Practices This Week
Darnell Washington

Is it Time to Drop Darnell Washington in Dynasty Leagues?
Fernando Mendoza

a Top Dynasty Target Even if He Doesn't Start Week 1?
Tyreek Hill

Dynasty Outlook Dependent on Landing Spot
Mack Hollins

Should Managers Trade for Mack Hollins Amid Roster Questions?
Michael Wilson

a Prime Dynasty Sell Candidate
Jake Ferguson

Insurance Upside Makes Him a Borderline TE1 in Dynasty
Brock Bowers

One of the Most Valuable Assets in Dynasty
Devin Vassell

Contributes 22 Points in Wednesday's Loss
Mike Gesicki

Still Provides Some Dynasty Insurance as His Standalone Value Fades
Stephon Castle

Tallies Team-High 25 Points in Game 2 Loss
Victor Wembanyama

Records Eighth Postseason Double-Double
Philadelphia Eagles

Nolan Smith Arrested for Speeding and Reckless Driving
Isaiah Hartenstein

Bounces Back With Double-Double
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander

Leads Thunder to Game 2 Victory WIth 30 Points
Dylan Harper

Exits Game 2 Early Due to Right-Leg Injury
Jalen Williams

Suffers Another Hamstring Injury
Valeri Nichushkin

Ends Scoring Slump in Game 1 Loss
Nathan MacKinnon

Extends Point Streak With an Assist
Brett Howden

Pots Another Goal in Game 1 Win Against Avalanche
Tomas Hertl

Extends Point Streak to Four Games
Pavel Dorofeyev

Scores in Fourth Straight Outing
Carter Hart

Records Third Consecutive Win
Timothy Liljegren

Capitals Re-Sign Timothy Liljegren to Two-Year Extension
Jackson Merrill

Tweaks his Back on Wednesday, Pulled Early
Chicago Bulls

Jerry Stackhouse Emerges as Bulls Head-Coach Candidate
Cooper Flagg

Kon Knueppel Headline All-Rookie Team
Jiri Kulich

Aims to Return Next Season
CFB

Lincoln Riley Believes USC is Ready for Playoff Run
CFB

Notre Dame-Stanford Rivalry Renewed Through 2028
CFB

Ahmad Hardy Says He's "Back to the Road to Success"
CFB

Texas Tech Graduate Judge Recuses Himself from Brendan Sorsby Case
CFB

UCLA Tackle Jordan Davis Officially Eligible for 2026 Season
CFB

Bret Bielema Supports Significant College Football Playoff Expansion
Michael Thorbjornsen

Brings High Upside to CJ Cup Byron Nelson
Luke List

Carrying Poor Form Into CJ Cup Byron Nelson
Tom Kim

Hoping to Build on Strong Myrtle Beach Finish
PGA

Sungjae Im Brings Upside to TPC Craig Ranch
Billy Horschel

Looking for Turnaround at CJ Cup Byron Nelson
Adam Hadwin

Difficult to Trust at TPC Craig Ranch
Tony Finau

Looking for Consistency at TPC Craig Ranch
Luke Clanton

Searching for Form at CJ Cup Byron Nelson
Aaron Rai

Withdraws From CJ Cup Byron Nelson
Wyndham Clark

Can Wyndham Clark Find Form at CJ Cup?
Si Woo Kim

Looks To Stay Hot at CJ Cup
Scottie Scheffler

to Defend CJ Cup Byron Nelson Title This Week
Jordan Spieth

Looking For Victory at TPC Craig Ranch
PGA

Matti Schmid Looks to Keep Recent Momentum Going at TPC Craig Ranch
Brooks Koepka

a High-Upside Play at CJ Cup Byron Nelson
Yandy Díaz

Yandy Diaz Exits Early on Tuesday After Being Hit By Pitch
Chris Kirk

Continues Search For Putting Form at TPC Craig Ranch
Rasmus Hojgaard

Looking to Shake Off Poor Major Showing at TPC Craig Ranch
Joel Dahmen

is of No DFS Consideration This Week in Dallas
Pierceson Coody

is Not The Fun DFS Play He Used to Be
Gerrit Cole

to Make Season Debut on Friday Against Rays
Drake Baldwin

Braves Place Drake Baldwin on Injured List With Oblique Strain
CFB

Ezavier Crowell has Immediate Opportunity at Alabama
CFB

Mark Bowman a Day 1 Impact Player for USC?
CFB

Bill Belichick Says Relationship with First North Carolina Team "Wasn't Great"
CFB

Kemario Taylor a Breakout Candidate at Quarterback
CFB

Trinidad Chambliss the Undisputed Top SEC Quarterback Entering 2026?
CFB

Rocco Becht The "Unifier" of Penn State's Roster
Jackson Holliday

Orioles Reinstate Jackson Holliday From Injured List on Monday
Ronald Acuña Jr.

Braves Reinstate Ronald Acuna Jr. From Injured List on Monday
Jose Altuve

Astros Put Jose Altuve on Injured List With Oblique Strain
Corey Seager

Going on Injured List With Back Injury
Jeremy Peña

Jeremy Pena Reinstated and Starting on Monday Against Twins
Melquizael Costa

Drops Decision At UFC Vegas 117
Arnold Allen

Bounces Back
Daniel Santos

Suffers Second-Round TKO Loss
MMA

Dohoo Choi Wins His Third Consecutive Fight
Malcolm Wellmaker

Suffers His Second Loss In A Row
Juan Diaz

Scores Second-Round Submission
Christian Edwards

Defeated At UFC Vegas 117
CFB

Transfer Running Back Arnold Barnes Visiting Iowa State on Monday
Modestas Bukauskas

Gets Split-Decision Win
Jhostynxon Garcia

Expected to Join the Pirates on Tuesday
Colt Emerson

Mariners Promoting Top Prospect Colt Emerson to Major Leagues
Munetaka Murakami

Fantastic First Season Continues With Two More Homers
Cristopher Sánchez

Cristopher Sanchez Dazzles With 13-Strikeout Complete Game on Saturday
Blake Snell

to Undergo Elbow Surgery on Tuesday
Clay Holmes

Could Miss Around Three Months
Jose Altuve

Exits After Swing
Corey Seager

Absent With Back Spasms on Saturday
Trevor Story

Hits the Injured List With Groin Injury
Blake Snell

Likely to Need Elbow Surgery
RANKINGS
C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
SP
RP

RANKINGS

QB
RB
WR
TE
K
DEF